2.5 stars. I have some really mixed feelings about this book. If I had any clue of how insanely (psychotically?) crunchy she is, I probably wouldn’t have read this. As someone who values a healthy lifestyle, my jaw was constantly on the floor at some of her suggestions:
- only having unpainted wooden blocks for your young children to play with, NOTHING with color.
- only 2-3 shirts & 2 pairs of pants per child, in neutral colors to “like your child better.”
- hiking barefoot
- having one bowl per family member and using that bowl for every meal. No other dishes.
- condemning western medicine and yet saying it has its value at times, then finishing off with “my oldest child has neurological issues, and I’m not saying it was a dose of Tylenol as an infant that did it, but it probably was. I understand you feel guilty if you gave it to your kids too.”
- genetically testing the whole family to find out what they’re pre-disposed to, and making sure they don’t eat any food or “toxins” that could trigger that disease.
There was so much fear-mongering. It’s one thing to decide to only eat raw, fermented foods, but to say THIS IS THE WAY TO BE HEALTHY when you have zero medical or dietary qualifications is laughable. She had some good advice, but none of it was groundbreaking and much of it was plain bonkers. She took her personal convictions and made it The Only Way, and if you follow her steps, your kids will have a better immune system and be perfectly healthy in mind and body, unlike everyone’s disease-ridden kids.
She comes from an extremely privileged place. Her Instagram shows a massive house on tons of lands and woodland. Of course they can hike 15 miles a week or whatever they do! They have resources and desires that do not match with the reality of most families. For a Christian, there was a severe lack of trust in the Lord to care for us and our bodies when we are not eating pounds of sauerkraut or wearing neon colors and thus causing sensory issues in everyone around us. Even with doing all the things, we can still get cancer, autoimmune disorders, or any other number or thing. The Lord is the one who knows every cell of our bodies and gives them permission to stay healthy or mutate. We are responsible to care for our bodies, but it’s not a sin to eat processed foods or give our children sugar, or GASP! Let them wear colors or play with *painted* wooden blocks. No matter what we do, we live in a fallen world and we’ll never be able to beat the curse.