Brilliant Writing - Flawed Angels.
'I am thousands of years old and have won many battles, but tonight I lost the war.'
Az is Azrail the Angel of Death. He is an archangel, created by 'Father' and his brothers are Gabriel, Michael and Lucifer. Having accomplished something none of the others had dared, Az was rewarded by being custody over human souls. But that meant he had to take them from life on earth. We follow him in his fight for human souls against Lucifer from Cain and Able, via Sodom and Gomorrah , through the Crucifixion and into the modern day. The book is a wonderful mix of myths and we get a really creative and fitting explanation for why Death carries a scythe and wears black.
If you park accepted religious interpretations of angels and Biblical stories, this is an interesting variant on the 'reaper' theme using a lot of well-known religious names and themes and a few quite original ideas. It is a very human story of emotional hardening, cynicism, betrayal, pride and family in-fighting. It traces the journey of Az from heartless disconnection to compassion through the redeeming power of love. It is a powerful, moving and beautiful story.
"Fear always supersedes love when obedience is concerned.”
This is a very well written book and I was drawn in from the first intriguing line and read it right though in one sitting. The use of language is almost flawless and the development of the characters we encounter, from archetype into individual personality is a fluent and effective journey. The use of familiar landmarks from religion and myth are woven into a tightly paced narrative which keeps the reader moving forward and wanting to know what will happen next. Even when the end of the event is a known, the way it will be told and its consequences in the story remain a fascination. I found the story itself a really gripping and unusual urban fantasy. The mixing of magic and modernity, so often the downfall of such books, was well achieved, blending them in a believable way.
"Ultimately, it’s the legacy you leave behind defined by what you’ve done and the choices that you’ve made because of your circumstances."
So why am I not stamping this with five blazing stars? Well, for a couple of rather impacting reasons.
Primarily, because it fell into the trap that too many such stories fall into. It is supposed to be about angels - creatures of a nature that is higher than human. But, as I said earlier in this review, 'it is a very human story'. This is a story of very human characters. They might be immortal and have super-powers, but they still have totally human emotions, outlooks, weaknesses and strengths. It would be completely understandable that Az becomes the cynical and callous individual he does, if he were a human trying to do the job he does. Az comes over more like Louis in 'Interview With the Vampire' than any idea I have of what an angel might be like. But he is not human and not a vampire, he is an arch-angel, supposedly the highest rank of spiritual being. So the whole basis of the story just does not wash.
The second reason it fails, is too much internal inconsistency. The story is predicated on the idea that Christian belief is true, all humans are offered redemption and when you die you still exist. But Az seemed to act as if he sees death as an utter ending - as if when someone he cares for dies, they are lost forever. And this despite the book presenting the case very strongly, more than once, that this is not so. This all too human view of death as an end, rather than the beginning of life eternal. is an internal inconsistency which leads Az to making some plot crucial important decisions which run against the knowledge he should have, regarding the true nature of mortal death in his reality.
These two flaws I struggled with a lot as I read, even wondering in parts of the book if it was intended as a deliberate satirical effect, if the final denouement would be a cynical slap in the face for religious sensitivities. But no. So, sadly, for me, it left a rough edge which the brilliance of the storytelling could not quite completely obscure.
This is still a really great book which, despite the flaws I have mentioned, is one I would recommend as a thoroughly good read. But suspend your disbelief, forget any religious preconceptions and try and buy into it as urban fantasy.