As suspected, I enjoyed this one overall better than the first book. 3.5 rounded up to 4
I liked Poppy as a character from the get-go. She sounds short, round, and determined. She was brave to push herself on the journey she's on at the beginning of the book and relatively smart about it. I also liked that she grew a backbone around Steagor and, in her own words, "For the first time in my life, I feel the urge to take over my own fate. To rebel against what others want for me—from me." Hell yeah!
I also enjoyed her journey to realizing she's an independent adult who can make her own decisions and choices. "My heart thumps hard, and a strange sense of wonder takes over me, the knowledge that I can do things on my own." Hell, I sometimes suddenly realize this myself. I'll find myself randomly thinking to myself, 'Wait a minute, why can't I do XYZ?' and look into it and see if it's feasible or not. Sometimes we get so caught up in the responsibilities and exhausting, neverending decisions of adulthood that we forget we have the freedom to make fun choices, too.
Steagor was alright. I like seeing the solemn, scowling character find his ray of sunshine and let slip some laughs and smiles. I would have liked him a lot more if the bulk of the conflict of the story wasn't him refusing to communicate with Poppy. Once he finally gets his head out of his ass, he's more likable.
I was annoyed, again, about some of the naivete the author tries giving the female character. In this one, I'm supposed to believe that a grown woman wouldn't even be able to recognize the feelings of sexual arousal. Like really? It's pretty natural and obvious and a basic part of growing up. Having little experience? Sure. But being oblivious to even understanding what being turned on feels like??? Cut me a break. There's no freaking way. ESPECIALLY given how quickly she learns otherwise. Absolute nonsense.
The whole public sex thing is apparently going to be a continual thing for the series so meh on that. Poppy actually says "I remind myself that orcs view lovemaking as a normal part of a relationship, not as shameful or something to be hidden." That's ... a shitty thing to say. If that statement were made about nudity, then I'd totally agree. It's really conveniently ignoring the whole issue of consent. I guess it's assumed if you're using the communal baths - even though most orcs don't have access to anything else - that you're consenting to people fucking in them, too? And Poppy faces a friend congratulating her on having sex in the baths because he'd heard her. You might be able to deal with a friend that's happy for you but what about other folks? Mentors? Family members? Your parents? Siblings?
While that harvest festival in the first book clearly had children leaving the festival before it turned into an orgy, the public baths are consistently described as being very steamy and while you can hear other folks there, you can't necessarily see them. Poppy expresses interest in public sex "as long as we don’t traumatize any minors" but it's never mentioned if they bother to check for the kids in the baths? If the orcs are so serious about cleanliness then surely orc kids would be bathing pretty frequently? It just doesn't make sense to me.