In “Sweet Cheat,” “Duncan” offers up a bawdy tale of backwoods intrigue. It’s a small town called Greenhill, somewhere outside of Memphis. Buck Peters is the police chief and church deacon and he narrates the tale in an aw-shucks Gomer Pyle way. The big intrigue in town is when the local Madam Rita is murdered and suddenly half the town’s men are suspects and half the town’s jealous wives as well.
Kip, the local millionaire, had threatened to kill Rita earlier in a drunken rage when he got tired of her teasing him. His alibi though is that he was home in bed with his wife, Lacey. And that’s a bit of a complicated alibi because, at the time the murder was committed, dear sweet Lacey was in the garden behind Kip’s home, making mad passionate love at least three times in a row with Buck.
Indeed, there’s a whole backstory about how, when they were sixteen, Buck and Lacey fell in love, but she swore they couldn’t marry because Kip’s family had swindled Lacey’s family out of all their money and she planned to marry Kip to get the family money back. So for twelve years Lacey has been carrying on with Buck, whom she claims to love, while failing to consummate her marriage to Kip. And if Kip ever got wind of what went on, he’d murder them both, alibi or no alibi.
The whole novel carries on like this with farcical comedy and Peyton Place attachments. Fir instance, the coroner on seeing Rita’s body and the four bullets fired through the window, three lodged in the wall, thinks he can call it as suicide and save the town quite a few headaches. And, a few in the town, including the defense attorney, think it would save everyone lots of trouble if it all got blamed on the town special needs guy who had a history of being a peeping Tom.
“Sweet Cheat” is thus a bawdy comedic small country town story masquerading as a crime novel.