I have read a few books on Stoicism this year and was excited to be offered an ARC copy of Brittany Polat's Journal Like a Stoic, in the hope that it would offer me the opportunity to apply aspects of the philosophy more readily to my own life. Unfortunately, I found the journaling program overall to be more frustrating than helpful.
Each of the 90 prompts begins with a quote from famous Stoics such as Seneca and Marcus Aurelius. I loved the quotes and am hoping to follow up by reading Aurelius' Meditations shortly. However, Polat's brief "translation" or "explanation" of each quote, leading into the writing prompts, was often very cutesy or overly generic, and seemed more to be searching for a sound-bite dynamic instead of adding clarity. I think these author paragraphs would have been much more helpful and enlightening if they were about twice the length and used language or tone similar to her brief background on Stoicism located in the first chapters of the book.
While I found some of the journal prompts inspiring and helpful, I more often found myself struggling to respond to questions either because I didn't fully understand what was requested, or because they appeared impossible. An example of the former was when the reader was asked to "write about the interaction between wise discernment, or wisdom, and fate. How do they relate to one another." I believe this prompt would have been understandable to a long-term student of Stoicism, but not to a beginner. And, this is a situation where more explanation from the author about the Stoic viewpoints and the associated quotes related to each of these entities would have been helpful. An example of the latter problem was when the reader was asked to rewrite a conversation/reaction/disagreement from the other person's point of view. How is this possible when we are not that other person and we have no idea what their life or thoughts have entailed up until the moment of our interaction?
There were also several repeat prompts. The ones appearing most often included setting a timer and then writing what came into your mind during the period of reflection, and the above-mentioned rewriting something from another person's point of view.
So, I enjoyed the brief overview of Stoicism, the quotes before each prompt, and some of the prompts themselves. But, overall, while I believe the concept of learning to practice Stoicism through journaling is a very good idea, I do not believe this particular book is the best example for curious beginners.
Thank you to NetGalley for an ARC copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.