Lisa Robertson's Magenta Soul Whip

by Lisa Robertson

A New York Times Notable Book of 2010

Verses, essays, confessions, reports, translations, drafts, treatises, laments and utopias, 1995–2007. Collected by Elisa Sampedrin.

Lisa Robertson writes poems that mine the past — its ideas, its personages, its syntax — to construct a lexicon of the future. Her poems both court and cuckold subjectivity by unmasking its fundament of sex and hesitancy, the coil of doubt in its certitude. Reading her laments and utopias, we realize that language — whiplike — casts ahead of itself a fortuitous form. The form brims here pleasurably with dogs, movie stars, broths, painting's detritus, Latin and pillage. Erudite and startling, the poems in Lisa Robertson's Magenta Soul Whip, occasional works written over the past fifteen years, turn vestige into architecture, chagrin into resplendence. In them, we recognize our grand, saddened century.

Genres: Poetry, Female Authors

104 pages, Paperback

First published April 14, 2005

Reviews

[Laura · Rating 5 out of 5]

it's hard to believe that there's enough room on any pages in the world for all this complicated sad fragmented sensual loveliness.

[Elizabeth Metzger · Rating 5 out of 5]

(Another version of the same beginning is simpler and more direct: in the long science of submission it is the mind that, quietly spectacular, unhooks the bodies and opens the face.)

my fidelity is my own disaster.

[Elisabeth · Rating 5 out of 5]

"Equipped with such formidable mortality
whatever style I choose operates in me like a sky--
it passes and changes and persists and I possess nothing
but the sum of naming, curious and
frantic."

[James Murphy · Rating 2 out of 5]

Phooey. I blame myself when I fail to connect to a book or author, poet. In this case Lisa Robertson has done her work, but I fail to get it. These poems are so obscure and difficult I have trouble finding allusion and experience enough to relate to them. I'm overwhelmed. At the end are 4 prose poems she calls essays; it's only there that I begin to find myself on solid ground. But then on the last page was something I thought lovely, a little untitled poem in which she likens poetry to a transcendant upward motion against all physical laws, so that it becomes not motion at all. Unfortunately, in the pages before this I was unable to overcome the resistance of atoms she writes about here and so couldn't achieve that motion. I'll try this book again next year, but for now it's my bad.

[Christine · Rating 5 out of 5]

Magnificent! The way her writing incorporates feminism with the continual fragmentation of the gendered-self is rattling, revealing passages in the body that I never even knew existed. Robertson's strongest work yet.

[Emma]

“This is the topic we discussed in your kitchen this winter.
I said I didn't know what thinking is.
You said you were trying to understand your sense of an inner voice, which was separate from thinking.
I didn't understand.
Ilet myself go blank.”

[Arun · Rating 3 out of 5]

Collected by Lisa Robertson's editor Elisa Sampedrin, this book spans essays, laments, translations, philosophical fragments, and poems written between 1995 and 2007. The lines unfurl—some tailored in Latin, some in Epicurean fragments, others in the syntax of appetite, desire, gender, melancholy, ornament. I'm still heavily moved by Robertson's 'The Baudelaire Fractal' which I finished this July, yet I found this earlier work sharper-edged, wilder in form, and somehow even more porous. I expected something quieter, but I was instead met with a kind of intellectual heat, kind of perfect for this summer. There were some Latin phrases I didn't understand (and didn't need to, necessarily) and at least fifty words I had to look up to know their definitions (I feel like my vocabulary expanded enormously). Despite this, I know her language is so full of feeling that it vibrates. Robertson constructs a textual space in which prose and critical inquiry coexist. Poetic language functions as a philosophical medium, and epistemology is inseparable from aesthetics. She aligns herself with Lucretian atomism and Epicurean thought, not only through direct reference but in the compositional logic of the work itself.

[ItsMe ButNot · Rating 5 out of 5]

I'm whipped up by this. I hope she never stops writing poetry. This is her 'most like an epic' to date.

[Mary Kathryn · Rating 5 out of 5]

Haters will call this book pretentious, but it's a deeply satisfying, sexy, workout for the mind book of feminist poetry. She nails it with her couplet "Utopia is so emotional./ Then we get used to it." How long does it take before paradise dulls? "Draft of a Voice-Over for Split-Screen Video Loop" is esp. seditious. Brainy girls will cheer her on as she challenges us to resist the temptation of the feminine as decoration, mystery and emotion: "It is not our purpose to obscure the song of no-knowledge."

[Karen Lepri · Rating 3 out of 5]

This book is an amazing exercise in intellectual rhetoric via poetry--perhaps a nod to the Romans or a life-ring thrown to a drowning (morphing?) language at sea in today's media-laden, digi-textual, post-document (?)world. References to Romanticism, Ancient Greeks, and more abound amidst a cadence and diction determined to redirect your attention, save you from the depths of pretty lyricism, and maybe make you learn something (Google is useful for decoding certain references!)

[Carrie · Rating 5 out of 5]

underlining like mad.

[Peaches · Rating 5 out of 5]

I've been in love with this book since I started reading it in Fall of 2018. It is a spectacular and unique book full action and truths. I waited so long to finish it because it exploded my understanding of what a poem could be and I didn't want it to end.
Magenta Soul Whip is my absolutely favorite book title. What Lisa Robertson embodies in her writing is sticky, scholarly, humorous and heartbreaking. One of my favorite books, with poems I will forever be reading. Particularly, "After Trees" & "Wooden Houses." A very special writer! Let the confusion, and the detail wash over you.

[Will Quabbit · Rating 5 out of 5]

Magnetic and musical. I don't particularly have comments on the "content", as in whether there are any ideas or philosophies in the conventional sense. But I love Robertson's music, which takes the language of intellectuality as its material and runs with it. The speaker feels magnanimous, the words charged with urgency, but lightness and humor undergird the whole thing. Each line has a transparency that still manages to - almost - resist the intelligence. There aren't fussy poeticisms or irritatingly opaque strains towards profundity. Rereadable and enchanting.

[t.a. · Rating 4 out of 5]

From 'The Stricture'

‘This is wrong’
‘This is beautiful’
‘This is social’
‘This is not thinking’

It is the handiwork of appearing only.

This is the topic we discussed in your kitchen this winter.
I said I didn’t know what thinking is.
You said you were trying to understand your sense of an
inner voice, which was separate from thinking.

I didn’t understand.
I let myself go blank.

I began by taking everything that was doubtful and throwing
it out, like sand.

[Trinity Hannah · Rating 5 out of 5]

One of my very favorite collections of poetry. Lisa Robertson is so keen and fierce in her use of language—there’s something really illuminating and generative about her poetics that opens up worlds of meaning. So good!

[marianne · Rating 3 out of 5]

maybe was too conceptual for me,,, in the sense that there was very little concrete imagery or language,, but the words were pretty and rhythmic and some lines landed with a lovely shock ! i think maybe it just wasn't for me,,, her writing is wonderful i just might not b smart enough to understand

[atito · Rating 4 out of 5]

now this was wild and also wow

[Caitlin Golding · Rating 5 out of 5]

"I am the first suckling among multa, your artifice, your animal, gaudy with cries, gaudy with hunger and lovely with hunger and hunger."

[Blake Levario · Rating 4 out of 5]

Lisa is so good.

"Your failures are no longer sacred."

[Mic Jones · Rating 5 out of 5]

I will be re reading this book always

[Bill Brydon · Rating 5 out of 5]

Lisa writes with strength and confidence
“One animal says to another animal it is not safe you must not return I love you. Another says to her sister animal when you go you will never return then she dies in a camp. Another is a child and she stops living because of deceit. The animals in their velvety dressing gowns have thought bubbles. They break the incest taboo during a long cruel close-up and you can’t help but watch.”
Also the entire Essay on Lust is in my quotes

[H]

So delightful & heady & inspiring & singular

Sometimes you find a book that just clicks in w the neuroses/ patternings of your own syntax… this is definitely one of those for me. While still existing in a space that leaves me intrigued/ seeking deeper understanding. I’ll have to read many times to keep grasping. Really really masterful.

“So long
Figtree
Especially”

“My Fidelity is My Own Disaster”

[Ryan · Rating 5 out of 5]

Within my own limited reading habits I can't think of anyone who writes like Lisa Robertson, and whose mind, in their writing, I love as much. Perpetually astonished.

And the object itself, (dear Coach House) is something everyone should want desperately.

[Opal McCarthy · Rating 5 out of 5]

"A young girl slept under/ the opening fingers. But what can we/ keep. All night they sleep. We launch into rest/ and the flames burn through/ alone in its clearing. The brave thing would be/ to sleep in a hut again, dawn to nervy/ dark, studying/ the ground."

[Dusie Press · Rating 5 out of 5]

I haven't even finished it yet, but this is a definite writerly-changing experience! I now need to find every bk she has ever written and reexperience them all!

[Theodora Danylevich · Rating 5 out of 5]

oh. my. what a supremely sexy book. on so many levels.

(reading still in progress)

[Abraham]

so far: incomprehensible with notes of genius

[Tiffany · Rating 5 out of 5]

holy sh*t.

[Rodney · Rating 5 out of 5]

Trinket pasticcio, flaunting skyey sheets,
With Crispin as the tiptoe cozener?
No, no: veracious page on page, exact.

[Alex Robertson · Rating 3 out of 5]

3.5