Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Trudy

Rate this book
When Esme meets Trudy at the county auction, she knows there's something really special about her. "She's quite a goat!" But she doesn't know how special, until she takes her Trudy can predict the weather. Esme's goat becomes a local superstar! "Heard you've got quite a goat!" But one day, Trudy disappears inside her barn and doesn't come back out. What's wrong with Trudy? Esme is very worried. But she soon discovers that Trudy has something even more special in store. . . .

32 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 2009

1 person is currently reading
35 people want to read

About the author

Henry Cole

256 books169 followers
Henry Cole was a celebrated science teacher for many years before turning his talents to children's books. He has worked on nearly one hundred and fifty books for children, including Nesting, Unspoken, Big Bug, A Nest for Celeste, Jack's Garden, and On Meadowview Street. Henry loves being outside where he can sketch and write.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
21 (15%)
4 stars
46 (34%)
3 stars
62 (45%)
2 stars
5 (3%)
1 star
1 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews
Profile Image for Ellon.
4,674 reviews
February 24, 2023
3 stars (I liked it)

This was a decent story. Trudy is cute and so is the relationship between child and goat. I was a bit disappointed with Cole's illustrations, just because I find them so beautiful in most of his other books.
Profile Image for Maddypictures.
298 reviews3 followers
April 10, 2012
Oh, how I longed for a pet goat when I was a child! So many of my friends had goats and they gave them the dullest, most obvious names. Billy. Nanny. Cappy.

I swore if I were ever lucky enough to get a pet goat, surely I'd give it a name with a little more pizzazz than that. While "Trudy" had never crossed my mind as a potential name, it surely would have if this book had been around when I was younger.

Prolific children's book illustrator Henry Cole has put together a captivating goat tale. Esme goes with her grandfather to the county auction to look for an animal to purchase. Nothing feels quite right. Holsteins are too big. Grandmother is allergic to feathers, so birds are out. Pigs are too stinky.

Wonder of wonders, here in a corner of the barn is a sign, "'Trudy' Free to Good Home” Trudy, of course, turns out to be a shy looking goat, with just a hint of sass behind her demure eyelashes. Grandpa chortles that the price is right, and Esme and Trudy quickly become fast friends. Esme takes care of Trudy, reads to her and even talks to her about her day. Astute readers will notice little details such as Esme reading "Jack's Garden" (also by Henry Cole) to Trudy.

Soon, Esme notices that whenever Trudy retreats to her barn, snow is certain to follow. A steady following for the prognostic goat emerges and the local townsfolk don’t hesitate to make Trudy a media sensation. (One is reminded strongly of a particularly famous "Some Pig") One illustration shows a bumper sticker affixed to a neighbor's car, "I Get My Weather Reports from TRUDY" and shortly after, we see a two-page spread with late 50's model cars, pick-up trucks and news crews circled round Trudy's modest shed. An enterprising townsperson has even set up a hot cocoa stand.

This last time, it's not snow however, that keeps Trudy in, rather, it’s a brand new “kid” for her to take care of.

Cole's gentle acrylic illustrations are almost reminiscent of watercolor, with a nice balance between vignettes of Esme and Trudy and full-spread illustrations of the farm. I loved this book… for anyone wanting to look at a charming old-fashioned story about an unusual pet, this would be a terrific read.
Profile Image for Tasha.
4,165 reviews138 followers
February 19, 2009
Esme's grandfather takes her to the farm auction where she is going to pick out an animal to take home. Her grandmother is allergic to feathers, so the ducks, roosters and pigeons are out. The pigs are too stinky and the cow is too big. Esme picks out Trudy, a goat who is being given away free at the auction. Trudy is given a small red barn to live in with her own fenced yard with an apple tree. Trudy goes out every morning to her favorite spot. Until one morning when she heads out, smells the air and returns to the barn. That day, it snowed. This happens again and again. Trudy returns to the barn, it snows. Crowds begin to gather to see the weather-forecasting goat. But then, Trudy returns to the barn and it doesn't snow. What could that mean?

This book has many of the same charms as Cole's On Meadowview Street. Cole's illustrations once again capture a feeling, a setting, a mood. The setting here is especially clearly done for a picture book, with the feel in each and every picture of modern but small farm life. The book reads aloud very nicely, with touches of repetition, moments of revelation, and its own pace. I appreciate a book that shows a child living with her grandparents as matter-of-fact and unexplained. Just normal and factual.

This book is a charmer. You may have to create a goat story time just to share this one. Oh, and who wouldn't want to pair it with a very different but equally great goat story - Gregory the Terrible Eater by Mitchell Sharmat.
Profile Image for N.
912 reviews13 followers
February 3, 2009
This book has a lovely cover which was appealing, but then again I have sort of a soft spot for goats. Meh-eh-eh. If I saw a sign that said, "Trudy free to a good home." I don't know if I could resist.

Trudy's new owners soon notice that her patterns seem to indicate the ability to predict the weather. This draws the attention of many folks in town, sort of like a little book I read awhile back, "Charlotte's Web".

Luckily the folks discover that Trudy's a fake, right before she.....
(I'd hate to spoil the ending).
Profile Image for Liana.
134 reviews
September 7, 2016
A girl gets a goat who can forecast snow.

This is cute and it's nice that it ends with a baby goat. The story doesn't have much of a plot, so there's not much progression, but that hardly stops me when it comes to childrens' stories.

The girls seemed to enjoy it. It helps that it recently snowed there.
Profile Image for Melissa.
776 reviews74 followers
October 28, 2012
A funny little story, but I don't mean that in a bad way. I like the laconic Grandfather ("Nope.") and the laconic Trudy, who is totally unphased by attention or lack of it. I like that this is a grandparent-grandchild family, and I love the ending, a great way to bring closure to a story without a lot of narrative drive or tension.
Profile Image for Erin.
373 reviews4 followers
February 4, 2009
With a little bit of wilbur the pig mixed in, and very evocative farm illustrations this is lovely little story.
Profile Image for Kati.
621 reviews12 followers
June 21, 2009
A nice story about a young girl who picks out a goat for a pet. The goat then seems to be able to forecast when it will snow.
Profile Image for Phuong.
109 reviews2 followers
May 12, 2012
Very sweet story about a goat.
Profile Image for MissInformation.
337 reviews8 followers
March 23, 2009
In this farm story, Esme can pick one animal from the auction, and decides on a goat. There is something special about this goat though. She can predict snow! Or is there something else....
Profile Image for Deanna Caswell.
Author 56 books16 followers
July 25, 2009
We're totally biased. We own goats. See my videos and bio for the goat drama. But seriously, I love this book.
Profile Image for Bear.
1,009 reviews4 followers
February 3, 2016
Not so good. It had potential and then it petered out.
Profile Image for Shannon.
439 reviews13 followers
January 28, 2014
A lovely story about a little girl named Esme and her goat Trudy.
Profile Image for Ellen Moore.
77 reviews1 follower
Read
December 4, 2017
This book reminds me of Charlotte’s Web. Trudy the goat goes inside every time it’s about to snow, and the whole rural town gets excited that she is a weather predicting goat. They make shirts and bumper stickers and the news comes out to film it, but with a twist ending, Trudy wasn’t expecting snow, she was expecting a baby goat. The acrylic illustrations are illustrative and cute with a softer color palette. This would be a good read aloud book.
Displaying 1 - 24 of 24 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.