I received a review copy from the publishers & Edelweiss.
I really wanted to like this one. I'm not deep into the Mignolaverse, but I'd understood this could stand relatively on its own. Heck, I love Frankenstein's monster being expanded on as a character, and I thought I'd give this a try. It turns out, I do think it can stand entirely on its own.
Well, it had all the potential to be something special, but it fell a little bit flat. There's a *lot* here. Heck, I think if this was 8 or even 12 issues, a lot of my problems could have been resolved, but there are only four.
The Murk storyline needed a lot more flesh. I could tell they wanted to really emphasize the dread it'd induce, but then there needed to be more death and decay or something. The frog storyline felt rushed, as well, which robbed it of any real heft.
The coloring was also a bit of a knock for me. I really felt like there should have been a more visual difference below ground and above. That being said, I really dug the art. Frankenstein looked great, and I loved the design of the first set of frogs. The other evolved animals throughout were awesome to look at, as well.
On top of all that, the main story feels about half-way done. That's not necessarily a huge problem, as I'm hoping this story thread gets picked up in a later run, but the conclusion we get feels so empty, like they ended it there because they got to four issues, not because it's a good place to end.
Ultimately, I think this can be a good jumping off point for more stories in this "New World", and it definitely makes me want to go back and read the related works taht came before. I just wish this entry was a little bit stronger overall.