4.5/5 Stars
This book is unlike ANY I've read before.
Home-Invasion stories are always the ones that scare me the most: from The Strangers to When A Stranger Calls; from The Last House on the Left to Hush; etc.
Seidlinger does such an incredible job at putting the reader IN the story. This novel is written in the 2nd-person perspective, so that, alone, puts the reader within the pages as the nameless "you." However, this is taken even further with the one-sided conversations of our "Director" that is guiding us through the home-invasion. Seidlinger uses the method to further put the reader in the mindset of the home-invader that is leading the charge on this specific night. When our "Director" asks a question of the lead invader, we, as the readers, have to fill in the gaps in the dialogue; therefore, WE are having this conversation... it's our own opinions, biases, beliefs, etc. that lead us to the inferred dialogue. This writing tactic was so MASTERFULLY done throughout the entire novel.
While reading Anybody Home?, I was reminded of another horror novel that I adored: Amityville Horror by Jay Anson. Now, this novel isn't about the supernatural/paranormal (which is odd because Amityville was the one claiming to be real); however, both of these books are written in a very cold, observational, and objective manner. There was no room for fantastical storytelling or beautiful prose... it was straight to the point. Even when describing the gore, it stated what happened clearly and didn't go into too much detail about the aesthetics of it. This is part of the reason I deducted half a star; I liked the cold, bystander type of storytelling because it is what best fits the story itself, but there were some aspects of it that I feel kept the story from being THAT MUCH BETTER!
One aspect of this writing that warranted my half-star deduction was the use of "filler names," so the characters were just called Invaders 1-5, The Voice, The Director, and Victims 1-4. Again, I understand the appeal of this because it further allows the reader to imagine themselves in ANY of these roles... they remain nameless for a reason; however, it slowed the pace of the novel for me. I feel like this is because, as readers, we see a word as a whole rather than ACTUALLY reading and sounding out that word each time we read it. In other novels, this works because the characters have names that are different, but, in this book, we couldn't just look at "Invader" and move on because there are 5 invaders... but we also couldn't just look at the number of that invader (1-5) because the victims were also numbered. I don't know... this might be nit-picky, but I continued to get frustrated at the pacing while reading the novel (because it is so short, and I felt like it was taking me FOREVER to get through it). Again, I 100% understand why Seidlinger did it this way... and, to an extent, it was successful in achieving what he wanted, but I felt that it was at the cost of other important elements of the story.
Another reason for the deducted star is the lack of description; however, again... I understand why it is this way! Seidlinger seems to want the reader to fill in the blanks throughout this novel in many different ways, the gore being one of those ways. He describes EXACTLY what happens... but there isn't much detail added for the reader to FULLY take in the scene being described. Though I understand wanting the audience to create their own descriptions within their mind to, again, put them in the shoes of the invaders, I still would've really liked to read Seidlinger's descriptions of these events taking place... creating a full atmosphere for the reader to take it all in.
Aside from those 2, very nit-picky reasons (behind which I can see the reasoning), this book is PHENOMENAL! It's an incredibly innovative and dark novel that uses masterful techniques to propel the gut-wrenching story of a family's night of horrors during a home invasion. DEFINITELY read this book at your earliest convenience; this would ESPECIALLY be a great October read. Also, if you enjoy The Strangers movie, then you will love this; I GUARANTEE IT!