What do you think?
Rate this book
To Be Called #2
To Be Called Worthy
Magic is only for the worthy. The clerics. Join them, or your magic is forfeit.
Rinnen doesn’t give the shadowy clerics much thought. At least not until his sister, Kessandra, turns out to have the rare gift. Kessandra wants to keep her magic, but they won’t let her.
When the magic-removal ceremony takes more from his sister than just her special powers, Rinnen is devastated. But he’s just a fighter in training. What good is a sword against magic? How can a handful of ordinary elves fight such a sinister power?
Rinnen knows one thing. He wants his sister back. And he will do whatever it takes to save her.
Rinnen doesn’t give the shadowy clerics much thought. At least not until his sister, Kessandra, turns out to have the rare gift. Kessandra wants to keep her magic, but they won’t let her.
When the magic-removal ceremony takes more from his sister than just her special powers, Rinnen is devastated. But he’s just a fighter in training. What good is a sword against magic? How can a handful of ordinary elves fight such a sinister power?
Rinnen knows one thing. He wants his sister back. And he will do whatever it takes to save her.
- GenresFantasy
319 pages, Paperback
First published July 12, 2022
44 people want to read
About the author
Penny Johnston
2 books27 followersWhen she’s not writing fantasy fiction or doing life with her two teenagers, Penny Johnston works as a medical admin assistant. She is the author of the To Be Called series, and is currently writing the next book when no one is reading over her shoulder. Penny has been known to fangirl over swordfights, rangers, and rescue stories, and she loves slipping away to go camping at the lake. Her third novel, Cleric Son, is expected in 2026.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews
September 23, 2022
Rating 4.5 stars.
I didn't know how beautiful this story was going to be! In that way, it's just like the cover. Softly beautiful. Full review to come!
Review:
I’m so late getting this review out, but that’s not to say that I hated this book, not at all!
Now, to be clear, this book is not necessarily marked as Christian fiction. But to my Christian readers, let me assure you that it is, in fact, by my definition, Christian fantasy. However, I think non-Christians can totally read and enjoy it.
Okay, where to begin?
I guess a good place to start would be the sibling bond between Kessandra and Rinnen. I haven’t seen this a lot in fiction, and their closeness was not said, but seen.
Rinnen was willing to do just about anything for his sister. And his pain at having lost her, his anger, is something I can understand because I would feel the same way. His devotion to her, just because she is his sister, is refreshing and endearing to read. And it was that devotion that MINOR SPOILER:
The romance I didn’t see coming, I didn’t think about pairing those two together ;)
My one complaint is that I think the book could have been fleshed out more. There were some little subplots that I would’ve liked to see developed, or even written into another novel. I would encourage the author to continue to explore what her world and characters have to offer, because I think there is potential.
Yes, you can tell this book is a debut novel, but it is a strong one. I would definitely recommend this book to others. If and when the author decides to publish more, I’ll be interested in reading it.
I was given a free ebook for an honest review, all thoughts and opinions are my own, and I was not required to leave a review.
If you’re interested in Christian fantasy and bookish blogs, check out my website: https://abbyswriting.wixsite.com/abby...
Until the next review,
Abby
I didn't know how beautiful this story was going to be! In that way, it's just like the cover. Softly beautiful. Full review to come!
Review:
I’m so late getting this review out, but that’s not to say that I hated this book, not at all!
Now, to be clear, this book is not necessarily marked as Christian fiction. But to my Christian readers, let me assure you that it is, in fact, by my definition, Christian fantasy. However, I think non-Christians can totally read and enjoy it.
Okay, where to begin?
I guess a good place to start would be the sibling bond between Kessandra and Rinnen. I haven’t seen this a lot in fiction, and their closeness was not said, but seen.
Rinnen was willing to do just about anything for his sister. And his pain at having lost her, his anger, is something I can understand because I would feel the same way. His devotion to her, just because she is his sister, is refreshing and endearing to read. And it was that devotion that MINOR SPOILER:
The romance I didn’t see coming, I didn’t think about pairing those two together ;)
My one complaint is that I think the book could have been fleshed out more. There were some little subplots that I would’ve liked to see developed, or even written into another novel. I would encourage the author to continue to explore what her world and characters have to offer, because I think there is potential.
Yes, you can tell this book is a debut novel, but it is a strong one. I would definitely recommend this book to others. If and when the author decides to publish more, I’ll be interested in reading it.
I was given a free ebook for an honest review, all thoughts and opinions are my own, and I was not required to leave a review.
If you’re interested in Christian fantasy and bookish blogs, check out my website: https://abbyswriting.wixsite.com/abby...
Until the next review,
Abby
December 27, 2022
***I received a free ARC copy from the author, and this is my honest and unbiased opinion***
Magical fantasy is not a genre I'm well-seasoned in. To give you an idea, the only elvish books I've read are LOTR and The Hobbit.
My reading experience wasn't the greatest. I started losing interest halfway through. This was partly due to my own reading schedule and the fact that it took me forever to finish. When I hit the 85% mark, my reading improved immensely. I think I would have enjoyed this much more if I'd read either in one sitting or at least without so many gaps in between.
The worldbuilding was enjoyable and definitely had a fantastical feel to it. Never once was I pulled out of this world. I especially liked the variety of made-up foods. The Bladesingers were cool. :) While magic was a focal point of the story, I didn't feel it was overdone or overbearing.
The characters Rinnen and Kessandra had an amazing sibling bond that was easy to root for. Mayda was sweet and I appreciated Linazon's much-needed leadership. As for Tawresh, I need closure. The clerics made excellent villains to despise. One thing I really appreciated was the dialogue and how it stayed true to the genre and didn't sound modern or out of place.
The Christian elements came as a surprise. The Maker is meant to symbolize God. While I did see several attributes of forgiveness, mercy, and love, I really had a hard time with the Maker being female. I get that it's a fictional world, but it was just something I had a hard time with. Aside from that, my favorite theme had to be forgiveness and remembering that if God forgives, who are we to deny forgiveness to others.
Overall Despite the struggles, I did enjoy this and I'm very glad I gave it a shot. I'm giving this 3.5 stars. If you like stories of elves, magic, and good vs evil, you'll like this.
Special thanks to the author for the review copy!
Magical fantasy is not a genre I'm well-seasoned in. To give you an idea, the only elvish books I've read are LOTR and The Hobbit.
My reading experience wasn't the greatest. I started losing interest halfway through. This was partly due to my own reading schedule and the fact that it took me forever to finish. When I hit the 85% mark, my reading improved immensely. I think I would have enjoyed this much more if I'd read either in one sitting or at least without so many gaps in between.
The worldbuilding was enjoyable and definitely had a fantastical feel to it. Never once was I pulled out of this world. I especially liked the variety of made-up foods. The Bladesingers were cool. :) While magic was a focal point of the story, I didn't feel it was overdone or overbearing.
The characters Rinnen and Kessandra had an amazing sibling bond that was easy to root for. Mayda was sweet and I appreciated Linazon's much-needed leadership. As for Tawresh, I need closure. The clerics made excellent villains to despise. One thing I really appreciated was the dialogue and how it stayed true to the genre and didn't sound modern or out of place.
The Christian elements came as a surprise. The Maker is meant to symbolize God. While I did see several attributes of forgiveness, mercy, and love, I really had a hard time with the Maker being female. I get that it's a fictional world, but it was just something I had a hard time with. Aside from that, my favorite theme had to be forgiveness and remembering that if God forgives, who are we to deny forgiveness to others.
Overall Despite the struggles, I did enjoy this and I'm very glad I gave it a shot. I'm giving this 3.5 stars. If you like stories of elves, magic, and good vs evil, you'll like this.
Special thanks to the author for the review copy!
Read
April 5, 2025How intriguing that Goodreads invites authors to review their own books. Intriguing, or presumptuous? ;) Well, I write the kinds of stories I like to read, so I love this one. If you like young adult fantasy stories filled with magic, sword fighting, memorable mentors, a dash of romance, and an overarching theme of hope amid darkness, then this book is for you.
February 18, 2023
I liked your book. I usually look for a pioneer, western, romance, history, down to earth every day life kind of book to read. My interest was tweaked by the first pages, wondering what would happen and wrapping my mind around the other world. Looking forward to reading the next one. You sold your audience successfully. All the best. I hope it does well for you.
April 14, 2023
*Disclaimer: I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.*
A lovely story! I enjoyed this read, and was never bored. The beginning was very intriguing and well-written so that I was kept on the edge of my seat, and we had a satisfying ending as well. The characters were convincing and likable, which is so very important in a story, especially to me! I think my favorite part is the deep themes the author brought out through the book, which is such a vital part of storytelling—the very soul of it—and yet so many accomplished authors have missed the mark in that regard. I was so glad that this book left me with something to think about.
My only suggestions is that the book could use a bit more polishing and trimming of certain scenes that are not quite necessary to the plot or character development. I think this book would be better suited for a slightly younger audience as well; my 11 year old brother would enjoy it even more and still be able to be impacted by the theme.
I want to thank the author for the privilege of getting to read their work! God bless.
A lovely story! I enjoyed this read, and was never bored. The beginning was very intriguing and well-written so that I was kept on the edge of my seat, and we had a satisfying ending as well. The characters were convincing and likable, which is so very important in a story, especially to me! I think my favorite part is the deep themes the author brought out through the book, which is such a vital part of storytelling—the very soul of it—and yet so many accomplished authors have missed the mark in that regard. I was so glad that this book left me with something to think about.
My only suggestions is that the book could use a bit more polishing and trimming of certain scenes that are not quite necessary to the plot or character development. I think this book would be better suited for a slightly younger audience as well; my 11 year old brother would enjoy it even more and still be able to be impacted by the theme.
I want to thank the author for the privilege of getting to read their work! God bless.
August 20, 2022
I absolutely enjoyed this book. I loved the bond between the brother, Rinnen, and the sister, Kessandra. So many times while reading this book I was worried and wondered what will happen next. Which I love. That's the best thing about reading books is wanting more. I was also so happy this book didn't end on a cliffhanger. Plus I want to know what their next adventure will be. So I'm excited about a second book. The surroundings were lovely, the characters were compelling, and the story was dangerously adventurous. If you enjoy fantasy, swords, and magic then you'll love this book. I liked that the characters were faithful to who they call “The Maker” she seemed the correct character for this fantasy adventure. So grab a copy of this marvelous book.
I received an advanced reader's copy for an honest review.
I received an advanced reader's copy for an honest review.
August 22, 2022
For real, you need to read this book. Adventure, love, suspense, a real page-turner! Also a stunning reminder of the love of our Maker for us. The characters were lovable, enjoyable and easy to follow along their personal journeys. You couldn’t help but be invested.
I could hardly put it down, and I was grinning at the end. A phenomenal debut novel. Can’t wait to see what’s best for Penny Johnston!
I could hardly put it down, and I was grinning at the end. A phenomenal debut novel. Can’t wait to see what’s best for Penny Johnston!
October 20, 2022
This story caught my interest right away. Elves. Forbidden magic. Escaping.
What's there not to love?
And, the book didn't disappoint.
We're thrown into a story of sweet relationships, strong characters, and high stakes.
The characters were great. All of them.
The story is mostly in the present, with a few well-placed scenes taking place in the past. The auther made it very clear where in the story we were. (Besides for one scene of some memories, which was a few pages long and left me unsure if we were in the past or the present.)
The writing was both well paced, and left time for me, and the characters, to process one event before moving on to the next.
The name of the book was very fitting, too. The whole book we're shown that characters are all worthy in the Maker's eyes. Even those that have magic and choose not to use it as a cleric. Even those that have done wrong. The Maker herself reassures characters that though they've made mistakes, all is forgiven and they're still loved. This made for a very positive tone to the book. (And, no, it wasn't overdone or preachy.)
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book, though, the rating is my own, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Kessandra, or Kessi, lives in a world were only the clerics are allowed to have magic. They use it to serve the Maker, or so they say. Anyone with magic who chooses not to join them has to return their magic to the Maker in a ceremony called the Emptying.
Kessi has magic, and she doesn't want to become a cleric. So, at 15, when she becomes of age, she goes through the Emptying. Not all people survive it. Even those that do never get back to themselves.
She and her brother, Rinnon, have a very strong bond, and we're shown how hard this is for him, too.
At her Emptying she discovers that the clerics have a dark secret. The clerics, led by the Exalted, their leader, are taking the magic for themselves.
This book has one exciting event after another right until its end. I thought it was all wrapped up very nicely.
Content to be aware of:
The Exalted is an evil, power-hungry, lustful man.
He almost kills Kessi while taking her magic and turns her into a broken shell. He won't let anything, including killing others, get in the way of his desire for power and control.
We're told that Trizla is often in his bed. He seems quite possesive of her and Drianna, another woman cleric.
Rinnon and Kessi, are bladesingers, knowing how to wield a blade and other weapons. Many of the other characters are, too. There are various fights both with and without weapons, knocking people unconscious with frying pans, killing in self defense. Cutting a hand with a hatchet.
One of the characters is shown eating minlin root, an addicting and dangerous weed. He hides this from Rinnon and Kessi since he knows they wouldn't approve.
Religious is also a big part of this book.
Elven means children of the Maker. The characters often pray to the Maker. She watches them from the moon. Some characters hear a voice that they identify as the Maker's. She's mentioned all the time.
There's some romance.
What's there not to love?
And, the book didn't disappoint.
We're thrown into a story of sweet relationships, strong characters, and high stakes.
The characters were great. All of them.
The story is mostly in the present, with a few well-placed scenes taking place in the past. The auther made it very clear where in the story we were. (Besides for one scene of some memories, which was a few pages long and left me unsure if we were in the past or the present.)
The writing was both well paced, and left time for me, and the characters, to process one event before moving on to the next.
The name of the book was very fitting, too. The whole book we're shown that characters are all worthy in the Maker's eyes. Even those that have magic and choose not to use it as a cleric. Even those that have done wrong. The Maker herself reassures characters that though they've made mistakes, all is forgiven and they're still loved. This made for a very positive tone to the book. (And, no, it wasn't overdone or preachy.)
Disclaimer: I received a free copy of this book, though, the rating is my own, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
Kessandra, or Kessi, lives in a world were only the clerics are allowed to have magic. They use it to serve the Maker, or so they say. Anyone with magic who chooses not to join them has to return their magic to the Maker in a ceremony called the Emptying.
Kessi has magic, and she doesn't want to become a cleric. So, at 15, when she becomes of age, she goes through the Emptying. Not all people survive it. Even those that do never get back to themselves.
She and her brother, Rinnon, have a very strong bond, and we're shown how hard this is for him, too.
At her Emptying she discovers that the clerics have a dark secret. The clerics, led by the Exalted, their leader, are taking the magic for themselves.
This book has one exciting event after another right until its end. I thought it was all wrapped up very nicely.
Content to be aware of:
The Exalted is an evil, power-hungry, lustful man.
He almost kills Kessi while taking her magic and turns her into a broken shell. He won't let anything, including killing others, get in the way of his desire for power and control.
We're told that Trizla is often in his bed. He seems quite possesive of her and Drianna, another woman cleric.
Rinnon and Kessi, are bladesingers, knowing how to wield a blade and other weapons. Many of the other characters are, too. There are various fights both with and without weapons, knocking people unconscious with frying pans, killing in self defense. Cutting a hand with a hatchet.
One of the characters is shown eating minlin root, an addicting and dangerous weed. He hides this from Rinnon and Kessi since he knows they wouldn't approve.
Religious is also a big part of this book.
Elven means children of the Maker. The characters often pray to the Maker. She watches them from the moon. Some characters hear a voice that they identify as the Maker's. She's mentioned all the time.
There's some romance.
July 8, 2022
There is so much I love about this story! If I need to choose a favorite, I will say that it is the bond between the siblings. The closeness this brother and sister share and the determined love between them is special and uniquely distinctive from any other book I have read in that it is the main plot point. I truly loved read this adventure tale.
I must note that I received an advance review copy for free, and I am joyfully leaving this review voluntarily.
I must note that I received an advance review copy for free, and I am joyfully leaving this review voluntarily.
Read
April 5, 2025How intriguing that Goodreads invites authors to review their own books. Intriguing, or presumptuous? ;) Well, I write the kinds of stories I like to read, so I love this one. If you like young adult fantasy stories filled with magic, sword fighting, memorable mentors, a dash of romance, and an overarching theme of hope amid darkness, then this book is for you.
August 13, 2022
Four stars for content, based on my own preferences. T
All-around great book!
Disclosure: I received a review copy of the ebook from the author. Opinions conveyed are my own.
Scripture Connection
There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear, because fear has to do with punishment. The one who fears is not made perfect in love.
1 John 4:18
Spiritual Themes
Given that I typically review Christian books, it’s worth noting that this book was described as having Christian themes, not as being a “Christian” book. And that classification makes sense to me, since the novel read more like a clean YA, in my opinion.
The novel’s characters worship the “Maker,” who, significantly (in my opinion) is female. However, aside from the gender, the Maker is very similar to God/Jesus. She has made the characters worthy, and they find value and acceptance in her). Many of her lines ring true with Scripture.
Themes of forgiveness and worthiness (in direct correlation with the Maker’s evaluation/gift) are big, in the novel.
I also liked the symbolism with the Clerics and their behavior. I feel that this provided some good food for thought.
What I Liked
This was a very enjoyable read, and a bit different than what I usually read. The writing and narrative are crisp; the author is an editor, and I felt that showed through in the writing.
The brother/sister dynamic between Rinnen and Kessandra was beautiful and brought a lot of power to the novel. Between the cover, the magic and the sibling relationship, I thought at first that the novel would be very similar to Frozen. Having finished the book, I could observe a few other similarities, but I don’t think the author is trying to draw a connection with the Disney film. Again, though, the sibling relationship was so good. I especially liked seeing how Rinnen protected Kessi over the years— and another thematic plot point I won’t spoil, here.
Overall, the family elements, in general, were really well done. I liked the juxtaposition between Linazon and Jorwen as dads and the contrasts shown in their relationships with their sons. I found it particularly interesting to compare Linazon’s relationship with his own son with his relationship with Rinnen. (Linazon, in spite of being more of a secondary character, was one of my favorite characters).
The spiritual content was so rich and strong, particularly the symbolism associated with the different colors of magic. The meaning was clearly accessible for Christian and non-Christian readers, alike. I feel that this was one of those books that can function evangelically, by introducing non-Christian readers to some powerful themes.
The foods were PERFECT, in my opinion— so delightfully imaginative. When I’d read the names of the foods, my first thought was “fairies,” but it also makes sense that elves would eat moon bread and fireweed syrup. This was such an excellent world building element (as was the repetition of the forgiveness phrase), which went really far in setting the scene. I’d like to see more books doing this 🙂
Content
Magic is integral to the plot line. I was a bit more okay with it than usual, because the characters are elves who are born with magic given to them by the Maker, rather than humans who are practicing witchcraft.
There are a few kissing scenes, one of which was rather confusing to me. The other main kissing scene was a bit on the descriptive side, for me (it was part of a flashback). In that scene, there is also a reference to being able to see down the girl’s shirt.
Additionally, there are two mild innuendos/references but this is a mainstream novel and the statements are in relation to a really gross character.
Recommendation Status
This was a really enjoyable book. I’d recommend reader discretion on the basis of content, but (as I saw a reviewer note about a different book) it is still much “cleaner” than most YA books. I’m also really happy with the portrayal of the Gospel, in this novel, which is MAINSTREAM. Yes! I’d like to see this book used for a book club with discussion about the spiritual content.
All-around great book!
Disclosure: I received a review copy of the ebook from the author. Opinions conveyed are my own.
Scripture Connection
There is no fear in love. But perfect love drives out fear, because fear has to do with punishment. The one who fears is not made perfect in love.
1 John 4:18
Spiritual Themes
Given that I typically review Christian books, it’s worth noting that this book was described as having Christian themes, not as being a “Christian” book. And that classification makes sense to me, since the novel read more like a clean YA, in my opinion.
The novel’s characters worship the “Maker,” who, significantly (in my opinion) is female. However, aside from the gender, the Maker is very similar to God/Jesus. She has made the characters worthy, and they find value and acceptance in her). Many of her lines ring true with Scripture.
Themes of forgiveness and worthiness (in direct correlation with the Maker’s evaluation/gift) are big, in the novel.
I also liked the symbolism with the Clerics and their behavior. I feel that this provided some good food for thought.
What I Liked
This was a very enjoyable read, and a bit different than what I usually read. The writing and narrative are crisp; the author is an editor, and I felt that showed through in the writing.
The brother/sister dynamic between Rinnen and Kessandra was beautiful and brought a lot of power to the novel. Between the cover, the magic and the sibling relationship, I thought at first that the novel would be very similar to Frozen. Having finished the book, I could observe a few other similarities, but I don’t think the author is trying to draw a connection with the Disney film. Again, though, the sibling relationship was so good. I especially liked seeing how Rinnen protected Kessi over the years— and another thematic plot point I won’t spoil, here.
Overall, the family elements, in general, were really well done. I liked the juxtaposition between Linazon and Jorwen as dads and the contrasts shown in their relationships with their sons. I found it particularly interesting to compare Linazon’s relationship with his own son with his relationship with Rinnen. (Linazon, in spite of being more of a secondary character, was one of my favorite characters).
The spiritual content was so rich and strong, particularly the symbolism associated with the different colors of magic. The meaning was clearly accessible for Christian and non-Christian readers, alike. I feel that this was one of those books that can function evangelically, by introducing non-Christian readers to some powerful themes.
The foods were PERFECT, in my opinion— so delightfully imaginative. When I’d read the names of the foods, my first thought was “fairies,” but it also makes sense that elves would eat moon bread and fireweed syrup. This was such an excellent world building element (as was the repetition of the forgiveness phrase), which went really far in setting the scene. I’d like to see more books doing this 🙂
Content
Magic is integral to the plot line. I was a bit more okay with it than usual, because the characters are elves who are born with magic given to them by the Maker, rather than humans who are practicing witchcraft.
There are a few kissing scenes, one of which was rather confusing to me. The other main kissing scene was a bit on the descriptive side, for me (it was part of a flashback). In that scene, there is also a reference to being able to see down the girl’s shirt.
Additionally, there are two mild innuendos/references but this is a mainstream novel and the statements are in relation to a really gross character.
Recommendation Status
This was a really enjoyable book. I’d recommend reader discretion on the basis of content, but (as I saw a reviewer note about a different book) it is still much “cleaner” than most YA books. I’m also really happy with the portrayal of the Gospel, in this novel, which is MAINSTREAM. Yes! I’d like to see this book used for a book club with discussion about the spiritual content.
July 7, 2022
I received a free ARC copy and am leaving a review voluntarily.
I really enjoyed this one. There’s a lot of thought out into the religion of the world and how people perceive and use it—sometimes for good, sometimes for evil. The author doesn’t shy away from showing both sides.
The characters are a lot of fun, with each one having their own goals but also a kindness to them that I really appreciate. I love kind characters and you’ll find a bunch here, yet each still have their own flaws and desires.
The villain is the kind you love to hate and I truly enjoyed watching him. He works great within the setting the author has set up.
Definitely an engaging and thought provoking read and highly recommended!
I really enjoyed this one. There’s a lot of thought out into the religion of the world and how people perceive and use it—sometimes for good, sometimes for evil. The author doesn’t shy away from showing both sides.
The characters are a lot of fun, with each one having their own goals but also a kindness to them that I really appreciate. I love kind characters and you’ll find a bunch here, yet each still have their own flaws and desires.
The villain is the kind you love to hate and I truly enjoyed watching him. He works great within the setting the author has set up.
Definitely an engaging and thought provoking read and highly recommended!
June 28, 2022
This YA fantasy kept me turning pages! The premise of a world where some people are born with magic, but only certain people are allowed to keep their magic, was an interesting one. I don't know if this book was a standalone, but I'd love to see more stories in this world, maybe to see what happens with Rinnen's bladesinger friend whose name escapes me?
I received an e-ARC from BookSirens for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an e-ARC from BookSirens for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 22, 2022
The cover caught my attention. Really good read. Nice new twist on the magic theme. Characters were great, writing flowed nicely. Sorry I finished it so quickly. I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 21, 2022
A great story written in superb style. One of the best futuristic books I've read. Enjoyed the magic and intrigue especially with main characters Mayda, Rinnen the brother playing protector of Kessi, his younger sister, Gilspa and his father Bladesinger Linazon. Plenty of twists and turns between good and evil until end of story. Highly recommend this exciting read.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 11, 2022
I loved this book, it was very well written with very believable and credible characters. The story was focussed on Rinnen and his sister Kassandra who live in a village where anyone who has magic has it taken away from them in a very brutal way. This is bad news for Kassandra, who does not want to lose her magic, and her protective older brother Rinnen. What follows is an exciting story of Rinnen and Kassandra and their friends as they seek to resist The Exalted who is the very powerful leader of the Clerics, who all have magic. Very worth reading and highly recommended.
October 20, 2023
Good read
I love a good sibling bond story with a good overall reading experience, and this book met my expectations perfectly. There was a lot to like. Rinne was such a wonderful brother to Kessandra, having her back and protecting her through her time of difficulty. One of my best bits was the words Rinne used when addressing his friend's drug addiction - "You have to want this. You have to want to be free of it. To want your life more than you want this accursed plant that gives you a little, then takes everything!” I'll definitely be borrowing those words in my day job! I also really liked that I could conclude the story in one book with no cliffhanger. Definitely recommended.
I love a good sibling bond story with a good overall reading experience, and this book met my expectations perfectly. There was a lot to like. Rinne was such a wonderful brother to Kessandra, having her back and protecting her through her time of difficulty. One of my best bits was the words Rinne used when addressing his friend's drug addiction - "You have to want this. You have to want to be free of it. To want your life more than you want this accursed plant that gives you a little, then takes everything!” I'll definitely be borrowing those words in my day job! I also really liked that I could conclude the story in one book with no cliffhanger. Definitely recommended.
June 11, 2022
To Be Called Worthy is a novel by Penny Johnson. I thought that the story was very interesting. The characters were great and I thought the book was well written. Magic is often found in fantasy books and the magic that elf Kassandra has is not allowed unless she is a cleric. I thought the loss she has and the effect on her family, especially brother Rinnen, was emotional. I felt the story was very emotional with a perfect ending. I received an arc for free and am leaving my review voluntarily.
June 18, 2022
I love the story… the characters were great too. If you are a fantasy lover, then you should probably give this one a read. Another thing I love about the book was the way it's written.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
June 6, 2022
This was a well done fantasy novel, I appreciated getting to know Kessandra and Rinnen. It was a really well done story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 9, 2024
I truly loved this book! It kept me turning the page and had a 'walk away Happy' ending. We are ready for another by Penny :)
October 13, 2025
I loved this book! Totally my preferred genre and it is so well written with excellent character development, which can make or break a book for me.
While reading I couldn’t believe this was Penny Johnston’s debut novel!
Magic, sibling bond, a truly loving greater power, and a sprinkle of romance make this book a real page turner.
Can’t wait for more from the author.
I read this and listened to the audiobook, read by Penny Johnston herself. Both excellent!
While reading I couldn’t believe this was Penny Johnston’s debut novel!
Magic, sibling bond, a truly loving greater power, and a sprinkle of romance make this book a real page turner.
Can’t wait for more from the author.
I read this and listened to the audiobook, read by Penny Johnston herself. Both excellent!
January 17, 2023
(Scroll down for a longer review)
This was a lot better than I thought it would be. (Elves are just... really not my thing.)
The good:
- The portrayal of the Maker was really beautiful. I like how the culture in the book talks more of shame and worthiness where ours is more about punishment and mercy. The sacrifice works both ways!
- The family relationships were very cute, and I loved seeing both men and women treat the bonds as important.
- The portrayal of mental problems was very cool. I didn't always get how all of it worked, but the main idea got through and I liked it.
Not so good:
- The "childish" way a certain disabled character talks isn't really accurate to how actual children talk. No idea whether it isn't accurate for disabled people, though.
- Some of the content was a bit too edgy for me, even when the author clearly condemned it. That's just me.
- The romance between two characters felt rather forced.
All in all, I'd recommend this to people who enjoy elf books and adventure.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The following review was originally posted to homeschoolingteen.com
In Kessandra’s world, only an elect few are allowed magic. They are the worthy, and every young elf with magic must make a choice: join the tyrannical elite or be drained of their magic. When Kessandra makes her choice, it has terrible consequences. Her brother Rinnen is devastated and resolves to do whatever it takes to get his sister back. But what can he, a young trainee, do against the mighty clerics?
To Be Called Worthy is a Christian fantasy novel by Penny Johnston. I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review and to be honest I wasn’t expecting much. Elves are not really my thing and new authors usually have a lot to improve upon. Thankfully, the book was a lot better than I thought it would be.
I appreciated the portrayal of the Maker (aka God). It was very beautiful. It was also interesting how the culture of the elves in the book is more interested in shame and worthiness whereas ours is more about punishment and mercy. The great things is: Jesus’ sacrifice works either way! I didn’t think it was a great idea to make the villains be clerics. I know that they, in the end, are clearly shown to not actually be on the Maker’s side, but I feel it perpetuates myths about the negative role of the church throughout history. Some of the content was also a bit too edgy for me, even when the author clearly condemned it. That’s just me, though.
The family relationships in this book were very cute, and I loved seeing both men and women treat the bonds as important. I feel we miss that a lot in books, with people gravitating more towards “found family.” That’s nice, but it’s a lot better when the actual family is being modeled as a good institution. What I liked less when it came to relationships was the romance. It felt rather forced to me, as if the author wanted it to be there but didn’t know exactly how to go about making it so.
Mental problems are portrayed in a very magical way. By that I don’t mean in a glittery way, but in the sense that we can basically take a look inside someone with problems. I’m going to admit I didn’t always get how it worked, but the main idea got through and it was pretty cool. On the other hand, I disliked how a certain mentally disabled character starts talking like a child. The reason I disliked it is because it didn’t actually sound like the speech of a child. Dumbing down grammar and leaving out words, etc. doesn’t automatically make it “childish.” I don’t really know how people with mental disabilities talk, having only met a few of them, but I’m pretty sure they don’t talk that way either.
I would recommend To Be Called Worthy for Christian fantasy lovers. There are plenty of funny, exciting and emotional moments, and the message about forgiveness and elevation through Christ was portrayed well. There are some lesser sides to the book, but that’s normal and they’re not bad enough as to be incredibly distracting. Of course, it’s also a nice way to support indie Christian authors who are trying to make the world of literature a better place.
This was a lot better than I thought it would be. (Elves are just... really not my thing.)
The good:
- The portrayal of the Maker was really beautiful. I like how the culture in the book talks more of shame and worthiness where ours is more about punishment and mercy. The sacrifice works both ways!
- The family relationships were very cute, and I loved seeing both men and women treat the bonds as important.
- The portrayal of mental problems was very cool. I didn't always get how all of it worked, but the main idea got through and I liked it.
Not so good:
- The "childish" way a certain disabled character talks isn't really accurate to how actual children talk. No idea whether it isn't accurate for disabled people, though.
- Some of the content was a bit too edgy for me, even when the author clearly condemned it. That's just me.
- The romance between two characters felt rather forced.
All in all, I'd recommend this to people who enjoy elf books and adventure.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The following review was originally posted to homeschoolingteen.com
In Kessandra’s world, only an elect few are allowed magic. They are the worthy, and every young elf with magic must make a choice: join the tyrannical elite or be drained of their magic. When Kessandra makes her choice, it has terrible consequences. Her brother Rinnen is devastated and resolves to do whatever it takes to get his sister back. But what can he, a young trainee, do against the mighty clerics?
To Be Called Worthy is a Christian fantasy novel by Penny Johnston. I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review and to be honest I wasn’t expecting much. Elves are not really my thing and new authors usually have a lot to improve upon. Thankfully, the book was a lot better than I thought it would be.
I appreciated the portrayal of the Maker (aka God). It was very beautiful. It was also interesting how the culture of the elves in the book is more interested in shame and worthiness whereas ours is more about punishment and mercy. The great things is: Jesus’ sacrifice works either way! I didn’t think it was a great idea to make the villains be clerics. I know that they, in the end, are clearly shown to not actually be on the Maker’s side, but I feel it perpetuates myths about the negative role of the church throughout history. Some of the content was also a bit too edgy for me, even when the author clearly condemned it. That’s just me, though.
The family relationships in this book were very cute, and I loved seeing both men and women treat the bonds as important. I feel we miss that a lot in books, with people gravitating more towards “found family.” That’s nice, but it’s a lot better when the actual family is being modeled as a good institution. What I liked less when it came to relationships was the romance. It felt rather forced to me, as if the author wanted it to be there but didn’t know exactly how to go about making it so.
Mental problems are portrayed in a very magical way. By that I don’t mean in a glittery way, but in the sense that we can basically take a look inside someone with problems. I’m going to admit I didn’t always get how it worked, but the main idea got through and it was pretty cool. On the other hand, I disliked how a certain mentally disabled character starts talking like a child. The reason I disliked it is because it didn’t actually sound like the speech of a child. Dumbing down grammar and leaving out words, etc. doesn’t automatically make it “childish.” I don’t really know how people with mental disabilities talk, having only met a few of them, but I’m pretty sure they don’t talk that way either.
I would recommend To Be Called Worthy for Christian fantasy lovers. There are plenty of funny, exciting and emotional moments, and the message about forgiveness and elevation through Christ was portrayed well. There are some lesser sides to the book, but that’s normal and they’re not bad enough as to be incredibly distracting. Of course, it’s also a nice way to support indie Christian authors who are trying to make the world of literature a better place.
January 19, 2026
Update:
Check out my full review on my journal!
Click here!
Short Review:
Finished my first NEW book for the year! And I LOVED every second of it! (Don't be fooled by the cover. It's a beautiful adventure!)
Check out my full review on my journal!
Click here!
Short Review:
Finished my first NEW book for the year! And I LOVED every second of it! (Don't be fooled by the cover. It's a beautiful adventure!)
September 22, 2024
I enjoyed reading To Be Called Worthy, and quickly became engrossed in this world of elves and magic. My favorite character was Rinnen, the one who always felt he had to be strong and right and responsible for his broken sister. The concept of clerics gone bad was a good one, and I was rooting for the Free in the snow lands to join the fight.
I do feel that the author could have gone a little further with this. The ending tied up loose ends and was good, but it was a bit anticlimactic. The world created in To Be Called Worthy is wonderful, and I would love to revisit it if there are future stories written in it. But the last few chapters were a bit of a letdown after getting so emotionally invested in the beginning and middle of the journey.
Overall a good read, and I do look forward to more works from Penny Johnston.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily
I do feel that the author could have gone a little further with this. The ending tied up loose ends and was good, but it was a bit anticlimactic. The world created in To Be Called Worthy is wonderful, and I would love to revisit it if there are future stories written in it. But the last few chapters were a bit of a letdown after getting so emotionally invested in the beginning and middle of the journey.
Overall a good read, and I do look forward to more works from Penny Johnston.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily
Displaying 1 - 25 of 25 reviews