This is the third volume of McManus’ trilogy relating the history of the US Army in the Pacific during WWII, and the “slimmest” of the three since there were really only two US Army battles of note in 1945 – the invasions of Luzon and Okinawa. Iwo Jima was a Marine Corps affair and thus mentioned in contextual passing, albeit with admiration and respect. There is a ‘sameness’ that characterizes McManus’ battle narratives across all three volumes. He writes with perception and a comprehensive knowledge of the sequences of a battle, the predicate conditions leading up to it and the strategic and tactical issues involving it. He is excellent describing and assessing the leadership on both sides, US and Japanese, in terms of personalities, character strengths and weaknesses, and performance under pressure – and for several, under fire. That is compelling and absorbing history.
Then he fleshes out each battle or campaign with extensive description of what it was like there, on the ground, for the combat soldier himself... and that is where the ‘sameness’ comes in, a dejà vu reading experience. He goes on at length describing the heat, the rain, the jungle (or the coral rock as the battles moved north of the equator), the diseases, the lack of sanitation, the mud, the malnutrition, the fatigue, death and decay, the stench of decomposition, the proliferation of corpses and the existential horror, the deaths and wounds and dismemberments... and in this segment of the telling, each battle or campaign is indistinguishable from any other one. What becomes patently apparent is that combat in the Pacific was horrific, and the scale of suffering and sacrifice was immense.
Of course, in this book focused on 1945, there are fewer battles to write about – only Luzon and Okinawa, really. The Luzon campaign is notable for the immensity of the US forces employed, but the narrative of the campaign is more of the “same” – it is interesting, but somewhat pedestrian in the telling, as perhaps could be said of the actual campaign. McManus’ narrative of Okinawa is stellar – you could argue it alone makes the book worth buying, especially when coupled with his chapter on the Japanese surrender and its implementation – also stellar, engrossing, fascinating. Of course, about halfway through the Okinawa chapter he again expounds on the experience of combat in the battle, and he again descends into that aura of ‘sameness’... a horrific experience, but indistinguishable in the narrative from all previous battles in the descriptions and accounts.
As mentioned above, McManus has a superb ability to examine and assess the various generals, admirals and support officers (both staff and combat leaders) that is exceptional, and exceptionally good reading. However, in the 1945 campaigns that are the focus of this book, the primary characters are unchanged from previous books – MacArthur, Nimitz (in passing – this is an Army book~!), Krueger, Eichelberger, Sutherland – leaving little new ground to plow for the reader. In fact, whereas McManus was rightly and severely critical of MacArthur’s enormous flaws of character, vanity, personal motivation and egocentric motivations, subordination of the larger war to his individual megalomaniacal ambitions, in this book he mentions those criticisms relatively briefly while going to greater lengths to applaud MacArthur as a gifted and effective leader. I am not sure that squares with reality – MacArthur was blessed with talented, effective and dedicated combat leaders in Krueger and Eichelberger (although he took personal credit for their successes), and he isolated himself from his troops and surrounded himself with sycophantic toadies who gratified his ego. Just like before. However, I do agree that MacArthur deserves enormous credit for his handling and implementation of the Japanese surrender, and subsequently for his handling of conquered Japan as Supreme Leader of the occupation. MacArthur deserves credit for the emergence of a modern Japan characterized by representative government, economic success and staunch alliance with the US. No small achievement, that.
One other aspect of the book bears mention – McManus goes off on flights of narrative impulse in between campaigns. He describes at length the immense logistical prowess of the US, trailing combat operations with vast stores of ammo, supplies, food, and conveniences building bases replete with recreational facilities, ice cream plants, PX stores and all the small luxuries and conveniences of American largess. Then he details at length life in liberated Manila – bars, prostitutes, black market economies – and a lengthy exposition on venereal disease rates and countermeasures - not sure how that augments the larger purpose of the book. He offers a lengthy and moving discussion of the POW experience as endured by Allied personnel at the hands of the Japanese. The death rate ran to 37%... terrible, outrageous and barbaric. And then finally, he offers an Epilog that relates the post-war histories of many of the principles of the Pacific War years. It is moving, interesting and a fitting end to this overall superb work of history.