What do you think?
Rate this book
Midnight in Manhattan #4
She'll Steal Your Heart
A thief seeking redemption forms an unlikely connection with a former lawyer looking for a fresh start of her own, but what starts as friendship soon feels like much more…
Last year, Lauren Booker fled New York with a warrant out for her arrest. Now she’s back and ready to make amends for her crime. She wants to rebuild her life, and Brooklyn is home. There’s not much waiting for her here now, though, nothing except an online friend who’s brought her so much joy during one of the hardest years of her life. When they finally meet in person, Lauren’s unprepared for her attraction to Mia, but she’s even less prepared to discover that Mia has an unexpected connection to her crime, putting Lauren’s plans in jeopardy.
Mia Solano has also had a difficult year. Recently divorced, she walked away from her legal career after a health scare caused her to reexamine her priorities. Now Mia owns a cat café, and she’s struggling to adjust to a slower pace of life. She finds an unlikely friend in Lauren, but Lauren’s legal troubles force Mia to revisit a part of her life she’s trying to leave behind. She can’t explain why she’s so drawn to Lauren. They shouldn’t have much in common, and yet, they just seem to click.
As the connection between them strengthens, Lauren and Mia wrestle with growing feelings, but neither wants to risk their friendship by crossing that line. With Lauren’s court date looming ever closer, they might lose everything, including each other.
Last year, Lauren Booker fled New York with a warrant out for her arrest. Now she’s back and ready to make amends for her crime. She wants to rebuild her life, and Brooklyn is home. There’s not much waiting for her here now, though, nothing except an online friend who’s brought her so much joy during one of the hardest years of her life. When they finally meet in person, Lauren’s unprepared for her attraction to Mia, but she’s even less prepared to discover that Mia has an unexpected connection to her crime, putting Lauren’s plans in jeopardy.
Mia Solano has also had a difficult year. Recently divorced, she walked away from her legal career after a health scare caused her to reexamine her priorities. Now Mia owns a cat café, and she’s struggling to adjust to a slower pace of life. She finds an unlikely friend in Lauren, but Lauren’s legal troubles force Mia to revisit a part of her life she’s trying to leave behind. She can’t explain why she’s so drawn to Lauren. They shouldn’t have much in common, and yet, they just seem to click.
As the connection between them strengthens, Lauren and Mia wrestle with growing feelings, but neither wants to risk their friendship by crossing that line. With Lauren’s court date looming ever closer, they might lose everything, including each other.
320 pages, Kindle Edition
First published October 19, 2022
161 people are currently reading
1078 people want to read
About the author
Rachel Lacey
37 books2,344 followersRachel Lacey is an award-winning contemporary romance author and semi-reformed travel junkie. She's been climbed by a monkey on a mountain in Japan, gone scuba diving on the Great Barrier Reef, and camped out overnight in New York City for a chance to be an extra in a movie. These days, the majority of her adventures take place on the pages of the books she writes. She lives in the mountains of Vermont with her family and a variety of rescue pets.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews
October 28, 2022
Okay, let’s be clear from the beginning: this book not only stole my heart, it also stole my breath. Which is exactly what I look for in books. God, the longing. The pining. Feelings, people, so many feelings. Also, collarbones. Hot.
If you’ve read the first book in the Midnight in Manhattan series, Don’t Cry for Me, you already know Lauren Booker. If you haven’t, close this page and go get the book, you’re about to be spoiled. She’ll Steal Your Heart is set a year after Lauren disappeared. She’s finally coming back to Manhattan to make things right. But first, she’ll allow herself one carefree weekend, meeting online friends IRL for the first time, binging the new season of the show that brought them together, In Her Defense, starring Piper Sheridan from Come Away With Me (book 3). One of these friends is a bit older than the rest of the group, a bit less of a fangirl. Mia Solano, whose marriage ended after eighteen years, also quit her job as a lawyer after a burnout and is now the owner of a cat café.
Lauren and Mia are so lovely, so perfect for each other that my heart is all soft and warm and every corny feeling you can think of. She’ll Steal Your Heart is the perfect book to conclude the Midnight in Manhattan series, with references to all the previous ones and more.
On a personal note, just like Piper’s panic attacks in Come Away with Me felt very real to me, I can relate all too well to Mia’s post-burnout anxiety. “What if I fall back into old habits?” is a question I ask my therapist (and my wife) at least once a month. It’s been seven years and I still miss the adrenaline of the job I loved but felt was killing me. So yeah, I understand Mia’s fears and know how important it is to know you have unconditional support from the woman you love when faced with hard choices.
As for Lauren, despite all the hardship she has had to endure, she’s not bitter, not blasé, she has hope in the future and in humanity and it could be too much but it simply works. She and Mia are two women looking for a second chance at life, not so much at love, even though they’ll get that as well, but at fulfilling who they know they can be. It’s inspiring, it’s exciting, it brought me so much joy because even though I know it’s fiction, Lacey writes it in a way that is also very relatable.
On top of cameos by characters from previous books, there are a few new secondary characters, some of which I wouldn’t mind reading more about, and, as always in Rachel Lacey’s books, cats that will, too, steal your heart. Lots of cats, including a very shy one I would have loved to meet for real. Thanks to all these cats, I didn’t have to think long about what I wanted on the graphic for this review (if you're reading this review on a platform that won't let me share the image, go to my blog for the real deal). Ginny is always trying to help and this time, she got to stay. Which made both of us happy.
If there weren’t so many promising books being released all the time, I’d probably would have reread this one right away. I’ll just have to wait a few months for the audiobook to come out and give me an excuse to enjoy this story and the characters for a bit longer.
I received a copy from the publisher and I am voluntarily leaving a review.
Read all my reviews on my blog (and please buy from the affiliation links!): Jude in the Stars
January 10, 2024
5⭐️
I listened to this audiobook, narrated by the amazing Lori Prince.
A year ago, Lauren Booker did a hugely stupid thing (see book #1 Don't Cry for Me) and fled Brooklyn to avoid arrest. Now she's back with a plan to put things right as best she can, take responsibility, and face the consequences. But first, she wants to spend a weekend without worries. She meets up with online friends who are meeting up for the first time IRL to watch the latest season of the series "In Her Defense", starring Piper Sheridan from book #3.
Mia Solano is a former lawyer who now runs a cat cafe after the pursuit of a career ruined her marriage and nearly ruined her health. She's still struggling to find her footing in her new slower-paced life. She belongs to the group of online friends. Lauren, however, has known her for a long time, as she exchanges ideas with her about the fan fiction Lauren writes based on "In Her Defense".
Even after her stupid action in book #1, once Lauren showed her true, caring personality, she quickly grew on me. Life was often hard on her, but she fought her way back repeatedly, which impressed me. She showed sincere remorse, a willingness to help, compassion, and an irrepressible will to make things right.
It is a wonderful, heart-warming story about second chances in life and love. About trust, friendship, flaws and stupid decisions, forgiveness and ultimately finding happiness. But as we know, getting there is not always easy. The problems and fears are real and I could empathize with Mia and Lauren, even though I've luckily never suffered a burnout and never committed a crime. The attraction and chemistry between the two is palpable, the romance sweet, but so is the fear of losing their friendship or being rejected.
And who must not be forgotten are the four-legged supporting characters, the cats like Mia's Lola, and the furry friends to adopt. I would have loved to adopt Gilbert myself.
A slow-burn romance, as always with Rachel Lacey, written with a lot of emotion, good dialog, and humor.
By the way, meeting online friends IRL can be very exciting, I know what I'm talking about, last September I met up with my nine book club friends from all over the world for the first time after three and a half years of chatting online, and it was amazing.
I highly recommend the whole series, preferably in the right order, as the MCs also make guest appearances in the other books.
I listened to this audiobook, narrated by the amazing Lori Prince.
A year ago, Lauren Booker did a hugely stupid thing (see book #1 Don't Cry for Me) and fled Brooklyn to avoid arrest. Now she's back with a plan to put things right as best she can, take responsibility, and face the consequences. But first, she wants to spend a weekend without worries. She meets up with online friends who are meeting up for the first time IRL to watch the latest season of the series "In Her Defense", starring Piper Sheridan from book #3.
Mia Solano is a former lawyer who now runs a cat cafe after the pursuit of a career ruined her marriage and nearly ruined her health. She's still struggling to find her footing in her new slower-paced life. She belongs to the group of online friends. Lauren, however, has known her for a long time, as she exchanges ideas with her about the fan fiction Lauren writes based on "In Her Defense".
Even after her stupid action in book #1, once Lauren showed her true, caring personality, she quickly grew on me. Life was often hard on her, but she fought her way back repeatedly, which impressed me. She showed sincere remorse, a willingness to help, compassion, and an irrepressible will to make things right.
It is a wonderful, heart-warming story about second chances in life and love. About trust, friendship, flaws and stupid decisions, forgiveness and ultimately finding happiness. But as we know, getting there is not always easy. The problems and fears are real and I could empathize with Mia and Lauren, even though I've luckily never suffered a burnout and never committed a crime. The attraction and chemistry between the two is palpable, the romance sweet, but so is the fear of losing their friendship or being rejected.
And who must not be forgotten are the four-legged supporting characters, the cats like Mia's Lola, and the furry friends to adopt. I would have loved to adopt Gilbert myself.
A slow-burn romance, as always with Rachel Lacey, written with a lot of emotion, good dialog, and humor.
By the way, meeting online friends IRL can be very exciting, I know what I'm talking about, last September I met up with my nine book club friends from all over the world for the first time after three and a half years of chatting online, and it was amazing.
I highly recommend the whole series, preferably in the right order, as the MCs also make guest appearances in the other books.
November 8, 2022
Wonderful conclusion to this series and all the MCs from the previous books are also a part of this book.
I enjoyed the two MCs personalities and their development very much.
Especially Lauren had to overcome her criminal past to embrace a better future and Mia is right by her side the whole time. And also Mia had to revaluate some choices she made in the past.
It’s a very well written friends-to-lovers age-gap romance.
Highly recommend.
I enjoyed the two MCs personalities and their development very much.
Especially Lauren had to overcome her criminal past to embrace a better future and Mia is right by her side the whole time. And also Mia had to revaluate some choices she made in the past.
It’s a very well written friends-to-lovers age-gap romance.
Highly recommend.
November 29, 2022
Lauren Booker did not endear herself to me with her appearance in book one of this series, Don’t Cry for Me. She upset my girl, Josie, and I don’t forgive anyone who does that. I knew Rachel Lacey would work her magic and I would end up forgiving her, but I didn’t expect that she would touch my heart more than any of Rachel’s other characters. Maybe it’s because we have something very painful in common or it may just be because I love how Lauren is determined to make things right. And given how life has continuously knocked her down, I appreciate how she keeps getting back up and moving forward.
Mia Solano is also at a crossroads. She recently left her successful law career, got divorced and opened a cat cafe. She knows she needs to get back to living and meets up with her online friends to watch the new season of their favorite show. Mia is pretty perfect. I love how she carries herself and the calm she projects, even if internally her mind is racing. What impresses me the most about Mia is how she looks beyond Lauren’s issues and really “sees” her.
With She’ll Steal your Heart, Rachel Lacey continues to show why she is so successful and one of our best writers. In Lauren, she gives us a character I will be thinking about for quite a while. She is flawed but given her history, the fact she is still standing, shows the strength she has inside. Rachel writes her characters with such care, as if they are fragile friends, she just wants to hold close. The romance that develops is years in the making, while the two chat online about their favorite tv show and Mia reads Lauren’s fanfic. They share details about their lives and when they finally meet, the feelings that have been developing over years evolve so naturally.
This is the fourth book in the series and it was lovely to see some familiar faces make appearances. While I have a special place in my heart for Don’t Cry for Me, this is my favorite of the series. It made me tear up several times because things hit a bit close to home but more than anything it made me feel hopeful and it made me smile a lot. I love to see characters overcome adversity to find happiness and experience growth both individually and as a couple. This is a book I will revisit many times.
An ARC was received from the author for an honest review.
Mia Solano is also at a crossroads. She recently left her successful law career, got divorced and opened a cat cafe. She knows she needs to get back to living and meets up with her online friends to watch the new season of their favorite show. Mia is pretty perfect. I love how she carries herself and the calm she projects, even if internally her mind is racing. What impresses me the most about Mia is how she looks beyond Lauren’s issues and really “sees” her.
With She’ll Steal your Heart, Rachel Lacey continues to show why she is so successful and one of our best writers. In Lauren, she gives us a character I will be thinking about for quite a while. She is flawed but given her history, the fact she is still standing, shows the strength she has inside. Rachel writes her characters with such care, as if they are fragile friends, she just wants to hold close. The romance that develops is years in the making, while the two chat online about their favorite tv show and Mia reads Lauren’s fanfic. They share details about their lives and when they finally meet, the feelings that have been developing over years evolve so naturally.
This is the fourth book in the series and it was lovely to see some familiar faces make appearances. While I have a special place in my heart for Don’t Cry for Me, this is my favorite of the series. It made me tear up several times because things hit a bit close to home but more than anything it made me feel hopeful and it made me smile a lot. I love to see characters overcome adversity to find happiness and experience growth both individually and as a couple. This is a book I will revisit many times.
An ARC was received from the author for an honest review.
November 8, 2022
Kindle Unlimited.
This is a great solid lesfic series. In this one there are quite a few references to the previous couples from the series - and the MC here had featured slightly in book 1 for a time - So I would recommend reading them in order, I do believe they are all available on KU.
This installment was just as excellent as the others. I love that in this series the women have realistic and relatable issues but actually work on them and TALK about them! The communication is perfect and exactly what I want from my romances. I very much dislike miscommunication and needless drama, and these don't do that - so if you're like me and want more substance and realism in your lesfic romance stories, give this series a try!!!
This installment features an age-gap, Lauren is 29 and had a past in foster care that made her grow up quickly but lonely, and a little brother who had issues that she tried to take care of. She's alone now, but has regrets and past mistakes she is coming back to Brooklyn to atone for.
We meet Mia, 42, who had been married for a long time and was overworking herself in her law career. She now owns and runs a cat cafe, and is doing a lot better physically and mentally, but still feels something missing.
The two women form a lovely connection and supportive friendship that leads to more. It was just nice to see them get that chance at happiness with one another and get that healthy supportive relationship that they deserved with each other.
Very swoon-worthy, and just ticks all the right boxes for romance. Highly Recommend this entire series.
This is a great solid lesfic series. In this one there are quite a few references to the previous couples from the series - and the MC here had featured slightly in book 1 for a time - So I would recommend reading them in order, I do believe they are all available on KU.
This installment was just as excellent as the others. I love that in this series the women have realistic and relatable issues but actually work on them and TALK about them! The communication is perfect and exactly what I want from my romances. I very much dislike miscommunication and needless drama, and these don't do that - so if you're like me and want more substance and realism in your lesfic romance stories, give this series a try!!!
This installment features an age-gap, Lauren is 29 and had a past in foster care that made her grow up quickly but lonely, and a little brother who had issues that she tried to take care of. She's alone now, but has regrets and past mistakes she is coming back to Brooklyn to atone for.
We meet Mia, 42, who had been married for a long time and was overworking herself in her law career. She now owns and runs a cat cafe, and is doing a lot better physically and mentally, but still feels something missing.
The two women form a lovely connection and supportive friendship that leads to more. It was just nice to see them get that chance at happiness with one another and get that healthy supportive relationship that they deserved with each other.
Very swoon-worthy, and just ticks all the right boxes for romance. Highly Recommend this entire series.
November 7, 2022
This was a lovely age gap romance. My first by this author.
I’ll definitely be checking out her other books.
I’ll definitely be checking out her other books.
November 12, 2023
ETA: audiobook re-read; just as great if not better and improved by Lori Prince’s performance!
~~~~~
Awww I loved this. I’m sad to see this series end, bc I’ve rlly loved all of it. But I can’t wait to re-read it all when the rest come out in audiobook form, I can already picture some of Lori Prince’s performance for some of these and I can’t wait to see how it plays out.
This one was lovely. Not quite what I expected it to be, but I rlly enjoyed myself. Both Mia and Lauren are super lovable and easy to root for, and I loved the slow burn pace of their dynamic of merging from friends to lovers. And i LOVED the little bits of cameos we got from all the other couples in the series. Especially Josie and Eve, I think they are still my favs overall and seeing them rlly get their happy ending was adorable, esp with how full circle Lauren’s role is in it.
I can’t rec this series enough and I already can’t wait to re read it. Def one of my fav sapphic series out there I think.
~~~~~
Awww I loved this. I’m sad to see this series end, bc I’ve rlly loved all of it. But I can’t wait to re-read it all when the rest come out in audiobook form, I can already picture some of Lori Prince’s performance for some of these and I can’t wait to see how it plays out.
This one was lovely. Not quite what I expected it to be, but I rlly enjoyed myself. Both Mia and Lauren are super lovable and easy to root for, and I loved the slow burn pace of their dynamic of merging from friends to lovers. And i LOVED the little bits of cameos we got from all the other couples in the series. Especially Josie and Eve, I think they are still my favs overall and seeing them rlly get their happy ending was adorable, esp with how full circle Lauren’s role is in it.
I can’t rec this series enough and I already can’t wait to re read it. Def one of my fav sapphic series out there I think.
October 29, 2022
I always wonder what the deal is with Lauren in Don't Cry for Me; the robbery seems so out of the blue. So I am happy we have her redemption in the final book of Midnight in Manhattan's series. Although it is not what I expected of Lauren's redemption. It's fluffy and low angsty. Overall, it makes you feel good and smile the whole time. It's the perfect ending for this series.
November 20, 2022
This is the conclusion of the Midnight in Manhattan series, while all the books could be read as standalone I would advise on reading them in order. Actually for this book I’d say it is necessary.
We’ve met Lauren in Don’t Cry for Me, the first book in the series, and let’s just say she didn’t leave the best of impressions, she was a bit of a villain. So, that raises the question, can a villain be redeemed? I’d say they could, but only if the author does it the right way. Lacey does it the way it’s supposed to. She humanises Lauren, gives her a good backstory, and redemption story. Not to mention Mia, a former lawyer and now cat cafe owner. She is recovering from a burn out and getting over her divorce of her wife of 18 years. These beautifully flawed humans connect because of fanfic that Lauren wrote about a show they adore. The show that Piper from Come Away with Me plays the lead in. This is how we check in with yet another couple of the series, our Broadway stars also make an appearance in the cat cafe. Oh and did I mention the cats? Rachel Lacey writes the most adorable cats! I really liked the shy one in this book, I would like to adopt him.
This book is emotional and lovely. The way the author writes about recovering from a burn out seems like it is so real. Lauren dealing with her charges, her loss and getting her life in order, it’s so real and heartwarming and maybe even a bit heartbreaking. The longing between these friends, oh my it is just endless and amazing!
This is a great end to a lovely series. All the couples have a check in, we get a lot of cats and so many happy endings. I’m even a little sad to see this series come to an end, however great it may be, I’ll miss these characters. I’d say it’s a job well done by Rachel Lacey.
We’ve met Lauren in Don’t Cry for Me, the first book in the series, and let’s just say she didn’t leave the best of impressions, she was a bit of a villain. So, that raises the question, can a villain be redeemed? I’d say they could, but only if the author does it the right way. Lacey does it the way it’s supposed to. She humanises Lauren, gives her a good backstory, and redemption story. Not to mention Mia, a former lawyer and now cat cafe owner. She is recovering from a burn out and getting over her divorce of her wife of 18 years. These beautifully flawed humans connect because of fanfic that Lauren wrote about a show they adore. The show that Piper from Come Away with Me plays the lead in. This is how we check in with yet another couple of the series, our Broadway stars also make an appearance in the cat cafe. Oh and did I mention the cats? Rachel Lacey writes the most adorable cats! I really liked the shy one in this book, I would like to adopt him.
This book is emotional and lovely. The way the author writes about recovering from a burn out seems like it is so real. Lauren dealing with her charges, her loss and getting her life in order, it’s so real and heartwarming and maybe even a bit heartbreaking. The longing between these friends, oh my it is just endless and amazing!
This is a great end to a lovely series. All the couples have a check in, we get a lot of cats and so many happy endings. I’m even a little sad to see this series come to an end, however great it may be, I’ll miss these characters. I’d say it’s a job well done by Rachel Lacey.
October 22, 2022
So many amazing things to say about She’ll Steal Your Heart. First off, Lauren and Mia were perfect. The sparks, you could literally feel them - they were that intense. Second, Mia’s cat cafe sounds like a dream. And finally, I absolutely loved the way the other books in the series were tied into this story. Between Lauren, Mia and their friends geeking out about In Her Defense and Lauren writing fanfic, and then Josie and Eve too, so good. What a perfect way to end the series. Highly recommend reading all of the books in the Midnight in Manhattan series and doing so in order.
Thank you to Rachel Lacey for reaching out and providing the arc for an honest review!
Thank you to Rachel Lacey for reaching out and providing the arc for an honest review!
November 25, 2022
I absolutely loved She'll Steal Your Heart, what more apt title for a book. Lauren did steal my heart and I kept cheering for her throughout the pages.
Talk about redeeming a character? Woah! She's now one of my fav characters of the whole Manhattan series.
She'll Steal Your Heart has so many tropes in it that it will appeal to anyone. From friends to lovers, coming back to town, forced proximity... it has it all!
I particularly enjoyed the whole fandom theme, the big group of online friends meeting in real life for the first time, and the zoom-in in the life of an indie self-published author... and the Twitter community? Fingers crossed on this!
Lauren deserved a second chance, she has made mistakes but her heart is in the right place. She's a society made caregiver, always doing what's best for the others and forgetting herself, and I was so happy when she met Mia and found finally a safe harbor.
Lauren and Mia complete each other on so many levels. Mia finally believes in love again and is not alone anymore, and Lauren has found her way through life.
The cameos of Sophie and Jules, Josie and Eve, and Chloe and Piper were the cherry on top!
I adored that all the novels of the series were filled with pets, and especially cats.
Lola... made me laugh out loud... and not only the cat version... but also you know what!
5 stars at least! Mia... hot lawyer... oef!!! 🤣
Talk about redeeming a character? Woah! She's now one of my fav characters of the whole Manhattan series.
She'll Steal Your Heart has so many tropes in it that it will appeal to anyone. From friends to lovers, coming back to town, forced proximity... it has it all!
I particularly enjoyed the whole fandom theme, the big group of online friends meeting in real life for the first time, and the zoom-in in the life of an indie self-published author... and the Twitter community? Fingers crossed on this!
Lauren deserved a second chance, she has made mistakes but her heart is in the right place. She's a society made caregiver, always doing what's best for the others and forgetting herself, and I was so happy when she met Mia and found finally a safe harbor.
Lauren and Mia complete each other on so many levels. Mia finally believes in love again and is not alone anymore, and Lauren has found her way through life.
The cameos of Sophie and Jules, Josie and Eve, and Chloe and Piper were the cherry on top!
I adored that all the novels of the series were filled with pets, and especially cats.
Lola... made me laugh out loud... and not only the cat version... but also you know what!
5 stars at least! Mia... hot lawyer... oef!!! 🤣
February 4, 2024
I think I’ve realized why I love Rachel Lacey’s books so much: they make me feel safe. Lacey treats her characters’ emotions with the utmost amount of care, so much that I myself feel taken care of. Plus, the romances are just so freaking good: the sweetness and tenderness are just off the charts!
With She’ll Steal Your Heart, Lacey has absolutely outdone herself. Watching Mia and Lauren fall in love was one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever experienced. Lauren stole my heart from the very first page. I felt so much for her: how she navigated setbacks in life and how she worked hard to build herself back up. And MIA! Oh my word, I definitely have a crush on Mia. She’s a slightly intimidating, no-nonsense woman who says the *loveliest* things (I’m swooning), and the way she became a safe space for Lauren just had me drenched in the feels.
I loved the role fandom played in the book, since I’m very familiar with how a shared love of media can bring people together as friends or as lovers. I also, of course, adored the cat cafe setting, because cute animals are my jam. 😻 And that epilogue was basically everything I could have ever wanted! What a great way to end this wonderful series.
So yeah. 5+ stars for this one!
With She’ll Steal Your Heart, Lacey has absolutely outdone herself. Watching Mia and Lauren fall in love was one of the most beautiful things I’ve ever experienced. Lauren stole my heart from the very first page. I felt so much for her: how she navigated setbacks in life and how she worked hard to build herself back up. And MIA! Oh my word, I definitely have a crush on Mia. She’s a slightly intimidating, no-nonsense woman who says the *loveliest* things (I’m swooning), and the way she became a safe space for Lauren just had me drenched in the feels.
I loved the role fandom played in the book, since I’m very familiar with how a shared love of media can bring people together as friends or as lovers. I also, of course, adored the cat cafe setting, because cute animals are my jam. 😻 And that epilogue was basically everything I could have ever wanted! What a great way to end this wonderful series.
So yeah. 5+ stars for this one!
August 17, 2024
4.5
This book is definitely my favorite in the series. Lauren and Mia’s relationship was so well-developed, transitioning smoothly from friends to something much deeper. I really appreciated how mature they were in focusing on their own growth before fully committing to each other. The way they supported each other through their personal challenges and ended up in such a fulfilling, happy relationship was beautifully done.
The ending gave all the characters in the Midnight in Manhattan series a really satisfying happily ever after.
This book is definitely my favorite in the series. Lauren and Mia’s relationship was so well-developed, transitioning smoothly from friends to something much deeper. I really appreciated how mature they were in focusing on their own growth before fully committing to each other. The way they supported each other through their personal challenges and ended up in such a fulfilling, happy relationship was beautifully done.
The ending gave all the characters in the Midnight in Manhattan series a really satisfying happily ever after.
November 17, 2022
This, in a lot of ways, really is the climax of the series in all respects.
November 20, 2025
I adore this series.
I love all the characters and I'm happy we got to see all of them again in this one.
I could read 3000 pages more about all of them.
In this one the fact that Lauren was such a huge fan of Piper (from book 3) and the character she plays and how she was writing smutty fanfics about her character was very very cringe and made me uncomfortable.
Because of that I really didn't enjoy the first 20% and a few scenes throughout.
I also feel like that was very unnecessary and didn't really add much to the story.
Another thing that bothered me was that they were talking about spending Thanksgiving with Mias dad, Lauren was very anxious about it and then we didn't even get to read about it, why make such a big deal about it if you're not even going to write about how it went?
But besides that I don't really have any complaints.
I've loved basically all the books Rachel Lacey has written and I'm excited to read the ones I haven't yet red.
I love all the characters and I'm happy we got to see all of them again in this one.
I could read 3000 pages more about all of them.
In this one the fact that Lauren was such a huge fan of Piper (from book 3) and the character she plays and how she was writing smutty fanfics about her character was very very cringe and made me uncomfortable.
Because of that I really didn't enjoy the first 20% and a few scenes throughout.
I also feel like that was very unnecessary and didn't really add much to the story.
Another thing that bothered me was that they were talking about spending Thanksgiving with Mias dad, Lauren was very anxious about it and then we didn't even get to read about it, why make such a big deal about it if you're not even going to write about how it went?
But besides that I don't really have any complaints.
I've loved basically all the books Rachel Lacey has written and I'm excited to read the ones I haven't yet red.
September 10, 2023
OH MY GOD! I absolutely love this entire series and She’ll Steal Your Heart could not have been a more perfect ending! This is officially one of my all time favorite series and is one that I see myself rereading in the future (probably more than once). I loved every book in this series but She’ll Steal Your Heart might possibly be my favorite (it’s a close call between this one and Don’t Cry For Me). It was a second chance story, but not in terms of romance. Both main characters, Lauren Booker and Mia Solano, are trying to get a fresh start in life and in many ways start over - but for very different reasons.
Lauren is trying to make amends for her past mistakes and take responsibility for them after having been on the run for a year, while also dealing with the recent death of her brother. Mia recently got divorced and went from being a powerful attorney to a cat cafe owner. I related a lot with Mia’s character and the overwhelming existential crisis that comes from multiple life changes happening all at once.
Mia and Lauren are in a group of online friends that met because of Lauren’s sapphic fanfic for In Her Defense (from book 3, Come Away with Me), finally meeting in person to celebrate the new season. When Mia discovers Lauren’s secret about her past, she decides to help her-both legally and with a job.
Their friendship is so pure and endearing and just warms your heart. Mia worries that she’s too old. Lauren worries that her life is too much of a mess. They both worry about ruining the friendship thinking they must be the only one having these feelings. But as their friendship continues to grow, those feelings get harder to ignore. Their relationship is both sweet and sexy and I adore them. They truly are perfect for each other.
And the ending! I won’t share spoilers, but OMG! So many surprises, so much love, all the feels! 🥹😍🥰🥳
Also, Lori Prince is fantastic! Her narration for this whole series was incredible and very consistent! She is definitely one of the greats in my book! Do the audiobooks if you can. But PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE - read this series! It is sooo good!
Lauren is trying to make amends for her past mistakes and take responsibility for them after having been on the run for a year, while also dealing with the recent death of her brother. Mia recently got divorced and went from being a powerful attorney to a cat cafe owner. I related a lot with Mia’s character and the overwhelming existential crisis that comes from multiple life changes happening all at once.
Mia and Lauren are in a group of online friends that met because of Lauren’s sapphic fanfic for In Her Defense (from book 3, Come Away with Me), finally meeting in person to celebrate the new season. When Mia discovers Lauren’s secret about her past, she decides to help her-both legally and with a job.
Their friendship is so pure and endearing and just warms your heart. Mia worries that she’s too old. Lauren worries that her life is too much of a mess. They both worry about ruining the friendship thinking they must be the only one having these feelings. But as their friendship continues to grow, those feelings get harder to ignore. Their relationship is both sweet and sexy and I adore them. They truly are perfect for each other.
And the ending! I won’t share spoilers, but OMG! So many surprises, so much love, all the feels! 🥹😍🥰🥳
Also, Lori Prince is fantastic! Her narration for this whole series was incredible and very consistent! She is definitely one of the greats in my book! Do the audiobooks if you can. But PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE - read this series! It is sooo good!
March 18, 2023
She'll Steal Your Heart
I love the depth of this book by Rachel Lacey. I enjoyed this series very much and will be rereading the entire series again. I love the references to previous characters from the other books. Its great to see a snap shot in their lives. I look forward to more books by this author in the future.
I love the depth of this book by Rachel Lacey. I enjoyed this series very much and will be rereading the entire series again. I love the references to previous characters from the other books. Its great to see a snap shot in their lives. I look forward to more books by this author in the future.
May 13, 2024
3.5 star rating
Great lessons and an enjoyable romance alongside
Great lessons and an enjoyable romance alongside
December 11, 2023
This dragged a little for me. Also, the beginning of the story was so deeply connected to the fandom world (nothing wrong with it per se), which I just personally don't really like.
The epilogue was incredibly cheesy, but, surprisingly, I loved it.
I'm really grateful for this series and the much needed distraction all of these stories provided.
The epilogue was incredibly cheesy, but, surprisingly, I loved it.
I'm really grateful for this series and the much needed distraction all of these stories provided.
January 7, 2023
FTC DISCLAIMER: I RECEIVED AN E-ARC FROM THE PUBLISHER THROUGH ONE OF A VARIETY OF SOURCES. I VOLUNTARILY OFFER MY HONEST REVIEW OF THE BOOK, THOUGH IT IS NOT EXPECTED OF ME! RECEIPT OF THIS BOOK IN THIS MANNER DOES NOT AFFECT MY OPINION OF THE BOOK OR THE CONTENT OF MY REVIEW!
This book, by far, was my favorite of the series!!! I loved the redemption story arc, and the tenderness between the two heroines in this story! Having read the previous books in the series over a year ago, I thought I would be lost by such a secondary character taking center stage, but I was happily, very wrong about that!! Ms. Lacey did an excellent job of putting details into the story that were logical to have in this current read, but were also reminders of what had happened previously in the series. In that way, it came off as a totally fresh read, and not a rehashing of events to catch folks up. This one actually made me want to read, during a depressive time where I've been in a reading slump! I'm sad to see these characters and this series go, but what a way to send them off!!
This book, by far, was my favorite of the series!!! I loved the redemption story arc, and the tenderness between the two heroines in this story! Having read the previous books in the series over a year ago, I thought I would be lost by such a secondary character taking center stage, but I was happily, very wrong about that!! Ms. Lacey did an excellent job of putting details into the story that were logical to have in this current read, but were also reminders of what had happened previously in the series. In that way, it came off as a totally fresh read, and not a rehashing of events to catch folks up. This one actually made me want to read, during a depressive time where I've been in a reading slump! I'm sad to see these characters and this series go, but what a way to send them off!!
May 29, 2023
Proper gooey emotional stuff. This book is chock full of callbacks to the previous three books in the series, most of which I entirely failed to notice. In other words, you don’t need to read the other books first, your heart will still be stolen.
April 8, 2024
A beautiful mix of characters and locales. Loved the cat theme and the chance at redemption for a bad decision made in the spur of the moment, coupled with meaningful character growth, and true love.
October 30, 2022
Super excellent book
I loved this story so much. My heart went out to Lauren and I embraced the idea of her and Mia and just loved it.
I loved this story so much. My heart went out to Lauren and I embraced the idea of her and Mia and just loved it.
November 1, 2022
She’ll Steal Your Heart might be my favorite book in the Midnight in Manhattan series. It follows two online friends who meet in person to celebrate a new season of the show that brought them together. Mia is an ex-lawyer who runs a cat cafe and Lauren is returning to Brooklyn after being away for a year. Both women come with baggage, Mia is recently divorced and went through a career change, and Lauren is looking to make amends for robbing Josie in Don’t Cry For Me (the first book in the series) and not go to jail. Mia agrees to help Lauren with her legal troubles and the two grow closer.
I loved this book so much. It’s the perfect swoony friends-to-lovers, age-gap, slow burn romance. Mia and Lauren have chemistry from their first in person meeting and their journey from becoming friends to more is *chef’s kiss*. Besides the baggage Mia and Lauren have, the book is pretty low angst, so you can enjoy the two women slowly growing closer and falling in love. As a huge fan of this series, I loved seeing couples from the previous books make an appearance, especially Piper and Chloe. And being a huge nerd, the use of fandom and fan fiction throughout the book made my heart happy.
If you’re looking for a book with cute cats and a romance with sizzling yearning with the best payoff, then I highly recommend She’ll Steal Your Heart and the entire Midnight in Manhattan series.
I loved this book so much. It’s the perfect swoony friends-to-lovers, age-gap, slow burn romance. Mia and Lauren have chemistry from their first in person meeting and their journey from becoming friends to more is *chef’s kiss*. Besides the baggage Mia and Lauren have, the book is pretty low angst, so you can enjoy the two women slowly growing closer and falling in love. As a huge fan of this series, I loved seeing couples from the previous books make an appearance, especially Piper and Chloe. And being a huge nerd, the use of fandom and fan fiction throughout the book made my heart happy.
If you’re looking for a book with cute cats and a romance with sizzling yearning with the best payoff, then I highly recommend She’ll Steal Your Heart and the entire Midnight in Manhattan series.
June 5, 2023
I think this story was my favorite one in the Midnight series. The chemistry between Lauren and Mia was hot, and the build-up of sexual tension made for an exciting read. I adored the ending, and loved seeing so many of the past characters’ lives intertwine with each other. This book made me proud to be a member of the LGBTQ community.
December 28, 2022
Lauren is ready to make amends for past mistakes, but she’s less prepared for receiving help, especially from her online-turned-in-person friend Mia. As the women grow to rely on each other, their friendship blossoms into something deeper…with the help of a fictional legal drama and some irresistible rescue cats.
She’ll Steal Your Heart is a beautiful story of redemption, friendship, love, and hope. Lauren and Mia are compelling characters who are each on a challenging journey, and their unlikely relationship unfolds with an entertaining mixture of warmth, passion, and a little humor. Because of all these elements, it’s easy to be so drawn into Mia and Lauren’s story that you’re laughing and crying right along with them.
Additionally, with catchup scenes for all of the chief characters from the previous three books, She’ll Steal Your Heart is a heartwarming and satisfying conclusion to the Midnight in Manhattan series.
She’ll Steal Your Heart is a beautiful story of redemption, friendship, love, and hope. Lauren and Mia are compelling characters who are each on a challenging journey, and their unlikely relationship unfolds with an entertaining mixture of warmth, passion, and a little humor. Because of all these elements, it’s easy to be so drawn into Mia and Lauren’s story that you’re laughing and crying right along with them.
Additionally, with catchup scenes for all of the chief characters from the previous three books, She’ll Steal Your Heart is a heartwarming and satisfying conclusion to the Midnight in Manhattan series.
December 29, 2022
Im so sad this series is over now. I’ll admit I shed a tear. This book was by far my favourite and I mean I don’t partially like age gap trope so going into this I thought it wouldn’t be as good as the other three. I was proven wrong however as I did in fact fall in love with the characters of both Lauren and Mia.
October 21, 2022
Thank you to the author for the opportunity to read this advanced reader copy. This honest review was based off my experience reading this eARC, which in no way biased me. All opinions are my own.
This is my 6th book I’ve read from Rachel Lacey, I first discovered her books through her Ms. Right series back in like February. I have read all the books in the Midnight In Manhattan series. I would like to say, yes they are stand-alones and can be read separately or out of order, BUT I would recommend you do read them, and in order. The couples from the earlier books make cameos throughout, and I believe you will have a better experience if you know the back story.
Like for example, one of the FMCs in this book is actually a pretty big character in book 1, and honestly I didn’t read the books back to back so I had briefly forgotten that she was in book 1. I was reading and I was like ok she’s a criminal? What did she do? And then it hit me and everything started to make sense.
And like to get the fascination with the In Her Defense show (and fanfic) you should probably read book 3 for this to make sense.
This had some fun tropes to work with:
Criminal/Lawyer
Age Gap (13 years)
Slow burn
(Internet friends to in person) Friends to Lovers
Boss/Employee
Roommates
But it also included some pretty heavy themes. Mentions of a family member with addiction, a family member death via overdose, negligent parent, divorce, homophobic parent, and I am sure I am missing some.
I had a good time, its not my favorite in this series but it was good. 3.5 stars overall.
This is my 6th book I’ve read from Rachel Lacey, I first discovered her books through her Ms. Right series back in like February. I have read all the books in the Midnight In Manhattan series. I would like to say, yes they are stand-alones and can be read separately or out of order, BUT I would recommend you do read them, and in order. The couples from the earlier books make cameos throughout, and I believe you will have a better experience if you know the back story.
Like for example, one of the FMCs in this book is actually a pretty big character in book 1, and honestly I didn’t read the books back to back so I had briefly forgotten that she was in book 1. I was reading and I was like ok she’s a criminal? What did she do? And then it hit me and everything started to make sense.
And like to get the fascination with the In Her Defense show (and fanfic) you should probably read book 3 for this to make sense.
This had some fun tropes to work with:
Criminal/Lawyer
Age Gap (13 years)
Slow burn
(Internet friends to in person) Friends to Lovers
Boss/Employee
Roommates
But it also included some pretty heavy themes. Mentions of a family member with addiction, a family member death via overdose, negligent parent, divorce, homophobic parent, and I am sure I am missing some.
I had a good time, its not my favorite in this series but it was good. 3.5 stars overall.
October 27, 2022
Lauren spent the last year running from her problems, including the robbery she committed to help her brother. Now she’s back to clean up the mess she made, but first she is going to meet up with the only friends she has left. Her online friends, and her fanfic writing, has kept her going the last year. Especially her friendship with, ex-lawyer and now Cat Cafe owner, Mia Solano. When they discover a shared connected to Lauren’s crime Mia has to revisit her old life to help.
For a book where the main character has a felony charge there is a surprisingly low about of angst. Lauren and Mia’s relationship is a classic friends to lovers tale. Mia is starting to live her life after a divorce and career change, and is able to offer help getting Lauren back on her feet. With uncertainty due to her legal issues, Lauren is able to care for Mia in different ways. Their friendship is loving, and the progression to a romantic relationship is almost a forgone conclusion.
I loved the representation of fandom in this book! Lauren’s path to becoming a published author reflects so many of the authors I love to read. Although now I want to know what fandoms Rachel Lacey is a part of.
Sidenote: I always appreciate the acknowledgments section of a book, and Lacey lays out exactly how this book came to be. Particularly in regard to its place in her book universe and the character profile changes throughout the outlining process.
For a book where the main character has a felony charge there is a surprisingly low about of angst. Lauren and Mia’s relationship is a classic friends to lovers tale. Mia is starting to live her life after a divorce and career change, and is able to offer help getting Lauren back on her feet. With uncertainty due to her legal issues, Lauren is able to care for Mia in different ways. Their friendship is loving, and the progression to a romantic relationship is almost a forgone conclusion.
I loved the representation of fandom in this book! Lauren’s path to becoming a published author reflects so many of the authors I love to read. Although now I want to know what fandoms Rachel Lacey is a part of.
Sidenote: I always appreciate the acknowledgments section of a book, and Lacey lays out exactly how this book came to be. Particularly in regard to its place in her book universe and the character profile changes throughout the outlining process.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 117 reviews