I mentioned to a friend that reading Faithfully Different by Natasha Crain reminded me of fishing. Tangled lines and birdsnest reels happen. When they do, they shut you down until someone (usually not yourself) comes along with the skill and patience to help you unravel the knotty mess.
That's what this book does. It unravels the knots so many of us are experiencing as we try to live faithfully in the various twists of post-Christian American society. Other books have addressed similar issues: I think of Carl Trueman's The Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self. But where Trueman assays history to unriddle how western culture came to adopt identity-forming beliefs which run crossways of foundational cultural norms, Crain's book unwinds the present messy moment.
Specifically, Crain unpacks the secular (secularist?) worldview. It rests on four pillars: feelings are the ultimate good, happiness is the ultimate goal, judging is the ultimate sin, and God is the ultimate guess. Patiently, with a guiding hand, Crain walks the reader through how secularism has become the dominant worldview and how that worldview has become so deceptively attractive to many, including Christians, especially those walking through doubts and redefining faith along the lines of deconstruction or Progressive Christianity.
Her analysis accounts for so much cognitive dissonance felt today; however, Faithfully Different is way more than dry analysis. It provides readers wisdom, insight, and tools to interact shrewdly with secular culture.
Particularly helpful is the discussion of "moral marketing" in Chapter eight. Using her background as a marketing executive, the author demonstrates how the familiar AIDA funnel functions in contemporary discussions of virtue and vice. The application of this model elegantly explains what's going on with virtue signaling and related mechanisms of moral authority. In the hands of secular activists, redefinition, normalization, and celebration work together to change the popular moral consensus. Christians who believe God has spoken authoritatively on such subjects as the self, sexuality, and justice in society will be necessarily at odds with the resulting moral messages. But we shouldn't be surprised. We are called to be salt and light within a decaying society.
Emphatically, this book is not a manifesto for the culture wars, on which Crain asserts, "While we may wish it were otherwise, and we should grieve over what we see, we have to resist the temptation to feel like discouraged or disgruntled losers." Christians are now in a worldview minority. Her final chapter reminds the reader that the gospel is still good news for a world that has tangled its vision of what "good" looks like, and if we want to help those who are caught in it, Christians must be willing to live faithfully different lives.
This book would be excellent for small group study, men's or women's groups, reading clubs, pastoral staffs, or anyone seeking to sort out their practical theology of Christ and culture. Taken together with Trueman's trenchant treatment of the self under modernity, Faithfully Different promises readers clarity and challenge to help re-calibrate our spiritual and moral compass and navigate the rough waters of secularized society.