DOUBLE JEOPARDY (LegalThriller-Mike Daley/Rosie Fernandez-San Francisco-Contemp)
by Sheldon Siegel
Sheldon M. Siegel, Inc.-Oct 2022, 298 pp.
RATING: VG+/A
First Sentence: The Honorable Robert J. Stumpf Jr. arched a bushy gray eyebrow over the top of his aviator-style glasses, flashed a charismatic smile, and spoke to me in a commanding baritone leaving no doubt that he was in charge of his stuffy courtroom the Department Seventeen on the second floor of San Francisco’s crumbling Hall of Justice.
After serving three tours in Afghanistan, Lenny is living on the streets of San Francisco taking OxyContin for the pain from his injuries. Trying to help fellow-street person Annie, he gives her a bottle with his last three Oxy. So how did Annie die from the fentanyl found in Lennie’s bottle? After a year in jail, Lenny’s case is about to come up. His public defender has been called to Southern California to care for her mother who is believed to have COVID, and no one knows what to expect. Criminal Defense Attorney Mike Daley steps in and agrees to take over the case. With everything closing, including trials, Mike has very little time to find witnesses and build a case, all the while risking his own health.
Many authors have tried setting books at the beginning of, or during, COVID. Siegel has, by far, been the one to capture it the best. He picks it up at the very beginning of the pandemic, when little was known about what to do or how long it would last, and the introduction of Zoom into everyday life and the common lexicon…”I don’t think “Zoom” is a verb.” “It will be—just like Google.” That uncertainty adds a very strong level of suspense to the story.
There are times where the conversations may seem repetitive. Then one realizes how realistic it is when talking about the same subject to many different people, and how representative of most conversations during those days. Yet it is Mike’s personal relationships that truly hold the book together. There is such a wonderfully strong core of family whether actually related or not.
It is the mystery that intrigues the reader. How can one have a pill bottle belonging to one person, with their prints on the outside, but the pills within the bottle not be theirs? Because of the danger, Mike is left doing much of his own investigative work in highly dangerous and infection-prone areas, which is an interesting difference. Even with all the concern over COVID, Siegel doesn’t lose the importance, or tragedy, of the fentanyl crisis.
For some, however, it is the courtroom scenes that shine, particularly Mike’s uncertainty about them and his inner monologue. The latter provides the advantage of seeing the events and knowing Mike’s thoughts on them. Rather than being intrusive, it’s informative and, often, humorous.
DOUBLE JEOPARDY is an excellent legal mystery set during the beginning months of the coronavirus, and Sheldon Siegel retains his place as an ‘auto-buy” author.