You in the West may call that an "own voice review".
As a Ukrainian refugee and an avid reader, I was happy to see this book in the local Texas library and know that someone in the US cared enough to write, publish, buy, and display comics about my country, about the events that ruined my life. Unfortunately, after actually reading the book, I wished nobody had written it since it is full of subtle Russian propaganda.
After seeing the title, one may think that this is a diary of a journalist who has worked in Ukraine or an illustrated diary of a person who survived the tragedy of Mariupol. However, the title is misleading because the author has never been to Ukraine or spoken to any Ukrainian person, consultant, or editor to publish the book; he just read a few articles on the topic (listed on the back) and compiled a lazy narrative out of them.
The second next misleading thing after the title is the Prologue, in which Don Brown tries to explain the history that led to the invasion of 2022. He starts strong with the phrase "the fortunes of Russians and those who had come to see themselves as Ukrainians diverged" (why not the other way around, if we are talking about Kyivan Rus? but I guess I should be grateful for not reading "so-called Ukrainians" here) and continues with a wild Russian propaganda about mass Ukrainian support of Nazis during WW2, about how every non-Jewish Ukrainian went on assasinating Jewish Ukrainian neighbors and how "the most hideous episodes of the Holocaust occured in Ukraine", being conveniently silent about the fact that the entire territory of Ukraine was under Nazi occupation at the time and the most hideous episodes of the Holocaust were committed by the occupiers (and of course, who needs to know about the numerous resistance groups during the occupation, Don Brown only reads Russian propaganda according to which every Ukrainian was in SS - apparently, including my own grandparents who fought against Nazis and who I had a personal honour to know but Don Brown knows better). It's funny how later on, the author tries to debunk Putin's rhetoric about how Ukraine needs denazification while playing right into Putin's narrative on the previous page.
Then Brown claims that "Russian sympathizers in the eastern Ukrainian province of Donbas declared independence from Ukraine". I am from Donbas, born and raised in (and sought refuge from) Luhansk; it is sad for me to read in a book such a lie - those "sympathizers" were brought (and sometimes bought) by Russia, and it was a full-scale invasion to my city from Russia's side, with tanks, helicopters, armed Russian regular army personnel, etc. In this book, Donbas is called "the Donbas province of Russian separatists" later on. The author called Ukrainians of Donbas living under Russian occupation "Russian-backed residents, broken away from Ukraine in 2014, setting off something of a civil war between the separatist and Ukrainian forces", relentlessly playing into the "civil war" narrative so popular among Russian propagandists in the West. It is aimed at Western countries to lower the support of Ukraine and has nothing to do with reality.
The author also talks a lot about Russians, protesting against war (are they really?), and even Russian soldiers with immense sympathy. "And the agents of the terror, the Russian troops? Some are shocked to find themselves in a real war." That is the direct quote from the book, illustrated with a bunch of Russian soldiers who look like a group of confused children, with bubbles that say, "I didn't know this was going to happen. They said we were going for training" and "We were fucking fooled like little kids". Mind it, the author tries to infantilize and victimize fully grown men who joined the military, trained to attack the borders of a foreign country for months and months, and currently are the perpetrators of a bloody genocide for which they have been preparing all their lives. They perfectly knew what they were training for, and are telling these lies about not knowing where they were going only when they are captured as prisoners of war (and lots of them are because Ukraine is the only side in this war that is playing by the Geneva Convention).
The author even described the Russian troops as "cheerful and friendly" to fleeing Ukrainians. Maybe he got this information from the International Committee of the Red Cross, a money-laundering organization that was supporting deportation, kidnapping, and torture of Ukrainian civilians at Russian checkpoints, and which he proudly quotes on another page. I can only wish everyone who can agree with that description of a Russian soldier to encounter cheerfulness and friendliness of this kind for themselves in real life.
Meanwhile, Ukrainians, in his words, "became vicious" against each other in the times of occupation. They are also portrayed as racist against the people of color who are trying to evacuate from the country, an influential Russian propaganda of the early invasion which has been debunked numerous times but somehow is still affecting the Western audience and even found its way into this little book.
The Ukrainian government is continuously pictured as weak, indecisive, and spreading fake news about its victories.
Apart from propaganda takes, the book does not portray a bigger picture of what's going on in Ukraine and even in Mariupol. The author shows his continuous lack of understanding of the war's scale. There's also no story in the book whatsoever, and there is no reminiscence of the author focusing on one group of people surviving the bombing or something. He is not even trying to tell a story of any kind. The text is just some quotes from the articles Don Brown found online, illustrated in a sketch style.
Generally, it feels like a cash grab from someone who has built his literary career on abusing stories of other people's tragedies to publish another quickie, which a library will purchase to tick off the "important" topic in their teen collection. The art style is wannabe rough and hazy but comes out as plainly unfinished and lazy. You can watch a 10-minute video on YouTube about Mariupol and have more substantial understanding of the events than after buying and reading this graphic novel.