Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Don't Trust the Cat

Rate this book
“Don’t Trust the Cat is not your average switcheroo story. Tracy deftly pulls off an honest accounting of friendship and belonging and middle school angst, wrapped in a zany, action-packed, nail-biting page-turner of a tale. It’s bananas!”
—Megan McDonald, bestselling author of the Judy Moody series

“This book is really, really funny.”
—Mac Barnett, New York Times–bestselling author of the Kid Spy series

“This is the perfect book to read to your cat. Or for your cat to read to you. Full of feline fun.”
—Polly Horvath, National Book Award–winning author of The Canning Season

“Kristen Tracy’s offbeat humor is surprising and alive and real, and we’re lucky we have her stories.”
—Nina LaCour, Michael L. Printz Award–winning and bestselling author

WHAT IF YOU SWITCHED PLACES WITH YOUR CAT? Mean Girls  meets Freaky Friday in this laugh-out-loud story about self-acceptance, learning who your friends are, and coming of age . . . as a cat.
 

Fifth-grader Poppy McBean likes rules and order. She's a follower, and she's totally okay with that. And if you judge her for that, she's okay with that too! But after falling prey to her friends' bullying one too many times, Poppy makes a wish to be happy—and it comes true in a very unexpected She wakes up in the body of her cat, Mitten Man.
 
Mayhem ensues as Poppy-the-girl attempts to navigate the wilds of the wilderness as a cat . . . and her free-thinking, groundbreaking kitty has had it with his owner's timidity. He's out to put the purr in perfectionist and take over middle school—as Poppy.
 
Hilarious and unexpected, Don't Trust the Cat is a coming-of-age adventure that will keep readers cringing, cracking up, and reconsidering what it means to be a good person.

Guaranteed, this will be many kids' favorite book of the year.

EMPATHY This book is a sneaky way to talk about empathy with kids. Both cat and human learn a lot about each other and change over the course of the book. Each becomes a better being because of their unusual experience.

DEEPLY This book has a funny premise and is packed with hysterical scenes, but it's also grounded and emotional. Readers will sympathize with all characters and leave the book feeling like they made friends while reading.

CAT When Poppy's cat takes on Poppy's body, she wants to transform Poppy's life, turning her from a timid kid into someone who believes in herself. Like most cats she has good intentions, but things don't always go according to plan.
 
LEARNING NEW WAYS OF For anyone who has ever wanted to communicate with their pets, this novel might make you think twice! Poppy and her cat come to meet in the middle, but they have to learn a lot about communication along the way.

Friendships are often messy, but this book shows that it's important to never lose sense of yourself within a friendship, and that sometimes it is necessary to stand up for yourself even to your best friends.

336 pages, Hardcover

Published July 25, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Kristen Tracy

28 books123 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
32 (21%)
4 stars
46 (31%)
3 stars
54 (36%)
2 stars
13 (8%)
1 star
3 (2%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews
Profile Image for Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore.
970 reviews254 followers
June 14, 2023
My thanks to Chronicle Books for a review copy of this book via Edelweiss.

Don’t Trust the Cat (2023) is a children’s adventure story with its own spin on the body swap story (like Anstey’s Vice Versa, or Wodehouse’s version, Laughing Gas), and one which involves a cat! Poppy McBean is an 11-year-old, middle school student—a not very assertive girl who is currently focused on securing the part of ‘a pony’ in the annual school play, something her group of four friends all aim towards, since they don’t wish to be ‘dogs’. One day after things go badly in school (involving Poppy tripping over a bucket holding dirty water and none of her friends, even Heni who is her neighbour and whom she considers particularly close, coming to help), she returns home to find herself locked out, as is her cat Mitten Man. She sits with him in the garage, and tries to put on his new collar (sent as a present by her aunt Blanche who is something of a hippy), and amidst all this ends up saying how he has a nice time of it unlike her. This mixed with various other little placements of things ends up causing a swap, and now Poppy is ‘old Poppy’ trapped in the body of Mitten Man while Mitten Man is Poppy or Big Poppy. But this not just a swap of girl and cat but of two very different personalities (er… a personality and a purrsonality, rather).

Now Big Poppy must live Poppy’s life which she is determined to improve for Poppy did rescue Mitten Man even when he had ear mites, didn’t smell very good, or look very appealing. But while Big Poppy begins with good intentions (especially ensuring that she gives her best performance at the audition and in fact aims for a better part than just a pony), she also ends up rubbing her friends the wrong way and souring some relationships. Some of this may be deserved, but perhaps not all. Meanwhile as time moves on, her cat-like behaviours also come to the surface causing some odd situations.

On the other hand, Old Poppy must deal with navigating life in a cat’s body, but this is not the worst. For one she is terrified (unfairly I thought) Big Poppy will ruin things in her real life, and then more trouble arrives in the form of Aunt Blanche herself. As Poppy’s parents are to be busy for a while, they’ve asked Blanche to come and stay. This wouldn’t be a problem except Blanche thinks cats should live ‘free’ and so Old Poppy is now put out into the wilderness to make her own way. Not only are there the dangers of the world outside, she is soon thrown into an adventure where she must help some one she had a very different impression of but who turns out to be a friend, rescue another friend.

Misunderstandings between Big Poppy and Old Poppy complicate things as we see the story unfold and how the two eventually make their way to back each other (not just physically) and to their original selves!

This was a fun adventure story which had much more to it than I’d originally expected. Opening with Poppy, once the swap takes place, the story unfolds in parallel narratives, as we follow Big Poppy at school or at home and Old Poppy at home and then outside. Both tracks involve their share of adventure, Big Poppy’s navigating school and Old Poppy the world outside, though it is the latter which involves elements of real danger, even life-threatening situations. At school Big Poppy is now a confident young girl, ready to take risks, and even tell off those who deserve it (and even some who don’t deserve it to some extent). I especially liked how she dealt with a school bully and found myself cheering her on. While for the most part, she is a convincing human (even managing to sign her name, write letters and such—but no maths for sure), at other times her cat behaviours get the better of her leading to some fun situations. Old Poppy’s adventure on the other hand, does take her into more dangerous territory, but she too seems to manage rather well. This thread of the story did make me skip a heartbeat a couple of times, hoping all would be well with all the characters involved.

Big Poppy does love Poppy very much for she rescued her as a kitten and gave her a chance, so when she becomes Poppy, she genuinely wants her to have the best life, trying to do all she can to ensure this. While Old Poppy is in the house (before the arrival of Aunt Blanche), she takes care of her well, feeds her good things and makes sure she doesn’t get in trouble. There are certain missteps of course, but she never intends creating trouble. I liked in this sense how the author kept away from the stereotypical images of a cat (selfish, seeking world-domination and such), even though some hints of a different side to Mitten Man do emerge in Old Poppy’s narrative. In fact, if anything, it is some of the human characters who end up being not very likeable. Old Poppy seems really not to trust poor Big Poppy thinking that she will ruin things or create trouble. From an 11-year old’s perspective of course some of these apprehensions make sense, especially given her shy nature and the fact that she doesn’t wish to offend those she considers her friends, but still somehow she comes across as being a little unfair to the cat.

Since this is a body swap plot, there is also that element of myth and magic involved (an upcoming solar eclipse among them) but none of this is specific. More a case of magic happening because of certain elements being in certain places and certain thoughts being in Poppy and Mister Mittens’ minds. The story is in essence more about the bond between human and cat, which is affected by some misunderstandings (largely on the human’s part) but then emerges once again, stronger than ever.

A mostly light and fun read, though there are moments where there is danger to the animals involved which do make one anxious! My only minor complaints were the hints to another side of Mitten Man’s personality which don’t seem to be in sync with what he’s like (may be the author originally planned to take things on a different path), and some of the nastier aspects of some human characters which seemed unnecessary (like in Poppy’s mother).
Profile Image for Laura.
3,397 reviews108 followers
October 16, 2022
Poppy is upset about her life, and wishes she had it easy, like her cat Mitten Man. And her cat wants her to be happy, so they both wish at the same time, and end up switching bodies.

Big Poppy, the name that Poppy as the cat gives to her human version, and Old Poppy, as Mitten Man refers to the cat version of Poppy, try to switch back, but can't seem to find the magic way to do so.

Big Poppy then goes and ruins all her friendships, while Old Poppy goes off to do cat things, such as help her cat friend rescue a turtle who is being tormented.

I have to say, reading Old Poppy's adventures dragged on, because she was complaining so much. But once she gets into rescue mode, things pick up.

And, as I expect, Big Poppy's ruining friendships turned out to eliminate the bad ones, and keep the good ones.

So, an ok middle grade book. Second half of book was better than the first.


Thanks to Edelweiss for making this book available for an honest review.
Profile Image for Natalia.
141 reviews4 followers
March 25, 2024
3.5/5

This was a pretty fun middle-grade book!

I was pulled in by the premise of a mischievous cat, and ran into the nice surprise of body swapping.

Poppy was such a sweet character; she felt pretty believable in her day-to-day struggles, anxieties over friendships and school, and overall desire to be accepted.

Mitten Man was very, very cat-like. She clearly loves Poppy and has good intentions (for the most part), but she is still a cat--no matter how much she tries to behave like a human, Mitten Man will do what Mitten Man believes is best, even if it doesn't align with Poppy's actual desires.

I will admit that the first half of the book felt pretty slow-moving, which slowed me down in my reading progress. While the body swapping was a great inciting incident to get the plot rolling, I felt that we spent too much time hearing about Mitten Man and Poppy's days in their new bodies, without getting any actual action from either of the main characters. It wasn't until Death Tiger showed up for the rescue that the story started to pick up and get me excited about the book again, which hadn't happened since the body swapping.

In the end, both main characters showed personal growth and appreciation for each other, which is ultimately what books for this audience group should strive for.

Overall, it was really fun and enjoyable; though I feel that some middle-grade readers would probably lose interest before the halfway point due to the slow progress in that first half.

*This ARC was received through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review*
Profile Image for Rachel.
322 reviews11 followers
December 23, 2023
I enjoyed the second half of the book much more than the first.
At this point, Poppy the cat is on a quest with Death Tiger to find their lost turtle friend, Raul.

Contrary to the famous author blurbs on the back cover, I did not find any part of this book to be "really, really funny."

The story decent job of portraying changing friendships, belonging and some of the additional the difficulties a 5th grader might encounter.

However, for the majority of the book, I disliked just about every human.

And I could not get over the mother's treatment of Mr. Mittens. Perhaps the premise of tossing Mitten Man in the garage on a regular basis as punishment is supposed to be a foreshadowing of his sassy behavior. But the reaction I had was that Poppy's mother is not a nice person.
(Also, as a PSA, garlic can kill a cat - so mom, take responsibility and put the garlic butter in the fridge.)

There is another incident where the mother throws Mitten Man /Poppy in the garage because Poppy is so happy to see her mom, she "enthusiastically launches herself at her ankles to try to hug her."
The mom declares Mitten Man will stay in there until he can calm down. Clearly the mother is not a cat person, and it is an insult to female dogs to call her what I think of her.

Lastly, if some crazy relative threw my cat outside to let him "run free and wild", we would not be putting off the search to eat dinner, and the Aunt would be out the door.
Profile Image for Marisa.
725 reviews15 followers
January 8, 2023
3.5 stars.
Appropriate for grades 4-6, following 5th grader Poppy and her cat, Mister Mittens having a Freaky Friday switch. Slow to start, but has a sweet ending for all.
Profile Image for Chad Durham.
207 reviews1 follower
December 23, 2023
A fun but odd book. Weird and idiosyncratic but with a good message and a compelling offbeat story.
Profile Image for Kate.
530 reviews34 followers
August 14, 2023
I read a fair amount of middle grade books (because they're amazing and you should consider reading them too) and I loved the idea behind the story but just didn't love the execution of it
Profile Image for Ms. Yingling.
4,718 reviews660 followers
April 12, 2023
E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus

Fifth grader Poppy is trying out for the middle school play with three of her best friends, Henri, Rosario, and Kit. They hope to get secondary roles as dancing ponies, figuring that the 8th graders will get speaking parts in their drama teacher's production of Circus Animal Tricks, Riddles, and Songs. They hope to avoid being cast as dogs. Poppy doesn't really want to be in the play at all, and doesn't dance very well, which sometimes ends veyr poorly. She has a cat, Mitten Man, whose life seems so much better. Mitten Man doesn't have to do homework that involves recreating a solar eclipse on paper, does he? After recieving a special collar for her cat, Poppy makes a wish, and ends up switching bodies. "Big Poppy", as Poppy refers to her body while Mitten Man inhabits it, is fearless. He not only auditions for the play, but gets an even larger role. Since he has an innate sense of cat superiority, he tries to make a splash for his human by making new friends and having new experiences. There are plenty of cat like moments, of course, when he asks to change seats so he can sit in the sun, although naps in school are discourages. It's hard for Poppy to inhabit Mitten Man's body, since she has to poop in a box and deal with Death Tiger, a neighborhood stray who often comes around and presents her with dead birds. This is a constant source of tension between the two as they struggle to find a way to go back to their own bodies. When Poppy gets lost as a cat, Mitten Man is worried that the switch is permanent. When the two are reunited, will they be able to figure out the clue to returning to their own bodies?
Strengths: There are many more dog adventure books than cat adventure ones, mainly because cats don't seem as inclined to save humans. If a cat were in a human body, however, I think that their superior attitude would play out exactly as Tracy describes! There are just enough details about what it is like to spend the day as a cat to be interesting but not gross, and the fun comes from seeing Mitten Man acting like a 5th grader! I have plenty of readers who adore cats, and this might be something that Hunter's Warrior Gang series can be handed that might encourage them to read something else!
Weaknesses: There were a lot of cat details, and the book was a little longer than some middle grade titles. While readers who like cats will enjoy this, I wasn't as fond of it.
What I really think: I like Tracy's more YA books, and her Bessica Lefter series, and this was quite a different style for her. Fun to watch authors stretch a bit. Keep this one around to hand to students wearing cat ears or shirts with sequined felines.
Profile Image for Stacie.
2,019 reviews123 followers
November 9, 2023
DON’T TRUST THE CAT is a silly switcheroo story like Freaky Friday or 13 Going on 30 but with a fifth grader and her cat. After a bad day at school, Poppy comes home and is stuck in the garage with her cat, Mitten Man. When she makes a wish, Mitten Man and Poppy switch bodies. As you can imagine, there is quite a bit of chaos, craziness, and ultimately, a lot of love.

Poppy is struggling with friends and trying out for the school play. When the magical switch happens, Poppy is now actually Mitten Man who knows nothing about going to school and managing friendships. Poppy makes a mess of things at school with her friends but gains new eighth-grade friends, but do they have an ulterior motive?

“What was I thinking when I agreed to this? My cat doesn’t know how to be a fifth grader.”

This chapter book offers all kinds of make-believe while also offering kids solutions when they struggle with their parents, friendships, or difficult days at school. Fifth grade can be difficult as kids start to become more independent while also wanting to be taken care of. When Poppy returns home to an unexpectedly locked house, she becomes angry with her mom and dad. This incident is what leads to the big switch and reminds Poppy that everyone makes mistakes and should be forgiven. Poppy learns how to handle disappointment and friendship struggles as well as learning it is okay to be bold and try new things.

“You’re doing great, Poppy, ” she says. “Just, when a bad thing happens, try your best not to make it worse.”

I think most kids will enjoy the silliness and the climatic lead-up to whether Poppy and Mitten Man will ever be able to switch back to their own bodies. But, they will also relate to real-life feelings of rejection, fear, and sadness. Tracy writes from the mind of a fifth grader and makes the story relatable for kids.
Profile Image for Becky.
6,329 reviews331 followers
August 28, 2023
First sentence: What if it's possible to fix your whole life in an instant?

Premise/plot: Poppy (a human fifth grader) changes places accidentally with Mitten Man (her mischievous cat). The novel is told in alternating view points. Poppy has no experience being a cat, of course. And Mitten Man has no experience being human, let alone a GIRL in fifth grade with delicate, fragile friendships. Both struggle with difficulties. Mitten Man isn't treated all that well by the parents OR the visiting aunt. Mitten Man is super-independent and before switching places was in troubles of his own--involving a feral cat (Death Tiger) and a turtle. Poppy, as I said, is having some typical troubles with her friend group. Poppy has to learn how to follow her cat instincts. Mitten Man has to LET GO of all his natural instincts and think about what is best for Poppy. (But is he capable of higher thinking????)

My thoughts: I wanted to love this one so much. I liked the premise. I think it could be relatable for young cat lovers. Cats can seem to have it all. But Mitten Man seems contrary. He doesn't seem to like any of the humans who live with him. (Not even Poppy). And everyone but Poppy seems to dislike Mitten Man. I personally don't like the way he's treated. (He's almost always being "punished" and stuck in the garage for hours on end. The VISITING aunt decides to go a step further, and put Mitten Man outside (lock him out). Since this is Poppy at that point, it's even more annoying. Ideal cat owners they are not. Mitten Man, to be fair, is super annoying. But I didn't want him to be annoying. I wanted to LOVE him.

I ended up disliking almost all the characters in this one--but especially the adults.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Benjamin.
1,531 reviews25 followers
Read
June 27, 2024
How? Stage 1: kiddo grabs a playaway of this at the library. (Playaways are standalone mp3 players.) We listen to some of it while playing.
Stage 2: we reintroduce audiobooks at night and decide to finally finish this one.

What? Poppy is a 5th grader with typical 5th-grader problems: one of her friends is bossy, there's a bully at school, and there's an upcoming audition for a play. And then she gets a not-so-typical problem: she bodyswaps with her cat.

They plan for the cat to stay as the human for a few days, just to audition, but things go awry and soon Poppy-the-cat is out in the wild, dealing with a wild cat, a lost turtle, and all the animals in the neighborhood, etc.. Meanwhile, cat-the-person is wreaking havoc on Poppy's life -- climbing a tree during a school fire drill, cutting ties with her friends, auditioning for one of the lead roles in the play, etc.

A few times, while listening at night, the kiddo would jump up and say, "don't do that!" which is how he responds to people getting into awkward situations or times they could get into trouble. But of course, it all works out in the end, with them learning lessons and swapping back.

Yeah, so? The publisher's copy for this book notes that "This book is a sneaky way to talk about empathy with kids." But when one of the final chapters includes Poppy-the-cat looking in on her human friends and seeing them when no one else sees them -- the bossy girl is anxious, this other one who they made fun of for playing with a skipit really likes her skipit -- then I don't think it's exactly sneaky. Heck, the narrator comes out and says, "Being alive is hard work no matter who you are."

Which is kinda all I want my books to say.
Profile Image for Matt Glaviano.
1,570 reviews24 followers
May 13, 2024
2.5

I think it would be better to be a cat. So does Poppy, a fifth grader who has so many family, friend, and school problems that curling up and napping in a sunbeam seems like the only way to go. Luckily, with the help of a magic collar and/or a solar eclipse, Poppy is about to get her wish. But when the new Feline Poppy turns everything in Old Poppy's life upside down, will things ever be the same again? And is it better if they're not the same? And what if Poppy is always a cat now?

At heart, a classic Vice/Versa kind of story. That story arc always feels like it ends up enforcing the values of normative mainstream culture - things sure were better before all that change! We didn't know how good we etc.

This version of the switcheroo is too long and never particularly interesting. That said, Tracy has some wonderful turns of phrase throughout the book. Sometimes they'll just say something very succinctly - sometimes they're really funny. But the writing can't sustain the overlong plot and the whole thing ends up feeling like a drag.

Also, for a book that came out in 2023, it fails to capitalize on the solar eclipse subplot. This feels like a marketing failure to me. What an opportunity - put eclipse art on the cover and play that shiz up. However, Tracy does a crappy job of writing the eclipse itself; it just kind of...happens in the story - BE READY NOW IT'S TOTALITY - whereas an actual eclipse takes time to achieve totality. I wish that aspect of the plot had been played up and used more efficiently.

For a book that seems like it should offer wish-fulfilling purrfection for a cat lover, this book never became a cozy spot in which to cuddle up.

Profile Image for Sarah.
98 reviews8 followers
February 12, 2025
This story contained all the things I knew my oldest reader would love - humour, drama, antics, empathy, friendship, and, of course, cats.

𝘘𝘶𝘪𝘤𝘬 𝘴𝘺𝘯𝘰𝘱𝘴𝘪𝘴: Poppy McBean is in middle grade and is fed up with feeling bullied by her friends. One day, she makes a wish to be happy, only to discover that she has traded places with her cat Mitten Man. Now Poppy must face life as her cat and deal with the fact that her cat has taken over her life. They both must navigate life as the other, which for Poppy means fending off weasels and facing Death Tiger, the stray cat, and for Mitten Man, it’s experiencing life as a middle-grader, drama and all.

What I liked most about this book:
- How Poppy experiences life as her cat and gains a different perspective on life, a great way to teach and discuss empathy
- The humour and silly antics that occur, it really drives the story and makes you want to read on
- The fact that Poppy can communicate to Mitten Man when they switch bodies because let’s
face it, if you’re a cat owner, you have likely wondered more than once what your cat is thinking
- The important life lessons the characters learn about themselves and each other, what it means to be a true friend

What my daughter loved about the book:
- When Poppy turns into Mitten Man, her cat, because it's funny
- When Poppy (as Mitten Man) becomes friends with Death Tiger, the stray cat
- When Poppy coughs up a hairball because it's so funny
- The eclipse because it’s interesting
2,451 reviews38 followers
July 30, 2023
When Poppy was laughed at school after an embarrassing day and friends don’t “stand up” for her she goes home to tell her cat Mitten Man what happened. Mitten Man is a good listener. She wishes she could be Mitten Man with his simple and easy life, she finds herself switched with Mitten Man. Mitten Man has gone into Poppy’s body and of course Poppy has gone into her cat’s body. How did that happen? The two of them can now telepathically talk to each other as long as they are looking at each other. Poppy is now called Big Poppy. Why? Big Poppy isn’t too good about thinking of others and makes some decisions that aren’t too good. Poppy in cat form isn’t happy to be losing friends. She then goes on a dangerous rescue mission that involves a stray cat and a turtle. Will she succeed?

There is a lot of humor throughout the story making me laugh out loud. The story does an excellent job at exploring feelings. Feelings of empathy and understanding are especially explored. It will appear to anyone. It’s a good book for parents and tweens to read and talk about feelings.

Disclaimer: I received this book from the author/publisher from Netgalley. I wasn’t obligated to write a favorable review or any review at all. The opinions expressed are strictly my own.
1,032 reviews6 followers
April 4, 2023
There's an awful of angst in this book about fifth graders. The MC was complaining and miserable all the time, and this was not a book about a dysfunctional family.
The premise was cute. A girl and her cat switch places and proceed to mess up each other's lives. The cat is called Mitten Man but it is unclear if the cat is male or female. If the cat is male, this creates an obvious plot hole. The parents seemed to hate the cat and punish him by throwing him in the garage. The cat was just being a normal cat. The cat was not destroying anything or being "bad", whatever that might be. At one point, the mother told the cat he did not deserve his food. I almost stopped reading right there. She did not want to feed the cat? She wanted to punish the cat by withholding his food? I should really give this book 1 star. What a terrible precedent to set for young readers.
Would kids like this book? I really don't know. I think they'd like the idea but they might be as put off by the angst as I was.
Thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for an ARC.
Profile Image for Darla.
5,276 reviews1,407 followers
July 25, 2023
Poppy McBean and her cat Mitten Man are literally walking in each other's footsteps. A magic collar and a wish for happiness turns weird and the two switch in the McBean garage. In their new forms, the cat is Old Poppy (with a 5th grader inside) and Big Poppy is the 11-year-old girl (with a cat inside).
Fortunately the two are able to communicate and decide to stay switched just long enough for Big Poppy to help with a play audition. Meanwhile Aunt Blanche comes to visit with her hippy vibes and determines that the cat belongs in freedom outside. Old Poppy runs away in fear of weasels, skunks, and bullies. Will the two be reunited in time to switch back? Or is this the new normal? This will be a humorous read for cat-lovers. Old Poppy helps solve a neighborhood mystery and Big Poppy dials up the drama in the 5th grade classroom. It was a fun read and reminded me a bit of that classic film "The Shaggy DA."

Thank you to Chronicle Books and NetGalley for a DRC in exchange for an honest review.
Profile Image for Rebecca Shelton.
458 reviews12 followers
April 17, 2024
"Don't Trust the Cat" delivers a whimsical and engaging story suitable for younger readers. The novel follows Poppy McBean, a fifth-grader who strives to navigate school life and friendships, which are put to the test after a troubling incident at school. Amidst her social turmoil, Poppy experiences a fantastical soul swap with her bold and confident cat, Muffin Man. This bizarre twist leads to a series of humorous and enlightening adventures as each attempts to rectify the other's dilemmas, highlighting their unique perspectives and the complexities of their lives. The narrative sparkles with playful and adept writing, making it accessible and appealing, particularly to reluctant readers. The portrayal of friendships and family dynamics is nuanced, adding depth to the lighthearted plot. Its charm primarily lies in its pure, unpretentious entertainment value, marked by its delightful premise and the amusing juxtaposition of human and feline worlds.
Profile Image for Hope Hunter.
638 reviews9 followers
June 10, 2023
Sweet, mild-mannered Poppy is trying to navigate life in the middle school. Roped into the school play by her friends when she really didn't want to do it, and forced to try out for a part she really doesn't want, Poppy starts to wonder if her friends are real friends. As she becomes more frustrated with her world, she finds herself switching bodies with her cat, Mitten Man. Mitten Man has been fed up her her life as well, and is dealing with other neighborhood cats and has some situations of her own going on that she is having a hard time handling.

I had high expectations for this one and was disappointed. The story was slow and just seemed stuck in the same place no matter how many pages I read. I love the classic Freaky Friday story, and was interested to see how it would for an only child to change places with her pet, but it just didn't work for me.
Profile Image for Liz.
2,491 reviews30 followers
June 30, 2024
Poppy is stressing out about the auditions for the school play, but at least she's got her friends with her, right? Wrong! When she trips and falls into the school's puke bucket, they just leave her on the ground to get laughed at. She goes home that night to vent to her cat, where they both hope for her life to get better, leading to a Freaky Friday switcheroo. Poppy is now in the body of her cat while her cat is in her human body. Initially, it might be nice with her cat's athleticism to help out with the play auditions, but he quickly goes rogue and makes some radical changes in Poppy's life: changing her desk, forgetting her homework, and dropping her friendships. It's a bit long, but nothing feels left out. I'm surprised there wasn't more time spent on the eclipse, especially since it came out in time for there to be buzz for it. For cat fans.
10.1k reviews143 followers
April 1, 2023
A DNF, I'm afraid, with life short, the reading list too long, and this pretty much adult-proof and only good for the target audience. It's not too bad an elevator pitch – schoolgirl and her cat swap bodies – but the way it presents isn't that great. The cat-as-the-girl is sassy to the point of being a bitch, the girl-as-a-cat seems initially there for slapstick purposes, but we have to wait a heck of a long time for the swap to even happen, and the over-writing carries on from there. Oh, and if you wanted to see the childlike humour of the girl having a feline sense of smell and needing to wee into a tray, it can't be bothered, proving this very much felt the missed opportunity. Two and a bit stars for what I did look at.
Profile Image for Caroline.
2,385 reviews31 followers
September 4, 2023
I thought this a pretty funny body swap comedy where a fifth grade girl, Poppy, trades bodies with her cat. Expected hilarity ensues. I think that a lot of the cat-centric comedy will be most enjoyed by cat people. Mr. Mittens is a cat who is adored by his person but feels mostly ambivalent to the people in his life. I think kids who have a cat home that they love will feel the familiarity in this cat-person relationship -- I know I did. Kind of a classic style children's book with adults who never quite get "it", bullies at school who are also tormentors of neighborhood pets, and a friendship on the ropes due to an embarrassing moment at school. Fans of Beverly Cleary might give this one a try.
Profile Image for Elizabeth.
687 reviews21 followers
February 4, 2023
I received this book as an ARC and intend to gift it to my niece. It was cute and awkward the way middle-schoolers often are. I liked that Poppy and her cat have very different personalities, and I enjoyed their differnt story lines. There were a few moments that challenged my suspention of disbelief (even considering this was a middle grade read) but for the most part, I had no issues with this book.
Profile Image for Patti.
532 reviews38 followers
July 23, 2023
I read this one out loud to my kids at bedtime and they enjoyed it! My middle school aged daughter completely related to Poppy, and thought that the switching was hilarious. I was a bit horrified that poor Poppy had to stay out in the garage during her first night as a cat, but the kids enjoyed the overall hijinks. Middle school is not easy, but neither is being a cat!

Very cute read, recommend for animal lovers and especially those kids who wish they were cats!
Profile Image for Melissa Borsey.
1,924 reviews40 followers
March 3, 2023
This is the story of what happens to Poppy, a 5th grader and her cat, Mitten Man magically and accidentally switch bodies. Lots of fun. I found the story to be very funny and heartwarming. I thank Netgalley and Chronicle Books for the opportunity to read and review this book.
Profile Image for Steph.
5,654 reviews92 followers
September 16, 2023
This is like Freaky Friday, but with a girl and her cat switching bodies instead of a girl and her mom. I actually enjoyed it, but I do wish the story was shorter so more of our kids would be able to get through it - since the story is appealing for a large range of middle grade ages otherwise.
Profile Image for AlohaKarina.
260 reviews4 followers
September 16, 2023
I really wanted to like this book. I love cats, I love elementary and middle grade books, but I am sorry to say this was just painful. I hated the cat, I didn’t like the girl, and the whole thing was just not good. I very rarely abandon a book, but I just could not stick with it. So disappointing!
Profile Image for Myra.
1,585 reviews10 followers
January 31, 2024
Closer to 2.5 stars. There's a cute enough story behind this of a young girl 'trading places' with her cat. However, the execution isn't great. There is so much mean-spiritedness in so many of the characters that I really had to force myself to keep reading.
Profile Image for evelynmaeve13.
450 reviews
March 19, 2024
This book was pretty good. I enjoyed the aspects of adventure and friendship, but would have loved to learn more about Raul and his backstory. I recommend it to an audience of 8-11 years old.
-SnowSnowKitty
Profile Image for Ruth R..
56 reviews
June 11, 2024
This was quite a funny and ironic book! I kept wanting to shout while I was reading it, "It's not really her, it's her cat!" or "It was your aunt who did it!" It definitely made me question a lot of things in life.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
4 reviews
March 29, 2026
This book is so good. Read if you love body swap books and cats. For elementary school kids. The girl goes on an adventure in the cats body learning that life isnt so easy as a cat and the cat is in the girls body trying to navigate around school but accidentally ruining her social life
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews