I have read a few of the short stories included in this book. And I agree with what many of the other reviews have said so far; getting an anthology right is challenging. With this one specifically, while there were some amazing stories included in the selection, some were better quality than others. For example, the first story in the book, Gretel and the Lost Prince by Caitlin Denman, reads like a Wattpad story. While I could clearly see what the author was trying to do and how she wanted the story to unfold, it unfortunately felt a bit rushed. Understandably, this is a short story after all, and so that can be excused. There were many enjoyable elements to the story, but a lot of it was ruined by some strange plot points. Without giving too much away, the main character is to be queen of the kingdom and emphasis is placed on her competency. But then, she makes many mistakes that prove her to be the exact opposite of what she is described. No hate to the author though, the story was still entertaining, but there are quite a few things that can be improved upon.
In comparison, though, and the reason the book received four stars is for the inclusion of the second short story, The Hunt for Red by Jacqueline Syne. With all the other stories in the book being more than ten chapters, I was disappointed to find here was only seven for this one, as it was my favourite.
I was pleasantly surprised by how fulfilling the story was, despite it only being seven chapters long. The writing was good (save for one or two typos in the text), and all the characters were well-written and explored in the short time I spent with them. If there were a short story I would like to see turned into a full-length book, then it would be this one. Partially because I feel the lore she included can be greatly explored, and I would like to know more about the monsters of this world. Furthermore, I am really interested to explore Red's past even more and see how she became the person she currently is.
However, I might be a bit biased with this story, as it reminds me of Opal Rayne's Duskwalker series. And most importantly, the spice in this short story was a solid 5/5. The spice for the overall book would earn a 3.5/5 from me.