Re-Listening (3 years later)
So I was recently trying to find a book to revisit in an audio format by looking over my shelf - the Five-Stars book to be exact and I came across a rejected mate story of all things. Now that was a blast from the past and not unwelcome. But considering the preference that was obviously well in progress at that time (judging by the original review below) I decided to instead turn to Ben instead of Mave.
It was kind of fun at times. But I still stand by everything I said in the OG review, which is a bit of a shame. I think I found moments where I actually enjoyed the sheer teenage drama of two alphas masquerading as omegas confronting the (in some way) progressive but also super traditional pack in the future alpha and current jerk and his two minions. There's a certain pettiness we all (most of us) enjoy, that I try not to give into 😅 when watching the most popular shifter get rejected repeatedly and put into place by the girl he insulted and underestimated. That moment of triumph not many bullied kids (people) experience by revealing they're better than the jerks.
It did make romance kind of precarious because both love interests (for both books) were the de facto antagonists and the book was only digging deeper into the issue as every encounter deepened the negative feelings between them and when you don't want the MC to get into the relationship with the love interest... in a romance book... something is wrong, to say the least. This isn't even enemies to lovers, I feel like, just another example of "he may have behaved like a jerk but Trauma so all can be forgiven". Or, in this case, because of peer pressure? Society? His parents certainly don't believe you shop for a spouse instead of falling in love. It did provide some opportunities for growth. I feel like most romances go for circumstances rather than character. X is perfect for Y, now they just have to realize that and figure out how to be together. The End. But Thad being a snob provides a rudimentary version of character development and he has to change before he can find his HEA.
I was just as bothered by Lena this time around. I liked what we saw of her at the beginning, she was the goal-oriented, level-headed, smart and ambitious girl in a bunch of cheerleader-types. It was great. I think good characters are a sign of a well-rounded book and Lena quickly became the worst of them all - I was constantly annoyed by her behaviour aaaand by Thad not standing up to her demands, which made me respect him even less. For someone who proclaims to be the badassest Beta, he sure could use some spine in him. Not to mention her behaviour was so... stalker, obsessive no-is-not-an-answer birch - I think there's this layer of "protection" because she's a woman, I think we're not as quick to judge as if this was a guy harassing a girl even thought the situation should be just as creepy.
The aforementioned encounters did get pretty repetitive: Knox was a jerk, Mave stood up to him, and both parties were super angry, rinse and repeat with minor variations.
The posturing was kinda hilarious but really fit into the whole trying hard to impress vibe. Characters always posing in their own scenes like they're doing a photoshoot and someone is going to whip up a fan to provide the dramatic wind in their hair. He's not wearing sweatpants, they're Designer sweatpants 😂 he says in the middle of a crisis. People can say someone is so hot they could rock a potato sack, when you try the character to say it about themselves, that just makes them conceited. There was this almost fourth-wall feeling to the narration because of it, like they're waiting for applause or a gasp or wolf whistles once the scene was set and we could be in awe of the Fortune twins. Look at me and my too-small shirt stretching across my pecs? *flex, flex* And Ben having a sex playlist in his car? And supplies? I am both impressed and... scandalized 😂.
I think reading this without reading Mave's story first is also hurting my impressions. Don't get me wrong, I adore the fact we are not regaled with the same scenes from her book but it means I am missing some crucial facts as well as emotions.
---
While this book was more my target reading at the moment, I am actually happy it brought me to the first book with Mave and her badass ways. Unfortunately, the high from having a strong female lead I could respect could not longer mask the underlying... complications of this series.
And while I enjoyed reading it, I can't help noticing all the things that make this more of a three-star reading.
The main problem being that this whole book (and series) seems to thrive on this unhealthy cycle of rage and soothe. Sure, the whole fiction is basically based on the fact you have to make your reader feel negative emotions just to make him feel happy but this was a particularly... frustrating and pretty angsty version. I am not fond of angst. Or drama. And here, someone was way too often saying or doing stupid stuff and then we could watch Ben or Mave or sometimes Blake or Harriet (or really, others) kick-ass of their enemies - again and then it happened again and yeah, then it was HEA. Watching Mave win was good because so many books disappointed me but here, it was not only repetitive but... meh.
Lena was the second and more pressing issue. She was supposed to be a calm and collected character and - spoiler, I mean it, she is not. She is the antagonist and her descent into madness... it felt undignified especially because it already happened with Nikita and treating Mave well but then making these two girls into some power/men-hungry itches... I had hoped for more. But then, her treatment of any female beside Mave and Harriet is pretty... disappointing, though I guess it was still better here than in Mave's book.
The last issue was more general and straddling the line of awkward and effective. Making a cool scene - as in making your characters and the scene look cool (we're talking Avengers assembling in the middle of that bridge, the music playing and the camera rotating around them) is tough. Super tough. And the author have gone... bit much? Some of it was (as other review pointed out) this insistent need to repeat car brands. Mave and Ben don't have a car, they have Tesla, bunny shifter has a convertible, Nerdy has Mercedes, Blake has BMW... and see! see?! I rarely care about cars and here I can actually recite them off the top of my head. The same with songs. More generally, it's the descriptions. You always know what someones is wearing (and I just don't care) including how hot /cool / unemotional/ sexy / graceful / etc. someone looks.
"I had my large body draped across the back seat of Harriet’s tiny car while I lazily watched the sparse patches of clouds float along over our heads." (who refers to their own body as large or say they were draped over something?)
It's like the author is trying to image this on the big screen though it's not unusual.
Overall, it's a fairly good book but unless you thrive on this kind of conflict, it might not be the one for you.