Imperium Restored, like Conventions of War, proves that WJW is terrible at ending a trilogy. What happened, we had a really solid build up for 2 full books and then this absolute slogfest nothingburger of a finish.
This book can be summed up in a single word: Mundane. So much tedium and so little resolution of anything.
The first third of this book is insufferable. While the set up for the coming war was solid and promised an exciting battle, the set up for the Martinez/Sula romance was absurd contrived nonsense, and everything that happens at the beginning of this book is predicated on that. The resulting forced melodrama infects every aspect of the narrative and makes it grating and tedious. Both mains are forced into making a long string of completely uncharacteristic decisions for...reasons. As they follow this new path, Sula and Martinez both become extremely unlikable. I honestly came to hate them both and wished they would just get killed off already.
One of the best aspects of these books was the synergy between Martinez and Sula when they would work together and that happens exactly never in this book. Any time they have to discuss tactics, Martinez has a middleman that talks to Sula and reports back to him. This is so boring. The most important battle in the entire 6 book series and they don't work together. W H Y????? Why would anyone want this?
Sula becomes a broken shell of a human wallowing in misery. She has taken up drinking and literally every scene of hers involves drinking heavily or being hungover, because a descent into alcoholism is apparently character development? At one point we're treated to a scene of her waking up in her own vomit and she has the stark realization that she "smells like the real Caro Sula". What's this, are we on the cusp of a major character breakthrough?? Nope, this event has no impact and Sula doesn't change whatsoever. She has also embraced her inner edgelord and taken up the nihilistic mantra "nothing matters, everything dies" which is so cringe every time she says it.
Martinez, who typically walked the line between likeable and unlikable has taken a bold leap firmly into unlikable. He cuts Sula out of his life for the stupidest reason ever and while she is wallowing is misery he is pleased that he has saved his marriage and cant wait to go pop out another kid. He is back to being a pompous ass who only cares about his promotion and his own glory. In the middle of the book he finally takes some time to research Lamey and realizes he was a horrible person. Martinez even develops a hatred for him, yet despite the fact that this casts Sula's killing of him and Martinez's subsequent decision to banish her in a completely different light, he has no change of opinion whatsoever. How is that possible?
What should have been an epic final space battle in the middle of the book is hollow and boring. While there are lots of missiles and explosions, there is no tension whatsoever. Nobody works together. There are no harrowing actions, no heroics, no tragedies, no unexpected events, nothing. It almost feels like everything was scripted in a playbook and it plays out exactly as scripted...hey, wasn't that the whole thing they were fighting against?? As with everything else in this series, no one is ever in real danger, therefore the events carry no weight or impact. You know they're going to win and they do it exactly how you expect them to. The battle in book 5 was much better. There is a scene where Martinez has the option to help Sula or seek glory and without hesitation he seeks glory because of course. Although it doesn't matter whatsoever because the enemy surrenders 2 seconds later and therefore Sula was never actually in danger. Awesome writing. Sula suffers potentially life-threatening trauma but is of course fine and it is never mentioned again. She does decide to start sleeping with the doctor though who turns out to be...actually kind of fine, but like Casimir he is given almost no development whatsoever. Can she seriously not just have one decent romance for more than 5 pages??
After the war we're treated to 200 more pages of endless procedure, politics, meetings, discussion, dinner, and more politics. Lots of irrelevant side plots for minor characters, including multiple pages of how someone stole a plate from Martinez's suite. Everything is super mundane and nothing leads to any actual resolutions. Nobody can decide how to run things after the war and nothing gets settled.
At one point there is a firefight in the street which brings together Sula and Martinez in further contrived circumstances. Things almost get exciting for a minute when explosions threaten the group, but guess what, the two of them don't exchange any dialogue whatsoever (seriously, how is that even possible?) and no one is ever in any real danger. Nothing comes of this event whatsoever.
More Procedure and meetings. No decision making. They throw some convocates off a building I think? I was skimming at this point.
At the very end Sula and Martinez both happen to be at a random party and out of nowhere FINALLY have a "confrontation" where they exchange a whopping 5 or so lines of "heated" dialogue where she finally tells him why she killed Lamey to which he is just like "oh" and then he acknowledges he knows she isn't the real Caroline Sula to which she is like "what are you gonna do about it?" and he is like "nothing" and that's it, case closed. Absolutely nothing comes of this dialogue whatsoever. Nothing! And then I guess they never speak again or whatever. 5 books of the author building this relationship where these two were supposedly soooo in love and this is all the resolution we get? WTF. I don't understand how an author can spend so many books and so much of their time and energy developing a pair of characters only for this sort of pitifully brief exchange to be the climax. All of the pain and turmoil and struggle and...that's it!??? I used to really care about these characters but this has become unbelievably dull. Honestly, as much as I wanted this ship to sail initially, he should have just dropped the romance entirely from the new trilogy, it's so utterly pointless and unsatisfying and only corrodes the rest of the narrative.
Afterwards, Sula decides she just wants to gain enough power to be a military dictator and decides to marry a random rich dude because she needs more money and status. Wow, I can't believe I used to really enjoy this character.
Martinez returns to the same character he started the initial series as, his arc and struggle change nothing and merely lead him into being the exact person he was fated to be anyway.
And then in the author's typical last few page "twist" where he tends to ruin everything with some ridiculous and contrived dramatic point, its revealed that it was actually Terza Chen all along! She was obsessed with being with Martinez for...some reason, so she vaguely plotted to keep him and Sula apart. Which was effective only because they are apparently just too stupid to simply communicate with one another. oh my god! so crazy! except that this is also contrived and really doesn't change anything about the story or characters other than to provide a cheap twist.
Overall this book is extremely frustrating and deeply unsatisfying. By extension it taints the rest of the series considering there is no real point to any of what happened: the war was boring and potentially changes nothing, the romance built up to literally nothing, and there very little resolution for anyone or anything. Big GoT Season 8 vibes where an enjoyable series is ruined by an enormously unsatisfying finale where, despite the characters arcs that have been set up over the course of 5 books, the author has specific places he needs the characters to end at and so the characters are forced to act in absurd/unrealistic/extremely out of character ways to make sure they get there. Similarly, major plots go unresolved and it's largely unclear what, if anything, was the point of all this. The author had 15+ years to figure out how to end the Dread Empire's Fall series and this is all we got? Weak.
While I definitely enjoyed 4 of the 6 books, I kind of regret wasting my time with this entire series considering how disappointing the finish for both trilogies is. I really hope WJW doesn't try to write more in this universe and if he does I certainly won't be reading it.