Anthologies are tough and usually hold hits and misses. I enjoyed this anthology for the most part, and even the misses were mostly due to the nature of the story length and medium that the writer could’ve utilized better. The main reason why I picked this up was to read Kevin Conroy’s memoir piece and oh boy, did my heart weep while reading it.
Pride short stories tend to go a little ham-fisted for me, but the hit stories for me (“Confessions,” “Think of Me,” “Up at Bat,” “The Gumshoe in Green,” “Bats in the Cradle”) were more focused on characters who happen to be queer rather than the queerness itself. “Confessions” is about Connor Hawke’s asexuality, but it stood out to me as a story with strong character voice and it’s one of the shorter stories so once it made its point, it didn’t drag. The climax in “The Gumshoe in the Green” did end up a bit ham-fisted about the bisexual stereotype of sleeping around, but I was so intrigued by the story and worldbuilding that it got me to request Far Sector from the library, so I say it did their job.
Unfortunately, as cute as “Special Delivery” was, I’m personally not sold on Tim/Bernard as a couple, even with the “Sum of our Parts” included in the book. I’m sorry, TimBern shippers! 😂 If anything has the author’s ham-fist showing, it’s Tim/Bernard. I was hoping to learn more about Bernard as a character, but he’s still painfully two-dimensional next to Tim. If there’s any reading recommendations to flesh out his character more, I’m all ears.
The other stories not yet mentioned were okay, not memorable, but still got me interested. But please, do not get me started on “Super Pride.” There was ham all over the place that I was tempted to tell Damian to get out of there. If I wasn’t sold on TimBern, then I’m definitely not sold on JonJay. I’m all for Damian and Jon content since my DC fixation started with Super Sons, but Jon’s character here was just a mouthpiece for positive queer virtue signaling, while Damian actually has the right idea of bringing protective gear to Pride despite being drawn with shadows and a villain-y smirk. I don’t know, I just hated (and I don’t use that word lightly) the way Jon dismissed him with as many words as possible. There’s this one panel where Damian mentions Jon’s missing childhood (*shouts to the sky* Brian Michael Bendis!!!) and I felt more for Damian in that one panel than for Jon’s cardboard characterization and forced relationship with Jay (trust me, I actually did read the Son of Kal-El run to try and understand it; I could not).
Okay, I’m gonna stop before this turns into a Jon Kent “look at what they did to my boy” rant, but I see Damian Wayne in three of these stories (yes, I counted his other-universe girl variant) and I know what he is… Gay, gay boy 😂