I read this as part of an Open University module I took. This is a review of the text as a standalone workbook, not the course or the book's integration with the course.
What worked for me:
👍 For the most part, I didn’t get a sense of gatekeeping here. The introductory sections were very open and welcoming, even encouraging workbook users to claim the identity of writers.
👍 While it felt repetitious at times, there’s an attempt to draw the sections (fiction, poetry, and life-writing) together cohesively, encouraging writers to borrow and shape techniques across forms.
👍 I found the fiction exercises and prompts the strongest in the book - there was a good mix of activities and, early on, it’s evident how the exercises are crafted to build and shape skill.
👍 The contributors all had different styles and voices. Some I gelled with, others I didn’t. I was grateful for the sheer number of contributors across fiction and life-writing as it gave me a rounded view of the topics without getting bogged down by an instruction style that didn’t work for me.
What I wasn’t so keen on:
👎 Some of the sections are written in very dry, corporate language that didn’t suit the theme of creative writing particularly well.
👎 Heavy emphasis on western tropes and storytelling mechanics. I was disappointed that there wasn't much space for deviation or experimentation.
👎 I was disappointed by the lack of depth to the workbook. It’s very general and high-level.
👎 I found the extracts very English, culturally (they felt overly bleak across sections too).
👎 The content warnings were so robotic and stilted: list the warnings, please don’t tell us how we should feel about them!
👎 The poetry section felt the most inaccessible to me. I found the readings reinforced my dislike for poetry rather than opening my mind to this diverse form. The exercises in the poetry chapters were also the most uninspired in the book, for me.
👎 The publishing section felt like filler. Basic research into submitting work makes this section feel dated and clunky. For a book this introductory, including a section on getting published feels really premature.
Personally, I found this book most useful when paired with edX and Coursera courses to broaden my perspective, examine more diverse forms of fiction and poetry, and deepen my understanding.
Like any workbook, the usefulness of this book will depend on your existing knowledge and what you’re trying to achieve. Overall, I found it too surface-level and very geared toward an England readership. It was fine to work through but I’m glad it was a companion to a course, rather than something I purchased alone.