The Whispering Women

Delafield & Malloy Investigations #1

by Trish MacEnulty

Born into a once-wealthy Manhattan family, Louisa Delafield survives by doing the one thing she’s suited for: writing a society column. But in January 1913, the death of a police matron in a bombed brownstone convinces Louisa to write about darker subjects. “Muckraking” goes against her upbringing, but once her blinders are off, she can’t continue to protect the privileged.

Ellen Malloy came to America to escape the priests who told her she would go to hell for loving women. However, her job as a debutante’s personal maid affords her no opportunity for a life, much less for finding love. After witnessing the death of a fellow servant during an illegal abortion, she flees her comfortable position in fear for her life.

When the two women are brought together by New York’s top bomb squad cop, Louisa and Ellen dive into a dangerous world of gangsters, bordellos, and back-alley abortions to find the connection between Ellen’s friend and the dead police matron. Their investigation makes them the target of powerful forces who will stop at nothing, even murder, to bury the truth.

This book is a timely reminder of an era when the legal system and social norms prevented women from enjoying the freedom to control their own destinies.

Genres: Historical Fiction, Mystery, Fiction, Mystery Thriller

383 pages, Kindle Edition

First published August 27, 2022

About the author

I have also written books under the name "Pat MacEnulty."

Reviews

[Dea]

It’s worrisome when you can say that a story set over a hundred years ago is timely and relevant, but this book couldn't be more so. Most of the rights it addresses are under attack today: abortion, contraception, LGBTQ equality, the right to vote, etc. Early 20th century New York was a fascinating time and place, so we also get an exploration of what life was like for both the upper and lower classes, early labor union conflict, burgeoning feminism, the fight (still ongoing...) for equality for women in the workplace (even delving into the roles women played in street gangs).... it's a lot. There are a LOT of moving parts here, and unfortunately not enough time to explore them all properly.

The novel is well-researched: New York City of the 1910s comes alive in vibrant detail, though we often get overwrought descriptions like this (of an old church): “The incensed air smells of oppression, of men’s musty vestments, and of old women’s tears.” Our two protagonists live in very different worlds, and we get to know both - the old money high society elite, and the immigrant servant class - as we traverse old New York from ballrooms to brothels. Ellen's narrative accurately represents the lack of power and the consequent opportunity for exploitation faced by the servant class. Louisa's arc is well-paced, and her growing awareness of the inequality, corruption, and cruelty inflicted by the world she comes from on those less fortunate is well-done. There are compelling supporting characters with interesting backstories, and hopefully there will be time to develop some of these further in future books in the series.

Thank you to NetGalley and Prism Light Press for this ARC.

["Avonna · Rating 5 out of 5]

Check out all my reviews at: https://www.avonnalovesgenres.com

THE WHISPERING WOMEN (A Delafield & Mallory Investigation Book #1) by Trish MacEnulty is the first book in an exciting historical mystery series featuring two very different young women in early 20th century New York who come together to fight against injustice. This is a story set over a hundred years ago and is yet eerily relevant to the present.

Louisa Delafield was born into a Manhattan society family. Due to her father’s murder and her family’s financial downfall, she now earns her living and is supporting her mother by writing a society column for The Ledger. Ellen Mallory came to America from Ireland and is a lady’s maid to a young debutante. When Ellen witnesses the death of a fellow servant during an illegal abortion, she finds she must flee her position in fear of her life.

Louisa and Ellen stories converge as Louisa looks to discover why a police matron was blown up while investigating an abortionist and Ellen is running from those Louisa is investigating and wants to seek revenge for her friend. The two must learn to navigate the social class system to discover a way to combine their strengths and find the power to bring powerful evil into the light.

I loved this story and both Louisa and Ellen are great protagonists. Louisa and Ellen are well developed, and their differences make them a good pair that you want to succeed. You can tell the research into early 1900’s New York life and society is extensive and the descriptions pull you right into the story. The plot is well paced, and the investigation is believable. So many of the topics in this plot, such as illegal abortion, women’s rights, and LGBTQ issues are as discussion worthy then as they are today.

I highly recommend this wonderful start to a new series with memorable strong main characters, and I am looking forward to seeing where this author takes them next.

[♡Heather✩Brown♡ · Rating 5 out of 5]

Louisa Delafield was only 12 years old when her father was found murdered in a hotel room. Now as an adult, she takes care of her elderly mother and writes for the local newspaper. When confronted with the hard truth of her finances, Louisa must do something before she loses everything she and her mother have left. Her new boss wants a 1910’s version of TMZ but Louisa doesn’t know if she can write such gossip about her peers. Then Ellen, a servant woman who has witnessed a terrible crime and needs a place to hide, enters Louisa’s life. When these two women meet, will Louisa find her inner strength to do what needs to be done or cave under the pressure of conformity?

This is a historical fiction crime thriller that focuses on women, abortions, and women’s rights in the 1910’s era and the women who dared to take on these issues. Once you pick this book up you won’t be able to put it down. This was another “read the entire book in one sitting” type of read. It’s an easy read that flows so smoothly you’ll hardly realize you’re even reading - the best kind of reading.
This was a fun book to read. A more feminist read at the core, but there’s enough guts and glory in this book that any reader could pick it up and enjoy it. I would recommend to anyone who likes historical fiction, crime, thriller type reads.

Triggers: abortion, murder

I love historical fiction reads because they teleport you back in time. Trish MacEnulty writes so vividly that the reader feels like they’ve been transported back in time. All her research paid off. I felt a range of emotions while reading this, from excitement to horror to the suspense of doing something you shouldn't be doing but do it anyways. I cannot wait to read her next book The Burning Bride - where we will see more of Louisa and Ellen!

I received an ebook for free but then bought my own paperback version, either way, I leave this review of my own accord. Thanks Trish, HenryRoi, and Tide Phoenix!
@henryroipr @tide.phoenix.coffee

[Kathy · Rating 3 out of 5]

I don't have much to say about this book as I appreciated parts and disliked parts. Others here have represented the content fairly enough. Basically it's a story highlighting women's issues early 1900's New York and at times is very melodramatic.

Kindle Unlimited

[Nancy · Rating 4 out of 5]

Given the opportunity to read this book prior to its publication, I jumped at the chance. As the first effort by Ms. MacEnulty in the historical fiction genre, it definitely piqued my interest!

Additionally, I'm fond of novels about earlier periods in history, whether local, national, or international. There are so many pieces and parts here that I found fascinating: early 20th century New York, both upper and lower class; the blossoming of feminism in the early century; and certainly an introduction to the role of women in street gangs and even early labor union conflict.

The Whispering Women hooks the reader from the first page and moves at a fast pace - certainly a page-turner. I must admit that I'd love to have read more about the actual whispering women in the brand-new Grand Central Station; hopefully MacEnulty will pick up that thread in future novels in the series. There are other threads. With the current turmoil over the issue of abortion, we could all use educating about where we were 100 years ago. And what about LGBTQ issues? Yes - definitely in the mix 100 years ago. All that's missing is the pandemic of 1918. Maybe that is to come?

This is a well-written novel that was a lot of fun to read. I look forward to the next chapter in the Delafield/Malloy adventure.

[Lynelle Clark · Rating 5 out of 5]

Can two women get the lowdown on high society?

Louisa Delafield and Ellen Malloy didn’t ask to be thrown together to bring the truth to light. But after Ellen witnesses the death of a fellow servant during an illegal abortion, Louisa, a society columnist, vows to help her find the truth and turn her journalistic talent to a greater purpose.

When I agreed to review this book, I did not know how inspiring this book would be. The synopsis and book cover alone were enough to convince me to read. Debut novelist Trish MacEnulty’s has written such a compelling story it left me in awe.

This historical fiction is based on true events and factual persons that lived during this period. This was a turnkey period that opened so many doors for us womenfolk. Sometimes we forget how great the struggle was, but it is authors like Ms MacEnulty that remind us again of the sacrifices and the sheer will that drove these women to speak up.

The topics she touches on are not an issue for the poor, but one that touched every woman from the highest to the lowest in society. Even today, it is still a much debated topic with no straightforward answers to the problem. But theses women refused to be silent. Refused to lie down and accept it. They did something; and that alone makes this a powerful story.

The whispering women take you back to 1913 where gangsters made a living from poverty and the political, legal and power hungry rich ruled the world. (Nothing has changed, but today we see them for who they are.)

The Garrett’s, and Bloodgoods are prominent families in this plotline. Their goodness heralded on the front pages of the newspapers. But once Ellen Malloy sees the reality of who they are, she had to run for her life. When she met up with Louisa Delafield, hell was at their doorstep.

Louisa Delafield was one of the high society but also shun because of a murdered father whose failed investments left them destitute. However, her choice of work kept he doors open and with her pen and paper and the knowledge of this society she revealed what these people tried to hide. Her naivety quickly faltered when she experience how the other women lived. What they struggle with and the means to cope with unwanted pregnancies. And, when a policewoman is killed, she found her purpose.

Together, they set out to find the proof to bring the culprits to justice, and fight against an enemy out to destroy them.

The world of gangsters and suffrage, illegal abortions and sex trafficking is an ugly reality that cannot be ignored.

Especially Louisa had to realize who her so-called friends were. And the lengths they would go to protect their money and power. In the end, money doesn’t buy you peace when trouble knocks on your door and the women you try to silence refuse to be quiet.

With the help of an Irish police officer, and Teddy Roosevelt’s input, and a very handsome publisher, these two women find their way in a world so different from what they believed in. Their belief system challenged with each new door that opens, which leads to truths they cannot unlearn.

The author’s writing is crisp and clear. The fast-paced tempo takes you through the streets of New York at such a speed that your fingers struggles to keep up. Each moment a revelation of strength and determination as they built a friendship and grew in their own right. Both women’s characters are relatable. Their sheer will that drives them to the truth is a testimony of the courage each woman possessed. Their voices refused to be silent, no matter what curveballs life (the author) throws at them.


Even the supportive characters’s roles carried the weight of the story and emphasises their most vulnerable moments with honesty.

[Beatrice Rivers · Rating 5 out of 5]

Louisa Delafield has been struggling to scrape by. The wealth her family once had is gone, and she is barely making enough money writing columns for a newspaper to pay the bills. When her job is threatened, she must start writing less about the dresses and events of the upper class, and try to dig up some dirt, something that will draw more readers to her columns.

Ellen Malloy was simply trying to make her way in America, working as a ladies' maid, when a fellow servant, Silvia, ends up pregnant. Ellen goes with her Silvia to an illegal abortion, arranged by one of the people they work for, but things go sideways when Silvia dies, and Ellen finds herself running from people who would capture her for Heaven knows what purpose.

When Louise and Ellen find their paths entwined, a solution reveals itself – Louisa can help to ensure Ellen’s safety by exposing the people that did such things in the paper, but even with the two working together to protect each other, there are many dangerous obstacles in their way, and the way forward is not quite as easy to find as it may seem.

This is a novel I thoroughly enjoyed reading, and I just simply could not put it down. Louisa and Ellen are absolutely fabulous characters, and I loved following their stories. The mystery behind who the doctor is, and what the plans were for Silvia and, after her death, for Ellen, remains mostly unsolved until very near the end of the book. If the wonderful characters weren’t enough to keep me reading, not knowing the truth made it very difficult to put the book down. The story has been laid out perfectly, with just enough information given as you read to keep you hooked, and not enough revealed to let you leave the world within the pages until you knew the truth.

This book deals with some issues that are, unfortunately, still prevalent in today’s society. Topics of the legality of abortions, and women’s rights, are covered in great detail, as Louisa and Ellen delve into trying to find out the truth. Certain things in particular are highlighted, especially how, even though Silvia’s pregnancy was forced upon her, and she had no choice in stopping it, she would’ve been the one punished for ending it. The men face no consequences, even when it is them who are the cause of the problem. The way this book covered such topics was, in itself, tactful, although these things were still very real in the telling. The things Louisa writes about in her column are still pressing issues, over 100 years later, and such parallels show just how important these things are in society now, when we see the layout of society in the past as barbaric.

I loved the inclusion of Louisa’s columns as the story progresses, so the reader knows exactly what information has been revealed and what hasn’t. Louisa is among the women of high society, who all want their names in her column to show off who has the best dresses of the season while living like the lower classes. The inclusion of the column helps to show the difference between the classes as well, catering to both the higher and lower classes by showing off the higher-class ladies to those of the lower classes.

The gangs that lurk in the undergrounds of the streets were an excellent addition that I really enjoyed. The seedy underground has connections that not many can achieve, so if you are after some information, and are not too concerned about safety, that is the place to go. Louisa and Ellen both find themselves in the midst of the Gophers, in the presence of Owney the Killer, in some very different scenarios, and I did creep forward to the edge of my seat while I was reading. Louisa and Ellen find themselves in some incredibly dangerous situations, and I definitely feared for their lives at some points in this novel. If you are after a book that will keep you perched precariously on the edge of your seat throughout the entire book, this is definitely one to go on the to-read list.

This is an absolutely amazing book, that gives a real insight into life for a woman in the early 1900s, and the kind of political and social divides that existed. The entire topic of illegal abortions, and the way the book has been laid out, draws some scary parallels between the past and some present events, which makes this book an even more interesting read. I couldn’t stop reading, it is certainly a great novel, and one I would highly recommend.

[Jade Doodes · Rating 5 out of 5]

I really enjoyed this one, I truly couldn’t put it down. Even though it’s set over 100 years ago, events in it are still relevant - which is a little scary really! I found that the story was well written, as were the characters. The storylines were great, and who doesn’t love a strong leading lady?

[Gregory Byrd · Rating 5 out of 5]

Don’t start reading The Whispering Women unless you can be up until 2:30 a.m. finishing it, as I was.
In this age of social turmoil, one might expect to read a book set in an strange time in the future where women are arrested for their sexual choices, where young female servants are sexually exploited and given abortions by unscrupulous doctors and then die of complications, where women are denied the right to vote and where a privileged class prays on the working classes, even controlling those who make and enforce laws. But The Whispering Women is not a Hunger Games / Handmaid’s Tale future dystopia—it is 1913 New York city.
In this historical whodunnit, Trish MacEulty immerses the reader in the well-researched details of New York city, inserting us among both its old-money elite and its recently-arrived immigrant servant class. Louisa Delafield is the society writer from an old fortune, struggling to support her small household after her father is murdered and her fortune runs out. She is thrust into the role of detective when Irish servant Ellen Malloy arrives in her safekeeping after witnessing her fellow servant die on the table during a botched abortion. As she searches for the doctor in question, Louisa slowly confronts the corruption and brutality of the upper class existence she has written about and supported for a long time. Ellen Malloy’s parallel narrative gives us a view to her powerlessness and exploitation by those she serves and her need to hide her sexual preference for women lest she be arrested as a deviant, and shows us how her grit and determination allow her to rise above her difficulties.
MacEnulty recreates the vibrant atmosphere of 1913 New York city in vibrant detail and astute readers will attend the famous Armory art show, ride along on for the Woman Suffrage Procession in Washington, DC, be there for the opening of Grand Central Station and see the impacts of the criminalization of abortion and birth control on rich and poor alike. The Whispering Women is much more than a time capsule. In the spirit of Miss Fisher’s Murder Mysteries, the reader gets to enjoy an earlier time while experiencing the roller-coaster ride of solving a crime with two strong young women who experience danger and self-growth in a challenging society.

[Janalyn, the blind reviewer · Rating 5 out of 5]

Ellen Malloy work for the Garretts she was the ladies maid for Hattie Garrett, But one night when fellow maid Sesealia, had to be rushed to the hospital she witnessed certain things that would’ve been better for her not to see. She went to the police station looking for an Irish detective that used to know her brother after a miserable stay at the Work house he asked Miss Louisa faraday to take her in. Louisa Fairaday was from one of the nicer families in the upper crust of New York in until recently was thought to be high society but since the death of her father she has since found out they were destitute. She wrote an inconsequential society column for a small paper but when she took Ellen then and learned about what she witnessed and the death of Adele Cummings she made it her business to get to the bottom of it. This book was so good not only was it historically accurate but it was way more than the small summary I put. The author tackles lots of issues that were popular in the day and some that were so popular but we’re still around. Besides touching on popular culture there’s also a great mystery and that is what I enjoyed the most. I found this book to be humorous intriguing compelling and so worth reading a total five star book. I cannot wait for the second book in this New Victorian era mystery series and I can’t recommend this one enough. I received this book from NetGalley and the publisher but I am leaving this review voluntarily please forgive any mistakes as I am blind and dictate my review.

[Mystica · Rating 4 out of 5]

1913 Louisa finds herself in a peculiar position. once part of the rich, upper class
welcomed everywhere now after her fathers financial ruin the family are barely tolerated
in society but Louisa is happy doing what she feels she has a knack for. She writes a society column for The Ledger and though it is not the journalism she seeks, it is the family's
bread and butter.

Forced to face head on the unspoken subject of abortion and the death of a young maid at
the hands of an unscrupulous doctor - not a backyard abortionist but a suave well spoken of
high society, Louisa sets on a course of investigation which literally turns society upside down.
not just abortion, abduction of young women, trafficking them into forced prostitution,
a murder of a young female police investigator and corruption in the Police itself and
cover ups galore.

Louisa puts herself in grave danger and though rescued the story she uncovers shows Manhattan
society at its worst, with those at the top equally involved at least some of them in the
unsavory machinations of high society.

An eye opener at behind the scenes of society - the division between the rich and the poor,
the class consciousness and the condescension and discrimination shown to the Irish, the
Jews and to those involved in 'trade' are all featured here. The struggle for the female vote
is also a small part of the book.

Very well written keeping the reader focussed on the story of Louisa as well as the history
of the time.

[Timothy Miller · Rating 5 out of 5]

It’s rare when you can call a story set over a hundred years ago timely, but that’s the only word for Trish McEnulty’s The Whispering Women. In 1913, a society writer from an old New York family and an immigrant lady’s maid are flung together by fate. Louisa wants a news story; Ellen wants revenge for a death. Two such different allies could hardly be imagined, but both are under the thumb of a corrupt system which still wears a straitlaced Victorian costume. Arrayed against them are a society abortionist, a white slavery ring, and powerful forces who work in the dark to keep their secrets from the light of day—some of whom may appear as their closest allies. Two powerless young women must navigate a soul-crushing class system and find the levers of power they wield when they combine their strengths. These women may have been taught to whisper, but when their time comes, they will roar. Highly recommended.

[Mike Root · Rating 5 out of 5]

A wonderful story!

I had a hard time putting this book down. It kept me guessing till the end. I'm looking forward to reading the next book in this series as soon as I can.

[Yvonne · Rating 4 out of 5]

Louisa Delafield is a society column reporter for a local newspaper. Once a part of the high society she writes about, her father's death and the bad investments he made caused a dramatic change in her family's circumstances. Now she works to support her mother and Suzie, their help. Marriage would have been the answer to her problems; however, with the family's reputation in tatters, Louisa is not considered the catch she once was. Besides, she prefers a career to marriage, but that is not to say she rejects romance entirely. Although she still attends high society events, as a reporter she is no longer one of them and some have great pleasure in reminding Louisa of that fact.

Ellen Malloy, destined for Hell according to her former parish priest, has left behind her family and an unwanted marriage proposal in Ireland. She is employed as a lady's maid by the Garretts, a prominent New York family. After witnessing an illegal abortion performed by a well-known society doctor that ended in tragedy for another servant from the Garrett household, Ellen's life is threatened. Finding it too dangerous to return to the home of her employers, she seeks help from the police. To Ellen's dismay, a safe haven is found for her with the Delafields, once close friends of the Garretts and with whom Louisa is still in contact.

When Ellen recounts her story and reveals who is responsible for the pregnancy which led to the death of her colleague, Louisa is shocked and reluctant to believe her. Ellen fears that Louisa's loyalty is to her class and will divulge her whereabouts to the Garretts, but Louisa has promised to keep this information to herself.

Still in pursuit of a good story to prove that she is able to write more than a society column and with Ellen's help, Louisa launches her own investigation into the murder of a policewoman who had been on the trail of an abortonist at the time of her death. This leads them into danger and reveals more to the naive Louisa of life and the questionable behaviour of the upper echelons of society

Louisa and Ellen are a great partnership. Both are courageous and sensible, and gradually come to trust each other despite their different backgrounds and experiences.

An added bonus is that Louisa's submissions to the newspaper: her society pieces and her more grittier stories, are included in the narrative.

The Whispering Women is an excellent introduction to this series set during a time when New York was changing socially and politically, but not so much for women of the era. This novel raises many issues relevant to their lives: employment, marriage, same sex relationships, abortion, prostitution, and briefly, the suffragist movement. It also explores government corruption and organised crime, the changing cityscape as more opulent buildings are added and the disparity between the poor, immigrants and the wealthy.

The author provided strong characters and a rich historical background against which this mystery unfolded and I'm hoping that the second book in the series, The Burning Bride, will be similarly informative and exciting.

*https://adarngoodread.blogspot.com.au

[m.e.d.u.s.a_r.e.a.d.s · Rating 5 out of 5]

Loved it to the point I was recommending it to friends while reading. It brought 1910s New York culture to life with a classic whodunnit kind of feel that I, simply, thoroughly enjoyed.

[Karen Heenan · Rating 5 out of 5]

The mystery aspect of The Whispering Women was, for me, the least of the book but not because it wasn't well done. I'm not a mystery reader, as a rule, and the fact that the characters and the excellent early 20th century rendering of New York City kept me reading to the end is serious points to the author.

I really enjoyed the variety of characters and settings, from high society to gambling clubs to missions for the poor to brothels. The two main characters, Louisa and Ellen, are well developed, and their motivation stay true to character throughout.

Descriptions of clothing and locations are suitably lush, and add to the immersive feeling of a New York that is now lost. But even in 1913, the period of this book, New York was changing rapidly, so perhaps the characters would recognize our New York more than we would recognize theirs. Certainly many of the issues these women dealt with are still relevant today. We've lost the corsets, but not all of the restrictions.

Back to the mystery. While I said it was not my reason for reading, it was compellingly developed, and I'm already curious to see what Louisa and Ellen get up to in the next book.

[Sandra Vdplaats · Rating 4 out of 5]

Louise is financially grounded after her father's death. To still be able to support herself somewhat, Louise writes a society column.
A second storyline is that of Ellen, she witnesses an abortion gone wrong - and she knows who the child's father was. She has to flee at the risk of her life.
The storylines appears to have a common link: the death of a policewoman, a doctor who helps ladies of good character with "their problem" (i.e., an unplanned pregnancy, because with it, of course, they were no longer marriageable, as the rest of the family would be shunted because of the scandal)

This historical novel turned out to be a pleasant surprise. I enjoyed reading the book immensely.
It gives a glimpse into the world of ‘endless blitz of revelry and noise.’ ‘..[ red..]
The story takes place in 1913 in New York, and begins with the opening of Grand Central Terminal in New York, ending with the Great Suffrage Parade of 1913.
Actual historical events and - people are included in the narrative, making it lean toward narrative nonfiction.
I found the writing style very enjoyable to read, you are completely immersed into the story. It is very cinematically written.
The story is somewhat cliche here and there, and lightheartedly written, it is the historical setting and the historical figures that make it a compelling account.
So we meet Lady Lucy Duff (Titanic survivor- later a leading fashion designer), the VanderBilt family, Nelly Bly, Owney Madden, who ran the famed Cotton Club, -among others, the Knickerbocker Club, Marcel Buchamp whose works caused quite a stir at the 1913 Armory Show…and the notorious Dusters, and Gophers.
The main emphasis of the story is on the (suffocating/changing/social) position of women, suffrage, social class, and lbthiqi+ -

This was both a bizarre as well as a fascinating time: - these were the times that made New York. - from the Gophers and the Dusters to the puissant rich branches of the Dutch and British aristocracy who at that time were among the very-very-rich in the world.
I found the ending of the story a bit of a shame - I would have liked to see Louse be completely independent - in the end she is just like the women she writes about…
And oh, that miserable money and status, if you are unhappy, or have to marry for money to be financially secure to keep up appearances and the family name- no, then Ellen has the best going for her: not a penny to her name, but someone who truly loves her for who she is.
This is the start of a series, and I look forward to reading the sequel.

**** four stars. Thank you Netgalley and the publisher for this arc. I leave this review voluntarily.

[D.K. Marley · Rating 5 out of 5]

Set in the early 1900s in the glittering New York City, The Whispering Women by Trish MacEnulty tells the story of Louisa Delafield, a woman born into a wealthy family who must learn to work and support herself and her mother following the murder of her father. Louisa begins working as a journalist to make ends meet. She finds herself in the middle of the muckraker news era. She shies away from this news style and focuses instead on the society events that she would have been attending as a young socialite if her father had not been murdered leaving her and her mother with little money. When Louisa’s path crosses with Ellen, a woman working as a maid, Louisa begins to understand that there are forces at work hiding the questionable things that are happening within the city after Ellen witnesses the death of a fellow servant from an illegal abortion gone awry. Ellen and Louisa think they have very little in common. They come from different classes, have different ideas about sexuality, and have had vastly different experiences. They will quickly develop a relationship and armed with Ellen as her ally, Louisa will need to embrace the muckraking journalism style she had avoided to uncover those responsible for several unsavory things going on in New York City all while she searches for her father’s murderer. The Whispering Women challenges traditional values about marriage, independence, sexuality, birth control, and more that are just as relevant today as they were in the early 1900s.

“She had seen what could happen when a woman’s livelihood was dependent on marriage. Her once vibrant mother now lived like a hermit, sitting in her invalid chair all day, reminiscing about days long gone.”

The Whispering Women is full of well-developed, rich characters. WIth clear internal and external flaws, the main characters are far from perfect but easy to relate to. Louisa Delafield and Ellen Malloy serve as excellent character foils for each other and balance the two very different aspects of society and wealth that are expertly portrayed throughout the book. When their stories collide, readers are taken on a journey that allows them to see how women’s lives, rights, and experiences parallel each other regardless of economic status, sexuality, background and experience.

“That’s what women like her were, according to the law. Criminals. Deviants. She thought of her first and only kiss with a woman. That didn’t make her feel like a criminal or a deviant. It was as natural as singing.”

As a historical fiction book, the setting, issues, and experiences of the characters are deeply rooted in the history of the early 1900s. While the plot is clearly set in this time period, The Whispering Women creates a story that will easily parallel modern day issues that are very relevant to women’s rights in the early 1900s and now. True historical fiction readers will be able to easily pick up on these parallels and themes. The Whispering Women and all the issues within the book are extremely relevant to current events, ideas, and beliefs. Issues that are addressed in the stories of these women include birth control, abortions, and sexuality as well as marriage, careers, independence and so much more. This book, whether intentional or not, provides an excellent commentary on everything from abortions to homosexuality and clearly illustrates how it affects all women from all walks of life even today. Modern readers, particularly female readers, will relate to the stories of the women in this book.

““Well, I didn’t even know women were working for the police in investigative roles. She, apparently, was looking into illegal...I don’t know how to put this delicately,” Louisa said.
“Abortions?” Dorothy asked.
“Yes. An issue that affects all women, don’t you agree?” She hoped that Dorothy’s interest in suffrage would extend to other problems women faced. ”

The book is incredibly well written and is free of grammatical errors. It has been expertly proofread and edited. Readers will find the writing to flow nicely and in a way that feels seamless. MacEnulty is a master of imagery and does an incredible job describing the scenes throughout the book in a way that readers will easily be able to picture each place she describes and feel as if they are right there in the middle of the scene. This creates a book that is engrossing and readers may find that they are not able to put it down.

“Winter memories were equally idyllic. Bundled up under blankets as they traversed Central Park in a sleigh pulled by snorting horses, steam billowing from their nostrils. An only child, she had loved it when the children all piled together like puppies and the parents pretended they didn’t exist.”

The intended audience for The Whispering Women is readers who enjoy historical fiction, particularly those who are interested in early 1900s urban history, as well as mystery lovers. MacEnulty has done a phenomenal job creating a well developed plot that maintains historical accuracy. It is clear that MacEnulty has put in appropriate research about the time period, city, and society of the era. The descriptions of New York City, Grand Central Station, women’s rights, healthcare, and so much more are both accurate and vivid. MacEnulty clearly knows what historical fiction fans like in books and she caters to that with her writing, descriptions, plot, and historical elements. There are elements of mystery as well making this very much a historical fiction mystery.. Readers who enjoy fiction with a focus on history, women’s rights, or even a bit of mystery will also thoroughly enjoy The Whispering Women.

The Whispering Women comes highly recommended for those with an interest in women’s rights and movements, history, or just well written fiction. MacEnulty knows her audience well and easily writes to satisfy her readers. For those with a budding interest in historical fiction, this would be a fabulous book for first time historical fiction readers. Historical settings and references are well developed and explained so even those not familiar with this era should be able to easily follow and understand the plot.

“If women knew their power before signing it over to some husband for life, they’d never marry, she thought. Instead they’d rule the world.”

Overall, The Whispering Women by Trish MacEnulty is a well researched and well written historical fiction and mystery novel with an expertly developed plot with rich characters that are both believable and relatable as women. Readers will enjoy the fast paced tone and beautifully detailed descriptions and settings all while sitting on the edge of their seats as Lousia tries to uncover the truth.

*****

“The Whispering Woman” by Trish MacEnulty receives five stars and the “Highly Recommended” award of excellence from The Historical Fiction Company

[Joni · Rating 4 out of 5]

Louisa Delafield was previously a member of high society but has since lost her standing due to her deceased father's bad investments. However, Louise is still able to rub elbows with the upper class through her role as a writer for the society page of The Ledger. This allows her to attend all of the high-class events while making money to support her mother and their modified standard of living.

In a strange turn of events, Louisa gets connected to Ellen Malloy. Ellen was previously a ladies maid for the Garrett's - a longtime family friend of the Delafield's. Ellen was a witness to some suspect events that led to the death of fellow maid, Sesealia.

Both women, from very different levels of society, find themselves on the trail to find out who killed Sesalia. This exposes them to corruption at the very highest levels and the willingness to do whatever it takes to keep things secret and keep images untarnished. The story also exposes the world of forced abortions, white slavery and gangs. Despite Louisa's decline from society, Louisa still considers the Garrett family and other families to be her friends. However, this murder investigation forces her to look more closely at these individuals and she struggles to believe they could have any involvements in these corrupt events.

This story takes place in New York City in 1913 but in many ways Louisa and Ellen reminded me of historical Nancy Drews. They were both on the case, risking their lives and fighting for justice and the rights of others. The novel is a page turner and will keep you on the edge of your seat.

I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed above are my own.

[Nicole Dunton · Rating 5 out of 5]

Title: The Whispering Women
Author: Trish MacEnulty
Release Date: September 6th, 2022
Page Count: 387
Start Date: November 18th, 2022
Finish Date: December 1st, 2022

Review:
Story: I didn't know how I was going to feel about this book going into it. I went into it like I go most books. Blindly. It's a historical fiction. It's also filled with mystery and intrigue. It's told in two different points of view. Both points of view are very important to the story. It is very important to understand that this story takes place in 1913 and is very realistic to the time period as well. I'll leave it at that. I did really enjoy the book. I did not expect the ending at all. Any of it.
Characters: Louisa is your average wealthy society girl. Until she isn't. Her father winds up in a scandal, and everything she knows gets turned upside down. I empathized with her a lot. I also related and connected with her in quite a few ways as well. We also have Ellen. She finds herself in a situation that puts her in danger. She manages to flee, but she won't be safe until things come to a close. I also related to her as well.
Critiques: None.
Final Thoughts: I have loved everything about this book. Then I found out it was the first book in a series! You have no idea how happy that made me. I will definitely be continuing this series. I'm really looking forward to seeing the adventures of these two ladies from here forward! I want more people to read this book so I have somebody to talk about it with!

[Tera (TheBookishAbyss) · Rating 5 out of 5]

Louisa Delafield is a former member of high society, but her father’s murder and the loss of wealth have damaged her family’s standing. Now, she writes the society page for The Ledger, a local newspaper, allowing her to make money to support her mother, their maid, and herself in their small dwelling, but still be part of aristocratic functions with the friends from her past life. Sordid events, however, will put her on the trail of murder where she will experience lifestyles and conditions far different from her own. Her path crosses with Ellen Malloy, a victim and target of those Louisa is investigating. As Ellen helps Louisa chase the story, both women build self-confidence and realize their worth in 1913 society.

This story is very well-written with amazingly developed characters. I enjoyed witnessing Louisa’s growth from the girl stubbornly clinging onto her past to a strongly determined woman looking toward the future. This book tackled a lot of feminine issues within a strongly developed plot successfully. A fun, recommended read.

[Leslie Erkman · Rating 5 out of 5]

This story sucked me in. I stayed up late reading and only stopped once I dropped the book from falling asleep.
This story is a wonderfully written historical mystery romance. You can tell the author did her research.
We get to follow two women in the story. A woman that was once a part of the upper crust. She now works in a newspaper and trying to still fit in. You get to see her change and grow throughout the book.
Then we have a poor Irish woman that has left Ireland for America hoping for a better life. She gets a job as a lady’s maid. She doesn’t feel like she’s making anything with her life. She witnesses something terrible and it throws these two women in the same orbit.
They both have lessons to learn and growing into their own skin.
I honestly didn’t expect to love this book as much as I did. I plan to continue with this series. I can’t wait to see what these two ladies do next.

[Pat Allen · Rating 5 out of 5]

A tumultuous time in history

I found this historical novel to be enthralling. Written at a time when society women did not go out to work, but often married into money, while the poor suffered.
Louise was born into society, but was forced to work to survive and support her mother, because her father had been murdered after losing his wealth.
Louise found work at minimal pay as a journalist. Being one of the first women reporters, she found herself unexpectedly experiencing the life poverty-stricken women had to endure. She was thrown in at the deep end where she very nearly became the victim of high society depraved men.
Her very truthful articles published in the women's column in the newspaper for the first time, exposed the evil taking place.
Fascinating and enjoyable!

[Melissa Horn · Rating 5 out of 5]

Set in 1913 Manhattan, Ellen, a handmaid to an elite family, witnesses a doctor kill a young woman during a botched abortion. Louisa, a society journalist, is reaching out to capture the doctor performing these surgeries and bring him to justice. The two women team up, bringing a team of elites down by openly discussing the medical horrors that occur behind closed doors, and open the community's eyes to the importance of woman's rights.

This book was an amazing read. It discusses many important issues that are still being debated 100 years later (today) without making the book too political. I recommend this book to be read by all women to help remind us we do in fact have a voice! Although we have come so far, we still have even farther to go!

[Morgan Conn · Rating 4 out of 5]

I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.


Ellen Malloy witnesses a crime and goes on the run. Louisa Delafield is just trying to make it writing a society column for the local paper.

Together they team up to find out who killed a police matron and Ellen’s friend.

I could not put this book down. It was so fast paced, and so stinking good! The storyline was fantastic, and the twists and turns the book took you on I didn’t expect. And the ending, my word the ending made my heart so happy. This author exceeded my expectations when it came to a mystery, as well as a historical fiction.

I cannot wait to read the next book in this series.

[Michael Ross · Rating 4 out of 5]

You are pulled into the world of 1913 NYC, glimpsing through the doors and windows at the less-than-stellar lives of the upper class. MacEnulty gives a compelling vision of what it was like to be female and poor or lower middle class in New York in that period of time. The main characters, Louisa and Ellen, were well drawn, and you found yourself rooting for them as they navigate male chauvinism, crime, and sham morals of the rich. There was enough left hanging with Ellen to stimulate curiosity about the next book in the series. It reminded me of Anne Perry's Victorian detective novels, in a good way. The issues of abortion and lesbianism were handled tastefully and honestly.

[histeriker · Rating 5 out of 5]

I love historical crime novels and this one didn’t disappoint me. The setting is interesting and vividly described, the characters are lovable and interesting at the same time. I have already read several books with similar setting and characters, but this one still brought some new ideas and the style was very appealing. It is a story I would like to follow in next book.
I highly recommend this book.

[Sabrina · Rating 4 out of 5]

* 4.5/5


I will say I really enjoyed this one. The reason I rated it 4.5 instead of 5 is because the first half is pretty slow so it took me a while to get into it, but once I hit the second half it was hard for me to put it down. I never thought I’d say that a novel set over a hundred years ago is timely, but this is definitely one of them. It’s so well researched and is a good representation of issues back then surrounding abortion and contraceptives. Highly recommend

[Cathie · Rating 5 out of 5]

If you're looking for an intriguing mystery series with intelligent women protagonists, look no further!

The Whispering Women begins with a topic that was as taboo now as it is still today, over 100 years later, in some areas: abortion.

Silvia, a young maid in the household of the influential Garrett family, becomes pregnant by Hugh Garrett, as she would have risked her post had she denied his advances. Now, arrangements have been made for her to have an abortion. Her friend, fellow maid Ellen – a recent Irish immigrant – insists on accompanying her, as does the household chauffeur. But when Silvia has a fatal reaction to the anaesthetic, she dies, and when two men want to take Ellen away, in place of Silvia, she realises that the girl would never have been allowed to return to the house had she survived, but taken to a brothel.

Feisty Ellen fights the men off and flees, but has nowhere to go now. She can't return to the Garretts’ as she'd be apprehended. The secret can't come out. Desperate, she seeks out other Irish emigrants for help, and makes the acquaintance of an Irish detective.

Meanwhile Louisa Delafield, impoverished daughter of a murdered man who'd gambled away their fortune, finds herself destitute when their annual allowance that keeps her, her mother Anna, and maid Suzie, going is stopped. The pot is apparently empty.

A reporter with a local paper, Louisa earns little money, especially compared to her male colleagues. In her column, she reports on social events only – an area her new editor thinks little of – but now she needs to find a way of earning more money.

Their paths cross when Ellen is temporarily placed in Louisa's humble home for her safety, and Louisa begins to take an interest in what's going on, especially as she is a friend of the Garretts. Doubts creep in, but she still can't believe her childhood friend, Hugh, would behave so despicably.

As the police investigates, Ellen and Louisa start digging into the story, trying to identify the doctor who performed the illegal abortion. And it transpires he has friends in high places, putting both their lives in danger.

The Whispering Women is a gripping story, illuminating the social aspects of the times. Louisa is only permitted to attend society events because her family used to belong to the circles, but is still avoided by many due to that fact. Whilst she tries to fit in, she knows her new place. This gives her a sense of independence. Her mother's fate depended on her irresponsible father, and Louise never wants to find herself in that situation. Her transition from society girl transforming into an independent woman as the plot progresses is emotional, and shows up the snobbery of the times.

Ellen fled Ireland to avoid marriage to a man. But Ellen feels herself drawn to women, so she was already cursed in the eyes of her family. America offered a new opportunity, but with Silvia's death – and the social injustice it entails – makes Ellen a determined young woman. But even she has little choice but to accept her fate when the Garretts accuse her of theft.

The Whispering Women is a book you can't put down. It's gripping, utterly compelling, and the plot races from one dangerous incident to another, leaving you with a sense of anticipation of what happens next. The novel is very well researched, and the author takes great care to portray the social upheaval at the time – the abject poverty vs high society; the suffragette movement where Ellen meets Hester; and the injustice of the fate women face(d) at the hands of powerful men. These topics are still as valid now as they were then.

If you're looking for an engaging, intelligent mystery that makes you think and question the norms, this book is for you. It's one of the best novels I've read so far this year. The characters are flawed, very different to each other, but they grow throughout the plot. The setting is gritty and described in great detail. You can just immerse yourself into a world of opportunity – and of grave danger. And the masterful plot is utterly gripping. I can't wait to read the next instalment.

A highly recommended read.

[Siobhain · Rating 5 out of 5]

I was given a copy to review via Henry Roi PR for a book tour. My reviews are always honest and all opinions are my own. #TheWhisperingWomen #TrishMacEnulty #HenryRoiPR #BookTourReview #HistoricalBook #BookReview

The Whispering Women while set in 1913 could arguably be said to tackle some of today’s issues. Dealing with and challenging the ideals of sexuality, rights of women, rights to vote, class struggles, women’s autonomy and LGBTQ+ rights among other issues.

We are introduced to two unlikely allies; Louisa Delafield who was born into a once wealthy Manhattan family and now gets by doing the one thing she is suited for writing a society column. And Ellen Malloy who came to America to escape the priests who told her she would go to hell for liking women. Now working as a debutante’s personal maid she has no opportunity for a life. But fate seems to thrust these two women together and into a world of gangsters, bordello and back-alley abortions to find the connection between the dead police matron who was bombed in a brownstone and the fellow maid who Ellen saw die after an abortion gone wrong. But as they get closer to the truth they become targets of powerful forces who will stop at nothing to bury the truth.

I have to say the writing and characters in this one really kept me hooked and wanting to know more. While I did like Louisa toward the start I have to say I enjoyed seeing her grow and develop has her relationships with Ellen and others continued to grow. We really are almost transported back to the time period with the descriptions and actions of those around but it was almost eerie how a lot of the issues and barriers faced by our protagonists can be seen to still be present more than one hundred years later.

We are kept guessing throughout and learn to piece together the connections with the characters which was another thing I enjoyed. We don’t really know much before Louisa or Ellen do and I actually felt this made me get engrossed more in the story and feel the tension rising as we went on. Sometimes dark and gritty I loved the juxtaposition of ‘high society’ with the lower and dark underbelly of Manhattan. I could hardly put this one down.

Focusing on two strong female leads the Whispering Women is a wonderful introduction to what I hope will be a long series. If you love intrigue and sleuthing this one is definitely for you.