What do you think?
Rate this book
The Secret of More: A Novel
Into the beating heart of Bombay, a city that spins cotton into gold, a young man,Tatya, arrives to make a living. Ambitious and hard-working, he begins to make a name for himself in the city’s famed textile market. Meanwhile, his new bride, Radha, navigates the joys and the challenges of raising a family in a city that is a curious and often bewildering mix of the traditional and the rapidly modernizing.
Having tasted success in the world of textiles, Tatya chances upon an opportunity in an emerging industry—motion pictures—and is swept up in it despite his initial hesitation about this strange world of make-believe. His success seems unstoppable—the silent films he produces draw in the crowds and his new the atreis a marvel, but his friendship with and attraction to an actress, Kamal,threatens to shake his world and causes him to question his integrity.
Set against the backdrop of bustling colonial Bombay, The Secret of More is a journey of relentless ambition, steadfast love, and grim betrayal, as Tatya strives to unlock the secret of more—of having more and being more. In a story that travels from the clatter of textile mills to the glamour of the silent film industry, from the crowded chawls of Girgaon to the luxury of sea-facing mansions, one man and his family learn that in the city of Bombay you can fly—but if you fall, it is a long way down.
Having tasted success in the world of textiles, Tatya chances upon an opportunity in an emerging industry—motion pictures—and is swept up in it despite his initial hesitation about this strange world of make-believe. His success seems unstoppable—the silent films he produces draw in the crowds and his new the atreis a marvel, but his friendship with and attraction to an actress, Kamal,threatens to shake his world and causes him to question his integrity.
Set against the backdrop of bustling colonial Bombay, The Secret of More is a journey of relentless ambition, steadfast love, and grim betrayal, as Tatya strives to unlock the secret of more—of having more and being more. In a story that travels from the clatter of textile mills to the glamour of the silent film industry, from the crowded chawls of Girgaon to the luxury of sea-facing mansions, one man and his family learn that in the city of Bombay you can fly—but if you fall, it is a long way down.
- GenresHistorical Fiction
455 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 5, 2022
8 people are currently reading
357 people want to read
About the author
Tejaswini Apte-Rahm
4 books21 followersTejaswini Apte-Rahm is an award-winning writer from Mumbai, India. Her novel of historical fiction, The Secret of More, won the Tata Literature Live! Book of the Year Fiction Award 2023. It was also shortlisted in 2023 for the JCB Prize for Literature, Atta Galatta-Bangalore Literature Festival Award and Tagore Literary Prize, and longlisted for the Kalinga Literature Festival Award.
Her short story collection, These Circuses That Sweep Through the Landscape, was shortlisted in 2017 for the Shakti Bhatt First Book Prize and the Tata-Nexon Literature Live! First Book Award.
She has co-authored an environmental education book for children, The Poop Book! , which was a Parag Honour Book 2020 and nominated for the Jarul Book Award 2021-22. It was translated into Tibetan in 2022.
Tejaswini's fiction has appeared in various publications including Helter Skelter, Himal Southasian, Mint Lounge, BLink and Six Seasons Review.
She has worked as a journalist and environmental researcher, and has written for Screen, Hindustan Times, Times of India and Asian Age.
She studied in Singapore and the UK, and has lived in Serbia, Israel, Cambodia, Thailand, Myanmar, Bangladesh, Fiji and Azerbaijan. She currently lives in Germany.
Her short story collection, These Circuses That Sweep Through the Landscape, was shortlisted in 2017 for the Shakti Bhatt First Book Prize and the Tata-Nexon Literature Live! First Book Award.
She has co-authored an environmental education book for children, The Poop Book! , which was a Parag Honour Book 2020 and nominated for the Jarul Book Award 2021-22. It was translated into Tibetan in 2022.
Tejaswini's fiction has appeared in various publications including Helter Skelter, Himal Southasian, Mint Lounge, BLink and Six Seasons Review.
She has worked as a journalist and environmental researcher, and has written for Screen, Hindustan Times, Times of India and Asian Age.
She studied in Singapore and the UK, and has lived in Serbia, Israel, Cambodia, Thailand, Myanmar, Bangladesh, Fiji and Azerbaijan. She currently lives in Germany.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews
September 10, 2023
A novel set in the first half of the 20th century, The Secret of More begins with teenaged Tatya coming to Bombay to get a job in the city's bustling cloth trade. The story then follows Tatya, and his growing family - especially his wife Radha and their daughter Durga - as the years pass. As Tatya, ambitious and hungry for more, scales new heights, ventures into areas he could never have dreamed of, including silent cinema.
The characterizations in this novel are excellent. Tatya, hard-headed businessman but at the same time a man of integrity; traditional but forward-thinking, forward-looking. His first boss, who teaches him so much; his brother; the men who become his partners—and, very importantly, the women. Three women in particular play a crucial role in The Secret of More: Tatya’s wife Radha, his daughter Durga, and the beautiful Kamal, the actress who is the leading light of Rising Sun, Tatya’s film company. Three very different women, but each sympathetically depicted, women I could understand even when they behaved or believed in ways that are utterly divergent from my own beliefs and behaviours.
The language is excellent, the storyline gripping, and Bombay—busy and vibrant—is brought vividly to life. From the traditions, the religious beliefs and social norms of the day, to the cloth trade, the world of silent films, the two World Wars, the freedom movement, social reform: it’s all there, woven subtly into the fabric of the story and creating a picture that’s very real.
Coincidentally, the very day I finished reading this book, I heard that it’s been long-listed for the prestigious JCB Prize. This is the nomination I’m rooting for, I loved it so much.
The characterizations in this novel are excellent. Tatya, hard-headed businessman but at the same time a man of integrity; traditional but forward-thinking, forward-looking. His first boss, who teaches him so much; his brother; the men who become his partners—and, very importantly, the women. Three women in particular play a crucial role in The Secret of More: Tatya’s wife Radha, his daughter Durga, and the beautiful Kamal, the actress who is the leading light of Rising Sun, Tatya’s film company. Three very different women, but each sympathetically depicted, women I could understand even when they behaved or believed in ways that are utterly divergent from my own beliefs and behaviours.
The language is excellent, the storyline gripping, and Bombay—busy and vibrant—is brought vividly to life. From the traditions, the religious beliefs and social norms of the day, to the cloth trade, the world of silent films, the two World Wars, the freedom movement, social reform: it’s all there, woven subtly into the fabric of the story and creating a picture that’s very real.
Coincidentally, the very day I finished reading this book, I heard that it’s been long-listed for the prestigious JCB Prize. This is the nomination I’m rooting for, I loved it so much.
November 18, 2023
The secret of more felt home. It's a heartwarming #historicalfiction with cinematic quality to it.
Narrative is beautifully woven in highly orthodox maharashtrian traditions, many of which I am well versed in. While the mention about food made my heart glee, the talk about ill treatment of women in name of culture brought back instigating memories that I have heard from my mother and aunt. I highly appreciate author #tejaswiniapterahm to begin a dialogue around it.
Tatya in his want for More travels the world of textile to Cinema. On his way, his interactions with various female protagonists forms the crux of this beautiful story
The arc traveled by characters in this novel is one of the finest that I have read in recent times
Highly highly recommend it
Narrative is beautifully woven in highly orthodox maharashtrian traditions, many of which I am well versed in. While the mention about food made my heart glee, the talk about ill treatment of women in name of culture brought back instigating memories that I have heard from my mother and aunt. I highly appreciate author #tejaswiniapterahm to begin a dialogue around it.
Tatya in his want for More travels the world of textile to Cinema. On his way, his interactions with various female protagonists forms the crux of this beautiful story
The arc traveled by characters in this novel is one of the finest that I have read in recent times
Highly highly recommend it
March 26, 2024
I enjoyed reading The Secret of More even though it took me close to a month to finish it. The story, which spans almost the entire first half of the twentieth century, is the story of its characters as much as the city where it is set - Bombay. With Tatya we visit it for the first time as he apprentices himself to Zaveri in the Mulji Jetha Market and from there in the world of textiles, cinema and more. With him we see the world from the chawl from where he begins to the sprawling sea-facing mansion where he ends. We witness him as he lives with his roommates to a bustling busy family consisting of children and grandchildren.
And yet, this is not just the story of Tatya. It is also the story of women who play a great role in his life, and vice-versa. His wife Radha, daughter Durga and the star of the silent-films Kamal. All these women impact his life in deep ways. The Secret of More is also the story of change, of success, of business acumen, of religious and cultural practices as they were in those days. There's no doubt that Rahm has done a lot of research into creating the world of that era. Be it the details of the haldi-kunku ceremony or the food preparations or the era of the silent talkies or the lively market place- they all come alive in the book.
I did wish there were certain areas that were explored a bit more too, they had a lot of potential. But at close to 450 pages of small font, I realise that it would have felt a bit much to delve into further side stories. Perhaps the secret of more actually is to know when to stop. I think Tatya would agree.
And yet, this is not just the story of Tatya. It is also the story of women who play a great role in his life, and vice-versa. His wife Radha, daughter Durga and the star of the silent-films Kamal. All these women impact his life in deep ways. The Secret of More is also the story of change, of success, of business acumen, of religious and cultural practices as they were in those days. There's no doubt that Rahm has done a lot of research into creating the world of that era. Be it the details of the haldi-kunku ceremony or the food preparations or the era of the silent talkies or the lively market place- they all come alive in the book.
I did wish there were certain areas that were explored a bit more too, they had a lot of potential. But at close to 450 pages of small font, I realise that it would have felt a bit much to delve into further side stories. Perhaps the secret of more actually is to know when to stop. I think Tatya would agree.
July 20, 2025
Tatya envied him his piece of mind, his patience with the world as it was, without the hunger to progress, to move ahead, to make more money, to know more and be more.
Set at the turn of the last century in Bombay where the cotton mills are picking up and the British are packing up. A hardworking young man comes to this city driven by poverty but seeking fortune. The problem is that he finds it. And also the cost that must be paid for it.
Did all aged bodies lie on their beds and try to pluck apart one day from the next?
In the final tally we don't look at the bank balance but at the relations we had and could not have. Alas, till that last moment we look elsewhere. Perhaps this will serve as a reminder to what really matters.
Set at the turn of the last century in Bombay where the cotton mills are picking up and the British are packing up. A hardworking young man comes to this city driven by poverty but seeking fortune. The problem is that he finds it. And also the cost that must be paid for it.
Did all aged bodies lie on their beds and try to pluck apart one day from the next?
In the final tally we don't look at the bank balance but at the relations we had and could not have. Alas, till that last moment we look elsewhere. Perhaps this will serve as a reminder to what really matters.
January 23, 2023
I am always partial to books set in Bombay, be it of yore or Mumbai. Hence, I was immediately drawn to Tejaswini Apte-Rahm's The Secret Of More.
I did enjoy this book, while the writing remained whimsical throughout, the story moved at a furious pace, compressing 53 years into a few hundred pages, beginning at turn of the 20th century and ending soon after Independence. It painted a vivid picture of Bombay as it evolved over the years. And, I was rather tickled by the subtle references to some of Bombay's more famous denizens through the story.
The reason I can't say I loved this book was, firstly, the blurb promised a lot more, and the story itself fell short of delivering it. Secondly, through the novel there were a fair few dramatic set-ups, but as they came to pass they fell a little flat, leaving me a tad bit disappointed. And lastly, the narrative, which interspersed the past and the present, didn't really do it for me, I always veer to a more linear structure.
Having said that, the ending, the final 'twist' (so to speak of) was truly enjoyable and really did make the book for me.
I did enjoy this book, while the writing remained whimsical throughout, the story moved at a furious pace, compressing 53 years into a few hundred pages, beginning at turn of the 20th century and ending soon after Independence. It painted a vivid picture of Bombay as it evolved over the years. And, I was rather tickled by the subtle references to some of Bombay's more famous denizens through the story.
The reason I can't say I loved this book was, firstly, the blurb promised a lot more, and the story itself fell short of delivering it. Secondly, through the novel there were a fair few dramatic set-ups, but as they came to pass they fell a little flat, leaving me a tad bit disappointed. And lastly, the narrative, which interspersed the past and the present, didn't really do it for me, I always veer to a more linear structure.
Having said that, the ending, the final 'twist' (so to speak of) was truly enjoyable and really did make the book for me.
January 12, 2023
The book is a bildungsroman, but more for the city that I dearly love, rather than just the protagonist. I got the feeling that the book is an ode to the teenage years of modern Mumbai – churning, faltering, developing, and vulnerable, coming into its own was Mumbai that we know of, and yet there was more to the book than that.
I wonder if Tatya was a character living at the turn of the 21st century rather than the 20th, would he have embraced Kamal? Would he have been a serial entrepreneur with a stake in e-commerce startups? Would he have been as pure as he was, or would he get affected by the politics of the times?
Strongly recommended. One of the best books I have read in a long time.
I wonder if Tatya was a character living at the turn of the 21st century rather than the 20th, would he have embraced Kamal? Would he have been a serial entrepreneur with a stake in e-commerce startups? Would he have been as pure as he was, or would he get affected by the politics of the times?
Strongly recommended. One of the best books I have read in a long time.
July 13, 2024
The Secret of More by Tejaswini Apte- Rahm is an expansive, engrossing and immensely evocative fictional story of social ascent that spans across momentous historical events, affecting lives and livelihood in every implicit and explicit scheme of its nature.
When Govind Abhyankar aka Tatya sets foot at the bustling Mulji Jetha Market as an apprentice to a cloth selling agent, the fate of this teenager changes with those who would be tied to him in the long haul. Tatya, commences work under the guidance of the selling agent to eventually taste success co-owning a mill, a factory, theatre and having sole selling agencies across cities and success at the path breaking silent film industries making him one of the most successful businessmen in Bombay.
Set in colonial Bombay, Tatya and his wife Radha begin with meagre possessions living lives within the bounds of culture and tradition following Brahmin rituals and way of living with utmost sincerity. With growing riches and an expanding family, they shift homes from a small room at a chawl to an apartment block and then a sprawling mansion. A very smooth and plausible transition occurs over the years with Tatya yearning to “be more” a desire and often an emotion that drives those who have tasted success and have been accepted by the city.
The Secret of More, is a story that gives the reader a pristine visual of the times and events its mentions, one can undoubtedly laud the authenticity about harsh customs and beliefs conversely existing with reformists who demand a fair share. Apprehensions while raising a daughter who is disabled and wishes to pursue education are just a few fears of parents raising a girl child in the unfair world of that time. As an obedient and responsible homemaker Radha, holds fort through every calamity that impacts the family while Durga accepts her reality with a grace and persistence to excel in every way she can. Subtle customary undercurrents existing in a patriarchal household, be it in relationships, decision making or simply having a meal together are present throughout the story. Tatya’s progressive yet often restrained socially impacted behaviour dictates the ways of the house leading to a pattern of acquiescence.
The story brilliantly depicts the silent motion film business becoming a craze with a lot of historical insight through Tatya’s interest in the same, adding fortunes to his already growing wealth. Introducing “actresses” and experiencing an emotional connection with one, often disorienting his thoughts is another complexity that he braves through. Conflicting emotions and dynamic demands of society shape this story, adding value to every characters’ arc in the premise.
This splendid tale portrays the success and growth through grit, intuition, brilliant business acumen and relentless striving. A tale of companionship and a steady routine, a loving family and abundance but also regrets that will have to be borne until the end.
Graceful, sincerely detailed and a wholesome reminiscence of a bygone era, this book is a sheer beauty!
Verdict: Immensely loved and highly recommended!
When Govind Abhyankar aka Tatya sets foot at the bustling Mulji Jetha Market as an apprentice to a cloth selling agent, the fate of this teenager changes with those who would be tied to him in the long haul. Tatya, commences work under the guidance of the selling agent to eventually taste success co-owning a mill, a factory, theatre and having sole selling agencies across cities and success at the path breaking silent film industries making him one of the most successful businessmen in Bombay.
Set in colonial Bombay, Tatya and his wife Radha begin with meagre possessions living lives within the bounds of culture and tradition following Brahmin rituals and way of living with utmost sincerity. With growing riches and an expanding family, they shift homes from a small room at a chawl to an apartment block and then a sprawling mansion. A very smooth and plausible transition occurs over the years with Tatya yearning to “be more” a desire and often an emotion that drives those who have tasted success and have been accepted by the city.
The Secret of More, is a story that gives the reader a pristine visual of the times and events its mentions, one can undoubtedly laud the authenticity about harsh customs and beliefs conversely existing with reformists who demand a fair share. Apprehensions while raising a daughter who is disabled and wishes to pursue education are just a few fears of parents raising a girl child in the unfair world of that time. As an obedient and responsible homemaker Radha, holds fort through every calamity that impacts the family while Durga accepts her reality with a grace and persistence to excel in every way she can. Subtle customary undercurrents existing in a patriarchal household, be it in relationships, decision making or simply having a meal together are present throughout the story. Tatya’s progressive yet often restrained socially impacted behaviour dictates the ways of the house leading to a pattern of acquiescence.
The story brilliantly depicts the silent motion film business becoming a craze with a lot of historical insight through Tatya’s interest in the same, adding fortunes to his already growing wealth. Introducing “actresses” and experiencing an emotional connection with one, often disorienting his thoughts is another complexity that he braves through. Conflicting emotions and dynamic demands of society shape this story, adding value to every characters’ arc in the premise.
This splendid tale portrays the success and growth through grit, intuition, brilliant business acumen and relentless striving. A tale of companionship and a steady routine, a loving family and abundance but also regrets that will have to be borne until the end.
Graceful, sincerely detailed and a wholesome reminiscence of a bygone era, this book is a sheer beauty!
Verdict: Immensely loved and highly recommended!
November 11, 2023
#bookhoarderreviews
The narrative of this compelling historical novel unfolds in 1899 Mumbai, a thriving hub of cloth mills that drew immigrants seeking better job opportunities, and it vividly illustrates the city’s transformation over time. Through Tatya’s life journey, the author masterfully delves into the history of cloth mills and wholesale cloth markets, providing meticulously researched details. The story follows Tatya’s evolution from a young man to Tatya Saheb, offering a rich tapestry of his life experiences, from the intricate workings of his cloth business to the nuances of managing a household alongside his wife, Radha, to his ventures into new business endeavors. The narrative culminates with his satisfaction in witnessing the success and contentment of future generations.
This narrative serves as a lens through which the reader can explore the social norms of the era, touching on themes such as child marriage, the impact of widowhood on women, the pursuit of female education, and the subtle confinement of women to domestic roles, away from professional spheres. Despite potentially evoking strong emotions in contemporary readers, the author’s non-judgmental writing style maintains a natural flow in the story.
As the tale unfolds, it also traces the introduction of cinema in India, beginning with silent films and evolving into ‘talkies.’ It underscores the changing roles of women, as they gain access to education and employment opportunities outside their traditional domestic responsibilities.
In this comprehensive historical fiction, the growth of the city is intricately woven together with the progression of the social fabric, with old customs giving way to new beliefs. The novel offers glimpses of India before and after independence, providing a panoramic view of its evolving landscape.
While the central plot revolves around Tatya’s quest for a more fulfilling life, the story is enriched by a diverse cast of well-developed characters, each with their own unique stories to share. From Mai’s resilience in the face of adversity to Radha’s simplicity and domestic prowess, Durga’s determination to improve her life despite physical limitations, and Sharad’s unwavering commitment to following in his father’s footsteps, each character embodies a range of human emotions and strengths that enhance the overall reading experience.
The narrative of this compelling historical novel unfolds in 1899 Mumbai, a thriving hub of cloth mills that drew immigrants seeking better job opportunities, and it vividly illustrates the city’s transformation over time. Through Tatya’s life journey, the author masterfully delves into the history of cloth mills and wholesale cloth markets, providing meticulously researched details. The story follows Tatya’s evolution from a young man to Tatya Saheb, offering a rich tapestry of his life experiences, from the intricate workings of his cloth business to the nuances of managing a household alongside his wife, Radha, to his ventures into new business endeavors. The narrative culminates with his satisfaction in witnessing the success and contentment of future generations.
This narrative serves as a lens through which the reader can explore the social norms of the era, touching on themes such as child marriage, the impact of widowhood on women, the pursuit of female education, and the subtle confinement of women to domestic roles, away from professional spheres. Despite potentially evoking strong emotions in contemporary readers, the author’s non-judgmental writing style maintains a natural flow in the story.
As the tale unfolds, it also traces the introduction of cinema in India, beginning with silent films and evolving into ‘talkies.’ It underscores the changing roles of women, as they gain access to education and employment opportunities outside their traditional domestic responsibilities.
In this comprehensive historical fiction, the growth of the city is intricately woven together with the progression of the social fabric, with old customs giving way to new beliefs. The novel offers glimpses of India before and after independence, providing a panoramic view of its evolving landscape.
While the central plot revolves around Tatya’s quest for a more fulfilling life, the story is enriched by a diverse cast of well-developed characters, each with their own unique stories to share. From Mai’s resilience in the face of adversity to Radha’s simplicity and domestic prowess, Durga’s determination to improve her life despite physical limitations, and Sharad’s unwavering commitment to following in his father’s footsteps, each character embodies a range of human emotions and strengths that enhance the overall reading experience.
December 31, 2023
This is a beautifully written tale set in early to mid-twentieth-century Bombay, full of fascinating details about the textile industry, the rise of "bioscopes" - silent movies - and talkies, and the journey of one family living through it all.
Three parts make up the narrative. The first part begins in 1899 and gives readers their first glimpse of the classic Bombay of the past, complete with people wearing dhotis, sadras, and dark caps. The main character is Tatya, and the First World War's impact on India's cloth sector is explored in the narrative. Tatya's astute business acumen is soon noticed by his kind teacher Zaveri, who suggests he go alone as a sales representative. From this point, his classic Bombay story of rising from poverty (or, in this case, middle class) to riches takes off. As was previously stated, Tatya's tale initially takes place in the Indian textile industry during the First World War before quickly shifting to the silent film industry.
Tatya, on the other hand, is a cautious and righteous guy who respects Zaveri's advice despite having enough business acumen to take some risks. But, alongside Tatya's story and his life enriched by the world outside the family, there are the stories of women who have been cribbed, cabined, and restricted in different ways, their stories moving in the shadow of men's stories. The Secret of More does just that, drawing you into the minutiae of individual people's moorings against the backdrop of Bombay's textile factories and the silent cinema period.
While reading the book, the flavour of the story reminds the readers of old Hindi movies that showcased Bombay and the life there. Undoubtedly, one can visualise Mr.X in Bombay movie scenes. The strong narration that author Tejaswini Apte presented in the book makes the readers instantly part of that city's rich past while also intimately engaging in a family narrative as it unfolds. It's almost as if the bigger platform and the interior worlds are both the warp and weft of an intriguing tapestry.
Overall, the book is a historical fiction spanning pre-independence and just-independent India, depicting business scenes, royal households, the silent movie-to-voice transition in theaters, the lives of women at various social levels, and other aspects!
Three parts make up the narrative. The first part begins in 1899 and gives readers their first glimpse of the classic Bombay of the past, complete with people wearing dhotis, sadras, and dark caps. The main character is Tatya, and the First World War's impact on India's cloth sector is explored in the narrative. Tatya's astute business acumen is soon noticed by his kind teacher Zaveri, who suggests he go alone as a sales representative. From this point, his classic Bombay story of rising from poverty (or, in this case, middle class) to riches takes off. As was previously stated, Tatya's tale initially takes place in the Indian textile industry during the First World War before quickly shifting to the silent film industry.
Tatya, on the other hand, is a cautious and righteous guy who respects Zaveri's advice despite having enough business acumen to take some risks. But, alongside Tatya's story and his life enriched by the world outside the family, there are the stories of women who have been cribbed, cabined, and restricted in different ways, their stories moving in the shadow of men's stories. The Secret of More does just that, drawing you into the minutiae of individual people's moorings against the backdrop of Bombay's textile factories and the silent cinema period.
While reading the book, the flavour of the story reminds the readers of old Hindi movies that showcased Bombay and the life there. Undoubtedly, one can visualise Mr.X in Bombay movie scenes. The strong narration that author Tejaswini Apte presented in the book makes the readers instantly part of that city's rich past while also intimately engaging in a family narrative as it unfolds. It's almost as if the bigger platform and the interior worlds are both the warp and weft of an intriguing tapestry.
Overall, the book is a historical fiction spanning pre-independence and just-independent India, depicting business scenes, royal households, the silent movie-to-voice transition in theaters, the lives of women at various social levels, and other aspects!
January 8, 2024
Every once in a while we come across a book that is so enriched with life, that it stays with you even after
*you have finished the book,
*wrapped up the story line,
*fallen in love with not one, but many characters for their strength and weaknesses,
*enjoyed the background and the era in which the story took place,
*gained knowledge and information about the events that took place,
*imagined the exact scenarios as described in the book,
*felt beyond doubt the helplessness of the characters,
*felt nostalgic since you live in the same city as the story and now appreciate it more,
*could relate with the incidents in the book as some of them have happened actually,
*was lost in the timeline and could not wait to deep dive into the book the whole time you were reading it,
*admired the author's narrative style and in-depth research which leaves no flaw in the storyline,
*want to keep the physical copy of the book because you are going to recommend this book many times over ,
*would like others to read the book and fall in love with it,
*would like other readers to read the book and then discuss with all.
You know you have read one gem of a book.
This being the first book that I completed in the year 2024, I just adored the book because of multiple reasons mentioned above, but most of all, I would like to appreciate the author for conducting a in depth research on all the characters etched out in the book, to cite various true life events that took place in Mumbai city in the era mentioned to which the readers can heartily relate, to make the readers drool over the traditional food and customs from the Maharashtrian community thereby giving the readers a win win book.
The main protagonist of the book, Tatyasaheb is the epitome of a small town man who works relentlessly towards his dream, his vision, his thirst to be more, give more and thereby creating a rags to riches story and passing on these values to the generations to come.
I loved how the staunch cultural norms were also portrayed in the book like child marriage, widow ship, no education for girl child, passing on the business to the next generation without considering their aspirations etc
Overall a must read book for all the Mumbaikars and otherwise who want to know how fortunes are build and made from the dust in this never sleeping city of the country.
*you have finished the book,
*wrapped up the story line,
*fallen in love with not one, but many characters for their strength and weaknesses,
*enjoyed the background and the era in which the story took place,
*gained knowledge and information about the events that took place,
*imagined the exact scenarios as described in the book,
*felt beyond doubt the helplessness of the characters,
*felt nostalgic since you live in the same city as the story and now appreciate it more,
*could relate with the incidents in the book as some of them have happened actually,
*was lost in the timeline and could not wait to deep dive into the book the whole time you were reading it,
*admired the author's narrative style and in-depth research which leaves no flaw in the storyline,
*want to keep the physical copy of the book because you are going to recommend this book many times over ,
*would like others to read the book and fall in love with it,
*would like other readers to read the book and then discuss with all.
You know you have read one gem of a book.
This being the first book that I completed in the year 2024, I just adored the book because of multiple reasons mentioned above, but most of all, I would like to appreciate the author for conducting a in depth research on all the characters etched out in the book, to cite various true life events that took place in Mumbai city in the era mentioned to which the readers can heartily relate, to make the readers drool over the traditional food and customs from the Maharashtrian community thereby giving the readers a win win book.
The main protagonist of the book, Tatyasaheb is the epitome of a small town man who works relentlessly towards his dream, his vision, his thirst to be more, give more and thereby creating a rags to riches story and passing on these values to the generations to come.
I loved how the staunch cultural norms were also portrayed in the book like child marriage, widow ship, no education for girl child, passing on the business to the next generation without considering their aspirations etc
Overall a must read book for all the Mumbaikars and otherwise who want to know how fortunes are build and made from the dust in this never sleeping city of the country.
October 29, 2022
This tale chronicles the life of Tatya, from the time he first came to the bustling Mumbai Pedhi s, to his last moments.
Having a good business mind, Tatya started his own business soon and mingled in the sight and sounds of the then Bombay Clothes business scene we see him get married to Radha. The rituals, the moments, the ways of those times, where a twelve year old Radha is considered too old for marriage already is depicted really well. Radha s mom - Mai to all is a widow and she passes on the ideas of the horrors of widowhood to Radha so well that it stays deep within her forever. Radha is delayed to reach womanhood and the taboos of those times are brought up .
Finally Radha joins her husband Tatya in Bombay and the story goes on with their lives and Tatya gradual prospering. After the first son, however, the couple lose some of their wards to typhoid, till Durga, a physically challenged daughter arrives. They are again faced with a strong challenge in their lives.
They move from their chawl house to a mansion, with Radha trying to set herself in the well-to-do environment and doing her haldi kunku s. Tatya now gets into the business of silent films of those times.
Life goes on for them in ups and downs for years, in success and events, till, Tatya feels an emotional connection with Kamal Bai an actress in the films. Although platonic he felt he loved her and he at times thought that as betrayal of Radha.
Lives of his children too come in and Durga is highlighted. The other minor characters to come up and showcase some of the social rigidities, norms and ways of those times.
Overall the book is a historical fiction overlapping pre-independent and just independent India, where in the business scenes, royal households, the silent movie to voice coming in at theatres, the life of women at different societal levels and some other aspects are portrayed!
The life of this one person in a circle is well written.
Having a good business mind, Tatya started his own business soon and mingled in the sight and sounds of the then Bombay Clothes business scene we see him get married to Radha. The rituals, the moments, the ways of those times, where a twelve year old Radha is considered too old for marriage already is depicted really well. Radha s mom - Mai to all is a widow and she passes on the ideas of the horrors of widowhood to Radha so well that it stays deep within her forever. Radha is delayed to reach womanhood and the taboos of those times are brought up .
Finally Radha joins her husband Tatya in Bombay and the story goes on with their lives and Tatya gradual prospering. After the first son, however, the couple lose some of their wards to typhoid, till Durga, a physically challenged daughter arrives. They are again faced with a strong challenge in their lives.
They move from their chawl house to a mansion, with Radha trying to set herself in the well-to-do environment and doing her haldi kunku s. Tatya now gets into the business of silent films of those times.
Life goes on for them in ups and downs for years, in success and events, till, Tatya feels an emotional connection with Kamal Bai an actress in the films. Although platonic he felt he loved her and he at times thought that as betrayal of Radha.
Lives of his children too come in and Durga is highlighted. The other minor characters to come up and showcase some of the social rigidities, norms and ways of those times.
Overall the book is a historical fiction overlapping pre-independent and just independent India, where in the business scenes, royal households, the silent movie to voice coming in at theatres, the life of women at different societal levels and some other aspects are portrayed!
The life of this one person in a circle is well written.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 19, 2025
Tejasvini Apte Rahm has, without doubt, crafted a truly remarkable and very engaging novel.
The writing style is nice, though just that little bit difficult to read - you cant sail through it at all - enough of sentence convolution to slow you down, forcing you to pay attention or miss the point completely.
There are three or four moments of sublime surprise crafted by the writer which are exceptional. Won't spoil them- they are the best bits and not easy to create unless your writing skills are exceptional.
It is a story of entire lives from the beginning to the end, in the late 19th and early twentieth century, with historical occurrences serving as a backdrop.
But it's more than just simple life stories - there is philosophical insight into the process of living and growing old, regrets, recriminations and moving on which are told in a very relatable manner. And that makes it an intergenerationally interesting tome, a rare breed that appeals across ages.
The book does become tedious over many sections. But given the breadth of the canvas that the writer has chosen, that is probably both inevitable and necessary. To my mind it could have been 30-50% shorter but to another reader who would find it equally interesting, other segments would appeal, which to me palled. And so they are all essential.
The period setting makes us forgive much - a modern look back at a time period which we have heard of from grandfathers and parents. There is much about the early 20th century India which remains unknown to modern Indians because we focus so much on reading about life in other countries and situations. Critical commentary of the British occupation drowns out much, when we look back at our own country.
Delightful to find such a story that recaptures an era in depth, without the political angles that distort history.
All in all a wonderful book.
The writing style is nice, though just that little bit difficult to read - you cant sail through it at all - enough of sentence convolution to slow you down, forcing you to pay attention or miss the point completely.
There are three or four moments of sublime surprise crafted by the writer which are exceptional. Won't spoil them- they are the best bits and not easy to create unless your writing skills are exceptional.
It is a story of entire lives from the beginning to the end, in the late 19th and early twentieth century, with historical occurrences serving as a backdrop.
But it's more than just simple life stories - there is philosophical insight into the process of living and growing old, regrets, recriminations and moving on which are told in a very relatable manner. And that makes it an intergenerationally interesting tome, a rare breed that appeals across ages.
The book does become tedious over many sections. But given the breadth of the canvas that the writer has chosen, that is probably both inevitable and necessary. To my mind it could have been 30-50% shorter but to another reader who would find it equally interesting, other segments would appeal, which to me palled. And so they are all essential.
The period setting makes us forgive much - a modern look back at a time period which we have heard of from grandfathers and parents. There is much about the early 20th century India which remains unknown to modern Indians because we focus so much on reading about life in other countries and situations. Critical commentary of the British occupation drowns out much, when we look back at our own country.
Delightful to find such a story that recaptures an era in depth, without the political angles that distort history.
All in all a wonderful book.
October 3, 2023
The Secret of More by Tejaswini Apte-Rahm has been longlisted for the @thejcbprize 2023. It is a captivating tale that immerses readers into the vibrant heart of colonial Bombay. This novel artfully weaves together the stories of Tatya, an ambitious young man, and Radha, his resilient bride, as they navigate the complexities of a rapidly changing city.
Apte-Rahm's vivid descriptions transport readers to the bustling textile market, where Tatya's journey to success begins. The author skillfully contrasts the traditional with the modern, creating a rich tapestry of Bombay's evolving identity.
The narrative takes an intriguing turn as Tatya ventures into the emerging world of motion pictures. The exploration of this new industry, filled with make-believe and allure, adds depth to the plot. Tatya's internal struggle, torn between ambition and personal integrity, is a central theme that resonates throughout the story.
The characters in the book are well-drawn and multifaceted, making their joys, challenges, and betrayals feel genuine and relatable. The backdrop of colonial Bombay, from the chawls of Girgaon to the sea-facing mansions, adds layers to the narrative, immersing readers in the city's contrasting worlds.
Ultimately, this novel is a tale of relentless ambition, unwavering love, and the consequences of chasing "more." Apte-Rahm's storytelling prowess shines through, making The Secret of More a compelling and thought-provoking read for those who enjoy historical fiction with a touch of romance and drama.
Apte-Rahm's vivid descriptions transport readers to the bustling textile market, where Tatya's journey to success begins. The author skillfully contrasts the traditional with the modern, creating a rich tapestry of Bombay's evolving identity.
The narrative takes an intriguing turn as Tatya ventures into the emerging world of motion pictures. The exploration of this new industry, filled with make-believe and allure, adds depth to the plot. Tatya's internal struggle, torn between ambition and personal integrity, is a central theme that resonates throughout the story.
The characters in the book are well-drawn and multifaceted, making their joys, challenges, and betrayals feel genuine and relatable. The backdrop of colonial Bombay, from the chawls of Girgaon to the sea-facing mansions, adds layers to the narrative, immersing readers in the city's contrasting worlds.
Ultimately, this novel is a tale of relentless ambition, unwavering love, and the consequences of chasing "more." Apte-Rahm's storytelling prowess shines through, making The Secret of More a compelling and thought-provoking read for those who enjoy historical fiction with a touch of romance and drama.
December 4, 2023
Tejaswini Apte-Rahm, in the initial pages of The Secret of More describes an incident where a worm has lodged in the leg of the protagonist. The treating doctor issues a warning: if you force me to make haste, the worm will break into two, some part of it stuck in the body forever.
So let me take my time and pull it out slowly, a few millimetres per day. That’s how the author’s storytelling works: like a cascade of honey. Slow and fascinating.
Tejaswini Apte-Rahm isn’t afraid of taking a pause here and there; she lets her characters marinate in the events she cooks out from the vast entrails of history available at her disposal. The pace is languid yet steady. She knows and believes in her way of storytelling. And it works.
Tatya’s brother, a man of words, brings Tatya to a cloth market in Bombay. The former is more interested in doing business than studying. Within a few years, Tatya is running his own shop in the market. His past owner tells him:
‘You may become a great man one day. Or you may not. Either way, don’t take good fortune for granted.’
A few years after that he dabbles in the movie-making business. Apart from a few personal losses here and there, his business works well and the family shifts from a tiny chawl room to a sprawling sea-facing abode. Also, an interesting advice he gets:
‘Buy your own horse carriage only when you have the capacity to buy three of them.’
So let me take my time and pull it out slowly, a few millimetres per day. That’s how the author’s storytelling works: like a cascade of honey. Slow and fascinating.
Tejaswini Apte-Rahm isn’t afraid of taking a pause here and there; she lets her characters marinate in the events she cooks out from the vast entrails of history available at her disposal. The pace is languid yet steady. She knows and believes in her way of storytelling. And it works.
Tatya’s brother, a man of words, brings Tatya to a cloth market in Bombay. The former is more interested in doing business than studying. Within a few years, Tatya is running his own shop in the market. His past owner tells him:
‘You may become a great man one day. Or you may not. Either way, don’t take good fortune for granted.’
A few years after that he dabbles in the movie-making business. Apart from a few personal losses here and there, his business works well and the family shifts from a tiny chawl room to a sprawling sea-facing abode. Also, an interesting advice he gets:
‘Buy your own horse carriage only when you have the capacity to buy three of them.’
October 31, 2022
Bombay, the "city of dreams" and "city that spins cotton into gold," observes a young guy walking on the streets that are the throbbing heart of the city in order to make a livelihood. Tatya, who is ambitious and diligent, starts to establish himself in the renowned textile market of the city. In the meanwhile, Radha, his new wife, manages the pleasures and difficulties of having a family in a city that is an odd and sometimes perplexing blend of the traditional and the quickly modernising.
This story traces Tatya's life from the moment he arrived in busy Bombay until his final moments. Tatya launched his own company and soon enough became a part of the Bombay cotton industry. We eventually meet Radha, a twelve-year-old who is deemed too old to be a prospective bride. When Radha married Tatya and moved to Bombay with him, it wasn't long after her mother, a widow, had warned her about the dangers of widowhood for young brides.
Set in colonial Bombay, amidst Victorian manors, silent cinema and the idea of Bombay dreams Tatya and his family realise that Bombay can give wings to everyone's dreams but if the flight crash lands you might not recover from picking up the millions of tiny pieces.
This story traces Tatya's life from the moment he arrived in busy Bombay until his final moments. Tatya launched his own company and soon enough became a part of the Bombay cotton industry. We eventually meet Radha, a twelve-year-old who is deemed too old to be a prospective bride. When Radha married Tatya and moved to Bombay with him, it wasn't long after her mother, a widow, had warned her about the dangers of widowhood for young brides.
Set in colonial Bombay, amidst Victorian manors, silent cinema and the idea of Bombay dreams Tatya and his family realise that Bombay can give wings to everyone's dreams but if the flight crash lands you might not recover from picking up the millions of tiny pieces.
November 15, 2023
Superb tale, a remarkable portal to an amazing universe. A voyage infused with the flavors, sounds, sights, and colors of Bombay and beyond, guided by love, dignity, and resolve. Exquisitely analyzed, utterly engrossing, and motivating. This book has been a winner of Tata literature live 2023 and best book of the year fiction award.
Taking place in Bombay in the early to mid-20th century, this exquisitely written tale is packed with fascinating details about the textile industry, the development of silent films known as "bioscopes" and talkies, and the journey of a single family that endures it all. The beginnings and development of the film industry were expertly documented, and I learnt a great deal about the textile trade and merchants of that time period. The Tatya family's ups and downs, which are mirrored in those of the outside world, are masterfully portrayed and make for an engrossing read.
I am grateful to @alephbookco for this wonderful gift. Thr author's writing style is so elegant and wise that I can't wait to read your next outstanding book. Strongly advised!
Taking place in Bombay in the early to mid-20th century, this exquisitely written tale is packed with fascinating details about the textile industry, the development of silent films known as "bioscopes" and talkies, and the journey of a single family that endures it all. The beginnings and development of the film industry were expertly documented, and I learnt a great deal about the textile trade and merchants of that time period. The Tatya family's ups and downs, which are mirrored in those of the outside world, are masterfully portrayed and make for an engrossing read.
I am grateful to @alephbookco for this wonderful gift. Thr author's writing style is so elegant and wise that I can't wait to read your next outstanding book. Strongly advised!
October 19, 2023
"The Secret of More" by Tejaswini Apte Rahm is a captivating novel that delves deep into the heart of colonial Bombay, weaving a tale of relentless ambition, enduring love, and bitter betrayal. Set against the backdrop of a city that transforms cotton into gold, this book immerses readers into the bustling textile market, the glamorous silent film industry, and the complex dynamics of early 20th-century Bombay.
At the heart of the novel is the story of Tatya, a young and ambitious man who arrives in Bombay, determined to make a name for himself and provide for his family. His journey from an inquisitive teenager to a successful businessman is the central thread of the story. Rahm captures Tatya's growth and transformation with great depth, making him a relatable and complex character.
Read the full review on:
https://readreactreview21.wordpress.c...
At the heart of the novel is the story of Tatya, a young and ambitious man who arrives in Bombay, determined to make a name for himself and provide for his family. His journey from an inquisitive teenager to a successful businessman is the central thread of the story. Rahm captures Tatya's growth and transformation with great depth, making him a relatable and complex character.
Read the full review on:
https://readreactreview21.wordpress.c...
July 1, 2024
Reading this book has been such an incredible journey. Tejaswini's prose has been uplifted by her meticulous research of Bombay and the way of life in the 1900s. She is thorough when it comes to detail, but at no point in time, does it take you away from the storytelling. What makes this book an important addition to the Bombay novels is the story she sets out to tell: the cotton trade boom and and the entry of bioscope with the coming of the silent films that would change the complexion of the city permanently. It's a tale of resilience, perseverance and the desire for more that guides every feverish heart in Bombay. I only wish that the cover and blurb had done justice to such a grand novel.
June 10, 2023
I absolutely loved this book.
It feels like an epic in how it sweeps the lifetime of the protagonist from youth to death. But it's made up of intimate moments where we're up-close and personal with the characters. And yet it doesn't feel like we're jumping unnaturally from one time to another in order to make it through his lifetime.
I like that, even though there's a clear protagonist (Tatya), the center shifts from him to his wife during periods, offering a glimpse into a world I wouldn't otherwise have access to (nor would we have access to through the eyes of a male narrator)
Ms Apte-Rahm has clearly done a ton of research. The characters, story, and details seem to emerge and unfold naturally rather than feeling forced.
It feels like an epic in how it sweeps the lifetime of the protagonist from youth to death. But it's made up of intimate moments where we're up-close and personal with the characters. And yet it doesn't feel like we're jumping unnaturally from one time to another in order to make it through his lifetime.
I like that, even though there's a clear protagonist (Tatya), the center shifts from him to his wife during periods, offering a glimpse into a world I wouldn't otherwise have access to (nor would we have access to through the eyes of a male narrator)
Ms Apte-Rahm has clearly done a ton of research. The characters, story, and details seem to emerge and unfold naturally rather than feeling forced.
August 22, 2024
An extremely well researched book that takes you through life in the city of Bombay at the turn of the 20th century through the lives of a family who migrate to the city. The family patriarch first works as an employee in a textile mill, grows to run his own business, dabbles in setting up a silent movie studio and culminates with the advent of sugar factories. The novel has beautifully portrayed the lives of those who lived in Chawls in the early 20th century. There is also a lovely unfulfilled love affair between the protagonist and a silent movie heroine.
July 12, 2023
The pages of the hardcover copies available in Mumbai bookstores are translucent and of poor quality. A really bad job by the publishers. They should feel ashamed for letting down the Author.
The title doesn't do the book justice. I wish the Author had thought of something better.
In time, this book will go down as one of the greatest written on Mumbai and Maharashtrian Brahmin culture.
Thank you Mrs. Apte Rahm for writing it. We owe you.
The title doesn't do the book justice. I wish the Author had thought of something better.
In time, this book will go down as one of the greatest written on Mumbai and Maharashtrian Brahmin culture.
Thank you Mrs. Apte Rahm for writing it. We owe you.
June 26, 2024
i did not love this. But I could easily imagine those who might. I am not given to historical fiction that feels like historical fiction, but I think Apte-Rahm is great at weaving characters around one another who struggle to actualize they things they desire and believe. I just have the attention span of a goldfish and find myself bored too easily. Love Radha. Love Durga. Tatya flop. Anywaaaays....
January 24, 2023
A beautiful journey back in time
Engrossing and beautiful my written. The characters and their lives journey become a part of you as its so well interwoven. Very interesting as the book describes an historical journey of movies in India.
Engrossing and beautiful my written. The characters and their lives journey become a part of you as its so well interwoven. Very interesting as the book describes an historical journey of movies in India.
March 3, 2024
The book ‘The Secret of More’ is a historical fiction set in the first half of the 20th century. It follows the journey of seventeen-year-old Tattya, who arrives in Mumbai, the City of Dreams, to forge his own path. Through the ups and downs of Tattya and his wife Radha’s life, the story sheds light on the customs, rituals, and social norms of that era.
The author skillfully develops each character, gradually revealing their traits. The narrative is engaging, and I appreciated the inclusion of details about the customs and traditions of the Maharashtrian Brahmin family during the early 20th century. From cloth-making to bioscopes, the book seamlessly weaves historical information into the storyline.
Despite its merits, the novel didn’t deeply resonate with me. While the strong prologue initially captured my attention, the subsequent story didn’t fully deliver on the promise set by the blurb and prologue.
Overall, "The Secret of More" offers valuable insights into pre and post-independent India, making it a worthwhile read for those interested in historical fiction.
December 11, 2023
Engrossing, compelling.
May 11, 2024
The old Bombay setting is beautifully captured, and I love the depth of detail around the cloth and film industries. Overall, a treat!
October 21, 2023
On 9th Sep I was elated as the long list for the JCB prize 2023 was announced. I had finished a book a day before and was looking for something to start. The book I finished was a non-fiction comparing science and spirituality. So I was looking for an immersive fiction now to loose myself in it. That is exactly what I found in 'The secret of more by Tejaswini Apte-Rahm'. It is like a big white pillow where you can peacefully lie down and you will be transported to a world of possibilities, to want more, to the shores of 'dariya' which always has something more to offer, to the charming city of Bombay.
The story begins with two brothers trying to find way in dense Bombay cotton bazaars. The year is 1899. The city is yet to become what it became but even in its coming of age, it was a metropolitan, a melting pot. Tatya is the name of the protagonist, the younger brother above, and this is the story of his ambition. His want for more.
This book is a triumph of excellent writing and good old story telling, simple yet infinitely convoluted, like how one small piece of rope can entangle itself into a blob, like life. It is nowhere dramatic yet extremely moving. The hold author has over human emotions allows her to be just with her characters. She knows them like back of her hand. And with extremely thorough research, she also knows this era as if she has somehow (impossibly) lived through it. The women characters are extremely well written - Radha, Durga and Kamal Bai. Somehow they are even more etched than Tatya, like a shadow which is longer than the subject. The writing flows like 'Makkhan'. Really, sentences rolling like free flowing avalanches. This book successfully achieves the mammoth task of looking entire life in perspective. The realtionship between Tatya and Kamal bai is explored as it developes. It is quite complex, very much unsaid and yet conveys powerful imagery. Did Radha intentionally forget? This question remains open. But that is for the best I guess.
The research about rise of motion pictures, silent era of movies, its transition to talkies and its demise, gives the story very well structured plot points. Tatya's relation with his son is also something I very much enjoyed. How his son presents the other end of spectrum: 'more is never enough'. Overall highly recommended read. Hope it wins the JCB prize (it is indeed short listed). But there is very tough competition.
The story begins with two brothers trying to find way in dense Bombay cotton bazaars. The year is 1899. The city is yet to become what it became but even in its coming of age, it was a metropolitan, a melting pot. Tatya is the name of the protagonist, the younger brother above, and this is the story of his ambition. His want for more.
This book is a triumph of excellent writing and good old story telling, simple yet infinitely convoluted, like how one small piece of rope can entangle itself into a blob, like life. It is nowhere dramatic yet extremely moving. The hold author has over human emotions allows her to be just with her characters. She knows them like back of her hand. And with extremely thorough research, she also knows this era as if she has somehow (impossibly) lived through it. The women characters are extremely well written - Radha, Durga and Kamal Bai. Somehow they are even more etched than Tatya, like a shadow which is longer than the subject. The writing flows like 'Makkhan'. Really, sentences rolling like free flowing avalanches. This book successfully achieves the mammoth task of looking entire life in perspective. The realtionship between Tatya and Kamal bai is explored as it developes. It is quite complex, very much unsaid and yet conveys powerful imagery. Did Radha intentionally forget? This question remains open. But that is for the best I guess.
The research about rise of motion pictures, silent era of movies, its transition to talkies and its demise, gives the story very well structured plot points. Tatya's relation with his son is also something I very much enjoyed. How his son presents the other end of spectrum: 'more is never enough'. Overall highly recommended read. Hope it wins the JCB prize (it is indeed short listed). But there is very tough competition.
Displaying 1 - 27 of 27 reviews