What do you think?
Rate this book


280 pages, Hardcover
Published June 23, 2022
While this book addresses important topics in building relational intelligence, it contains troubling flaws in both its scientific foundations and practical applications that could lead to harmful workplace practices.
Bandelli presents five essential skills for relational intelligence, weaving personal narratives with psychological research throughout his chapters. However, my primary concern is how this book might influence actual workplace practices, particularly through recommendations that could enable discriminatory hiring and invasive employee assessments.
Most problematic are Bandelli's three-hour "personal leadership journey" assessments that probe deeply into childhood trauma, family dysfunction, and personal history. On pages 74-75, he advocates asking questions like: "What role did your father and mother play in your personal growth? What values did they instill in you?" He mislabels these as "behavioral interview questions" when they're actually biographical probes that cross professional boundaries and raise serious privacy concerns. These 360 interviews feel more like psychological profiling appropriate for therapeutic settings than workplace environments, potentially violating ethical standards that distinguish job-relevant assessments from clinical psychology. True behavioral interviewing practices should focus on skills, experience, and job-relevant competencies rather than personal background.
The book's other significant flaws include claims about genetic determinism that oversimplify leadership development and potentially harm diversity efforts; cultural stereotypes that reduce entire nations to management styles without sufficiently acknowledging individual variation, structural limitations, or the complexity of global business; and discussions that pathologize adaptive survival strategies from "chaotic families" and "hostile environments." These run the risk of leading to discriminatory workplace practices and creating bias against candidates who have overcome significant challenges – and likely built invaluable problem-solving and resilience skills.
Perhaps this book's greatest value lies in demonstrating how to critically evaluate business recommendations: Do they align with research? How do we distinguish useful cultural awareness from harmful stereotyping? What are the real-world consequences of implementation?
While not entirely without merit, the book's ethical concerns significantly overshadow its useful insights. Effective leadership development should be based on proven methods that respect individual privacy while building genuine professional competencies.