What do you think?
Rate this book
Asperfell Trilogy #2
The Forest Kingdom
Briony is free from the walls of Asperfell. But not from its strange and savage world. Lost in the frozen wilderness, Briony leads her friends ever northward, in search of a rumored cave wherein lies their only hope of returning home to the kingdom of Tiralaen with Prince Elyan, the rightful heir to the throne, to save her people from civil war. What she discovers instead is an impossible kingdom of opulence and decadence beyond her wildest imagining. Here, an ancient goddess is about to awaken once more… and she has never forgiven Briony’s people for their intrusion into this world, nor the centuries of bloodshed that followed. Caught in a deadly web of secrets and lies that stretches across generations, Briony holds the fate of two kingdoms in her hands. To leave this new world behind is to condemn its people to anguish and death. But to stay and fight, Briony must abandon her home and everyone she’s ever loved—including Elyan. To save one kingdom, the other must fall. Praise for Book One of the Asperfell 2020 Fantasy Book of the Year Winner -INDIES Awards Top Ten Best Debut Speculative Fiction Novels of 2020 -Booklist "A haunting and beautifully written gothic tale." -Natalie Jenner, internationally bestselling author of The Jane Austen Society “Sure to win over fantasy readers.” -Publishers Weekly (starred review)
492 pages, Kindle Edition
First published August 24, 2021
53 people are currently reading
420 people want to read
About the author
Jamie Thomas
3 books131 followersJamie Thomas began crafting stories in the fourth grade with a tale of a brother and sister who accidentally bring the birds on their hotel wallpaper to life. Even though she ended with the cliched “It was all a dream” gimmick, she still won a regional young writers competition that year, thus beginning a lifelong love affair with the written word.
A certified Language Arts teacher in the state of Washington, Jamie holds a Master’s degree in English Education and did her graduate research in the area of gender equality in high school literary curriculum. Jamie is an avid lover of Victorian novels and poetry, Gothic Romanticism, and feminist literature, as well as epic female-led fantasy and historical fiction. Jamie aims to smash the patriarchy one novel at a time, creating characters and worlds that inspire, empower, and elevate women.
Previously, Jamie studied opera and received her formal training at the University of Montana and the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, and she still enjoys performing occasionally, as well as teaching vocal technique. She lives in Wenatchee, Washington, with her husband, daughter, two enormous dogs, and two mischievous cats.
A certified Language Arts teacher in the state of Washington, Jamie holds a Master’s degree in English Education and did her graduate research in the area of gender equality in high school literary curriculum. Jamie is an avid lover of Victorian novels and poetry, Gothic Romanticism, and feminist literature, as well as epic female-led fantasy and historical fiction. Jamie aims to smash the patriarchy one novel at a time, creating characters and worlds that inspire, empower, and elevate women.
Previously, Jamie studied opera and received her formal training at the University of Montana and the San Francisco Conservatory of Music, and she still enjoys performing occasionally, as well as teaching vocal technique. She lives in Wenatchee, Washington, with her husband, daughter, two enormous dogs, and two mischievous cats.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews
Want to read
April 16, 2021Ahhhh im so excited 😅😅 I really loved Asperfell and have been checking this space religiously to see updates for #2 🤞🏽🥺
July 29, 2021
Thanks to NetGalley and Uproar Books for an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
Asperfell was one of the first books I ever reviewed on NetGalley. I was captivated from the start and loved Briony and Elyan and their relationship and quest to return him to the usurped throne. After that ending I was not sure where a sequel would go, would they make their way back fast to Tiralean or would they have a detour. Well, this one had a detour, which can frustrate the reader as you don’t get momentum in the story. However, this detour is a doozy and I think I actually liked The Forest Kingdom more than Asperfell, something which I didn’t think possible.
The Forest Kingdom is linked with Asperfell, having been established by escaped prisoners. The magic here is strange, the palace opulent and the occupants live in a bubble of food, drink and pleasure of all forms. Briony is visited by a long dead goddess and she fights to uncover the secrets of this place while Elyan tries to find the cave they seek to go back to their world. You knew going in that our little band of found family would shake this place to the core and they don’t disappoint. I love the character development of Phyra, Arlo and Thaniel in this book. They became so much more than side characters in this and left their mark on the pages. I also loved the relationship development not only between the characters we already knew but also with new ones.
My only super minor issue is that I read Asperfell too long ago to remember some plot points and a recap would have helped. Some of the details were sprinkled throughout the book but it would have been handy to have. I probably should have reread the last few chapters of the first book before diving in.
This was a super fast read and now I can’t wait until the final book in the trilogy to see where the author takes this.
Asperfell was one of the first books I ever reviewed on NetGalley. I was captivated from the start and loved Briony and Elyan and their relationship and quest to return him to the usurped throne. After that ending I was not sure where a sequel would go, would they make their way back fast to Tiralean or would they have a detour. Well, this one had a detour, which can frustrate the reader as you don’t get momentum in the story. However, this detour is a doozy and I think I actually liked The Forest Kingdom more than Asperfell, something which I didn’t think possible.
The Forest Kingdom is linked with Asperfell, having been established by escaped prisoners. The magic here is strange, the palace opulent and the occupants live in a bubble of food, drink and pleasure of all forms. Briony is visited by a long dead goddess and she fights to uncover the secrets of this place while Elyan tries to find the cave they seek to go back to their world. You knew going in that our little band of found family would shake this place to the core and they don’t disappoint. I love the character development of Phyra, Arlo and Thaniel in this book. They became so much more than side characters in this and left their mark on the pages. I also loved the relationship development not only between the characters we already knew but also with new ones.
My only super minor issue is that I read Asperfell too long ago to remember some plot points and a recap would have helped. Some of the details were sprinkled throughout the book but it would have been handy to have. I probably should have reread the last few chapters of the first book before diving in.
This was a super fast read and now I can’t wait until the final book in the trilogy to see where the author takes this.
August 22, 2021
ARC from NetGalley
This book, this series really, deserves a better cover. The cover makes it seem as if the writing will be a lot more "indie" than it is. Jamie Thomas is an excellent writer. I do think she would benefit from a bit more experience, a bit more polish and development of her craft. I can see the potential for greatness, and I don't mean that in like a War and Peace kind of way, but she could be a really good, really popular fantasy writer one day.
Okay so this one started off a bit slow for me, and actually a bit young. It was around the 40% mark that suddenly we're dropping F-bombs and people are getting randy. Briony can be so frustrating. She's super impulsive and often just dumb. Elyan is such a dick so much of the time. I mean, I usually like that, but he is the kind of dick where I'm like EXCUSE YOU SIR?
This could have been a 5-star read for me if there was just a bit more character development and relationship progress. We are pretty much in stasis with Elyan and Briony for the entirety of the book. The relationship doesn't progress. They profess their love for each other but rarely even talk. We get like a couple make-out scenes and that's it. They aren't really ever in the same room together for very long. It's a romance that's much more told than felt, and the book suffered for it, for me at least. The setting was great. The kingdom is so lush and vivid. It's very over the top with the bling and the decadence, and I really enjoyed that. There's a lot to this book that I really liked, but it just felt like there was something missing, a few somethings, but I can't really articulate exactly what.
I really quite enjoyed this book once I got into it, and I likely would have rated it more highly if I had remembered anything from the previous one when I started reading it because I didn't have any connection to the characters until like halfway through. I highly recommend giving Asperfell a re-read before you start this one if it's been a while. I read it in January 2020, and that was too long.
Also, this book marks me starting my note to self so that I have some semblance of an idea wtf is going on when I pick up the next one, which I will be doing. I most definitely want to read the next one.
Note to self:
This book, this series really, deserves a better cover. The cover makes it seem as if the writing will be a lot more "indie" than it is. Jamie Thomas is an excellent writer. I do think she would benefit from a bit more experience, a bit more polish and development of her craft. I can see the potential for greatness, and I don't mean that in like a War and Peace kind of way, but she could be a really good, really popular fantasy writer one day.
Okay so this one started off a bit slow for me, and actually a bit young. It was around the 40% mark that suddenly we're dropping F-bombs and people are getting randy. Briony can be so frustrating. She's super impulsive and often just dumb. Elyan is such a dick so much of the time. I mean, I usually like that, but he is the kind of dick where I'm like EXCUSE YOU SIR?
This could have been a 5-star read for me if there was just a bit more character development and relationship progress. We are pretty much in stasis with Elyan and Briony for the entirety of the book. The relationship doesn't progress. They profess their love for each other but rarely even talk. We get like a couple make-out scenes and that's it. They aren't really ever in the same room together for very long. It's a romance that's much more told than felt, and the book suffered for it, for me at least. The setting was great. The kingdom is so lush and vivid. It's very over the top with the bling and the decadence, and I really enjoyed that. There's a lot to this book that I really liked, but it just felt like there was something missing, a few somethings, but I can't really articulate exactly what.
I really quite enjoyed this book once I got into it, and I likely would have rated it more highly if I had remembered anything from the previous one when I started reading it because I didn't have any connection to the characters until like halfway through. I highly recommend giving Asperfell a re-read before you start this one if it's been a while. I read it in January 2020, and that was too long.
Also, this book marks me starting my note to self so that I have some semblance of an idea wtf is going on when I pick up the next one, which I will be doing. I most definitely want to read the next one.
Note to self:
July 22, 2021
This may have been better than the first! Thanks to NetGallet for the arc.
May 13, 2025
i love this world so much, ive read a lot of fantasy and i can honestly say this world is unique and i didn’t even realize i’ve craved that in a book until reading this
March 2, 2024
Briony and her companions' have managed to escape Asperfell, however she realizes quickly that the escape was only the first part of a long and trying journey.
To get home they must first gain the help of another kingdom, one that seems to embody everything Brony hates about wealth. It seems that even the need for help wont stop Briony specking and acting as she sees fit. This irritates Elyan no end. It's almost as if he has never met Briony.
In the end it might be an ancient goddess they need help from and not a kingdom.
Spoilers
In some ways the second in the Asperfell series repeats some of the aspects and themes of the first book. We see unconditional friendship and loyalty. Some new aspects include the coming out of a character as a member of the LGBTQ+ community. There were also the themes of equality, poverty, murder, abuse, and more. .
Unfortunately I can not say I liked this book as much as the first. To begin with a lot of what were meant to be plot twists were actually quiet obvious and therefor dragged out.
Some parts of the story seemed conveniences that only appeared to speak to the political ideals of the writer. For example the abortion plot was extremely unnecessary. None of the characters were mentioned again once the woman escaped the palace. This leads to the question did Thomas add this "sub plot" to voice her anti-abortion opinion?
As if this was all a reader would question about an author who considers themselves to "Aim to smash patriarchy one novel at a time" and who hopes to "Inspire, empower and elevate women."
Unfortunately not. Briony is painted as someone who believes in equality., this seems questionable at times. For example even in the first book Briony questions the relationships around her. Particularly where sex is involved. She constantly judged anyone at Asperfell for having sex and not being married. In this book the same judgement arises. It seems as though when it comes to feminism Briony draws the line at sex before marriage and female bodily autonomy. Meaning that Briony is judging others by standers set by the patriarchy.
Perhaps if these were my only arguments I could give this book four starts but then there are two other major problems.
Firstly Elyan is an abusive character. What was plaid of as brooding and emotional, misunderstood should-be-King has mutated in to controlling and abusive behavior.. In too many scenes to count Elyan's behavior to the others and Briony is abusing and gas-lighting. Ranging from him demanding that she be quiet to grabbing her.
Are we not advanced enough to see this as abuse and not romance?
Secondly, and worst of all Thomas goes on to use one of the worst and most damaging tropes there are. After Briony is sexually assaulted by the King of Syr'Aliem and other men of the palace she then tries to have sex with Elyan. (you know once he has saved her from the cluches of her attacker *rolls eyes*) We are supposed to believe that Briony now thinks her self not worth Elyan and suddenly does not believe in marriage before sex? If Thomas thinks that sexual assault is foreplay or a turn then she is mistaken and to write such a scene between Briony and Elyan seconds after an assault scene is disgusting. and worthy of a bad Hollywood movie.
Regardless of how much I liked Phyra's character, the LGBTQ+ relationship, the goddess or what feminism there was I will be rating this book 2 stars for the reasons above. Bitterly disappointed
To get home they must first gain the help of another kingdom, one that seems to embody everything Brony hates about wealth. It seems that even the need for help wont stop Briony specking and acting as she sees fit. This irritates Elyan no end. It's almost as if he has never met Briony.
In the end it might be an ancient goddess they need help from and not a kingdom.
Spoilers
In some ways the second in the Asperfell series repeats some of the aspects and themes of the first book. We see unconditional friendship and loyalty. Some new aspects include the coming out of a character as a member of the LGBTQ+ community. There were also the themes of equality, poverty, murder, abuse, and more. .
Unfortunately I can not say I liked this book as much as the first. To begin with a lot of what were meant to be plot twists were actually quiet obvious and therefor dragged out.
Some parts of the story seemed conveniences that only appeared to speak to the political ideals of the writer. For example the abortion plot was extremely unnecessary. None of the characters were mentioned again once the woman escaped the palace. This leads to the question did Thomas add this "sub plot" to voice her anti-abortion opinion?
As if this was all a reader would question about an author who considers themselves to "Aim to smash patriarchy one novel at a time" and who hopes to "Inspire, empower and elevate women."
Unfortunately not. Briony is painted as someone who believes in equality., this seems questionable at times. For example even in the first book Briony questions the relationships around her. Particularly where sex is involved. She constantly judged anyone at Asperfell for having sex and not being married. In this book the same judgement arises. It seems as though when it comes to feminism Briony draws the line at sex before marriage and female bodily autonomy. Meaning that Briony is judging others by standers set by the patriarchy.
Perhaps if these were my only arguments I could give this book four starts but then there are two other major problems.
Firstly Elyan is an abusive character. What was plaid of as brooding and emotional, misunderstood should-be-King has mutated in to controlling and abusive behavior.. In too many scenes to count Elyan's behavior to the others and Briony is abusing and gas-lighting. Ranging from him demanding that she be quiet to grabbing her.
Are we not advanced enough to see this as abuse and not romance?
Secondly, and worst of all Thomas goes on to use one of the worst and most damaging tropes there are. After Briony is sexually assaulted by the King of Syr'Aliem and other men of the palace she then tries to have sex with Elyan. (you know once he has saved her from the cluches of her attacker *rolls eyes*) We are supposed to believe that Briony now thinks her self not worth Elyan and suddenly does not believe in marriage before sex? If Thomas thinks that sexual assault is foreplay or a turn then she is mistaken and to write such a scene between Briony and Elyan seconds after an assault scene is disgusting. and worthy of a bad Hollywood movie.
Regardless of how much I liked Phyra's character, the LGBTQ+ relationship, the goddess or what feminism there was I will be rating this book 2 stars for the reasons above. Bitterly disappointed
July 8, 2021
The Forest Kingdom was a great sequel to Asperfell, following Briony, Elyan and more as they attempt to return to Tiralaen. They encounter appealing luxury and horrifying secrets, unexpected kindnesses and many surprising developments. Briony is what you look for in a main character; compassionate and strong willed, with good morals and a kind heart. Jamie Thomas has a wonderful writing style, causing me to laugh and cry on multiple occasions. It is clear she has put much effort into the book, coming up with unique themes, detailed descriptions and emphasised the importance of friends and family throughout. All of the characters were extremely well written, and overall I would recommend The Forest Kingdom, and cannot wait for the next book in the trilogy!
did-not-finish
August 20, 2021I really liked Asperfell when I read it, and was grateful to receive an ARC of the sequel. Unfortunately, The Forest Kingdom struggled to capture my attention. Partly, the long gap between books meant that I’d forgotten much of Asperfell, so struggled to follow what was happening early. However this book also lacks what I do remember liking about book one, notably the eerie gothic atmosphere. And, maybe it’s just because I’ve read a lot of fantasy since then, but I couldn’t help noticing the lack of diversity relative to other books. I could have kept reading and maybe this book would have gotten an ok rating, but I’d rather a book inspire more in me than ‘meh’.
July 22, 2021
The sequel of Asperfell did not disappoint.
If you are looking for a series that is fantasy where you are not confused the entire time, then this is for you.
Strong female lead who shows incredible amount of development in this sequel.
The world building continues and just becomes more intriguing. It would have been easy to push the book in a completely different direction, and I am so glad that Jamie Thomas did not.
I cannot wait for the 3rd book to be released.
If you are looking for a series that is fantasy where you are not confused the entire time, then this is for you.
Strong female lead who shows incredible amount of development in this sequel.
The world building continues and just becomes more intriguing. It would have been easy to push the book in a completely different direction, and I am so glad that Jamie Thomas did not.
I cannot wait for the 3rd book to be released.
August 23, 2021
3.5 stars
Thanks to NetGalley and Uproar Books for providing an ARC of this ebook in exchange for an honest review.
When I requested this ARC, I did not pay close enough attention to the fact that it was a sequel. And so, without intending to, I quickly had to read Asperfell last month… and I was left somewhat underwhelmed. Not a good sign for an ARC. However, The Forest Kingdom stepped up its game and told a tale that was entertaining from start to finish.
Our characters have moved on from the prison and in their search of the gate to bring them home, they came across, you guessed it, The Forest Kingdom. Here they are met by extravagant people living grand lives of indulgence, all while a suppressed magic source strains beneath their feet.
This book had a vibe I can't quite articulate, but I really enjoyed it. I think I was in the mood for an easy story. The prose flowed with grace and I was genuinely interested in the characters from the first page to the last. It's been a bit since I've read something romantic, and this really scratched the itch. Also, I much preferred the smaller group in this story. It felt like a found family, and I genuinely connected with each member.
However, just as in Asperfell, there wasn't a ton of depth and I was a bit confused on the magical side. Magic seemed to be more of a convenience to the story, and I wasn't quite tracking with the climactic events. It's maybe the lack of concrete rules? The magic seems to do what it wants when it wants to…and then at other points it's of no use. In particular, I couldn't tell the difference between those who had magic in their blood and those who used magic from the source-thingy (already forgot the proper name). Despite this, I was happy to somewhat gloss over the parts I didn't get and enjoy the story anyway.
As a debut series, I think what Jamie Thomas is creating is a genuinely interesting world fleshed out through beautiful prose. Though I came into this series by accident, I intend to see it through when the third book releases next year.
TL;DR
5.0 —One of the best I've ever read. Will be burned into my brain. Couldn't care less about weaknesses (if any). Would recommend to everyone and their mother.
4.5 —Loved this read. Will remember it fondly. Few weaknesses. Would recommend to anyone.
4.0 —Enjoyed this read. Will remember it fondly. Minor weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
▌3.5 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Might be memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
3.0 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Not very memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.5 —Neutral or Underwhelming read. Not very memorable. Significant weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.0 —Underwhelming or unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for the wrong reasons. Significant weaknesses. Might recommend to people who like similar books.
1.5 —Unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for bad reasons. Major weaknesses. Probably wouldn't recommend.
1.0 —I wish I never wasted minutes of my life on this trash. I would go out of my way to convince others not to read it.
Thanks to NetGalley and Uproar Books for providing an ARC of this ebook in exchange for an honest review.
When I requested this ARC, I did not pay close enough attention to the fact that it was a sequel. And so, without intending to, I quickly had to read Asperfell last month… and I was left somewhat underwhelmed. Not a good sign for an ARC. However, The Forest Kingdom stepped up its game and told a tale that was entertaining from start to finish.
Our characters have moved on from the prison and in their search of the gate to bring them home, they came across, you guessed it, The Forest Kingdom. Here they are met by extravagant people living grand lives of indulgence, all while a suppressed magic source strains beneath their feet.
This book had a vibe I can't quite articulate, but I really enjoyed it. I think I was in the mood for an easy story. The prose flowed with grace and I was genuinely interested in the characters from the first page to the last. It's been a bit since I've read something romantic, and this really scratched the itch. Also, I much preferred the smaller group in this story. It felt like a found family, and I genuinely connected with each member.
However, just as in Asperfell, there wasn't a ton of depth and I was a bit confused on the magical side. Magic seemed to be more of a convenience to the story, and I wasn't quite tracking with the climactic events. It's maybe the lack of concrete rules? The magic seems to do what it wants when it wants to…and then at other points it's of no use. In particular, I couldn't tell the difference between those who had magic in their blood and those who used magic from the source-thingy (already forgot the proper name). Despite this, I was happy to somewhat gloss over the parts I didn't get and enjoy the story anyway.
As a debut series, I think what Jamie Thomas is creating is a genuinely interesting world fleshed out through beautiful prose. Though I came into this series by accident, I intend to see it through when the third book releases next year.
TL;DR
5.0 —One of the best I've ever read. Will be burned into my brain. Couldn't care less about weaknesses (if any). Would recommend to everyone and their mother.
4.5 —Loved this read. Will remember it fondly. Few weaknesses. Would recommend to anyone.
4.0 —Enjoyed this read. Will remember it fondly. Minor weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
▌3.5 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Might be memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
3.0 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Not very memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.5 —Neutral or Underwhelming read. Not very memorable. Significant weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.0 —Underwhelming or unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for the wrong reasons. Significant weaknesses. Might recommend to people who like similar books.
1.5 —Unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for bad reasons. Major weaknesses. Probably wouldn't recommend.
1.0 —I wish I never wasted minutes of my life on this trash. I would go out of my way to convince others not to read it.
July 13, 2021
The Asperfell Trilogy is my favourite accidental find for this year. After receiving an eArc from Netgalley I quickly went back to read Asperfell and absolutely fell in love with it. This is a stay up all night kind of read.
I adore magic and intrigue so this was really up my alley. The Forest Kingdom continues to provide plenty of secrets and mysteries to unravel, much like Asperfell. While the twists aren't necessarily jaw dropping, the way they all piece together in the end is very satisfying. Our characters all have a great amount of development although Briony still remains frustratingly naïve. Although, as the most sheltered person in the group, this should be expected.
The Forest Kingdom introduces another type of magic, a whole host of new characters and beautiful Narnia-esque landscapes. I am very interested to see how this series concludes because it simply beautiful, imaginative and a little twisted.
I adore magic and intrigue so this was really up my alley. The Forest Kingdom continues to provide plenty of secrets and mysteries to unravel, much like Asperfell. While the twists aren't necessarily jaw dropping, the way they all piece together in the end is very satisfying. Our characters all have a great amount of development although Briony still remains frustratingly naïve. Although, as the most sheltered person in the group, this should be expected.
The Forest Kingdom introduces another type of magic, a whole host of new characters and beautiful Narnia-esque landscapes. I am very interested to see how this series concludes because it simply beautiful, imaginative and a little twisted.
February 23, 2022
What a let down! 1.5 stars. The first book was so good and unique. It had wonderful world building and a mature, if stubborn, h; a H who was moody and smart, but came around to h. It had so much going for it. This on the other hand felt like generic YA. Characters who were interesting/complex in book one reverted to hormonal teenagers with superficial reasoning. This entire book read like the author was pushed by the publisher to make her story YA because It iS So HoT RiGhT NoW. Also, the mystery of this book was lame and I was nowhere near as invested in it as in the first book. First book is for adults, second book is for YA/14 year olds who think they’re edgy. Sigh. Alright rant over, on to my next read.
August 25, 2021
I really struggled on what rating to give this book, as I truly love the world of Asperfell and the unique characters within. In the end I went with my gut and had to go 4 star.
I will say what I love about the Asperfell trilogy in the sense that it feels real. The characters aren't larger than life, yes they have powers that I'd imagine the majority of people in this world do not, however the benefit of their magic is crippled by their own humanity. Phyra, a necromancer, cannot control her empathy for others and by using her powers she puts herself and others at risk. Brionny, who ironically has the power of words, can't keep her mouth shut long enough without putting herself and her friends in danger. The characters in this story have consequences for their actions and I love that aspect of this world. Likewise I love the world building and the politics in the societies. I won't go into details, because spoilers, but I loved the contrast between all of them. I think the saving grace of this book though are the characters, they feel so human with all their insecurities, fears and love for one another that you can't help but love them too.
That being said the characters were allowed to roam a certain kingdom far more than I thought was believable given their importance to said kingdom. I think the biggest disappointment for me though, was that Asperfell book 1 felt like it was building up to an epic war in Tiralaen that just never resolved in book 2. It felt very much like a tangent from the original story that I couldn't help but feel a bit put out by the end. Don't get me wrong through, the story of the Forest Kingdom was very enjoyable in itself, it just feels like I could have skipped this book and it wouldn't have made much difference. The key issues of book 1 are still the issues of book 3 and it feels like no progress was made which is the main reason I had to rate this 4 stars.
On a more positive note I can't wait for book 3 and to see how we resolve the issues in Tiralaen.
I will say what I love about the Asperfell trilogy in the sense that it feels real. The characters aren't larger than life, yes they have powers that I'd imagine the majority of people in this world do not, however the benefit of their magic is crippled by their own humanity. Phyra, a necromancer, cannot control her empathy for others and by using her powers she puts herself and others at risk. Brionny, who ironically has the power of words, can't keep her mouth shut long enough without putting herself and her friends in danger. The characters in this story have consequences for their actions and I love that aspect of this world. Likewise I love the world building and the politics in the societies. I won't go into details, because spoilers, but I loved the contrast between all of them. I think the saving grace of this book though are the characters, they feel so human with all their insecurities, fears and love for one another that you can't help but love them too.
That being said the characters were allowed to roam a certain kingdom far more than I thought was believable given their importance to said kingdom. I think the biggest disappointment for me though, was that Asperfell book 1 felt like it was building up to an epic war in Tiralaen that just never resolved in book 2. It felt very much like a tangent from the original story that I couldn't help but feel a bit put out by the end. Don't get me wrong through, the story of the Forest Kingdom was very enjoyable in itself, it just feels like I could have skipped this book and it wouldn't have made much difference. The key issues of book 1 are still the issues of book 3 and it feels like no progress was made which is the main reason I had to rate this 4 stars.
On a more positive note I can't wait for book 3 and to see how we resolve the issues in Tiralaen.
August 24, 2021
The Forest Kingdom is the second in the Asperfell Trilogy and having escaped the walls of Asperfell our mixed band of intrepid heroes and wandering in the wilderness aiming to find a mysterious cave that will allow them back to their own world.
I read the first book in this series without knowing very much about it and enjoyed it very much, this second book was very much a Second Book. The main arc of the trilogy concerns Elyan getting back to his kingdom to reclaim his throne from his dastardly brother but this whole second book is all about another kingdom and their problems (which are many) so it all seemed a bit spurious. Thomas aims to make it relevant by holding up this corrupt kingdom and comparing it to where they originally come from and the main take away we are supposed to get from that is that monarchies are bad we want democracy!
Elyan makes himself pretty scarce throughout this whole book and when we do get him he is usually just there to have a go a Brionay who is at her most tiresome for the majority of the book. Even she knows she’s being tiresome but still she keeps opening her mouth because that’s what plucky heroines do and all the powerful men around them can’t help but love her. It is well known that men in positions of power are hot for outspoken, tactless women…
There is a lot packed in here and it reads easily and moves forward quickly, the secondary characters are well rounded and interesting as is the world itself but I will be happy to get back to the main plot in the last book after this, what I am sure will turn out to be completely necessary, interlude.
I read the first book in this series without knowing very much about it and enjoyed it very much, this second book was very much a Second Book. The main arc of the trilogy concerns Elyan getting back to his kingdom to reclaim his throne from his dastardly brother but this whole second book is all about another kingdom and their problems (which are many) so it all seemed a bit spurious. Thomas aims to make it relevant by holding up this corrupt kingdom and comparing it to where they originally come from and the main take away we are supposed to get from that is that monarchies are bad we want democracy!
Elyan makes himself pretty scarce throughout this whole book and when we do get him he is usually just there to have a go a Brionay who is at her most tiresome for the majority of the book. Even she knows she’s being tiresome but still she keeps opening her mouth because that’s what plucky heroines do and all the powerful men around them can’t help but love her. It is well known that men in positions of power are hot for outspoken, tactless women…
There is a lot packed in here and it reads easily and moves forward quickly, the secondary characters are well rounded and interesting as is the world itself but I will be happy to get back to the main plot in the last book after this, what I am sure will turn out to be completely necessary, interlude.
August 23, 2021
I would be the First to tell you that Asperfell, the first in this trilogy was one of my favourite books in this rather distinct genre. A gothic Fantasy with the added bonus of a streak of feminist steel to the spine of our Heroine. Despite the gap between books, I found it easy to fall in again with our less than merry band of intrepid escapees. From the prison city of Asperfell.
The banter between two of the five has not subsided and the Romance still sizzles despite the increasingly dire circumstances that Briony and Elyan find themselves. The world that Jamie Thomas created both expands and contracts in this second instalment. We still get eerie spectral appearances, magics born of life and death . Nature is still a major character in her own right, and creatures tragic, majestic and ridiculous pepper this story too which was part of the allure for me in the first place.
Where our favourites learn to adjust and evolve in a plot of rescue, growth redemption , greed and compassion . The ultimate big reveal to set up the big finale was counterpointed by a loving subplot so delicately played and movingly resolved that it warmed my heart-immensely… I honestly think this is the more interesting of the two books thus far.. Ms Thomas takes the braver less trodden paths away from tropes to empower her characters and lay their foibles bare so they become nuanced and more relatable… men are both strong and vulnerable and women, wise, impetuous and committed to each other. There is power in those facets that made this a book I enjoyed immensely.
The banter between two of the five has not subsided and the Romance still sizzles despite the increasingly dire circumstances that Briony and Elyan find themselves. The world that Jamie Thomas created both expands and contracts in this second instalment. We still get eerie spectral appearances, magics born of life and death . Nature is still a major character in her own right, and creatures tragic, majestic and ridiculous pepper this story too which was part of the allure for me in the first place.
Where our favourites learn to adjust and evolve in a plot of rescue, growth redemption , greed and compassion . The ultimate big reveal to set up the big finale was counterpointed by a loving subplot so delicately played and movingly resolved that it warmed my heart-immensely… I honestly think this is the more interesting of the two books thus far.. Ms Thomas takes the braver less trodden paths away from tropes to empower her characters and lay their foibles bare so they become nuanced and more relatable… men are both strong and vulnerable and women, wise, impetuous and committed to each other. There is power in those facets that made this a book I enjoyed immensely.
August 11, 2021
Quote: "I do not think ignorance can ever be an advantage, no matter what the circumstances."
Pros: Excellent world building and good writing.
Cons: Just like in the first book, there is little to no diversity in this book. The pacing was much slower than the first book, and it took getting to the halfway mark for the plotline to actually start picking up. Even though Briony and Elyan are together now, Elyan is still a but of an asshole and constantly disregards Briony and treats her like she's careless and a burden at times. The story started to get a bit political and went down a pro life path where the main character, Briony, shamed a woman for wishing to end her pregnancy and it awful and the death of a child. I get everyone has their different political views, but this could have been handled a bit more gracefully, and honestly made me DNF the book.
Content Warnings: Talks of abortion.
Overall Rating: 3 star DNF (stopped at chapter 18/58%)
P.S. I received an arc copy to read and review before the official publishing of ths book. That being said this is an honest review with honest opinions.
Pros: Excellent world building and good writing.
Cons: Just like in the first book, there is little to no diversity in this book. The pacing was much slower than the first book, and it took getting to the halfway mark for the plotline to actually start picking up. Even though Briony and Elyan are together now, Elyan is still a but of an asshole and constantly disregards Briony and treats her like she's careless and a burden at times. The story started to get a bit political and went down a pro life path where the main character, Briony, shamed a woman for wishing to end her pregnancy and it awful and the death of a child. I get everyone has their different political views, but this could have been handled a bit more gracefully, and honestly made me DNF the book.
Content Warnings: Talks of abortion.
Overall Rating: 3 star DNF (stopped at chapter 18/58%)
P.S. I received an arc copy to read and review before the official publishing of ths book. That being said this is an honest review with honest opinions.
August 31, 2021
I was looking forward to this book because I liked the first one so much! The story had a different feel in this sequel. First, they encounter a people who really, really enjoy debauchery. I so enjoyed the development of Briony and Elyan's relationship in the first book. In this book, he's either mad at her, contemptuous of her, or clearly physically attracted to her. Yuck. I understand the importance of keeping tension in a relationship, but that combination does not lead to a romantic relationship that I want to buy in to. Actually, all of Briony's companions had unexplained, dramatic personality shifts. The best character development (as in most understandable and appearing to lead him to be a better, mature person) was Arlo's. I'm not sure I'll read the third book. I just didn't like the characters very much in this one.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
May 21, 2022
Still not for me
I hated the relationship between Briony and Elyan. I kept thinking it was going to get better. But there is no redeeming factor in it. Briony is still whiny and immature. She doesn't listen when others are telling her she's making mistakes or that something is a terrible idea. And Elyan just wants to change her. There is no explanation for why he loves her. What's worse is he doesn't act like it. He just shuts himself away and then yells at her. Apparently in the woods they're always fighting with each other, too. Why does Briony want to be with someone who treats her so horribly.
And the writing itself is so hard to get through. Its like wading through mud. There is so much that could be taken out. We don't need to know what Briony is doing every single moment. Leave some mystery. It wad so slow, which made it hard to read.
I hated the relationship between Briony and Elyan. I kept thinking it was going to get better. But there is no redeeming factor in it. Briony is still whiny and immature. She doesn't listen when others are telling her she's making mistakes or that something is a terrible idea. And Elyan just wants to change her. There is no explanation for why he loves her. What's worse is he doesn't act like it. He just shuts himself away and then yells at her. Apparently in the woods they're always fighting with each other, too. Why does Briony want to be with someone who treats her so horribly.
And the writing itself is so hard to get through. Its like wading through mud. There is so much that could be taken out. We don't need to know what Briony is doing every single moment. Leave some mystery. It wad so slow, which made it hard to read.
April 24, 2023
I love this book! The first book had me hooked and wanting more, now I can only say one bad thing. The next one doesn't come out until 2024!! This book picks up where the first left off and took you into a whole new kingdom.
September 1, 2021
4.5 Stars
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
In terms of action, The Forest Kingdom picks up pretty much when Asperfell stopped. After our mixed bag of criminals/heroes escaped the Sentinels, they went into the woods where they have been travelling for a few weeks now, looking for a mythical cave that should return them to their world. We find them hunting for their dinner.
In a trilogy, the second book is often the weakest, kind of a transition between the juicy bits. This is very much NOT the case here. The story is so well crafted that it could almost be a standalone. The world development is fairly extensive, the newly introduced characters have their own agendas, there is a lot of action, a different magic system, goddesses, creatures... I have a feeling that we haven't seen the last of the world beyond the Gate and that some of the new characters will play a role in the third book, their stories don't seem quite finished yet.
The Forest Kingdom starts with a memory, a memory of when Briony was a teenager living a sheltered if somewhat wild life with her aunt in a remote estate. The power of the memories in the book is perhaps one of my favourite things about it. I love how Briony looks at her past from a more mature point of view and a sense of irony, and at the same time is able to engage us and transport us there completely. She still can look and laugh at herself with kindness and to me that makes her very human. At the same time, she is very impulsive and makes some pretty dumb decisions without really thinking them out or talking to the people that surround her.
Elyan, as a character, did not get the development I was hoping for. He spends a lot of the book brooding, being evasive or just being rude. He is so focused on finding the Gate that he often looses sight of everything else. The love between him and Briony develops at a very slow pace, they don't have a lot of space to be alone. BUT I love the fact that they see the other's faults and foibles, they bicker if they are frustrated and they fight, they sometimes doubt each other and their hearts get hurt. That is what real people do.
This was a great and engaging read, and it will be great to revisit it when the third book hits the shelves.
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for an ARC in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
In terms of action, The Forest Kingdom picks up pretty much when Asperfell stopped. After our mixed bag of criminals/heroes escaped the Sentinels, they went into the woods where they have been travelling for a few weeks now, looking for a mythical cave that should return them to their world. We find them hunting for their dinner.
In a trilogy, the second book is often the weakest, kind of a transition between the juicy bits. This is very much NOT the case here. The story is so well crafted that it could almost be a standalone. The world development is fairly extensive, the newly introduced characters have their own agendas, there is a lot of action, a different magic system, goddesses, creatures... I have a feeling that we haven't seen the last of the world beyond the Gate and that some of the new characters will play a role in the third book, their stories don't seem quite finished yet.
The Forest Kingdom starts with a memory, a memory of when Briony was a teenager living a sheltered if somewhat wild life with her aunt in a remote estate. The power of the memories in the book is perhaps one of my favourite things about it. I love how Briony looks at her past from a more mature point of view and a sense of irony, and at the same time is able to engage us and transport us there completely. She still can look and laugh at herself with kindness and to me that makes her very human. At the same time, she is very impulsive and makes some pretty dumb decisions without really thinking them out or talking to the people that surround her.
Elyan, as a character, did not get the development I was hoping for. He spends a lot of the book brooding, being evasive or just being rude. He is so focused on finding the Gate that he often looses sight of everything else. The love between him and Briony develops at a very slow pace, they don't have a lot of space to be alone. BUT I love the fact that they see the other's faults and foibles, they bicker if they are frustrated and they fight, they sometimes doubt each other and their hearts get hurt. That is what real people do.
This was a great and engaging read, and it will be great to revisit it when the third book hits the shelves.
September 15, 2021
4.5 Stars
The Forest Kingdom picks up pretty much when Asperfell stopped. After our mixed bag of criminals/heroes escaped the Sentinels, they went into the woods where they have been travelling for a few weeks now, looking for a mythical cave that should return them to their world. We find them hunting for their dinner.
In a trilogy, the second book is often the weakest, kind of a transition between the juicy bits. This is very much NOT the case here. The story is so well crafted that it could almost be a standalone. The world development is fairly extensive, the newly introduced characters have their own agendas, there is a lot of action, a different magic system, goddesses, creatures... I have a feeling that we haven't seen the last of the world beyond the Gate and that some of the new characters will play a role in the third book, their stories don't seem quite finished yet.
The Forest Kingdom starts with a memory, a memory of when Briony was a teenager living a sheltered if somewhat wild life with her aunt in a remote estate. The power of the memories in the book is perhaps one of my favourite things about it. I love how Briony looks at her past from a more mature point of view and a sense of irony, and at the same time is able to engage us and transport us there completely. She still can look and laugh at herself with kindness and to me that makes her very human. At the same time, she is very impulsive and makes some pretty dumb decisions without really thinking them out or talking to the people that surround her.
Elyan, as a character, did not get the development I was hoping for. He spends a lot of the book brooding, being evasive or just being rude. He is so focused on finding the Gate that he often looses sight of everything else. The love between him and Briony develops at a very slow pace, they don't have a lot of space to be alone. BUT I love the fact that they see the other's faults and foibles, they bicker if they are frustrated and they fight, they sometimes doubt each other and their hearts get hurt. That is what real people do.
This was a great and engaging read, and it will be great to revisit it when the third book hits the shelves.
The Forest Kingdom picks up pretty much when Asperfell stopped. After our mixed bag of criminals/heroes escaped the Sentinels, they went into the woods where they have been travelling for a few weeks now, looking for a mythical cave that should return them to their world. We find them hunting for their dinner.
In a trilogy, the second book is often the weakest, kind of a transition between the juicy bits. This is very much NOT the case here. The story is so well crafted that it could almost be a standalone. The world development is fairly extensive, the newly introduced characters have their own agendas, there is a lot of action, a different magic system, goddesses, creatures... I have a feeling that we haven't seen the last of the world beyond the Gate and that some of the new characters will play a role in the third book, their stories don't seem quite finished yet.
The Forest Kingdom starts with a memory, a memory of when Briony was a teenager living a sheltered if somewhat wild life with her aunt in a remote estate. The power of the memories in the book is perhaps one of my favourite things about it. I love how Briony looks at her past from a more mature point of view and a sense of irony, and at the same time is able to engage us and transport us there completely. She still can look and laugh at herself with kindness and to me that makes her very human. At the same time, she is very impulsive and makes some pretty dumb decisions without really thinking them out or talking to the people that surround her.
Elyan, as a character, did not get the development I was hoping for. He spends a lot of the book brooding, being evasive or just being rude. He is so focused on finding the Gate that he often looses sight of everything else. The love between him and Briony develops at a very slow pace, they don't have a lot of space to be alone. BUT I love the fact that they see the other's faults and foibles, they bicker if they are frustrated and they fight, they sometimes doubt each other and their hearts get hurt. That is what real people do.
This was a great and engaging read, and it will be great to revisit it when the third book hits the shelves.
April 14, 2023
I am a very happy being for picking up this series. I truly enjoyed Asperfell, but The Forest Kingdom was definitely revved to new heights. I found myself really enjoying Briony more - she's my fantasy version of Jo March and I love it. I also think bringing more depth to characters like Arlo, Thaniel, and Phyra truly made me fall more deeply in love with the story. Seeing all of them break out of their shell in different ways was amazing and all I can say Phyra is my Queen of Death <3.
I was sad there was less Elyan and Briony this round, but it totally makes sense of why and makes their scenes together have that much more weight. They were so cute and tore me apart more times than one. I also think that having them apart allowed Briony to come into her own powers independently and really progressed the story beautifully by having her take the lead.
That brings me to the main storyline -- it was so captivating! The Dae Spira and the mystery behind the forest kingdom was so interesting and I loved that I couldn't guess what was going to happen the entire time. I loved Princess Evolet and how her story ended - she was such an intriguing person and I totally didn't guess her goals at the end.
The only thing I can really say I was disappointed about was that I felt like Briony could have had more moments of working on her magic other than Magefire. I was definitely given big power bursts that gave me enough to work with, but I really hope next book she figures out her powers more where she can just be the coolest Orare that ever lived.
Anyways, the short version of this review is just add it to your cart because it's worth it.
I was sad there was less Elyan and Briony this round, but it totally makes sense of why and makes their scenes together have that much more weight. They were so cute and tore me apart more times than one. I also think that having them apart allowed Briony to come into her own powers independently and really progressed the story beautifully by having her take the lead.
That brings me to the main storyline -- it was so captivating! The Dae Spira and the mystery behind the forest kingdom was so interesting and I loved that I couldn't guess what was going to happen the entire time. I loved Princess Evolet and how her story ended - she was such an intriguing person and I totally didn't guess her goals at the end.
The only thing I can really say I was disappointed about was that I felt like Briony could have had more moments of working on her magic other than Magefire. I was definitely given big power bursts that gave me enough to work with, but I really hope next book she figures out her powers more where she can just be the coolest Orare that ever lived.
Anyways, the short version of this review is just add it to your cart because it's worth it.
August 25, 2021
I enjoyed Asperfell much more than The Forest Kingdom. The plot took an enormous detour and once the main characters ended up at this new kingdom, things really fell flat. Briony has become an incredibly judgemental and selfish character, and while other characters actually point that out to her, she is such a Mary Sue that it all gets forgiven because she is needed to be special and to save everyone from everything. Elayn is completely one dimensional, and barely present. Maybe the 3rd book will be dependent on what happened in this book, but it felt less like a sequel and more like a standalone story with the same characters.
I also found the way the same sex relationship was handled to be very bizarre. It's like the author wanted everyone to pay attention to the inclusivity of the book, but instead of seeming like a normal, natural relationship, there was all kinds of judgement and guilt and stupidity surrounding it.
I received a copy of this book from Net Galley.
I also found the way the same sex relationship was handled to be very bizarre. It's like the author wanted everyone to pay attention to the inclusivity of the book, but instead of seeming like a normal, natural relationship, there was all kinds of judgement and guilt and stupidity surrounding it.
I received a copy of this book from Net Galley.
October 17, 2022
Lento, lleno de detalles insufribles, una protagonista que se vuelve cada vez más inmadura conforme pasa el tiempo, entrometida, sin sentido común, y falta de madurez. Estuve a punto de abandonarlo, pero seguí porque el primero me encantó, lo maduro y bien creado que estuvo todo, pero este es complemente opuesto. Tengo que agregar que hay un no muy sutil odio hacia los hombres a lo largo del libro que me incomodó, pero al final esto se volvió tan descarado que es ofensivo.
Slow, full of insufferable details, a protagonist who becomes more and more immature as time goes on, nosy, lacking in common sense, and immature. I was about to abandon it, but I continued because I loved the first one, how mature and well created everything was, but this one is the complete opposite. I have to add that there is a not-too-subtle hatred of men throughout the book that made me uncomfortable, but by the end this became so blatant that it's offensive.
Slow, full of insufferable details, a protagonist who becomes more and more immature as time goes on, nosy, lacking in common sense, and immature. I was about to abandon it, but I continued because I loved the first one, how mature and well created everything was, but this one is the complete opposite. I have to add that there is a not-too-subtle hatred of men throughout the book that made me uncomfortable, but by the end this became so blatant that it's offensive.
August 27, 2021
spoilers ahead!!!
This book is definitely a must read!!
I really enjoy the simple elegant cover. Also I thoroughly enjoyed the imersive world that Jamie Thomas has written. The characters are all deep and have vastly different personalities giving the story even more dimension. There were so many parts that I had no idea evade would come next, I loved the unpredictability of it! I never saw it coming that "king" Anwar was the usurper and purposely watching his land die just because he wanted the illusion of power. I can't wait for book 3 to see west adventures they have when they get back to Tiralaen.
This book is definitely a must read!!
I really enjoy the simple elegant cover. Also I thoroughly enjoyed the imersive world that Jamie Thomas has written. The characters are all deep and have vastly different personalities giving the story even more dimension. There were so many parts that I had no idea evade would come next, I loved the unpredictability of it! I never saw it coming that "king" Anwar was the usurper and purposely watching his land die just because he wanted the illusion of power. I can't wait for book 3 to see west adventures they have when they get back to Tiralaen.
October 15, 2021
This book didn't disappoint!
This book picks up right where Asperfell left off. The characters have some ups and do
wns, and more than a few fallings out. When they are welcomed to Syr Aliem, the hedonism and debauchery of the citizens is shocking and eventually our heroes tire of that lifestyle. When Briony learns more about the truth of the city, her biggest challenge is making her friends believe her.
This story is well-written and the characters are believable. It ends at a very good place that, I'm sure will lead us to the 3rd book in the series.
Overall, I enjoyed reading this series and look forward to the series finale!
This book picks up right where Asperfell left off. The characters have some ups and do
wns, and more than a few fallings out. When they are welcomed to Syr Aliem, the hedonism and debauchery of the citizens is shocking and eventually our heroes tire of that lifestyle. When Briony learns more about the truth of the city, her biggest challenge is making her friends believe her.
This story is well-written and the characters are believable. It ends at a very good place that, I'm sure will lead us to the 3rd book in the series.
Overall, I enjoyed reading this series and look forward to the series finale!
January 10, 2023
I was very disappointed in this sequel that I actually just gave up on it with only 100 pages left. The first book was so clever, left room for character development and then we enter the Forest Kingdom. And it was like I had picked up a desperately written YA novel with loads of immaturity. The character development felt like it came to a screeching halt and basically every single character just sounded like a whiny brat. On top of that, I was so grateful for the first book being free of sex and language. Unfortunately, I felt duped as the author added so much of that to this book. Just not my cup of tea.
August 31, 2021
I loved the forest kingdom ,and the first book asperfell,they both got my interest from the first page ,if you are a fantasy lover ,then you must read these books ,l highly recommend them ,but we all see things differently. To read these two books was definitely for me ,to be engaged in a fantasy world ,compared to the world we live in now ! Do your self a favour and get lost in the pages of these wonderful fantasy books .
May 30, 2024
I loved the first book. This one, not so much.
Second star is for supporting characters who are interesting and have some development.
Second star is for supporting characters who are interesting and have some development.
May 4, 2022
AMAZING MUST READ
This was one of those series’s were the second book was - dare I say - better than the first! The perfect balance of fantasy, world building, romance, chosen family, heartbreak, and subversion to always keep you gripping the pages for dear life.
Love this author and can’t wait for the next instalment!!
This was one of those series’s were the second book was - dare I say - better than the first! The perfect balance of fantasy, world building, romance, chosen family, heartbreak, and subversion to always keep you gripping the pages for dear life.
Love this author and can’t wait for the next instalment!!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 46 reviews