The story begins with a dream – the dream of Africa. Virgin forests, majestic mountains surrounded by savannas, vast plains punctuated with the rhythms of animal life where lions, elephants and giraffes reign as lords of nature, far from civilization – all of us carry such images in our heads, imagining Africa as a timeless Eden untouched by the ravages of modernity.
But this Africa has never existed. The more we destroy nature here, the more we fantasize about it in Africa. Along with UNESCO, the WWF and other organizations, we convince ourselves that the African national parks are protecting the last vestiges of a world once untouched and wild. In reality, argues Guillaume Blanc, these organizations are responsible for naturalizing large tracts of the African continent, turning territories into parks and forcibly evicting thousands of people from the lands where they have lived for centuries. Making use of archives and oral histories, Blanc investigates this battle for a phantom Africa and the contradictory claims of nations who destroy nature at home while believing that they are protecting the natural world abroad. In so doing, they enact a new type of green colonialism.
I am so pleased to seen an English translation of this superb work, which exposes much of the rot and racism at the core of the Western conservation movement in Africa. It gels with my own thinking and research in this area though from different angles. When an Ethiopian peasant asks why the "government cares more about walia (a rare ibex) than it does the people" he was echoing a cry that has long been heard across Africa. The colonial roots of the policies pursued to this day by the likes of the WWF, IUCN and UNESCO are clinically dissected here. Areas that Blanc does not explore in any detail include human/wildlife conflict (HWC) and doing so may have taken the book in interesting directions. This is more a quibble than a criticism - this is the kind of thoughtful work that raises angles that others can pursue. It is true as Blanc notes that the removal of people from African landscapes to "protect nature" has been a grave social injustice, and that mythical "African Edens" are an invention of the colonial mindset. It is also the case that the best way to prevent the horror of HWC is to keep people and big, dangerous animals separate through initiatives such as fencing. In fact, Africans and dangerous wildlife have historically tended to avoid each other with exceptions such as rivers, where poor Africans still share space with crocs and hippos. In the 21st century, this is a function of poverty and inequity. This iconoclastic book will challenge many of the Tarzan and Disney-inspired views that many in the West have of Africa, its people and its wildlife. I plan to write a much fuller view in the Daily Maverick - stay tuned ... And here it is: https://www.dailymaverick.co.za/artic...
Green Colonialism is about how 'science' (Actually various misleading biased research) provided Europe with the necessary legitimacy to exploit Africa and to expropriate the African people from forests. Actually it's not happened during colonial times, actually after gaining independence. Green colonialism, born of the declinist theories which legitimized the ecological burden of the western expert, throughout the whole of Africa. Foucault said, power is not something between those who have it and those who do not and who suffer in consequence. Again, African countries are suffering post-colonial implications.
In 1936, with the Snows of Kilimanjaro Hemingway transported western readers to a fairy-tale Africa. There, they discovered a landscape 'as wide as all the world' where the 'big five' reigned supreme: the lion, the leopard, the elephant, the buffalo and the black rhinoceros.
The Lion King, very few of them realized that the film was inspired by the colonial era. On the other hand, many spectators retained the image of a green planet, where enlightened prevented destructive creatures from burning the savannas.
US guide Ted Shatto, left his country and set up the Ethiopian branch of Safaris International Inc. was a keen sell Safari tours to tourists around the world. UNESCO, FAO, ECWO, IUCN actually involved local people's displacement. African forced to leave their territories to create more 'sustainable'! environment for animals, and tourists! They are convinced that in Africa, the small-scale farmers are inexorably degrading the soil.
Guillaume Blanc, brings shocking perspective to all African forests, and how people were not taken account in their own country. Amazing book. While you're reading, you'll see: how our point of view is that African people have been displaced from their own land and this actions are justified under the name 'we' 'Western people' are protecting nature.
I was in Kenya the first time I started to get a slightly queasy feeling about our approach to 'conservation' in Africa. I had spoken to some Maassai people who had been forced from their grazing land and were now selling trinkets to tourists, which, in the middle of a global pandemic wasn't working out great. Guillaume articulates that unease with passion and thoughtfulness in a people-centric way that makes you sit up and pay attention.
I am sure there is a degree of cherry-picking data and I will certainly seek out opposing views. But this is an important, sometimes uncomfortable, well-argued book that will stay with me for years.
The Invention of Green Colonialism is a searing and thought-provoking critique of the outdated ideas behind wildlife conservation in Africa today. Read my full review at https://inquisitivebiologist.com/2023...
this was recommended by my professor and probably my favorite read of the year! truly changed the way i view sustainable development and conservation around the world (and i will see The Lion King in such a different light now).
Essential reading for anyone interested in conservation, particularly in the context of Africa. It treads similar ground to Reframing Deforestation (Fairhead and Leach), but is much better evidenced and overall more persuasive.
I really like the book, I can relate so much with the community's stories, that is why when I ready the note that the organizations mentioned in the book was mad at the author, I know what he wrote is true.