Okay, so considering this is a debut novel, it’s not bad. It kept my interest throughout, despite some issues, which is saying a lot. I’d say it might be 3.5 stars but I just can’t round up to 4. Plenty of other people have rated this 4 or 5, and I didn’t find it as amazeballs as they did.
The writing is… okay. Thankfully the grammatical errors aren’t abundant, so I can gloss over that part. The biggest issue is probably all the periods when they should actually be commas or semicolons. Makes it a bit choppy.
What annoyed me to all heck was the amount of brand dropping (you know, like name dropping) and while I’m all for a well aimed reference, I don’t need 50 of them per chapter. Ok, maybe I exaggerated a little, but there are too many. I don’t need to know every song and the artist that someone listens to. I feel it takes away from the story and is more ‘telling’ than ‘showing’, but that’s just me.
It’s pretty cliche that the badass main girl always wears band tshirts and Docs or Chucks and the mean girl wears Louboutins or Jimmy Choos. Almost without fail, like it’s a requirement to mention, multiple times. At least I didn’t have to read about every single guy outfit, so there’s something.
And maybe this was a personal shoutout, but Ariah mentioning reading Toxic Creek by KC Kean was kind of corny. Again, maybe a me thing. But I digress.
This book is so full of tropes you can’t step anywhere without crunching over one. Which isn’t necessarily a bad thing, especially considering most of these RH and/or dark academy books are all somewhat formulaic. I kind of expect it at this point in my reading, and since I’m addicted to this kind of stuff for better or worse, I clearly don’t have a huge problem. If an author can insert a little of their own flair and creativity to mitigate the abundance of trope, that’s when the book is great (not literary great, but great for this genre). This book was not great, alas, but it was okay. Is okay the same as good? Jury’s still out on that one.
Ariah as a MC was… fine. I got the whole ‘I’m not skinny’ thing, so I really didn’t need to be constantly hit in the head with that fact. The guys were okay, though I feel their personalities could have been a little more distinct from each other. Maybe that’s just me nitpicking though. Ariah’s insta best friend was a little on the annoying side, mostly because their dialogue together got on my nerves. Maybe most teens these days talk to each other in a similar fashion, but after just meeting each other? Not in my day, that’s for sure.
Sam, the mean girl, is about as cliche as they come, and I found her character not even remotely interesting. Maybe that was the point. Don’t know, don’t care. Everyone else was just kind of there, a prop so to speak.
Lots of trigger warnings for those that need them. I don’t have any, but I can recognize the need to know if you do. I’ll be reading the rest of the series, assuming things don’t derail too badly. Here’s hoping they don’t!