A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower

by Patricia Bernstein

Based on the true story of Winifred Maxwell,
a Catholic in anti-Catholic England

Scotland, 1716 -

Traveling alone through a frightful snowstorm, Bethan Glentaggart is desperate to get to London where her husband languishes in the Tower of London. As the date of Gavin's beheading rapidly approaches, Bethan has only her wits and her women friends to support her against King George. Will she be able to free Gavin? Will she even be allowed to see him?

Genres: Historical Fiction, Historical, Scotland, British Literature

266 pages, Kindle Edition

Published March 7, 2023

About the author

After earning a Degree of Distinction in American Studies from Smith College, Patricia Bernstein founded her public relations agency in Houston.
In 2018, her third book was named a Finalist for an award from the Texas Institute of Letters. The Austin American Statesman named the book to a list of 53 of the best books ever written about Texas. Patricia's nonfiction is previously published by Simon & Schuster and Texas A&M University Press.
A Noble Cunning is her debut novel and was the winner in the American Book Fest category of Religious Fiction and a finalist in the categories of Historical Fiction, Literary Fiction and Inspirational Fiction.
Today Patricia lives in Houston with her husband, journalist Alan Bernstein, where she pursues another great artistic love, singing with Opera in the Heights and other organizations. She also basks in the glory of her three amazing daughters.

Reviews

[Fran · Rating 5 out of 5]

**Publication Day**

"For our wrong king and oppressed country...for our lives and liberties."
-The Jacobite Rebellion of 1715

In June 1701, the English Parliament passed the Act of Settlement. "...henceforth no Catholic or anyone married to a Catholic can succeed to the throne."

They were so-called "Convenant Ministers" searching for a secret missionary priest. They claimed Gavin Glentaggart (Lord Clarencefield) was breaking the law by hearing mass and harboring priests. They claimed that they had "just cause" to raid Heath Hall under cover of darkness. "I am Bethan Carlisle Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield, a Catholic amid the heathen Protestants...I must show neither fear nor weakness".

Bethan recounted the story of fleeing England with her family, the queen and baby prince, when William of Orange invaded England. According to English law, Catholics were forbidden from holding office or buying land. Attendance was mandatory at the Church of England services. Non- attendants incurred a fee. Queen Anne, in declining health, was the last Stuart to reign. King James II would be forced from the throne. More than fifty closer relatives were passed over until a Protestant cousin was located. German George, the Elector of Hanover, became King.

"According to rumor, this George...lacked a kingly appearance...he had neither wit nor conversation...had a capacity for malevolence...had arrived in England for his kingly coronation speaking no English...". Many Englishmen and Scotsmen wanted to overthrow King George and place the exiled Stuart prince, as King James III, on the throne.

"I cannot deny the call. Whether we succeed or fail, we must seize our best chance yet to restore our rightful king." Gavin, one of the principal leaders of the Jacobite Rebellion of 1715, helped organize the challenge to the reign of German George. Young James Stuart had not appeared. No victories in battle, no territory gained would suffice if [he] did not appear backed by soldiers and arms...seeing no King James to lead us...the disorganized military made serious strategic errors. "We were defeated and I [Gavin] was taken prisoner...Come to London as soon as you can. We will be held in the Tower, and I will have no way to petition for my release if you do not come." Troops had surrendered with the promise from the English that King George would be merciful. Would this be the case?

That day, Bethan swore a vow to stand against the forces that were crushing the Catholics. From the Scottish Lowlands, accompanied by her devoted companion, Lucy Dunstable, Bethan embarked upon a daunting journey by horseback, then coach and through a brutal, blinding snowstorm, doggedly determined to reach the Tower of London. She would petition the king for Gavin's release. Plans would falter, new strategies envisioned. A trusted inner circle of friends, putting their own lives at risk, included a silk merchant and a formerly estranged relative.

"A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower" by Patricia Bernstein is based upon the true story of Winifred Maxwell and her quest to save her husband from death. This work of historical fiction was thoroughly researched and meticulously detailed. It was a captivating read with fully fleshed out protagonists. Would Bethan's ingenuity and plan of last resort, masterful as it was, work out? What suspense! Highly recommended!

Thank you Patricia Bernstein, Colin Mustful and History through Fiction for the print copy in exchange for an honest review.

[Sujoya - theoverbookedbibliophile · Rating 4 out of 5]

Happy Publication Day! (March 7, 2023)


Based on true events, A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower by Patricia Bernstein revolves around forty-three-year-old Bethan Carlisle Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield and her efforts to save her husband Gavin from execution.

“It wasn’t just Catholics against Protestants. There were Dissenters like the Covenanters who hated the Church of Englanders almost as much as they hated the Catholics.”

The story is set in 1700s Scotland and England. After the death of Queen Anne, the last Stuart monarch, laws disallowing Catholics to ascend the throne resulted in bypassing several claimants and establishing the closest Protestant heir George of Hanover as successor. However, those loyal to the Stuart line of heirs support King James II’s son, James Francis Edward, the Chevalier’s claim to the throne. He had been living in exile but was expected to be returning to England shortly to take up arms and lead the rebellion. When Bethan’s husband Gavin joins the Jacobite rebellion she is fearful for him but supports his stance, both her family and his being loyal to the Stuarts. Unfortunately, the Jacobites are defeated and forced to surrender. Gavin is one of many who are imprisoned and awaiting trial. Bethan, leaving her children with relatives, travels to London amid inclement weather with her friend and confidante Lucy Dunstable to meet Gavin, who is imprisoned in the Tower of London. Bethan is no stranger to the perils of her journey and is aware of her precarious standing as a Catholic in anti-Catholic England. As a child of parents who served in the court of James II, she had been forced to flee to France with her family when he was overthrown by William of Orange. As a married woman settled in the Scottish Lowlands with her husband and children, she faced the Covenanters when they raided her home some years ago in search of a Catholic priest who Bethan was rumored to have (and actually had) harbored in her home. Unable to find the priest, her home was ransacked during the search and Bethan was physically assaulted by one of the Ministers.

“For so many of my years, I and those I love have been victims of the times, blown from pillar to post without any volition of our own. We have been able to find some happiness for a while, only to see it taken from us, simply because we are loyal to a disfavored faith, and because we subscribe to the belief that the English should be ruled by an Englishman.”

Gavin, along with others who fought with him , is pronounced guilty and sentenced to death. When Bethan's petition for Gavin’s pardon is ignored, she enlists the help of Lucy, her new friend Amelia Thrupp and her estranged sister Aelwen in devising and executing a plan to save her husband.

Based on the true story of Winifred Herbert Maxwell, Countess of Nithsdale, a noblewoman who plotted to free her husband William Maxwell, Earl of Nithsdale from the Tower of London with help of her friends, A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower by Patricia Bernstein is an informative and fascinating read that I thoroughly enjoyed. The story is shared from the perspective of the protagonist in the first-person narrative format. The narrative is fluid and well-structured. Meticulously researched, the novel sheds a light on the anti-Catholic sentiment and persecution of those of the Catholic faith and the changes in the political and religious landscape of that era, while also giving us a window into the societal practices prevalent in those times. Bethan is an admirable character as is her friend Lucy. The second half of the novel is particularly engaging as we follow these resourceful women as they go about working out the details of their plan. Please do read the Author’s Note where she discusses the historical context of this novel in further detail. This was a departure from my usual choice of books but I was glad for the opportunity to read an advance copy of this novel and share my thoughts.

Many thanks to author Patricia Bernstein, History Through Fiction, and Stephanie Barko for the digital review copy of this fascinating novel. All opinions expressed in this review are my own.

[PamG · Rating 3 out of 5]

In A Noble Cunning: The Countess and Tower , Patricia Bernstein brings to life the political and religious situation in Scotland and England. This novel is historical fiction set in the early 1700’s, but based on real events with names changed and fictional individuals added.

The story is told from the point of view of Bethan Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield, who lives in Scotland with her husband Gavin and their children. It’s the story of how people of different religions were treated. There’s fear, anger, hatred, and cruelty to others. When Gavin joins a group of rebels, he is captured. Bethan is determined to rescue her husband from the Tower of London before he is executed. She must face mob attacks, snowstorms, a cruel king, and more. Will she succeed?

The novel starts with a startling event that immediately grabs reader’s attention. There are a few unpredictable moments in the story, and even a couple of humorous moments to give readers a breather from the tension. The book is also very descriptive, which does a great job of giving readers a feeling of the time and place. However, it also slows the pace and adds to the instances of telling versus showing. Additionally, at the 95% point in the book, there is a fast jump in time with no transition. Despite this, the significant amount of danger, bravery, and plotting kept me fully engaged.

Overall, the book was atmospheric and full of suspense. The author has included a historical note at the end of the book. Since it contains spoilers, readers should not read this before reading the book. There are also two family trees, a timeline of events before and during the novel, and an extensive bibliography.

History Through Fiction, Independent Book Publishers Association, Members’ Titles, Patricia Bernstein, and Stephanie Barko provided a complimentary digital ARC of this novel via NetGalley. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own. Publication date is currently set for March 7, 2023.
------------------------------------------
My 3.19 rounded to 3 stars review is coming soon.

[Marilyn (not getting notifications) · Rating 4 out of 5]

Patricia Bernstein, author of A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower, based her novel on a true story that I had not known about. It took place in both Scotland and England during the early years of the eighteenth century. During that time, the citizens of both Scotland and England that continued to practice Catholicism, were in constant danger. The Church of England would not tolerate or recognize any form of Catholicism. Those citizens that continued to practice Catholicism were forced to do so in secrecy and even in the privacy of their own homes. Venturing priests that traveled through Scotland or England risked capture or execution. Those priests were forced to hide in the homes of trustworthy Catholics that could shelter them until it was safe for them to move on. One such night, The Countess of Clarencefield was awoken by an angry mob that believed the Countess and her husband were harboring a priest in their home. The Countess’s husband was away when the search occurred. During their search, the Countess was put in a very compromising situation. Luckily for the Countess, the situation was discovered in time and stopped but the tensions between the Protestants and the Catholics were escalating faster than anyone had expected in both Scotland and England.

During this time of religious upheaval, Bethan Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield, and her husband Gavin, were living in the lowlands of Scotland, at their estate, Heath Hall. Both Bethan and Gavin and their children were of the Catholic faith. War between the Church of England and those of the Catholic faith seemed inevitable. The death of Queen Anne and the subsequent coronation of King George of Hanover, the first and only King of England that had come from Germany, were the catalysts that sparked the onset of the Jacobite Rebellion in 1715.

Gavin soon set off from Heath Hall to join his countrymen to fight for religious freedom for all Catholics and to oust George of Hanover from the English throne. He wished to restore the thrown of England to the Stuart prince, James Francis Edward Stuart. The Stuart prince was living in exile at the time but was expected to arrive in Scotland very soon and lead his countrymen in battle. When King James failed to arrive, Thomas Forster, a man with no military background but a man who was a Protestant and a member of Parliament, was chosen to lead the Highlanders. Things did not go well for the Highlanders and they were soon defeated. Gavin was taken prisoner and was being held in The Tower of London. Fortunately, Gavin managed to get word to his wife, Bethan, the Countess,about his fate. He implored her to come to London as quickly as possible. Gavin instructed Bethan to bring as much money as she could. She would have to help Gavin petition for his release. The Countess’s worst fear had come to fruition.

The Countess made arrangements for her children to be taken to Gavin’s brother’s and sister-in-law’s house where they would be safe. She also borrowed money from them for Gavin’s release. Then the Countess set off from the Scottish lowlands to London, all during one of the worst snowstorms ever. After some set backs, illness and timely new acquaintances who offered the Countess help, the Countess arrived in London. The Countess had realized immediately that Gavin’s fate lay in her hands. Gavin had been condemned to death by execution. The Countess was able to devise a plan to save Gavin. It involved the intricate help of her devoted group women friends. Although it was a brilliant plan, nothing could go wrong with it or she would not be able to save Gavin’s life. The Countess planned to carry it out the day before Gavin’s scheduled execution. Was she and her courageous women friends up for the challenge? Would the Countess’s plan succeed in saving her beloved husband from his death?

A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower by Patricia Bernstein was based on real events and the lives of Winifred Herbert Maxwell, Countess of Nithsdale and William Maxwell, Earl of Nithsdale. Before reading this novel, I had not been aware of either Countess or Earl nor their extraordinary circumstances. It was about having courage, determination and strength. It was about love, friendship, trust, perseverance, taking risks, relying on others and having faith and confidence in oneself. A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower was well written and impeccably researched. I tend to enjoy books that have strong women protagonists and this one surely did. If you enjoy reading historical fiction, where the story was inspired by true events and there was a strong female protagonist, then I recommend A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower by Patricia Bernstein very highly. Publication is set for March 7, 2023.

Thank you to Literary Publicist, Stephanie Barko for providing me with an ARC of A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower by Patricia Bernstein in exchange for an honest and unbiased review. All thoughts and opinions are mine alone.

[Christy Hall · Rating 5 out of 5]

I adore a good and well-researched historical fiction novel. A Noble Cunning by Patricia Bernstein is exactly what I would want to read. She crafts beautiful characters, tension-filled action scenes, and a riveting story that holds your attention and makes you want to research the real story that inspired the tale.

The year is 1710 and Catholics are not very welcome in Scotland. The country has turned quite inhospitable towards Catholics since the kings and queens have inspired wars between people of different faiths. Bethan Glentaggart is a Catholic noblewoman so the community mostly tolerates her family. One night while her husband is away, local Protestant men ransack her house, looking for hidden priests. They assault and scare her, later causing her husband to feel he must join the fight to restore the monarchy to a Catholic Scot and remove the Protestant outsider from the throne. The rebellion is disorganized and short lived. Bethan finds herself in a difficult position when her husband is arrested for treason and thrown into the Tower of London. Can she risk everything to save him?

Bethan is one tough and cunning lady! I loved her! She is a beautifully loving mother and she cares for her people. She and Gavin, her husband, have a rich and layered love that inspires great acts of courage from both of them. Bethan is supported by several female friends who truly understand the difficulty of her position. They support her in her trials, which is one of the reasons Bethan is as successful as she is. The characters definitely make this novel feel rooted in reality.

I was deeply invested in the story. I made sure not to look up the real woman who inspired the story because I didn’t want to ruin the ending for myself. Bernstein is a phenomenal researcher. You can see the attention to detail in her description of surroundings and clothing, in the real historical people who make up her cast of characters and in the action that moves Bethan’s story to a tense conclusion. When I did finally read about the real woman, I was pleasantly surprised how much was the same between the novel and the real story.

The author says her original manuscript was much longer but she cut it for the flow of the specifics events of the novel. However, I really wish it was longer. I wanted more details about Bethan’s life prior to the events in 1710. I wanted details of her life after the ending. I just wasn’t ready to say goodbye to her. She was a deeply interesting, courageous and faithful woman. I did find that the religious conflicts were frustrating and rightly so. How can people claim to be faithful and then use God to wage war against others who worship differently? Bernstein shines a light upon this irony, giving readers much to ponder.

If you’re in the mood for a fantastically researched historical fiction about a unique and courageous woman of faith, then A Noble Cunning is for you!

Thank you to the author and her editor for sending me a copy of the book for my honest review.

[Christy fictional_traits · Rating 4 out of 5]

'A Noble Cunning' is a book inspired by real-life Winifred Herbert Maxwell, Countess of Nithsdale, who, after the failure of the 1715 Jacobite Rebellion, and the subsequent arrest of her husband, attempted to free him from his imprisonment in the Tower of London.

Bethan and Gavin, Earl and Countess of Clarenfield are secretly practicing Catholics living in Scotland, at a time when Catholics are regularly, and increasingly, persecuted by Protestants and other religious factions, 'But nowadays we must be careful because the heathens and the fanaticals have taken over my dear land, and we are strangers here'. When Queen Anne dies, an uprising rebellion forms, in an attempt to restore the true, exiled James Stuart, to his rightful crown. Gavin decides he must join the call to arms but is soon captured and sent to the Tower of London. Bethan rushes to London to try and save her husband from imminent execution. Everything seems hopeless and, as a Catholic in London, it's hard to know who to trust. 'But what was coming now and could not be avoided would be the trial of my lifetime'.

'A Noble Cunning' is well written and uses an authentic tone of voice and historical context. Methodically told in the first person, the book does take a while to build momentum, however, once it does it draws to a quick conclusion. I was left wanting at least an epilogue to tie up loose ends. Ultimately I did enjoy the read and learning about a brave woman who took on some daunting odds in an attempt to free her husband.

[Stephanie Barko · Rating 5 out of 5]

I read an early galley of this award-winning nonfiction author's debut novel.

[Ron · Rating 4 out of 5]

“I would see acres of valiant man slaughtered and young King James drowned in the English Channel if it meant you would come back to me.”

Excellent historical fiction; especially for Bernstein’s first novel. Extraordinary and extraordinarily literate characters. Many historical and cultural connections pull the reader deeply into that time and place.

“I have absolute faith that we can save you, but if you have already given up, we can do nothing for you. All I ask is that you fight for yourself!”

That era’s anti-Catholic sentiment is the warp of the tale. The weft the true story of the historic Winifred Herbert Maxwell, Countess of Nithsdale. In most particulars the narrative follows the actual history, even to some details. Why then, did Bernstein change the lady’s identity?

“All other things to their destruction draw, Only our love hath no decay.” John Dunne

Appropriate epigrams open each chapter. Awkward Italics font impedes reading.

“It was all so long ago and far away and had possibly happened to some ancestor of mine, in a previous era.”

(Full disclosure: Got ARC free in exchange for an honest review.)

[Smbergin · Rating 5 out of 5]

In a novel based on true events, A Noble Cunning tells the story of, a noble Catholic woman who stops at nothing to save her husband amid a time of anti-Catholic rule in England. Readers are taken on adventures through the Scottish Lowlands and Hanoverian London as they travel through the richly painted backdrops of the 18th century. I enjoyed learning new (old) words, phrases, Shakespearean sonnets, and Bible passages. One of my favorite lines, for example, was when a character was described as a “flibbertigibbet married to a block of wood.”

The book was also full of stunningly audacious scenes, hilarious moments, and heartwarming passages about friendship, loyalty, and love. I liked the book at first, but over time I fell in love with the characters.

Historical fiction buffs who like stories about strong, courageous women who band together to accomplish the seemingly impossible, will love this book. (release date 3/7/23).

Thank you to History Through Fiction for an ARC of A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower, in exchange for an honest review.

[Barbara Bamberger · Rating 5 out of 5]

Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower
Patricia Bernstein
Review by Barbara Bamberger Scott

Based on a remarkable true story, this debut novel by author Patricia Bernstein weaves fact and
fiction to create a dynamic history and to bring to light a strong, determined female long in
need of recognition.

Bernstein’s fictional heroine, Countess Bethan Glentaggart, is known near and far for a single
characteristic - her great beauty. But she will prove that she has brains, too, though her
complex, highly pragmatic thought processes will remain unknown to all but a few. She and her
husband Gavin, both Catholic, reside in Scotland, in the early 1700s, in comfort – but not
safety. They and others of their faith are being systematically – through orders of several
European rulers, and chaotically – through mob violence, being tormented, driven out and
sometimes simply murdered as Protestantism takes its foothold. When the couple’s home is
assailed by a group seeking to discover a Catholic priest allegedly hiding there, Gavin’s
involvement in the Jacobite Rebellion against the newly crowned German king is fortified, and
Bethan is forced to realize that her life as well as his is under threat. When Gavin is arrested,
the final ugly truth must be faced as he is locked in the Tower of London, awaiting execution.
Fortunately for Gavin, Bethan is no ordinary, obedient and fear-ridden female, but begins to
show her true colors as she gathers a group of similarly gutsy women around her to attempt
the impossible. After braving a massive blizzard to get to London, Bethan begins to set in
motion a bold plot to sneak Gavin out of the Tower so the two can escape and survive in a safer
place.

Bernstein, who has written other, nonfiction works, has previously focused on American events
(The First Waco Horror: The Lynching of Jesse Washington and the Rise of the NAACP, Ten
Dollars to Hate: The Texas Man Who Fought the Klan) was drawn to the story of Winifred
Maxwell, Countess of Nithsdale, during a visit to Scotland. The rescue planned by her
fictionalized protagonist and arrayed in fascinating detail here was, in Bernstein’s words,
“unique in the history of the Tower,” and, she felt, merited a fresh, wise, and well-structured
look. Her chapters open with quotations from Shakespeare, John Donne and other sources
relevant to the timeframe. Her grasp of phrasing and setting is especially appreciated, withher
description of the intricacies of the clothing of noblewomen like Maxwell/Glentaggart
particularly in focus. Bernstein’s vivid account – a mix of action, contemplation, and historical
underpinning - should inspire the sisterhood in all classes and climes to try harder, go farther,
than they perhaps thought possible in the pursuit of justice and better lives for all.

[Heather Thorup · Rating 4 out of 5]

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for the ARC. Bethan Glentaggart is the Duchess of Clarencefield. Her family is Catholic and have long been supporters of the Stuarts. The throne passed over many heirs, 50 to be exact, because they were Catholic. In its place they put George I. The Electress of Hanover passed away two months before Queen Anne. The heir of Hanover was George; he was elected under the Act of Settlement 1701 as a staunch Protestant. Bethan's home was invaded by a riot of men, looking for a Catholic priest they thought was hidden there. Bethan kept her cool, along with her loyal lifelong friend and former tutor.

When her husband returns home following the riot, he seeks redress for the damage done to the house. Once George I was put on the throne, The Duke of Clarencefield joined forces with several men to raise support for the real Catholic heir, James Stuart, son of James II. Bethan sends her husband on with love and the realization that he will face danger. She receives word from her husband regularly. The Battle of Dunkirk sees her husband and his co conspirators imprisoned in The Tower of London. Bethan panics, setting plans in motion to send their children to family somewhere safe, and packs for the journey to London.

Bethan leaves the Scottish Lowlands during one of the worst winter storms. When she finally arrives, she has a place to stay thanks to a traveler she met on the road. It wasn't easy to trust anyone especially with regards to religion and secret loyalties. Bethan depends upon the generosity and largesse of these good people that take her in. She reconnects with her sister after decades, bringing her into her quest to save her husband from The Tower. At the trial, the men are sentenced to a traitor's death, which is extremely gruesome and usually reserved for commoners. Bethan goes to Court to plead for her husband's life, actually hanging on to King George's coat as he walks away and ignores her pleas.

The sentence has been commuted to a beheading. Bethan is running out of time to save her husband. She sets an intricate plan into place. The very interesting part is that Bethan is based off of a real person that saved her husband from The Tower in the same way; Winifred Maxwell. It shows a strong, committed wife. The machinations of politics and the anti Catholic sentiment are vital to this story. I admit that I almost quit reading the book a couple of times at the beginning. It started slow. I found the end of the book a bit too succinct. It was such a buildup to Bethan saving her husband. I suppose the author wanted to focus on that instead of what happens after. Overall, an interesting read- 4 stars.

[Tahera · Rating 4 out of 5]

This book is based on the true story of Winifred Maxwell, Countess of Nithsdale and the daring rescue mission she undertakes for her husband William Maxwell, 5th Earl of Nithsdale who finds himself imprisoned in the Tower of London, on death penalty, for being part of the failed Jacobite rebellion of 1715.

While reading the book, it hit me that I knew about this story even though I was certain I had not read about it in detail. After a bit of brainstorming, I remembered that I had seen a picture of a painting in a book about the Tower of London which had depicted a scene very similar to the rescue scenario described in this book. Since my sister still has the book I took a sneak peak at the picture to confirm my suspicion and it turned out to be the one!

Winifred Maxwell managed to rescue her husband from a place- and during a period of political and religious turmoil which did not favour the Jacobites- where (as history states) it was nearly impossible for anyone to undertake a successful rescue mission, with many being caught and punished severely/brutally. Where powerful men had failed, Winifred managed to succeed with the help of only her wits, few friends and her love for her husband. Her story deserves to be turned into a movie or a series and I am surprised it hasn't been already. I would definitely watch it!

My thanks to NetGalley, the publisher History Through Fiction/IBPA and the author Patricia Bernstein for the e-Arc of the book.

[Julie Failla Earhart · Rating 4 out of 5]

“Based on a true story of Winifred Maxwell, a Catholic in Anti-Catholic England.”

As the novel opens, Bethan Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield, is pulled from her bed by loud banging on the front door. A group of men barge in, accusing her of hiding a Catholic priest in her home. The men search high and low yet cannot find their quarry. I found myself holding my breath as the men tracked in mud and snow, peering into private places and generally making a mess of things. Luckily Bethan’s husband, Gavin, was not at home and unluckily her children and servants were home in their beds. I really liked that Bernstein dropped the reader into the middle of the action.

In the following chapters, readers learn that is 1710 in Scotland. The Catholic religion has been banned, yet those who were practicing their religion continued to do so, hiding chapels in their homes and attending masses often held in unusual places.

I was really confused as Bernstein explained who was king, who should have been king, and what was happening and who sided with who. It made my head spin, and I wanted to give up, but I trudged ahead. I’m glad I did.

Gavin gathered the men of the region to go a Crusade-like mission to restore the rightful king. Unfortunately, the king’s men were better equipped and outnumbered Gavin’s throng. If the rebels weren’t killed in battle, they were taken to the London Tower.

Jails weren’t like they are today. The men had to purchase their meals, water, blankets, and everything they needed. If a prisoner had no money, they often died of malnutrition or lack of sanitary conditions. An eye-opening experience for this reader.

The last third of the book was Bethan’s determination to get the monies Gavin needed to purchase fresh foods.

As I watched Bethan take charge, I admired her strength and determination. Many times, I found myself holding my breath, worried that Bethan would not be able to succeed in her mission.

My suggestion to anyone who plans (and you should) read this, study Appendix B first. It’s a Chart of Stuarts and Possible Heirs to the Throne of Great Britain. If I had found that sooner, I probably wouldn’t not have struggled so much early in the story.

I enjoyed reading “A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower,” even though this is not preferred time period or setting. I loved the history and the escapades that the characters found themselves embroiled in. “A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower,” receives 4 out of 5 stars in Julie’s world.

[Christine Baleshta · Rating 5 out of 5]

Bethan and Gavin Glentaggart, Countess and Earl of Clarencefield, are Catholics in the early 18th century when Catholics in Scotland and England were severely persecuted. A Noble Cunning begins with Bethan awakened by an angry anti-Catholic mob demanding entry into the Glentaggart home and accusing her of hiding a priest. The Earl is away, but true to her noble upbringing, Bethan remains calm and succeeds in deterring the Covenanters. When Gavin returns, he is determined to seek justice from the magistrates for the assault on his wife and home, but while the magistrates agree the assault is not to be tolerated and fine the ministers, Gavin is forced to come to an unsatisfactory compromise with the Covenanters. As a few quiet years pass, Gavin and Bethan become increasingly worried that if the Queen dies and the throne passes to a Protestant, the persecution of Catholics will continue and there will be war. Which is exactly what happens, entangling Gavin and Bethan in a rebellion to overthrow the King and placing both their lives at risk.

Told through the voice of Bethan Glentaggart, A Noble Cunning is based on true events and the lives of the Countess and Earl of Nithsdale. As one of several strong women characters in the book, Bethan is devoted to her husband and Catholic faith and fearless when in protecting them. “But I could not fall. I am Bethan Carlisle Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield, a Catholic amid the heathen Protestants, I thought, and must show neither fear nor weakness.” Her companion and maid, Lucy, is sharp and perceptive, as well as loyal, sometimes to her own detriment. Bethan’s sister, Aelewen, from whom she has been estranged for many years, transforms herself from a recluse to an invaluable ally in a plot to save Gavin’s life. Then there is Amelia Thrupp, who Bethan grows to rely on to guide her through London society and the King’s court.

A Noble Cunning leads the reader with ease through a time when religious rights were constantly fought over, skillfully weaving history through its flowing narrative with characters that are both compelling and credible. The book holds to the facts and events of the period without weighing the reader down, while at the same time creating tension at a steady pace. From a story she heard years ago, Patricia Bernstein has crafted an intriguing novel written in the imagined perspective of a little-known historical figure that is both thrilling and educational.

[Saranicole · Rating 4 out of 5]

I loved this book. If you are a fan of British History esp. during the Stuart dynasty and the Jacobite uprisings you'll love this book too. I'd also recommend to fans of Outlander (the books). The author uses the same descriptive form of writing. Although if you are a fan of the spice in Outlander, I have to caution that this book does not have that.

This book is based on a true story of a woman who's husband is imprisoned in the Tower of London. The book starts with her family's persecution as Catholics in Protestant Scotland and takes you through the uprising and her husband's imprisonment in the Tower of London. The author does a great job of weaving a lot of historical fact and context into the narrative. Some reviews have complained about her writing style; however, I enjoyed it. The writing felt authentic to the main character, she had a clear voice and viewpoint, and I felt really immersed in her mind.

I will say that for such a throughly detailed book, the last few paragraphs in the ending felt rushed.

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher History Through Fiction for this ARC.

[Amy · Rating 4 out of 5]

An enjoyable, quick story that read more like a memoir. The characters were well developed and likeable and the history and culture of the time were well explained and understandable.

[Aria Harlow · Rating 3 out of 5]

It took me a while to get into this book and I am glad I stuck with it because I ended up enjoying the story, even though I found the writing style hard to engage with at times. I loved the character development in the book and the story was compelling, I had never hear dof this before and so I was thrilled to find out it is based on true events and I ended up looking it up afterwards.
Overall an enjoyable read.

[Joni · Rating 3 out of 5]

This book is based on the real-life events surrounding Winifred Maxwell, a Catholic living in anti-Catholic England. Overall, I felt this was a good read but at times, found some of the political details to be challenging to follow. However, if you enjoy historical fiction and strong female characters, this is not one to miss.

This story is told from the perspective of the fictionalized character, Bethann Gelntaggert. In the opening scene, Bethann's home is being searched by some fanatics who believe Bethann is hiding a Catholic priest. The scene sets the stage for how strong and pervasive the anti-Catholic sentiment is in England.

We then transition to Bethann's husband, Gavin, going off to battle to restore reign to the rightful king. However, Gavin and his men are no match for the royal army and are captured and jailed. Bethann then goes off on a lengthy journey to London Tower to save Gavin's life.

The prison environment is very different from the modern-day version whereas family and friends must care for and advocate for the prisoner in order for them to survive their sentence. Their survival requires large quantities of money to provide for meals, water. clothing, blankets, etc. There is also an elaborate process of bribing guards to ensure the prisoner is treated decently.

The remaining portion of the book focuses on Bethann's efforts to ensure her husband's safety and survival, and this will require lots of creativity and manipulation. Bethann and her friends that are helping her with her efforts are brave and a true force to be reckoned with. Unfortunately for the guards, they may have underestimated the power of women and their commitment to their loved ones.

I received a complimentary copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. All thoughts and opinions expressed in this review are my own.

[Sherry Chancellor · Rating 4 out of 5]

This novel is based on and inspired by the real life bravery of a Scottish countess in 1715. Her name was Winifred Maxwell, Countess of Nithsdale. She saved her husband from certain death by smuggling him out of the Tower.

The character in the book is Bethan Glentaggert, Countess of Clarencefield. When she was a child, her family fled to France with King James II (A Stuart king) when William of Orange and Queen Mary (Stuarts) took the throne. Her family was Catholic and lived in exile for many years. She married at age 27 and moved to Scotland with her husband. They lived happily for a while, having three children, but eventually, when the first Jacobite rebellion (to restore James to the throne) occurred, her husband joined in, taking many of his tenants with him into battle.

With the rebels’ loss at Preston, her husband was taken prisoner and held in the Tower of London awaiting trial. The countess sent her children to safety and traveled to London to try to save her husband.

We, as readers, make the journey with her. Through a terrible winter storm. One of the worst in years. The author did an excellent job with the descriptions and the travails of the trip. A lesser woman might have given up. The countess had to leave her companion at one point and continue on her own. As a modern day woman, I can’t even imagine how scary that was—first, with the weather and then when alone, worrying about cutthroats and robbers. A woman alone was very vulnerable, but she persevered.

Once she arrives in London, she visits her husband in the Tower and gets him legal counsel to try to fight the treason charges. She also tries to plead to the king to let him go free. She hatches a back-up plan to try to save him if the legal case doesn’t go well.

The book was full of historical details and the author did an excellent job of painting the reader a picture of the era. It was as if we were there with the intrepid countess in the snow and in the Tower. The feeling of fear she felt for her husband and what would happen to him read very real.

The only disappointment I had with the book was the ending. I wanted more information about what happened when the countess joined her husband at the culmination of her brave and daring plan. I guess I’ll have to read one of the books in the bibliography at the end of the novel to learn more about the real life lady who took on the British establishment.

[David Hawk · Rating 5 out of 5]

Really fun! Bethan Glentaggart is a commanding lead in this fast-paced rescue adventure, with her quick mind, no-nonsense sensibility, and insightful perspectives. Bernstein includes plenty of interesting historical details about the era in which the novel takes place, and her well-written characters and vivid descriptions bring extra depth and humor to this tale, which highlights the power of a group of women determined to support each other in the face of adversity.

[Cover Lover Book Review · Rating 4 out of 5]

First, I must mention the gorgeous cover of A Noble Cunning: The Countess and the Tower! It grabs my attention immediately and makes me want to know more. Especially knowing the story is based on true events centered on a woman trying to free her husband who is being held in London Tower.

As with the cover, the story pulls me in quickly, and I’m suddenly immersed in the world of the 1700s, with Catholicism being banned and the challenges of the Jacobite rebellion.

I did get lost a bit due to an abundance of historical information. descriptions, which king was who and such so it was difficult to fully connect with Bethan at times. But as the story progresses, I admire her courage and strength and root for her to complete her mission.

The author’s notes are a wonderful supplement after reading the story.

First Line: I had gone to bed early and slept soundly until I was awakened by a wild noise of cries and shouts almost under my windows.
Genre: Christian Historical Romance
Author: Patricia Bernstein
Page Count: 266

#CoverLoverBookReview received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions are 100% mine.

[Sarah W. · Rating 3 out of 5]

*I received a copy of this book through LibraryThing Early Reviewers.*

This novel had the framework of a good story and I'd like to read more about the real events which inspired it. Several of the characters, however, frustrated me - Bethan seems naive and unworldly one moment and then the next she's reflecting on her experiences at royal courts in both England and France. The character I found the most interesting was Bethan's sister Aelwen, who isn't very kindly regarded by her sister despite the fact that she funds and aids her sister's efforts to get her husband out of the Tower of London.

[Lauralee · Rating 5 out of 5]

A Noble Cunning is a historical fiction novel inspired by the real life of Winnifred Maxwell, a Catholic noblewoman who rescued her husband from the Tower of London. One night while her husband, Gavin, is away, a group of Protestants invade Bethan Glentaggart’s home and assault her because she is Catholic. A few years after the attack, Queen Anne dies and George I becomes the new King of England. However, Gavin is displeased over England’s new choice of king. He decides to rebel against George I and install King James II’s Catholic son on the throne of England. However, Gavin’s rebellion fails, and he is arrested and thrown into the Tower of London. He also receives a death sentence. With the help of her sister and female friends, Bethan schemes to save her husband from execution.

Bethan Glentaggart is a very strong and compelling figure. She is spirited, passionate, and strong-willed. She is also stubborn and impulsive which could put her into harm’s way. However, I admired her courage because she is not afraid of risking her life for her husband. I also admire her steadfast faith in God because she believes that God will eventually find a way to save him. I also respected Bethan’s intellect and her cunning scheme to save her husband. Her plan was not perfect and held that much could have gone wrong. However, she managed to succeed. Therefore, Bethan was an engaging and admirable character.

Overall, this novel is about faith, friendship, and rebellion. The message of the novel is to always trust in God, and that with God anything is possible. I found all of the characters, especially the females, to be likable and endearing. There were a few times where I thought that the writing style relied more on telling and not showing. However, it was a light and riveting read! I was enthralled from the first page! I did not want this novel to end and wished that it was longer. I do wish there was another novel about Bethan’s adventures before she rescued her husband. This is because I really adore Bethan! A Noble Cunning also opened my eyes to Winnifred Maxwell. Before I read this book, I did not know anything about her. After finishing it, I did more research on her. I found her to be a very intelligent and colorful heroine that would be the epitome of great novels. I also wondered why there were so few books on her. Hopefully, with the publication of A Noble Cunning, there will be books about her in the future. I recommend this novel for fans of The Freemason’s Daughter, White Rose Rebel, and The Pretender’s Lady! A Noble Cunning is an enthralling tribute to a little known yet extraordinary woman!
(Note: I read an ARC copy of this book in courtesy of Netgalley.)

[M. K. French · Rating 4 out of 5]

Bethan Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield, is a persecuted Catholic noblewoman in the middle of the 1715 Rebellion against England's first German king George I. Traveling alone from the Scottish Lowlands to London through one of the worst snowstorms, she is determined to save her husband's life. The king and his court have little interest in mercy, so Bethan and her friends must use a complex scheme featuring multiple disguises and poison to free Gavin.

This story is based on an actual Countess, which makes me enjoy the story that much more. It opens up with an attack on Bethan's home by a Protestant mob searching for an itinerant Catholic priest. One of them attacks Bethan, as he's completely unhinged. The religious conflict is alive and well not only in the Scottish countryside but in England as well. This sets off the rebellion against George that gets Gavin caught by the end of the first third of the novel. This extended beginning shows us the atmosphere of the period as well as the love between Bethan and Gavin. It's believable that she has the strength of will to go against the king, deal with painfully estranged family, and maintain love of her husband to push her forward.

We get a chance to see what life is like for the titled gentry as well as the merchant class and serving folk of the period. I can't help but think of Phillipa Gregory's novels with the level of detail for the time period and how threats of war, insurrection, and religious discord affected all walks of life. The scene where Bethan tries to petition the king is a complete melodrama, and as tense as they were leading up to it and after, I found it really memorable and it's easily one of my favorites. (It also actually happened!)

The second half of the novel is essentially a heist, which is really fun and detail-laden for all its tension. I enjoyed that part and seeing how all the friendships made it work out. Not exactly a spoiler, the story wouldn't have been known if not for the Countess' bravery and cunning. If you enjoy the time period, there's also an appendix with further reading suggestions thoughtfully provided.

[Joanne Leddy · Rating 4 out of 5]

I thought I knew about the Jacobites because I read Outlander. Boy, was I wrong! This short novel explains the lineage, family squabbles, and social issues of the times. Written as a historical fiction, the book is based on facts with two family trees provided to help the reader follow along. Solid 4 stars.

[Andrea Johnson · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is based on the fascinating true story of a Scottish countess who tries to get her husband out of the Tower of London where he is imprisoned. Much of the story is true and is a nod to the brave people involved in the Jacobite revolution who were fighting against a foreign king and religious persecution. Quite a historical page-turner. Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for the arc.

[Yvette · Rating 4 out of 5]

Subject to ill treatment by non-Catholics and with her husband imprisoned after the failed Jacobite rebellion against the first German king of England, Bethan Glentaggart is willing to face down King George himself in her quest to free Gavin from the Tower of London. Luckily she has a group of women on her side.

With main characters based on Catholic nobles from 18th Century Scotland, Patricia Bernstein has taken a lesser known piece of history and crafted an intriguing and riveting story. From the first scene, as she faces a vindictive assault on her home and her person, Bethan is an admirable mix of strength and vulnerability, a devoted mother and wife whose courage rises in the face of persecution and a seemingly impossible task.

A Noble Cunning is a strong fiction debut that will delight readers of Historical Fiction with high stakes suspense grounded in true history. Highly recommended.

This review refers to a print copy I voluntarily received and read, courtesy of the publisher. A positive review was not required and all opinions expressed are my own.

[John Wilhellm · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a great historical novel, and what an appropriate read for Women's History Month. Patricia Bernstein has taken real history and built a novel that brings the reader in and won't let go. In early 17th century England a Scottish noblewoman assembles a team of women to attempt a daring rescue from the Tower of London. The author's depth of research is impressive. She makes the reader feel like we are actually in the plot.

[Alison C · Rating 4 out of 5]

Bethan Glentaggart, Countess of Clarencefield, loves her husband Gavin, their children and their lives in Scotland in the early 1700s. But her husband’s family, and her own, have long been sworn allies of the Royal Stuarts, and so in 1715, when a contingent of Scottish nobles takes to the field of battle to restore James III, exiled son of James II, in defiance of the Protestant Parliament’s crowning of George, a minor German noble who is the closest Protestant cousin of the last ruling Stuart, Queen Anne, upon her death, Gavin Count of Clarencefield joins the rebels. Alas, their quest is foiled, not least because of the less-than-inspiring James III’s late and brief showing in the contest, and Gavin is imprisoned in the Tower of London along with other rebels. When he is sentenced to death, it is up to Bethan to obtain his release, by whatever means necessary…. This story is based on a true-life incident in 1715 Britain, where a Countess did indeed rescue her Count from execution, with the help of a handful of trusted female companions; presumably Ms. Bernstein preferred to fictionalize her account rather than write a straight-forward history. In any event, the result is a lively and tense recounting of a remarkable woman in a dangerous time. My only quibble would be that, as wickedly as the Protestants treated the Catholics in their midst, when the Catholics were in the ascendency, they treated Protestants just as wickedly, so some of the “Protestants behaving badly” complaint is a bit hypocritical; but then, wars between religious sects are never one-sided. Recommended! I received an ARC of this novel through LibraryThing’s Early Reviewer Program.

[Patsy · Rating 5 out of 5]

I just finished "A Noble Cunning" -- my first book of the New Year ~ superb, full of history, intrigue and loaded with terrific descriptions, tantalizing vocabulary and all the flourish of 1700's Britain.
As Ms Bernstein requested, I did not read the author's " spoiler" til the I finished the book, so was perfect then to learn the parallels of characters fictional and historic--uh oh I better say no more.
The schism between Protestants and Roman Catholics sets the book's boundaries for the havoc and chaos, wars and death that divided families and forever skewed the British royal lineage. I learned that George I was +-50th in line for the throne and yet chosen as King only because he was a Protestant. ( What did that do for the gene pool?! )
As a fan of Alison Weir and Antonia Fraser, I found "A Noble Cunning" complementing the oeuvre of remarkable women in tumultuous times. The smoothly flowing story is testament to Ms Bernstein's seamless merge of actual occurrences twirled into fiction. Well done. ☀
My Zoom book group says they'll be interested to know when it's an ebook, and we can have an author "appearance" !