Note on why I rated this so high:
While the language wasn't particularly breathtaking or anything, it was effective. What I liked about this book was the ideas it presented, though. It challenged my perceptions of how God works and who He is, how flawed the people He works through really are. Although he frames the Bible characters in such a way as to support his thesis, and some might argue that these are incomplete pictures and there are plenty of counterarguments that could be raised by his propositions - some addressed by the author himself - I feel like this is entirely valid; he is simply approaching what used to be seen nonchalantly with fresh insight, and he isn't trying to distort any truths by his take on the matter, just placing the truth under a different light in the hopes of illuminating something to help us understanding it better. So for all the things it didn't do well, I still think it deserves the five stars if only because it is real.
We try to fit God into a formula, a structure or pattern, this is how God works or God wouldn't do that and while there are certain absolutes, I do not believe in a God who is rigid and fixed and predictable. I believe He sometimes works in the unexpected, that He is not neat and tidy: that sometimes He works through ways we might find offensive, weird, deceptive, or sinful-- that sometimes He asks His people to sacrifice their son, throw themselves at the feet of a man in the middle of the night, marry a prostitute, or cook lunch over human dung. And that in all these God remains the same God from a thousand years ago, but He is never static. He continues to work in ways that surprise us and catch us off-guard.
So there.