Jeffrey A. Kottler is a professor, psychologist, author, consultant, workshop leader, keynote speaker, and social justice advocate who has spent the past 40 years working throughout the world to promote personal and professional development among professionals and marginalized groups. Jeffrey has worked as a teacher, counselor, therapist, and consultant in a variety of settings including a preschool, primary and secondary school, university, mental health center, crisis center, and corporate settings.
I was excited to read this, but the author lost me inch by inch through the book. I found it to skim too shallowly on subjects that seemed haphazardly selected for discussion. And honestly, the author's cynical and compassionless attitude really seeped through the page and turned me off. He seemed to take it for granted that everyone was as cynical as he and I was not willing to enter into that assumption with him. If you're looking for something like this but something a bit more affirming and (I think) truer to the compassion that should be the center to therapy, read Irwin Yalom's work. This is not to say that I don't think therapists are fully capable of cynicism, boredom, burn-out, loss of compassion, etc. but I wouldn't so easily leap to the conclusion that they are in the same state of mind as the author.
I've read a lot of psych books in the past 6 years but this was by far the most useful. Kottler provides the reader with an honest, raw, uncensored look at being a mental health professional. As a graduate student in Clinical Counseling I found his commentary to be at times frightening, really challenging me to reflect on the path I've chosen by confronting me with the bad and the ugly. But then there is the good! and it is so good, so uplifting and inspiring. Still challenging, but worthwhile. This book came at the perfect time in my program, a time where I was being tested by my professors and asked to answer that question "how much do you really want to be a counselor and what does that title mean to you?" Kottler's book was an indispensable part of my process of defining exactly what being a mental health professional means, in general and on a personal level.
I would highly recommend this book to anyone thinking of pursuing a career in mental health care (it is applicable to a variety of professions including social work but most of the content is specific to one-on-one sessions more indicative of counseling and psychology). If you are already on that path, even if you've been in the field for years, this is a must-read.
i read this for a class and found certain parts affirming and illuminating, and other parts simply long-winded or, worse, prone to the sort of biased behaviour the book rallies against (e.g., championing gender diversity but constantly saying "he or she" to encapsulate all of humanity). overall, i'm not sure this book was as radical or paradigm-shifting as i hoped it'd be.
There are some books that pretty much every would-be or practicing therapist ought to read during their tenure as a clinician. I believe On Being a Therapist to be one of them. Granted, there are also some books that ought to be approached with a certain measure of commitment, and Kottler's book fits with that sentiment. I've had a copy of Les Miserables sitting on my bookshelf for years now; I've promised myself that someday I'll read it, but a 1,000 page novel takes serious dedication to work through! In some ways, Kottler's book is like to Les Miserables. Granted, On Being a Therapist is only 320 pages of actual content, but it's a heavy read; I wouldn't suggest questing on it lightly!
Nevertheless, here's why I think it's worth your time. There are things a therapist deals with; questions, concerns, and burdens with which we wrestle during our training and practice. Sometimes, it's easy to think that those issues are our own, and unique from other therapist's experiences. Kottler drives home (sometimes with unnerving astuteness) the universality and homogeneity of our problems, our concerns, our issues. In some ways it was almost a disappointment to discover that I'm not so special after all. Questions of ethics, of morality, of "how in the world do I help people?" and "how can I maintain my sanity?" were all there, written exactly as I'd thought of them before, and usually more eloquently. There is an element of commiseration in On Being a Therapist that makes you feel like part of a tribe. Perhaps that is the true gift of Kottler's book. It sends the message, "You are not alone."
Kottler also does not sugarcoat who we are or what we do. At times reading the book was a bucket of ice-water on my pre-professional enthusiasm. He calls out the dark side of counseling; our narcissistic impulses, the stubborn hypocrisy in our personal versus professional lives, the intoxication of power we feel over influencing lives. He also describes with disturbing clarity the wear and tear of counseling on the therapist and other associated dangers. Sometimes while reading I wasn't sure if this book might not be intended as some kind of an informed consent document for the would-be practitioner!
All in all, On Being a Therapist is a frank discussion and dissection of the counseling profession. It's at once inspiring and tiring, because Kottler presents an un-photoshopped portrait of what we do - good, bad and ugly. I confess that as a novice therapist I want the haze and sparkle of idealism. I want unrealistic promises of change, goodness, and fairytale heroics of the heart. But let's be honest - having all of that in a book (and in real life) would cheapen what we do. Instead, Kottler offers the profession as it is: fraught with risk, but if entered with open eyes and an open heart, incredibly rewarding.
This review, and others on psychology related books, can be found on my blog: robfreund.wordpress.com
I started to read this book as it was a suggested reading for a class but unfortunately I could only make it half way though.
I think it’s important to note this anecdote mentioned in the book.
He had written a manuscript titled, Client’s From Hell, yes I will repeat that the author had a written a piece bashing his clients. And he received the following feedback from Albert Ellis, “I think Kottler has a problem because he thinks all his clients are sent from hell to make his life miserable. It seems to me he has lost his compassion”.
This then give him the a-ha moment where he realizes that he was indeed incompassionate then turn on a dime, renames his book so it now talks about how to be compassionate with difficult clients and leaves his job (because that must have been why he lost his compassion).
Reading through the book it seems that his compassion was never regained but he may of figured out how to get through the day in a career he doesn't really like. He takes a little too much joy in listing out every imaginable insult that he's said to a client and does so in a repetitive cycle.
It reminds me of the divorced middle aged man trope, "You two so young and happy, one day you'll see love's all bullshit! It's all just hormones, one day is the honeymoon and the next day she's out banging the pool boy!" And then tries to give you relationship on how to keep your relationship together.
What I got out of this is that on my path I need to find people who have the positive qualities I want and learn from them so I have the lowest possibility of becoming like the author.
Bu kitabı Elif Okan Gezmiş’in hayli temiz çevirisiyle okuma fırsatı bulduğum için şanslıyım, kavram karmaşası da yok, her şey yerli yerinde. Kottler’in bu kitabı size nasıl terapist olunacağını anlatmıyor, bu yolda yaşadığınız zorluklarda hiç de yalnız olmadığınızı çok çarpıcı örneklerle dürüstçe anlatıyor. Anlattıklarını araştırmalarla desteklemesi ve küçük öneriler vermesi de cabası. Kendinizi tükenmiş ve danışanlara yardımcı olamayacak gibi hissediyorsanız özellikle okumanızı öneririm.
I've been calling this book "supervision in a book" because Kottler touches on everything that is important and confusing and exciting about being a therapist. This is a must read for all new therapists as well as any experienced therapist who needs a reminder of why he or she became a therapist in the first place.
Kottler is so cynical to the point of being unattractive. This book did not discourage me from the profession, but I can see how it would discourage many beginning counselors trying to enter the field. Things should not be sugarcoated. But when every chapter talks about how tired he is of certain things or certain types of clients, maybe it’s time for the author to change professions instead of putting all that negativity into a book.
Edited review: what I considered “Like a hug for the aspiring therapist” at 50 pages in, became a bit of a desolate exploration into the very real and very depressing realities of being a therapist, without any tempering. In all honesty, I attempted to skim the latter half, but it honestly left me with feeling of burnout and hopelessness. Possibly not for someone struggling with their position within the therapy-scape, but not without its merits.!
This was so helpful for me. Put words to so many weird and difficult parts of this job, and gave permission to be imperfect. “What do we do with the stories we hear? How do we hold them? How do we live with them? The answer, in part, is with difficulty.”
It's in my own opinion that this book was unbalanced and favored exploring the downsides of providing therapy to the positives. Much of the book felt pessimistic, nihilistic, and like it was intent on giving a warning to stay away from the field of therapy. While it has its' good parts, and while I think much of what the author had to share and say are important, I felt it was extremely unbalanced, and was by no means what I was expecting upon reading it. I cannot say whether or not I was glad I read it. It's certainly not going to inspire enthusiasm in those studying to become therapists or those with the intention to work in the field. If anything, it leaves me questioning my decisions and struggling with the work I have done in my own therapy and the relationship with my own therapist. Valuable? Maybe. Overly pessimistic? That I am 100% sure of.
Kottler weighs the pros and cons of being a therapist, asking the curious cat to assess their own motivations, the "why" behind their interest in the profession, while he paints a realistic portrait of the trade. Like so many professions, therapists also face the perils of burnout, ego, and loss of compassion, all normal arcs in the course of the career, ones that either signal our exit from the profession or deeper insight and revelation.
An interesting read, one that periodically rambles on, On Being A Therapist sometimes seems to better reveal the author's motivations than the trade itself with a heavy emphasis on prestige and authority. Happily, the book culminates in spiritual, contemplative, and creative expression and potential as driving forces for the profession.
I'm pretty sure the intended title was On Being a Masochist.
Mr. Kottler here takes hating one's own life to the next level. He makes sure to work in a way that ensures not only he'll despise himself but also the people he sees (which mostly don't seem to think very highly of him either).
Good God I'm glad I'm coming across a crazy book such as this only now when I'm past my more suggestionable years and have accumulated a satisfactory record of helping people by being as much of a functional adult as I can and helping them do the same.
I can only hope other people, too, will read this book only after having a firm grasp on the sociology of our times and the infantilizing process of some therapeutic practices.
Me ha gustado mucho ❤️. Sobre todo porque ha verbalizado todos mis miedos, todas mis dudas, me ha hecho ver el lado más humano y bello de nuestra progresión y me ha hecho reflexionar sobre muchas cosas. De relectura asegurada 😊
This book only helped fuel my enthusiasm and excitement at the prospect of becoming a therapist. It helped me examine my motivations for wanting to become a therapist; some of which I never even realized before. Some of my motivations include Although Kottler talks about how spiritually fulfilling therapy and how it helps clients realize what was already in them all along, he does not sugarcoat the challenges that arise with being a therapist. His writing, however, did not make me feel intimidated by the prospects of severe burnout and compassion fatigue, but rather ready to take precautions and face any obstacles that arise. One of the biggest lessons I learned was how therapy is so hard to categorize and nail down precisely. Is it science, is it art, is it philosophy? Well, the answer is that it's all of those. Kottler then emphasizes the crucial role creativity plays in trying to integrate so many disciplines in a career where you face the totality of the human condition.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
NEED A HARD COPY OF THIS TO FULLY PROCESS! Loved how applicable this was and he has updated it several times to reflect current issues and things therapists run into today. Everyone could benefit from listening to track 23-24 which is all about how to get the most out of your own therapy and how to figure out of the therapist you are seeing is right for you!!
This book felt more like an outlet for Kottler to publicly examine himself, than to provide a resource for those looking to understand the profession. He owns all the best aspects of his practice, yet when it comes to the darker side of the profession and his personal struggles, he deflects ownership by including multiple examples of other therapist's behaviors that are worse than the traits he admits to. I enjoyed this window into the profession despite the litany of humble brags masquerading as vulnerability.
Many client relationship examples in the book reach beyond the therapist profession into other professions which also maintain long term client relationships. Over and over again Kottler speaks of the powers that therapists possess due to their training. It is as though he doesn't want to believe that those in other professions can be as effective or even more effective leveraging the tools of psychology to create change in the people they work with. Business consultants and teachers regularly use psychology to improve the lives and performance of others.
Kottler comes across as someone who doesn't really like people. It's more like he learned how people work through his studies, but his admitted lack of patience outside work and his frequent references to the extreme effort required to maintain hours of rapt attention tells me he doesn't really feel fulfilled by his profession on an emotional level.
This was originally required reading for a clinical class (the instructor assigned another book), but ended up being something I read for personal fun and learning. That said, On Being a Therapist is an honest and uncensored exploration of the profession. Kottler writes in an accessible and engaging style with plenty of personal anecdotes I could relate to in my own experience as both counselor and client. He begins by laying the foundation of how people get into the field and the basics of the therapeutic relationship. Then he explores personal and professional roles, how clients change their therapists, and the hardships of the profession. The following chapters cover dealing with failure, difficult clients, and boredom and burnout. The chapters covering the unsaid things about the profession and lies therapists tell were particularly enlightening and hilariously relatable. Finally the last two sections end on a more reassuring note and address self-care and creativity. Given the broad scope he covers, there are plenty of areas to revisit and consider as a professional depending on which topic may come up at a particular time. On Being a Therapist was an enjoyable and helpful read for anyone entering/working in the mental health field as well as those who are/have been clients to better understand their therapists.
I read this book out of the pure curiosity of how a therapist's mind works. Attempting also to gain insight and understanding to how a therapist could possibly be understanding and compassionate without having acceptance or tolerance of someone's actions. This is an intriguing skill to me!
Kottler's book On Being a Therapist provides insight into the mind of a therapist and tends to be focused on the negative aspects of the profession. Stressing the need for constant self-reflection and supervision.
This is the fourth edition of the book. The book was a bit repetitive and seemed to generalize Kottler's views on being a therapist, lacking in depth examples and explanations that could have created a more compelling read.
Two overbearing words come to mind when thinking about this book ~ cynical and narcissistic ~ therapists are human, struggling to maintain a professional identity.
I did not really enjoy this book. I was assigned it in a graduate school class and read the first half even though it was not assigned that way. I then followed the course and after it was over I grudgingly finished reading over a period of 3/4 of a year. This author is terribly negative and repeats himself ad infinitium. At the end of each very negative chapter he would add a page or two of positive thoughts and rebukes of his negative thinking. Although he has some positive things to say, overall I disliked this book very much.
This book had some good insights sprinkled here and there, but the overall tone was somewhat narcissistic and a little condescending at times. Kottler struck me as burned out in many places and definitely egotistical. It made for a hard read, even in audio form. I had to keep taking breaks. But the good gems here and there were worth it.
My husband and I have done pastoral care counseling/coaching for decades. While we are not licensed therapists, we spend many hours listening and trying to help men and women who express a need for support/help. Listening attentively and impartially and offering real help are not always easy. Our personal limitations show up. We get triggered by things that are said. We sometimes feel stumped about how to help. Kottler is honest about all of this which I found refreshing. (If you have never been on the other side of the couch, his vulnerable revelations might feel disconcerting.) There were a few things he shared about some clients that felt wildly inappropriate and way TMI. Had I served as his editor, I would have asked him to cut these.
It’s hard rating a book that is for academic reasons vs. for pleasure but I’ll give it a shot.
This wasn’t what I’d call a fun, easy read, it was VERY dense but I’m coming away from this book with more respect and knowledge about how difficult of a career this can be, how damaging it can be, but also how rewarding it can be. I really liked reading this both as someone in therapy as well as someone considering becoming a therapist. It gives me more of an understanding of my own therapist.
*I read the 5th edition published in 2017. As a therapist I can vouch that this book, especially the final chapter on being a client, is a must read for mental health professionals. Introspection and willingness to be challenged is something we often preach but do not take in. If you're not embracing it from your peers, embrace it first from here and digest the ideas presented. I will definitely be revisiting this book.
FINALLY finished this book. Oh my god, it was so redundant and boring. I wanted to read this because of my new career change and starting my masters, but holy shit I definitely did not need to read this. Some of it was insightful but most of it was just boring and repetitive stuff. Either way excited for my new chosen career path!