Read this to my daughter. As with most books I pick, she wasn't keen at first, but she was very into it by the end and wanted to go straight onto the next one. I haven't managed to track down the second book, so am trying to bridge the gap between the first and third by using the original version of My Place, which is a much more complex read. The simplicity and straightforwardness of this Young Reader version is really nice and direct. I'd probably give it 3 stars, as it's definitely for a Young Reader, but I think my daughter would give it 4.