Mark Twain said that lying is a universal behavior that can and should be used for good purposes. Pastor Bill Hybels of Willow Creek Church, the nation’s first megachurch, teaches that lying is wrong and Christians should eliminate the practice. So which is it, a universal behavior that can be used positively, or a regrettable violation of ethics?
Professor Robert Feldman takes a scientific approach, presenting what the research tells us about human beings and deception. It’s fair to say that the issue isn’t as black and white as Pastor Hybels would have it. Some lies are obviously destructive, designed to rip people off or to otherwise harm them. But Feldman says the evidence backs up Twain, that lying is a widespread, common and often harmless occurrence, not an act confined to cheating spouses or hardened criminals.
Why do people lie so regularly? One major reason is to build affinity.
When two people meet, they often look for what they have in common. Relationships are built by what people have in common and by agreement, not by disagreement and conflict. People build affinity by mirroring the other person's posture and by agreeing with him even if one doesn't really share the same enthusiasm. This process can involve exaggeration, emphasis and omission that presents a distorted picture of the truth.
Among the other reasons for lying are these:
* To express empathy, which is what the social situation calls for sometimes, even if we really don’t think, say, the death of a pet is a big deal.
* To grease the wheels of social discourse, not for illicit gain but to enhance communication.
* To be tactful to avoid giving offense (“those jeans don’t make you look fat.”) A great deal of deception is well-intentioned to protect our feelings.
This form of lying, which is not to cheat and manipulate, but to preserve relationships and to keep conversation going is relatively harmless, Feldman says. "Strict honesty is often directly opposed to what we consider to be standard social behavior." When they are exposed, however, white lies can weaken relationships. On the other hand, white lies can promote harmony as opposed to honestly telling others what we really think of them.
This book is full of interesting facts such as these:
* Some autistic kids seem incapable of lying; rather than being a virtue, however, it's a symptom of social difficulty.
* As with adults, kids who are good liars tend to have stronger social skills. Popular kids lie better; social confidence allows lying without showing distress. Socially skilled people are by definition tactful, polite and ingratiating -- all qualities that involve distorting or hiding one's true opinions.
* Deception might be hard-wired in our genes. Research finds that infants use fake crying or laughing to get attention. Given that animals often deceive each other and that the youngest of children lie, deception may be built into human nature.
* "Nature has selected deceit, and we see it in a vast array of plants, insects, and animals." Camouflage is a passive form of deceit used to fool predators. Many animals use deceptive behavior such as playing opossum when threatened.
* In hundreds of species of moths and butterflies, caterpillars or chrysalises display false eye and face patterns that mimic those of snakes, lizards or other animals to ward off birds.
Feldman recommends that we remain aware that everything we're told could be a lie, and that a person's manner isn't a reliable way to
gauge veracity. Since we can't verify everything, a rule of thumb is to verify those things that matter to us while not sweating the little stuff.