Un profond sommeil

by Tiffany Quay Tyson, Héloïse Esquié (Translator)

White Forest, Mississippi. Cachée au milieu de la forêt, la carrière fascine autant qu’elle inquiète. On murmure que des esprits malveillants se dissimulent dans ses eaux profondes. Par une chaude journée d’été, Roberta et Willet bravent toutes les superstitions pour aller s’y baigner avec leur petite soeur, Pansy. En quête de baies, ils s’éloignent de la carrière. Quand ils reviennent, Pansy a disparu.
Quelques années plus tard, Roberta et Willet, qui n’ont jamais renoncé à retrouver leur soeur, suivent un indice qui les mène dans le sud de la Floride. C’est là, dans les troubles profondeurs des Everglades, qu’ils espèrent trouver la réponse à toutes leurs questions.

Tiffany Quay Tyson nous entraîne dans un voyage hanté au coeur des terres américaines. Du delta du Mississippi aux mangroves des Everglades, l’histoire tourmentée d’une famille fait écho à celle de toute une région, le sud des États-Unis, peuplé d’esclaves, de prêcheurs, d’assassins, de laissés-pour-compte, de monstres et de saints.

Genres: Fiction, Mystery, Gothic, Southern Gothic, Thriller, Magical Realism, Mystery Thriller

400 pages, Paperback

First published March 6, 2018

About the author

Tiffany Quay Tyson's second novel, THE PAST IS NEVER, won the prestigious Willie Morris Award for Southern Fiction, the Janet Heidinger Kafka Prize, the Mississippi Institute of Arts and Letters Award for Fiction, and the Mississippi Author Award for Adult Fiction. It has appeared on bestseller lists in Mississippi and Colorado.

Tiffany was born and raised in Mississippi, where most of her fiction is set. Her debut novel, THREE RIVERS, was a Mississippi bestseller and a finalist for both the Mississippi Institute of Arts and Letters Fiction Award and the Colorado Book Award for Literary Fiction. She currently lives and writes in Denver. Colorado, where she serves on the faculty of Lighthouse Writers Workshop.

Reviews

[Mary Beth · Rating 4 out of 5]

On a hot summer day, Bert, Willet, and Pansy went swimming swimming in the quarry in Missippi Delta.

They were not allowed to swim there since it was known to be cursed. Their father always told them that it was evil, the devil's place. Bert and Willet wander off and when they come back, Pansy has disappeared. Not drowned, not lost... simply gone. Pansy is only 6 years old. They keep looking and hunting for her. They looked years for her. They were Pansy's brother and sister. Their mother died of a broken heart. They never gave up. Clues come to them, leading them to the remote tip of the Florida Everglades.
They think this might be the answer to Pansy's mysterious disappearance. But truth like the past is better left alone where it lies.

The Past is Never is a compelling addition to Southern Gothic fiction. I just love this genre. It deftly weaves together local legends, magical realism, and the search for Pansy. It is an atmospheric haunting story of myths, legends and the good and evil we carry in our hearts. I just loved the atmosphere of this read. It is also dark. This book was so different than I usually read, and it was really needed at the time. Some parts were really intense and heart breaking.

All the characters were very well done. I loved Bert and Willet. There mother made me so mad, because she didn't take responsibility for anything. You could really tell that she loved Pansy, the best. She always favored her more. I also loved Clementine. I really felt sorry for Bert and Willet, since they had so much guilt. Their mother just made them feel worse.

I loved the writing style, and I loved the ending. It was so touching. It was beautifully written. I didn't know what to think of it in the beginning, but it got a lot better and turned out to be an excellent read.

This was a Traveling Sister read and it was a really fun discussion.

I want to thank Edelweiss, the publisher and Tiffany Quay Tyson for the copy of this book, in exchange for an honest review.

[Angela M · Rating 4 out of 5]

4+ stars .

After I read the first few of pages, I thought maybe this was going to be a little too eerie, a little too dark, a little too suspenseful, a little out of my comfort zone. I continued reading and a few pages later I knew that I would not be able to abandon this writing. This writing that was full of emotion and beautifully descriptive. I couldn’t leave it without finding out what happened that day when Bert and Willet take their younger sister Pansy to the quarry, where the water was cool on this hot day, where they weren’t supposed to go. Something happens that changes their lives and several years later Bert wonders what she would have been like, what life would have been like if things had been different. She is on a journey to discover the truth. The book description gives a lot more details so I’m not going to do that here for fear of spoilers.

There’s evil in that quarry, and there’s prejudice in the Mississippi delta, and there’s sadness and heartbreaking losses . The prejudice is more powerful than the legends or beliefs in the curses. It’s a story of family and maybe fate. The first person narrative by Bert alternates with stories of the past . The stories that depict the legendary belief of the evil of the quarry, going back in time to the slaves who dug it. The stories go back in time to the children’s grandmother, Clementine’s past and the children she took in. One of them was the children’s father. I loved this going back in time because it eased the suspense of the present time for me a bit. The writing is phenomenal, the characters especially Bert and Clem are so well drawn. I might have given it 5 stars, but some of the ending felt a little rushed. An epigraph, of course at the beginning, but it wasn’t until I finished reading this book that I understood how perfect it was :

“The past is never dead. It’s not even past.” (William Faulkner, Requiem for a Nun)


I received an advanced copy of this book from Skyhorse Publishing through Edelweiss.

[Diane S ☔ · Rating 4 out of 5]

Southern Gothic takes us to the Mississippi Delta and a quarry said to be evil, cursed. Three siblings told to give a berth to this quarry, instead it becomes a place they regularly go to swim. Something horrible happened here in the past, bug the past is never, it is carried inside the person or inside a place that has seen the evil of man. Something terrible happens on this the three siblings last day, and changes their lives forevermore.

Fantastic characters, all terribly flawed as the most interesting characters often are the easiest in which to connect for the reader. Dark, atmospheric, descriptive, the story of what happened at the quarry years ago, and what happened at the quarry now. Some evil events can mark a person, leave its mark on a specific place. Two siblings will head out to the Everglades trying to solve the mysteries at the heart of their family. We make the connections within their family as we follow along. Totally drawn into this one. Loved the way it was written and the dark tone used to such great effect.

The closest comparison I can make between this book and others is with the author John Hart. Though this one is a bit more centered, tightly plotted. A wonderful sisters read where we all found it great.

ARC from Edelweiss.

[Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 mesmerizing, mysterious, magical stars to The Past Is Never ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️

This is a hard book to describe at first thought! I read Tiffany Quay Tyson’s debut, Three Rivers, and adored it. It was a simple book with beautiful writing and a story of family. I was thrilled when I saw she had a new book coming out.

Once again, Tyson focused on family. Three siblings, Bert, Willett, and Pansy go swimming at the forbidden local rock quarry, and one of them disappears. It’s a story of good and evil, the past and the present, and haunting myths and curses. The Mississippi Delta made for the perfect southern atmospheric setting, just as it did in Three Rivers.

I had a rough start with this book, but I’m so glad I stuck it out. After the first third, I was entranced with the characters. Overall, this book was a magical reading experience!

I read this with the Traveling Sisters, and I’m so happy that we all completely loved this book. It was the perfect book to discuss. For reviews of this book and others, please visit Brenda and Norma’s blog: https://twogirlslostinacouleereading....

The Past Is Never will be published on March 20, 2018. Thank you to Tiffany Quay Tyson, Skyhorse Publishing, and Edelweiss for the complimentary copy to review.

[Norma ~ The Sisters · Rating 5 out of 5]

Wow! So many great books that I have read since my little reading break! I loved this one and what an absolutely wonderful ending!!!

Thank you so much to Edelweiss for the opportunity to read an advanced copy of this book in exchange for a review!

[Susanne · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 Stars.

Growing up in the Mississippi Delta, siblings, Bert, Willet and Pansy, don’t have the easiest life, but they have each other. Pansy is the youngest, the favorite and is spoiled rotten. Their mom treats her like royalty and when he’s around (which isn’t often), their dad dotes on her.

They live in a place that is full of legends and is said to be cursed. Unexplainable things have happened in this place. Bad things. Is it legend, the curse, or do bad things happen to bad people?

The days are hot and humid and the only place to cool off is the quarry - and it’s forbidden. Yet Bert and Willet can’t resist and they always take Pansy along. While swimming in the quarry, they only leave her alone for a second and neither worry as Pansy is the strongest swimmer of the three. A second is all it takes. When Bert returns, Pansy is gone - she just disappeared into thin air and as the years go by, there is no sign of her. The tragedy tears the family apart, yet Bert and Willet don’t give up and will do whatever it takes to find their sister.

This novel is atmospheric, dark and eerie. It also has a beautiful, exciting and mysterious feeling to it, once that honestly I can’t describe. “The Past is Never” surprised me. I had no idea what to expect and honestly, was hesitant to read it as this was outside of my comfort zone. That said, “The Past is Never” wowed me and I loved it. From the beginning I was hooked. The characters felt so real to me, that they actually felt alive. The author, Tiffany Quay Tyson, knocked it out of the park. This was the first book that I have read by her and I can assure you, it won’t be my last. I highly recommend this to anyone who is looking for something a little different - it will take you by surprise, root inside of you, and make you feel alive too.

This was a Traveling Sister Read. It included Norma, Jennifer, Diane and Mary Beth.

Thank you to Edelweiss, Skyhouse Publishing and Tiffany Quay Tyson for an ARC of this novel in exchange for an honest review.

Published on Edelweiss and Goodreads on 2.3.18.
*Will be published on Amazon on 3.20.18.

[Theresa Alan · Rating 5 out of 5]

This is a sumptuously written novel. Told from the point of view of Bert (Roberta Lynn), she’s fourteen years old when she and her sixteen-year-old brother Willet go in search of berries, leaving their six-year-old sister Pansy swimming in the quarry. Pansy is the strongest swimmer of them all, and, even though their father has told them the quarry is cursed, it’s a brutally hot summer day, who wouldn’t want the relief of cool water to swim in?

Willet and Bert get separated in the woods, but when they return to the quarry, their sister is gone. Divers, police, and the entire town search for her, but as time passes, it seems she’s simply disappeared.

This is surprisingly a surprising gripping page-turner for a literary novel. The characters are likeable, especially Grandma Clem, who helps women with their pregnancies, even if that means helping place a child they can’t care for into the hands of a couple who can’t have children of their own. Also, helping woman who have been raped. Somehow, the powerless women in the face of men who deceive and hurt them isn’t depressing. I’m not quite sure how the author pulled that off.

Bert’s father disappeared frequently before Pansy vanished, but it used to be for weeks at a time, not years. When Pansy goes missing, so does he. Willet is convinced their father knows something about where their sister is. Bert can’t let the past go. She believes her father and her sister are still alive. She goes in search of answers, and her journey is a compelling one.

Highly recommend.

For more reviews, please visit: http://www.theresaalan.net/blog

[Cheri · Rating 4 out of 5]

!! NOW AVAILABLE !!

”Old black water, keep on rollin'
Mississippi moon, won't you keep on shinin' on me?

“Keep on shinin' your light
Gonna make everything, everything
Gonna make everything all right
And I ain't got no worries
'Cause I ain't in no hurry at all.”
-- Black Water, Doobie Brothers, lyrics by Patrick Simmons

"To understand the world, you must first understand a place like Mississippi."
- William Faulkner

The Mississippi Delta is known for many things, it is the birthplace of the Blues, it is home to many famous authors, most notably William Faulkner, Eudora Welty, as well as written works about it as in Mark Twain’s ‘Life on the Mississippi,’ and too many more to mention. Throw in the musicians… Muddy Waters, Elvis Presley, Conway Twitty, Tammy Wynette, BB King, John Lee Hooker. It’s a long list. Then there’s the architecture, the bottle trees, and yes, the food. Food so good it takes your mind off the sweltering heat and humidity. And then there’s the voodoo, the signs, the superstitions that abound here, all add an aura that is its own charm.

August of 1976 was hotter than most, the kind of sweltering heat that leaves your skin sticky with sweat, and sleep elusive. Willet was the oldest at sixteen, Roberta Lynn, who was called ‘Bert’ by everyone but her mother, was fourteen and Pansy, the youngest, was only six, but it was clear to everyone that she was the favourite.

The quarry wasn’t far from their home, a place that almost everyone referred to as “cursed.” Legends abounded about the quarry, how it was made, what lay at its bottom. Secrets best kept hidden. A place their father had always warned them about, calling it evil and saying that ”The Devil will find you there.” They’d heard all the stories about this place, but it offered the only respite from the heat that was available to them. And so, they head there not for the first time on this August day, with Pansy’s first day of school, first grade, starting soon, and their father away on business.
Pansy floats serenely on her back in the deep water, while Willet swings off ropes with wild splashes until hunger hits, and he grabs Bert and takes her with him to pick some brambleberries, telling Pansy they’d be right back.

By the time Bert returns, Pansy is gone.

They now have to confront a life of not knowing, absolutely, what became of Pansy. Their life lived outside the margins already flawed, begins to show signs of, cracking, crumbling underneath the pressure.

Southern gothic literature is typically a bit gloomy, strange, and always atmospheric. This has all of those elements, plus a very compelling story, a dash of tension and a sense of mystery that slowly unravels.

A new author for me, but I understand she has a debut novel which I missed, which gives me something new, to me, to look forward to reading.


Pub Date: 20 Mar 2018

Many thanks for the ARC provided by Skyhorse Publishing

[Beverly · Rating 3 out of 5]

At times, reading this, I thought this person is too fantastic to be believed. One of the secondary characters is Fern, a girl who grew up in the south in the 1950s who doesn't understand why she might encounter some trouble for dating an African-American. What the...!? I grew up in the south in the 1970s and there was plenty of racism even then.

Aside from that, this is a good coming-of-age novel, taking place in the 1970s in Mississippi and Florida, with an outstanding main character in Bert. Bert is a tomboy with a beloved older brother and a cherished baby sister, Pansy. Pansy goes missing. The disappearance happens at the beginning of the book, so it's not a spoiler. Bert's whole life revolves around the mystery of her missing sister.

As she grows up, Bert and her brother Willet try to deal with the worst moment of their lives and find themselves discovering more questions than answers.The almost satisfying ending helps make the journey worthwhile.

[Marialyce · Rating 4 out of 5]

4+ to a "quite a story" story!

This was a fascinating tale of family and the concept that family does not always mean blood. This tale brought together many characters chief among them were: Bert, Willet, and Pansy. The children, as well as their parents, were attracted to an old rock quarry where legends, folktales, and Gothic fiction seem to abide. The children in an attempt to cool off on a hot Mississippi summer's day head off to the woods and then to the quarry which contains a pool of collected water. They have been warned to stay away, this quarry is the devil's ground, but they decide much like children always seem to do, that what is forbidden makes for an attractive, irresistible lure. And so they go and by day's end, Pansy is missing, when Willet and Bert wander away while Pansy is swimming in the collected water.

What ensues is the search for Pansy and as the story is portrayed the children's family both now and in the past is told. Their father has disappeared a while back and the two remaining siblings, police, and volunteers search for Pansy. Where could she have gone? How can someone disappear without a trace?

Years go by but the guilt never leaves as both Willet and Bert continue to believe in their hearts that Pansy is alive. They grow, lose their mother to a broken heart and eventually wind up in Florida in the Everglades searching yet for the lost sister.

The Past Is Never is a true Gothic tale. It has all the elements which make it a scary yet realistic read, one that provides the reader with much in the way of secrets, myths, ad legends. It is also a story of family and the love that is often given by those not related by blood but by the human bond of acceptance and love. "We must take care of our families wherever we find them." (Elizabeth Gilbert) The finding of family and being family is the ultimate goal of who we are.

Thank you to Tiffany Quay Tyson, Skyhorse Publishing, and Edelweiss for making available an advanced copy of the tragic tale.

[Sadie Hartmann · Rating 4 out of 5]

My goodness.
I have a lot of thoughts and feelings about this harrowing coming-of-age story. The way little vignettes of history are nestled into the folds of a rich family saga.
Recommended for readers who enjoy
-Gritty Southern Gothic storytelling
-Coming-of-age/siblings (brother & sister)
-Cursed land/families
-Missing/kidnapped child
-Vigilante family justice
-Bleak, sad small towns
-Magical realism/Folk healers/midwives/herbalists
-Family sagas/relationships
-Strong female protagonists

Content Warnings
-pregnancy/motherhood
-abortions
-SA
-racial tensions and violence
-infanticide
-graphic assault
I skimmed over a few difficult parts so there might be more

Comps: Reminded me a lot of Betty, The Devil All the Time, and The Bottoms

[Sonja Arlow · Rating 3 out of 5]

I really loved the beginning of this story. Three siblings swim in a flooded quarry they are not supposed to be at, and when the youngest disappears this destroys the fragile threads of the family forever.

I loved the historic stories showing what happened in each generation around this quarry and its rumoured curse.

Its when the story moved away, with the road trip to find out what happened to the father, I slowly started losing interest.

I have had shorter and shorter reviews since 2020 and there was nothing in this story that gave me the desire to write something more detailed.

I have always struggled with gothic novels. I always think I will enjoy it and never do. Many others have loved it so if you like this sub-genre you may want to consider this tale.

[Petra · Rating 5 out of 5]

This was a good story of family secrets, family bonds, family past, present and future. It's told in an atmospheric, dark, tension-filled manner.
Six-year old Pansy goes missing without a trace after a swim in the quarry on a blistering hot summer day. Her 2 siblings are left with questions, fears and confusion that don't get answered. Five years later, they go in search of the truth.
Two time-lines always coming closer together give us history and truths.
The characters are all flawed and likeable. None are bad, yet all make choices that take them to the outskirts of "good" society. I particularly liked Grandma Clem.
This was a very good read. I really enjoyed this.

[The Girl with the Sagittarius Tattoo · Rating 3 out of 5]

Is that a great cover image, or what? I was able to snuggle up with this approachable Southern Gothic novel and finish it in a single day.

Set in rural Mississippi in 1976, three siblings are growing up in the shadows of poverty, dark history and superstition. Their father is a counterfeiter, gone for weeks at a time to distribute his "artwork." Their grandmother is an herbalist and healer - a couple centuries ago she would've been called a witch. She always has a steady stream of visitors (a lot of them girls in trouble) since the closest medical clinic is several towns away.

Nearby there's an old quarry haunted by something evil, and everybody knows not to go near the place. But on an air-conditionless summer day, few things seem more inviting than a swim. Teenagers Willet and Bert, along with their 6yo sister Pansy, sneak off for a dip. Pansy's a strong swimmer, so the older kids go to pick berries at a spot just out of sight. The teens return to find Pansy missing. After the townsfolk comb the woods and the police and newspeople stop coming, two things remain: Pansy is still gone, and nobody can find their father. Willet and Bert never quite get over all the things they lost in that single, fateful day.

The Past is Never is a solid Southern Gothic with a very approachable, straightforward writing style. My only real hangup is all the flashbacks on the place's history. In audiobook format, it wasn't clear when the timeline was transitioning between the present to the past, so I frequently found myself skipping back a bit to figure it out.

Honestly, I bitch about multiple timelines a lot. It might just be me.

SG is not everybody's cuppa - there's usually very little resolution by the time the book is finished - but the payoff is the atmosphere and the emotive, family-rich exploration of a generally overlooked population: poor white southerners. If you're curious about this genre, you can do worse than this novel.

[Bridget Vollmer · Rating 5 out of 5]

4 1/2 heartbreaking stars. I really don’t know what to say about this book. It was so sad yet so beautiful. I really wanted a different ending but the ending was strangely perfect. I felt so connected to Bert and Willet’s story....the prose was beautiful. I really loved this story, it’s a perfect example of Southern gothic done right. I’m done rambling....just read the book.

[Kirsten Mattingly · Rating 4 out of 5]

This Northerner really liked this Southern Gothic tale. I finished it earlier today and I have already sent texts recommending it to three people I know. I will be thinking about this book for a long time to come.

I listened to the book on Audible and thought the narration was very good. The narrator’s southern accent sounded natural.

Half the book takes place in the Florida Everglades and that made it more special to me since I have spent quite a bit of time there and recognized the landmarks such as Smallwood Store, and know some of the history such as the federal raid on drug dealers.

This novel reminds me of The Little Friend by Donna Tartt because of the rural southern setting and the plot. In that book, a young boy is murdered and the family falls completely apart in the aftermath. Here, a young girl goes missing and the family totally disintegrates.

Parts of The Past is Never were slow and I felt a little bored by the repetitive scenes, such as Mama lying in bed chain smoking and drinking sweet tea. Overall I was engaged and invested in the characters and their fate.

[Donna Everhart · Rating 4 out of 5]

A solid southern story with magical realism sprinkled through.

[Ann · Rating 5 out of 5]

Terrific Southern Gothic. You just cannot go wrong with any of the books that have won the Willie Morris Award for Southern Fiction.

[Tammy · Rating 5 out of 5]

If you’re looking for a dark and sleepy, highly atmospheric, southern gothic story centering on myth and mystery, look no further. I waited too long to read it. 5 stars

[Rachel (Into a Story) · Rating 5 out of 5]

4.5 Stars

This was such an engaging, haunting and atmospheric story.

There were supernatural elements...from ghosts to monsters to aliens, but in the end, it was about race and sacrifice, and what it means to be a family.

Some of the characters were infuriating and made outrageous decisions, but you still kind of understood where they were coming from. I felt angry at most of them because...how could you do those things to the people you loved?

I got the deep sense of injustice and powerlessness that so many women and minorities must have felt back then, and still continue to feel. It hurt.

I liked the writing but sometimes it was too repetitive. And the story was a bit predictable, and often frustrating, but it was also heartbreaking and beautiful.

Sometimes I have less to say about books I really liked. I don’t know why.

Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this.

[Pat · Rating 4 out of 5]

Dark and atmospheric. Different. A bit haunting and an enjoyable read.

[Laura · Rating 3 out of 5]

Strong finish. It took some time to get there.

[Eadle · Rating 4 out of 5]

4,75 stars

Those tenets of Southern Gothic resonate throughout this tale of family, loss and an unrelenting search for truth amid shrouds of buried secrets and longtime deception. I listened to the audiobook and frankly, I wish I had been able to read rather than listen. The poetry within the prose is well-worth savoring. The narrator is adequate—adequate plus—but the story would have been enhanced if someone had been able to do for it what Sissy Spacek did for TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD. Devon Sorvari is not bad at all. Had the quality of the voice-acting match the excellence of the writing, the overall listening experience would catapult to a whole new level.

From the Mississippi delta to the daunting beauty of the Florida Everglades, THE PAST NEVER exudes the dark, atmospheric sense of place you expect in this genre. It captures beyond the physical landscape. The author’s lens is also affixed on the people and the culture that give the South its perpetual identity, for better or worse. The “worse” parts in the stories are disturbing and haunting.

You’ll be on the side of our protagonist, Roberta Lynn, “Bert,” the middle child in a grossly dysfunctional family. She and her older brother, Willet, are allies in coping with and surviving the odd, troubling family dynamic. Their father is a frequently absent counterfeiter, although he maintains his role as a reliable provider. The character of the flaky mother deteriorates over the context of the novel. Her strangeness is revealed from the beginning as she blatantly, without apology, prefers the youngest child, Pansy, whose sudden, unexplainable disappearance is the catalyst of the story. The flawed characters, the “grotesques” anticipated in the Southern Gothic abound in THE PAST IS NEVER, and strongly contribute to its rich authenticity. Granny Clem is perhaps the most memorable.

Exceptional writing, the capture of setting and its people, this novel is lacking in nothing. It’s many damn good stories within a damn good story—multi-generational, mysterious, secretive, suspenseful and tragic, the bonds of family are really at the heart. Another strength is the knowledge subtly imparted of midwifery, holistic healing, the Everglades, kayaking and of course the history, beliefs and culture of the South itself. (I’ve found some authors lose themselves in research and a work of fiction reads like an info dump. Anyone else run across that?)

I’m withholding the illustrious fifth star due to the weakness of the audiobook, however small it is. It particularly robs Bert whose character could have been much more dynamic. I heartily recommend this book, especially for, but not limited to, fans of the Southern Gothic. Even though it is not a new title, it would still make an excellent selection for a book club. There is so much to discuss!

[Susann Cokal · Rating 5 out of 5]

Favorite read of 2023 (so far). Perfectly layered with a big-pay-off ending.

[Frankie Ness · Rating 3 out of 5]

I have a thing for motives and endings when it comes to plot drivers. I appreciate a good mystery & would chase it til the last page given that it SHOULD make sense in the end. Though I love some parts of of this book, I dislike the ending because it felt shallow and, IMHO, didn’t justify the hardships Willet & Bert went through. I’ve gotten invested not just in this siblings’ quest to find the truth, but also rooted for them hoping all the heartaches will be worth something in the end. Needless to say, I’m unhappy with how it all got resolved.

That said, I love the made-up folklores, it’s steeped in heartache and injustice eventually Nature will right itself by demanding the consequent pound of flesh to even up the score. The storytelling style is very engaging and definitely enthralling, alternating between present and past to make sense of the current situation as well as somewhat explain what led to the tragic disappearance of Pansy. I got a good sense of not just the small town of White Forest, Mississippi and it’s prejudiced townsfolk, but what it must be like living in the town as an outcast.

And for all it’s sympathetic slants, I wish THE PAST IS NEVER had a different ending. It doesn’t have to be a storybook one, just something that would not only give closure to Willet & Bert, but something that would give them comfort that all their pain and misery were for some higher purpose and not just another story about worthless parents who didn’t deserve to have kids like Willet & Bert.

[Sandy · Rating 2 out of 5]

J'ai été attirée par la couverture, le titre énigmatique et le résumé, qui laissait supposer la recherche d'une sœur portée disparue depuis longtemps.
J'étais intriguée par cette histoire, la Floride, les marais, la disparition, le mystère. Mais je n'ai pas trouvé que je pensais trouver dans ce roman.
Si une disparition a bien lieu, la recherche évoquée sur la quatrième de couverture se fait attendre plus de la moitié du roman. Le rythme est lent, très lent parfois, et une double temporalité se met en place sans qu'on comprenne où elle nous mène.
J'ai apprécié certains passages et certains revirements de situation, mais j'ai globalement trouvé le temps long durant cette lecture. J'avais hâte qu'on arrive au dénouement, qui ne m'a pas vraiment plu. Dénouement insatisfaisant et incomplet à mon goût, alors qu'il était très attendu.
Bref, une lecture qui s'écoute, que j'ai hésité à abandonner et qui ne me marquera pas.

[Sandy Holz · Rating 3 out of 5]

3 stars; liked, not loved. Reminded me of very much of CRAWDADS; the swamp, south, great local color. Middle part lagged; confusing intertwined stories, but they came together. Glad I persevered.

[Kim Lockhart · Rating 4 out of 5]

Wow! This is an addictive narrative from an author who will only continue to improve. Her talent for storytelling is obvious. I had chills by the end. I can't wait to see what she writes next.

[Mark Westmoreland · Rating 5 out of 5]

THE PAST IS NEVER is an instant classic piece of Southern Gothic fiction. It’s the first book in a long time that genuinely caught me off guard and I will be returning to it for reread after reread.

[Pauline]

Petite overdose du genre donc pas un grand coup de coeur, mais je n'ai pas manqué d'être émue quand même.