It was like the plot of a movie, and here I was in the starring role, unable to connect the dots. I imagined there'd be thousands of people shouting at the screen at my stupidity. I couldn't sleuth my way out of a paper bag.
No, Sophie, you could not. And you are stupid. Honestly. so many times, you should have called the police. Or, at the end when the detective is on the way, wait for him instead of going off on your own?
This storyline had potential, but there was a lot of repetition and filler. Example-- there was a whole paragraph about Robin shoplifting in the 1997 storyline, and how her friends did not like it when she did it while they were with her. Then, in the 2018 storyline, when Robin mentions getting in trouble at age 19 for shoplifting, the author makes sure to explain to us that Robin used to shoplift, and it made her friends nervous. We already knew that.
I kept waiting for this to get dark and suspenseful, but despite all the scary things that the (very obvious) villain was doing, it never got there. I just knew so early on what the truth about that night was, who the stalker was, and why they were doing the things they were doing.