If Tomorrow Doesn’t Come centres on Avery, a queer teen who is in love with her best friend, Cass. On the morning that Avery plans to jump into the river by her college campus, she receives a call from Cass, notifying her of an asteroid heading towards Earth. With nine days left before impact, Avery decides to head home to spend her last days with her family.
Although it is billed as an apocalyptic romance, the impending asteroid set to wipe them out was more a backdrop than a valid source of conflict. I understand that the real story was for Avery to realise that life is worth living, and essentially make peace with her mental health, but to have the threat of annihilation barely come into play during the book felt so bizarre. A lot of issues came up BECAUSE of it, but the lack of terror regarding their situation was confusing to me. The majority of conflicts were interpersonal or due to Avery’s insecurities, which I found quite repetitive and dull when in the shadow of such a huge impending event.
Avery’s perspective is shaped by her mental health, so a lot of what she says is meant to be unreasonable and inconsequential, but to her it’s the biggest thing in her life. The idea of having a failing grade and being kicked off her soccer team, as a teen, IS the end of the world, and they definitely make you feel the way that Avery felt. I think this accumulation of events leading to her declining mental health are portrayed very well, and make a lot of sense. What I found frustrating was that they continued to be used a source of tension when there is a week left before they all potentially die. Surely that can’t be the most pressing thing on your mind? As we are in Avery’s perspective for the entire book, it becomes a little difficult to sympathise with her, especially when almost every other character is being prevented from being with family during the end of the world, including her roommate, Aisha, whose family are literally 5,000 miles away. I could empathise for the first half, but when it’s close to 400 pages of catastrophising, it becomes a lot.
One of the main issues I had with this was the inconsistency surrounding the apocalyptic landscape. When they first leave the college, it is a horror show with people abandoning cars, being beat up on the side of the road, and being near impossible to travel anywhere, but within a couple of days, Cass was able to drive to New York and back (and put on a fashion show?), and then on to the college where Avery had easily gotten back to with no issues. As well, the constant talk of the outside being too dangerous, yet the girls go to a house party, take a toddler sledding on their own without supervision, and go scavenging through people’s houses? It drove me crazy, honestly. To follow it with an armed robbery (!!!), and then have two teenage girls show up to the robbers’ house with baseball bats and sewing needles (?) to try and get their stuff back… idk man.
Following this, the armed robber was Avery’s prom date who just felt so unbelievably cartoonish, like a complete caricature of a mean, entitled villain. Considering he is the only antagonist throughout the entire book, I feel like he could have been fleshed out more to make him feel more threatening, rather than just being some guy.
The romance side was… fine. I didn’t particularly care about Cass or Avery as characters, and I felt that there was a lot of telling rather than showing when it came to their pining. I appreciated that they began as friends, and there was a rich love between them that would only get richer, but I felt like there wasn’t a lot of fleshing out either relationship to begin with, so we just know that they are friends, but we don’t know why.
I think this book has solidified to me that I can no longer read young adult books that aren’t rereads from my young adult life (this was made extremely clear to me when they referred to Bend It Like Beckham as an ‘old’ movie, and that Avery wasn’t even born in 2002 when it came out). Maybe I just can’t relate to the writing style, and that’s fine. I loved the lesbian representation, and how the word is used openly and freely, rather then being hidden behind ‘safer’ vocabulary, and I think the portrayal of mental health is positive. This is 2⭐️ for me, but I can understand why people like it.