ISBN 1439100020 – In all fairness, I have to admit upfront that I dislike Tavis Smiley with a passion. That isn’t nice and maybe isn’t fair, but it’s reality and I don’t mention it to bash the man, but to inform anyone who reads this review, just in case my feelings have inadvertently impacted my review.
Personal stories are centered around major issues of our time, from health care to the environment and everything in between. At the end of each chapter, there is a checklist of questions.
The content is timely, certainly. The personal stories are often close to home. The problems I have with the books are twofold. The first is that the style and what the book (inadvertently, perhaps) suggests is that you’re an idiot. It would make an excellent tool for an eighth or ninth grade civics class, but it doesn’t bring much to the table for a reasonably aware, and reasonably educated, adult. Interestingly, the book had the potential for a long, healthy shelf-life, but that was killed by the almost too-timeliness of it; in a very short period of time, the contents will be so dated as to be utterly useless other than as a historical record (a purpose already well-filled by the internet).
My second issue is with the author, though not on a personal level. I find that it strikes me as questionable that Smiley, whose first two books in this “series” were aimed strictly at a black readership, suddenly has an interest in communicating with a broader audience. While I can’t prove that it means anything, Smiley has been involved in at least two instances in the past few years that might have turned a portion of the black population against him. Perhaps this is a factor in the abrupt attempt to broaden his audience. Whatever the reason, I can’t help thinking that there’s more to this than the apparent “we’re all in this together” idea that Smiley puts forth and that I’m just not buying from a guy whose career, to this point, has been all about speaking to a single race.
- AnnaLovesBooks