A dead body is found floating in a lake. A child's drawing places her at the crime scene. The shocking connection lands her in deep water.
For fans of Clue, Nancy Drew, and small-town cozy mysteries!
Advice columnist Olivia Penn’s cozy hometown of Apple Station, Virginia, is buzzing with preparations for the annual fall festival and Halloween parade. Pumpkins, witches, and ghosts line the streets, the leaves are turning, and the crisp autumn air makes for perfect sweater weather. With a new romance blooming, the season feels more charming than spooky—until a lakeside picnic with a friend puts her in the wrong place at the wrong time.
When a body is discovered amid an algae bloom under mysterious circumstances, long-standing tensions between a local organic farm and a country club resurface, revealing multiple motives for murder. As suspects point fingers, the only reliable witness is a young boy with autism who doesn’t speak.
As Olivia investigates why the child has linked her to the crime scene, she uncovers a crucial clue hiding in plain sight. But when an unexpected encounter leads to a startling revelation, she must improvise a risky plan to stop the killer. With time running out, justice hinges on quick thinking and a leap of faith.
Can Olivia unmask the killer before the evidence vanishes? Or will she become the next victim and be silenced forever?
Silence Says the Most is the gripping second installment in the award-winning Olivia Penn Mystery Series. This fast-paced, heartwarming cozy mystery features charming characters, small-town intrigue, and a heroine you’ll love to root for. Perfect for fans of amateur sleuths, strong female leads, and feel-good mysteries.
Dive into the enchanting world of Apple Station, where a clever sleuth is always on the case. Your next unputdownable cozy mystery awaits! Read today!
Kathleen Bailey is the award-winning author of The Olivia Penn Mystery Series and The Wren Meadows Mystery Series. She writes atmospheric mysteries with heart and humor that keep to the traditional and cozy sides of crime. For over twenty years, she worked as a pediatric physical therapist with children who have special needs, drawing on degrees in English, psychology, and physical therapy. She now writes in Virginia with her feline assistant, who insists on supervising every draft. When she’s not writing, Kathleen can usually be found covered in cat hair, surrounded by far too many sticky notes, and plotting new twists to keep readers guessing. She is a member of Sisters in Crime. Visit her online at kathleenbaileyauthor.com.
Full of unexpected twists and lots of heart, Silence Says the Most by Kathleen Bailey will keep you turning the pages!
There’s something about fall that lends itself to cozy mysteries, and especially at Halloween. As that aforementioned spooky holiday approaches, Apple Station is preparing for its big fall festival and Olivia is enjoying the season. At least she is until she stumbles on a body and opens a can of worms she didn’t see coming. Before this case is solved, she’ll take some unplanned swims, dodge venomous snakes, get lost in a corn maze, and end up in the slammer… all for wont of a dog’s lost (read: favorite) ball. It took me – and Olivia – a bit to get fully interested in this case but once she did, I did too. I loved the unpredictable twists and clever distractions that ultimately led to figuring out the culprit, and it’s always a win in my book (given how many mysteries I have read & watched in my 45 years) when a mystery surprises me. Silence Says the Most did that, and more!
Bottom Line: All the things that charmed me in this series’s first book also charmed me in Silence Says the Most – Olivia, her father, their beagle puppy Buddy, Olivia’s various long-time friends, and (particularly) Floyd and Dorothy. The mystery was, once again, cleverly done and utilized some unique elements that intrigued me. If you haven’t already met the book’s protagonist, you will easily embrace Olivia and be rooting for her all the way through this Halloween read. The author’s warm & witty writing voice extends to Olivia’s character, too, and the plot is nicely layered. I was a bit disappointed at the mostly-lack of romance in this one, but there are still hints of its potential for the future. Another delightful visit to Apple Station, Virginia – already looking forward to the next!
(I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book)
Silence Says the Most Earns 5/5 Algae Blooms…Clever & Engaging!
Olivia Penn and her friend A.J. are enjoying enjoy a lunch picnic by Lake Crystal, but an unexpected algae bloom has spread a noxious odor, so heading out seems necessary. But, Buddy, Olivia’s dad’s beagle, wants just one more game of fetch. Olivia’s curiosity blooms seeing a man from Virginia Department of Environmental Quality checking the lake and is worried seeing an unaccompanied young boy, later known as Mikey, all alone in the woods. Boom! The gunshot is a disturbing surprise. Jason Rotterdam, who also lives nearby, is know for a bit of poaching, but a possible rabid raccoon looks to have been today’s target.
Time to head home, but Buddy’s red ball is missing, and if she and her dad expect Buddy to settle down, the ball needs to be found. A needle in a haystack search, but Olivia agrees to head back to the lake to get Buddy’s favorite toy. But, the red ball is not all she finds…there’s a body in the water next to the dock.
Kathleen Bailey’s second book in her Olivia Penn Mystery is blooming good with another engaging, complex mystery along with weaving in environmental issues, organic farming, and development projects all wrapped up in a corn maze, costumes, and lots of Halloween fun. Olivia is an advice columnist for a major newspaper group, but she’s pressured by the local paper’s editor to get the scoop on the murder, even if she’s considered a target herself. Hidden agendas. Past connections. Greed. It all culminates in a nail-biting fight to survive.
Kathleen Bailey’s writing style is very entertaining with sensory-laden description of the environment, Halloween festivities, characters, and mood, and her banter illustrates well the emotional connections and multi generational personalities. The characters are realistic, several admirable: a troubled vet, a single mother, a special needs child. It was a compelling idea to include an autistic boy whose non-verbal skills posed a unique obstacle in the investigation, and Liv’s nosing around has Detective Preston in conflict with his superior. There continues to be an air of something between Olivia and Preston as they dance around their interest for each other, and if Preston’s mother has anything to say, it’ll all turn out. But Daniel, the ex, is texting giving Olivia an opportunity to compare, contrast, and make a decision about what she really wants in life. Complex mystery. Diverse characters. A nice bit of romance. A favorite in my book!
Disclosure: I received an ARC from the author. My review is voluntary with honest insights and comments.
I don’t know what it is about fall but I love curling up with a good cozy mystery and Silence Says the Most has been my favorite so far this season!
First off, the cover is absolutely breathtaking, the coloring are some of my most favorite colors, which endeared me to this novel before I even read a word. It didn’t take long for me to become eve more charmed by Olivia Penn and this very character driven tale.
No matter what Olivia does she always seems to find herself in the wrong place at the wrong time. What starts out as an innocent lunch with a childhood friend turns into a murder mystery that leads Olivia down a rabbit hole of deceit and deception. This is the first book I’ve read in the series, but it was easily read as a standalone, as the author does a great job of including the main parts of the first book, so you never feel lost.
The Gilmore Girls feel wafts off the pages like a fresh cup of coffee, giving warm fall vibes that made me want to snuggle up with a nice, warm blanket and a hot cup of pumpkin spice latte. It has all the charming townspeople, the community events, and even has a part with a corn maze! I loved it!!
One aspect of the story I really appreciated was an autistic child, which added another dimension to this story. I myself have an autistic son that is high functioning and could relate to many of the boys special needs as well as some of the challenges that go along with having autism. I also loved the chemistry between Olivia and Preston, the handsome police officer. It’s obvious there is something there and I hope to see this relationship blossom in the future.
Overall this was a quick and charming read that really hit the spot. It was nice getting to know Olivia and her small town. It was great gathering clues with her, and getting lost in this cozy fall mystery.
*I have voluntarily reviewed a copy of this book which I received from the author/publisher through BookSirens. All views and opinions expressed are completely honest, and my own.
You've heard the old saying "You can never judge a book by its cover", but in this case, I chose to read this book BECAUSE of its cover. It called to me and demanded that I read it to find out more about the cover. It's a gorgeous cover - autumn trees, a body of water and a dock.
The cover art did not disappoint me for what was between the covers of the book. As you may have already guessed, the storyline takes place in autumn making it the perfect read for now. It starts out being captivating from the get-go and for me, the story line held my interest all the way through. I could use the cliché stating it was full of twists and turns, but I won't since one would expect a good mystery to have that as well as all the red herrings.
The storyline was very interesting and there were times I became quite concerned for the main character, Olivia. She's a likeable character that doesn't always make the best decisions (but then who does?) and her normal job has influenced her to not be as careful as she should be.
I love the whole storyline - the involvement of interesting side characters, beautiful park/forest and interesting small town living. Everything here made this the perfect cozy to read - especially at this time of the year.
I so want to tell you more about the story and what happened and wow! - I never saw that coming. I want to tell you more about the boy, his mom, the quite interesting neighbor, and... but I won't. You really need to pick up a copy of this captivating book and read it yourself!
Silence Says the Most by Kathleen Bailey is the second book in the Olivia Penn Mystery series. Though I didn’t read Where the Light Shines Through, the first book in the series, I could easily pick up on the important things that I missed as well as get to know the characters. I do like to read books in order, but I appreciate it when the author allows readers to jump right in no matter which book they start with.
Olivia is still back home in Apple Station, VA located in the beautiful Shenandoah Valley. She writes a syndicated advice column, and she’s been writing remotely since returning home for a visit six months ago. Circumstances from book one have kept her in Apple Station, and since reconnecting with her friends and spending time with her day, she’s not sure that she wants to leave. When she finds a dead body, she gets caught up in the case.
I really enjoyed Silence Says the Most. I feel like I got to know Olivia well. Her friends and the supporting characters in the book are well-written, and I felt like her dad and friends became more real to me as the book progressed.
The author uses descriptive language which makes you feel as if you’re in the wooded park with the lake and in the small town participating in their activities. The small town setting makes the book feel more cozy.
I enjoyed gathering clues and making a suspect list along with Olivia. I must admit that I waffled back and forth when it came to which character I thought was guilty.
If you’re a fan of small town cozy mystery books with a strong female protagonist, I think you’ll enjoy Silence Says the Most just like I did!
I received a complimentary copy of the book and am reviewing it voluntarily.
I absolutely loved this mystery!!!! This is the first book that I've read by this author, but it will not be the last. I received an ARC of this book and here is my voluntary review. The author is definitely one talented writer! She describes in detail to the point that you feel like you are in the book. It is also very clear that this author has a great editing team, as I found no errors in this book, which is beyond refreshing!!!!
I loved the characters in this book, and the mystery had me fooled until near the end. I love how she explained how all of the puzzle pieces fit in order to catch the killer. I also really enjoyed reading the acknowledgments in the back of the book which always gives one insight into the real person behind the authors name.
I enjoyed this book so much that I went and purchased the first book in the series so I could get a better understanding of the MC and her history. And I'm eagerly awaiting the next in the series!!!!
Silence Says the Most is Book 2 in an Olivia Penn Mystery by Kathleen Bailey. Olivia and her puppy Buddy are having lunch with their friend, AJ. This peaceful beginning at the dock will soon lead to the discovery of a murdered man. I am enjoying this cozy series. Olivia and her friends are good characters and I think that the murder and the why was well written and interesting. I found that I didn't want to put the book down but just kept reading to see what happened next. I am looking forward to reading the next book in the series. I received an arc for free and am leaving my review voluntarily.
Advice columnist Olivia finds herself, once again, involved in a murder mystery. This time drawing on environmental sciences, a special needs child, and death. These are so well written, and plotted that the story speeds by holding you captive. Our heroine, Olivia, is a strong, morally guided character, and one highly likable. Her friends and support network help round out the atmosphere.
Olivia is having a normal day, lunch with a friend and time with her dad's dog. Then a dead body changes everything. This is a mix between a cozy mystery and a police procedural and I really enjoyed how it was written. The characters have depth and the town sound wonderful. This was my first Olivia book but won't be the last.
This has easily become one of my favorite Cozy mystery series. This is even better than the first one, both in terms of the mystery and the character development.
It amazes me when an author can create such compelling and believable characters. I truly want to know what they are up to, and what they will do next.
Picked it up because of the cover And I like a good mystery Stepping into book 2 without reading book one still easy to know what was going on and it wrapped up quite easily at the end
I’m such a fan of the Olivia Penn Mysteries by Kathleen Bailey. Set around Halloween, book two, Silence Says the Most, was such a fun read to pick up during the actual week of Halloween.
Olivia is enjoying all the fall festivities in her cozy hometown of Apple Station, Virginia, that is until a lakeside picnic with a friend places Olivia in the wrong place at the wrong time–a dead body is found amid an algae bloom and the other reliable witness is a child who doesn’t speak.
Once again, Kathleen has penned a page-turning mystery brimming with cozy details and murder suspects! I enjoy all the details of the town, especially all the seasonal details. I did not guess the suspect ahead of time, although I enjoyed piecing the clues together with Olivia. Her journalist brain makes her one talented sleuth.
Looking forward to continuing to read more in this series!