What do you think?
Rate this book
Roja
Desde los cuatro años, Bisou Martel vive en casa de su abuela Mémé, sin molestar a nadie. Una noche de luna llena, se encuentra corriendo entre los árboles para salvar su vida, con una furia de garras y dientes que la persigue. Un lobo ataca. Bisou se defiende. Y junto a la luna nacen preguntas. Preguntas sobre la sangre: la que mancha el pasado de su familia y la que corre por sus manos mientras se arrastra para llegar a casa, sobre chicos violentos, sobre chicas en el bosque...
Una historia oscura, apasionante y empapada de sangre, acerca de las amenazas al poder femenino y el viaje de una joven para recuperarlo.
Una historia oscura, apasionante y empapada de sangre, acerca de las amenazas al poder femenino y el viaje de una joven para recuperarlo.
336 pages, Paperback
First published February 25, 2020
175 people are currently reading
16756 people want to read
About the author
Elana K. Arnold
42 books1,076 followersELANA K. ARNOLD writes books for and about children and teens. She holds a master’s degree in Creative Writing/Fiction from the University of California, Davis where she has taught Creative Writing and Adolescent Literature. Her most recent YA novel, DAMSEL, is a Printz Honor book, Her 2017 novel, WHAT GIRLS ARE MADE OF, was a finalist for the National Book Award, and her middle grade novel, A BOY CALLED BAT, is a Junior Library Guild Selection. A parent and educator living in Huntington Beach, California, Elana is a frequent speaker at schools, libraries, and writers’ conferences. Currently, Elana is the caretaker of seven pets, only three of which have fur. Sign up for her newsletter here: https://elanakarnold.us10.list-manage...
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 993 reviews
October 28, 2023
There are some things, after you finish a book, that are difficult to parse out immediately and set themselves straight only later, with enough distance from the page. Like removing a pair of smudged-up glasses that are fuzzing up the view.
Red Hood troubled me for days, sittig uneasily inside my mind. And here’s, I think, the reason why: the view of feminism that we get from Red Hood is reductive at best, and dangerous at worst.
Arnauld’s novel takes on some heavy themes—toxic masculinity, sexual assault, and female empowerment—to rework the Red Riding Hood fairytale in the service of poetic revenge. But that premise quickly withers on the page, fails to thrive and bear fruit, and it isn’t long before the novel leaps a chasm into genuinely preposterous territory. What one finds on the other side is a book stuffed with relentless, far-fetched plotting, thought experiments masquerading as characters, and an ending that packs some seriously disturbing implications.
The novel’s consoling message, emerging in the slaughter-numbed blankness of the book’s final pages, is that the answer to patriarchal violence is just more violence. This is how Red Hood winds up betraying itself in the end: for a novel that begins with a clarion call for accountability, a battle cry for “girls like us” who are fighting back to dismantle the system, the endings is a shallow victory. At some point, Arnold gives up interrogating the motivations of the characters to do right, gives up examining their tendency to rationalize their worst ideas without fully understanding the possibility of disaster, gives up engaging with how mouvements can easily vacate their best missions by submitting to their worst impulses. The novel, as a result, becomes its own cautionary tale.
In striving to write angry, Arnold forgets to leave room for nuance, complexity, and love. Red Hood is stripped of everything but anger, and I think, ultimately, that’s what makes it ring so hollow.
Red Hood troubled me for days, sittig uneasily inside my mind. And here’s, I think, the reason why: the view of feminism that we get from Red Hood is reductive at best, and dangerous at worst.
Arnauld’s novel takes on some heavy themes—toxic masculinity, sexual assault, and female empowerment—to rework the Red Riding Hood fairytale in the service of poetic revenge. But that premise quickly withers on the page, fails to thrive and bear fruit, and it isn’t long before the novel leaps a chasm into genuinely preposterous territory. What one finds on the other side is a book stuffed with relentless, far-fetched plotting, thought experiments masquerading as characters, and an ending that packs some seriously disturbing implications.
The novel’s consoling message, emerging in the slaughter-numbed blankness of the book’s final pages, is that the answer to patriarchal violence is just more violence. This is how Red Hood winds up betraying itself in the end: for a novel that begins with a clarion call for accountability, a battle cry for “girls like us” who are fighting back to dismantle the system, the endings is a shallow victory. At some point, Arnold gives up interrogating the motivations of the characters to do right, gives up examining their tendency to rationalize their worst ideas without fully understanding the possibility of disaster, gives up engaging with how mouvements can easily vacate their best missions by submitting to their worst impulses. The novel, as a result, becomes its own cautionary tale.
In striving to write angry, Arnold forgets to leave room for nuance, complexity, and love. Red Hood is stripped of everything but anger, and I think, ultimately, that’s what makes it ring so hollow.
August 12, 2019
You are the hunter, and this wolf, though he thinks he is the predator, is your prey.
Elana K. Arnold is one of my favourite writers of the twisted and disturbing. I eagerly seek out her new books and always find myself feeling a little shaken at the end. However, I've said before of Damsel that it should have been marketed as an adult book, and I think that is even more true of this one. Arnold's novels get these gorgeous YA fantasy covers, but I think it leads them into the wrong hands.
In Red Hood I think this is even more of an issue. This is a fantastic, gory, messed up fairy tale, but it also doesn't fully work as a high school thriller, in my opinion. Though I will say the honest depiction of menstruation is definitely something teens are missing.
Sixteen-year-old Bisou Martel has pretty much given up on getting her period when it suddenly arrives at the worst possible time-- homecoming dance, when things are getting sexy in the back of her boyfriend's car. In a moment of panic, she gets out of the car and runs away into the woods. There she encounters a vicious wolf, and somehow kills it. The next day it all seems like a bad dream, but when the dead body of one of her classmates is found in the woods, Bisou has to wonder: is she responsible?
There is a tree at your back. It rises behind you like all of history—your history, the history of girls in forests, the history of wolves and fangs and blood.
It is a very loose Red Riding Hood retelling, which I personally prefer. I have no interest in reading the same story over and over again. It's also very chilling and creepy, even outright scary in parts. I love how Arnold uses fairy tales to tackle issues young women face like periods, relationships, toxic masculinity, and the threat of violence, without seeming didactic or preachy. Red Hood is searingly critical of rape culture and "incels", at the same time as celebrating loving, consensual sex and relationships.
The problem is, I think the conclusion - the "message" of the book, if you will - doesn't sit quite right for me. It is clearly supposed to be about sisterhood and female empowerment, but it comes across as an endorsement of . I also feel that the YA label doesn't help. Would this have been as jarring as an adult novel about ? I can't say for sure, but I feel like it maybe wouldn't.
I will still recommend this to fans of the dark, twisted and gory, but I will need to add a caveat that I don't fully support the message so no one thinks I'm a psychopath.
Blog | Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | Youtube
February 27, 2020
im just not buying whatever brand of ‘feminism’ this book is trying to sell.
this story attempts to show the strength and empowerment of women through the retelling of a classic fairytale and i highly encourage that message, especially within novels directed towards teens (even though this story is definitely on the mature side of YA). but wow, i really do not agree with how that message is conveyed in this.
killing men because they mistreat you is not the answer. the taking of another life is never okay and it definitely wont solve your problem(s). i really dont like how this gives the impression that all men are horrible human beings and should be punished. its a really toxic mentality to encourage. to me, feminism is the promotion of gender equality, not the hating of men. this story just really rubbed me the wrong way.
also, i cant stand second person POV, so that was annoying to deal with. overall, im not impressed and im glad this was a library rental so i didnt waste any money on it.
↠ 1.5 stars
this story attempts to show the strength and empowerment of women through the retelling of a classic fairytale and i highly encourage that message, especially within novels directed towards teens (even though this story is definitely on the mature side of YA). but wow, i really do not agree with how that message is conveyed in this.
killing men because they mistreat you is not the answer. the taking of another life is never okay and it definitely wont solve your problem(s). i really dont like how this gives the impression that all men are horrible human beings and should be punished. its a really toxic mentality to encourage. to me, feminism is the promotion of gender equality, not the hating of men. this story just really rubbed me the wrong way.
also, i cant stand second person POV, so that was annoying to deal with. overall, im not impressed and im glad this was a library rental so i didnt waste any money on it.
↠ 1.5 stars
November 12, 2025
Bisou was raised by her grandmother - and her g-ma was a cool one. She could go to her for anything...until she couldn't.
“It’s not that we need more wolf hunters,” you say. “It’s that we need men to stop becoming wolves.”
On the first day of her very first period, Bisou finds herself confronted by a vicious wolf. And, somehow, she manages to kill it.
And then...it turns back into a man.
Bisou learns that there's a secret in her past - one that turns wicked men into wolves - but she can't run forever...one of these days, the wolves will catch her.
So.
I thought I was going to love this one based off the description...but I wasn't prepared for this book.
There's a lot of second person perspective - where Bisou addresses a collective "you" for the audience...which threw me out of the story constantly.
Every time I'd try to sink in...I would get pushed out by the direct "you".
Also, all of the powers were tied to the "womanly cycle" - which meant that men turned into wolves around her when she's on her magical period...which also kinda threw me.
I kept trying to figure out the magic rules of this world...and apparently they just are...when Bisou is on her period, bad men become wolves.
Which really makes me wonder...how are there SO many irredeemable men in this world?
Some times Bisou stops them mid-heinous act but sometimes they just turn into wolves and try to kill her.
I really feel like just murdering people (even before they do something) is worse than stopping the crime.
I don't know, it just didn't gel with me.
YouTube | Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Facebook | Snapchat @miranda_reads
Want to read
July 29, 2020I loved GIRL IN RED and now another captivating retelling is out there! I want this wolf! I want this hood! I want every retelling of Grimm Brothers' bloody stories!
March 3, 2020
3.5 stars. The only reason it’s not 5 stars is I’m tired of people using wolves as the bad guy/animal. And I hated the female period stuff. Gross. But the killing of evil bastards was the 5 star part 😉
Mel 🖤🐶🐺🐾
Read
February 10, 2020I originally rated this novel 4 stars, but the more I think about it, the more I am bothered by and uncomfortable with the ending. So I am leaving the rating off. Maybe one day I will settle on something...
__________________
Hoo boy, this review is a hard one for me to tackle. I am a huge Elana K. Arnold fan, but I am not sure I can get fully behind Red Hood, like I gladly did with Damsel. Some more people need to read this ARC and tell me if I'm wrong.
Red Hood is a sort of, kind of a retelling of Red Riding Hood set in a modern world. The novel is definitely written in a fairy tale tone, almost entirely in second person. I thought it worked well for the story's dreamy, but tense narrative.
It opens with Bisou getting ready to attend a school dance with her boyfriend of 6 months. She doesn't really love parties, especially not some of the guys at these parties. After the dance Bisou and her boyfriend drive to nearby woods where things get hot and heavy. And then suddenly and unexpectedly Bisou gets her first period (she is 16 and a late bloomer) at the most inopportune moment (brace yourself for it). Mortified, she flees her boyfriend, runs through the woods and encounters a wolf that she somehow finds strength to kill. Next morning, Bisou learns that one of her school mates is dead. Was it Bisou who killed him the night before?
Let me tell you, there are many things Red Hood delivers on -
PERIODS! They are described in visceral, bloody, BLOODY detail.
Young love and first sexual experiences, which are both thrilling and terrifying.
Toxic masculinity. I feel like it is explored here more intelligently than it ever was in another #girlpower! YA novel I like to rant about - Moxie.
On the journey to learn more about herself and her body, Bisou meets other women and becomes a part of a real life force to fight misogyny and violence against women.
What I do find problematic, is what happens after her coven of strong women is formed. I just can't wrap my head around the fact that book seems to suggest that it's a triumph of sisterhood for these women . It would have worked in a Damsel-type setting, but because this is present time, it seems completely wrong. . The novel ends with a tremendously well written, but totally misguided, in my view, epilogue, that is essentially an ode to Hmm... Did I get that right?
Once you've read it, come and tell me what you think.
I doubt Red Hood will get anywhere near the Printz shortlist:(
__________________
Hoo boy, this review is a hard one for me to tackle. I am a huge Elana K. Arnold fan, but I am not sure I can get fully behind Red Hood, like I gladly did with Damsel. Some more people need to read this ARC and tell me if I'm wrong.
Red Hood is a sort of, kind of a retelling of Red Riding Hood set in a modern world. The novel is definitely written in a fairy tale tone, almost entirely in second person. I thought it worked well for the story's dreamy, but tense narrative.
It opens with Bisou getting ready to attend a school dance with her boyfriend of 6 months. She doesn't really love parties, especially not some of the guys at these parties. After the dance Bisou and her boyfriend drive to nearby woods where things get hot and heavy. And then suddenly and unexpectedly Bisou gets her first period (she is 16 and a late bloomer) at the most inopportune moment (brace yourself for it). Mortified, she flees her boyfriend, runs through the woods and encounters a wolf that she somehow finds strength to kill. Next morning, Bisou learns that one of her school mates is dead. Was it Bisou who killed him the night before?
Let me tell you, there are many things Red Hood delivers on -
PERIODS! They are described in visceral, bloody, BLOODY detail.
Young love and first sexual experiences, which are both thrilling and terrifying.
Toxic masculinity. I feel like it is explored here more intelligently than it ever was in another #girlpower! YA novel I like to rant about - Moxie.
On the journey to learn more about herself and her body, Bisou meets other women and becomes a part of a real life force to fight misogyny and violence against women.
What I do find problematic, is what happens after her coven of strong women is formed. I just can't wrap my head around the fact that book seems to suggest that it's a triumph of sisterhood for these women . It would have worked in a Damsel-type setting, but because this is present time, it seems completely wrong. . The novel ends with a tremendously well written, but totally misguided, in my view, epilogue, that is essentially an ode to Hmm... Did I get that right?
Once you've read it, come and tell me what you think.
I doubt Red Hood will get anywhere near the Printz shortlist:(
March 24, 2020
[English Review - Reseña en Español]
|English|
I love you Elana K. Arnold, thanks for writing this wonder!
I didn't know I needed this book.
I mean, I requested an ARC from this book to the publisher, expecting something completely different. A book that made me enjoy reading it, but, besides that, this book has gone beyond, it has made me feel so good, it has been like a caress in my soul.
Why?
Well.
It has been due to the fact that all my ideals are represented in this novel, all the claims that I make every day are reflected in this book, and in the best way, making see and explaining why even some humans must change in so many things.
Things you will find in this novel:
-Menstruation. It was time for me to read a book where it talks about the period as what it is. Something normal, not a taboo.
-Sexual Harassment and Rape Attempts.
-Gender Violence.
-Kills.
-Sex Scenes.
-Scenes of Struggle, Violence and Bloodshed.
-Feminism and Rights.
-Bullying.
-Strong Family Ties.
-Beautiful Friendships and Loyalty.
-Lovely Boy.
What is Red Hood about?
Bisou, a girl with a dark past, currently lives in Seattle with her grandmother, after her mother was mysteriously murdered many years ago.
On the night of the homecoming dance the high school is full of friends Bisou will never have for her lack of trust in others and in herself, but, even so, she feels she doesn't need anyone but James, her boyfriend. A popular boy and player in the high school basketball team.
In the middle of adolescence the hormones are in full bloom, and Bisou wants to experience new things. Therefore, when James and Bisou leave the party, they decide that they want the night to last a little longer, and they are wrapped in an atmosphere of passion and pleasure in the privacy of the car. But the moment is interrupted by a situation that Bisou didn't expect, her period has come, and at the worst time. Shame and panic take over her and flees to the forest without looking back.
Lost in the dark, her senses develop and she notices that something follows her. An animal. Bisou keeps running but her captor is faster, she has no way out, until Bisou has to decide between dying without fighting or trying to defeat the great wolf that stands before her.
The next morning, Bisou has too many things on her mind of what happened last night.
Her period has finally come.
Her boyfriend knows it too.
She killed a wolf.
She survived.
And when she arrives at the high school and learns that a dead body of a boy has appeared in the middle of the forest near there, knows that her problems have only just begun.
After all, she killed a wolf, right?
|Español|
No sabía que necesitaba este libro. Quiero decir, yo pedí un ARC de este libro a la editorial, esperándome algo completamente diferente, un libro que me hiciera disfrutar de la lectura como todos, pero este libro ha ido más allá, me ha hecho sentir muy bien.
¿Por qué?
Bien.
Ha sido por el hecho de que todos mis ideales se ven representados en esta novela, todas las reivindicaciones que hago día a día se plasman en este libro, y de la mejor manera, haciendo ver y explicando el porqué aún algunos humanos deben de cambiar en tantas cosas.
Lo que encontrareis en esta novela:
-Menstruación. Ya era hora de que leyera un libro donde habla de la regla como lo que es. Algo normal, no un tabú.
-Acoso sexual y intentos de violación.
-Violencia de género.
-Asesinatos.
-Escenas de sexo. (No muy descriptivas)
-Escenas de lucha, violencia y derramamiento de sangre.
-Reivindicación feminista.
-Bullying.
-Lazos familiares fuertes.
-Amistad y lealtad.
-Un chico encantador.
¿De qué va este libro?
Bisou, una chica con un pasado oscuro, vive actualmente en Seattle con su abuela, después de que asesinaran a su madre misteriosamente muchos años atrás.
En la noche del baile de bienvenida el instituto está repleto de los amigos que Bisou nunca tendrá por su falta de confianza en los demás y en sí misma, aún así, ella siente que no necesita a nadie más que a James, su novio. Un chico popular y jugador en el equipo de baloncesto del instituto.
En plena adolescencia las hormonas están a flor de piel, y Bisou quiere experimentar cosas nuevas. Por eso, cuando James y Bisou se marchan de la fiesta en dirección al coche deciden que quieren que la noche dure un poco más, y se envuelven en una atmósfera de pasión y placer. Pero el momento es interrumpido por una situación que Bisou no esperaba, su período ha llegado, y en el peor momento. La vergüenza se apodera de ella y presa del pánico huye al bosque, sin mirar atrás.
Perdida en la oscuridad sus sentidos se desarrollan y presiente que algo la sigue, un animal. Bisou sigue corriendo pero su captor es más veloz, no tiene salida, hasta que Bisou tiene que decidir entre morir sin luchar o intentar derrotar al gran lobo que se encuentra ante ella.
A la mañana siguiente, Bisou tiene demasiadas cosas en la cabeza de lo que pasó la noche anterior.
Su período ha llegado por fin.
Su novio también lo sabe.
Mató a un lobo.
Sobrevivió.
Y cuando llega al instituto y se entera de que ha aparecido un cuerpo en mitad del bosque cerca de allí, sabe que sus problemas solo acaban de comenzar.
Al fin y al cabo ella mató a un lobo, ¿no?
**I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.**
|English|
“Maybe there could be more of you. More fighters.”
“It’s not that we need more wolf hunters,” you say. “It’s that we need men to stop becoming wolves.”
“What we need right now,” Mémé says, her voice a cautious warning, “is to get through these next few days. Heads down. Eyes up. The world is not kind to women who cry wolf.”
I love you Elana K. Arnold, thanks for writing this wonder!
I didn't know I needed this book.
I mean, I requested an ARC from this book to the publisher, expecting something completely different. A book that made me enjoy reading it, but, besides that, this book has gone beyond, it has made me feel so good, it has been like a caress in my soul.
Why?
Well.
It has been due to the fact that all my ideals are represented in this novel, all the claims that I make every day are reflected in this book, and in the best way, making see and explaining why even some humans must change in so many things.
Things you will find in this novel:
-Menstruation. It was time for me to read a book where it talks about the period as what it is. Something normal, not a taboo.
-Sexual Harassment and Rape Attempts.
-Gender Violence.
-Kills.
-Sex Scenes.
-Scenes of Struggle, Violence and Bloodshed.
-Feminism and Rights.
-Bullying.
-Strong Family Ties.
-Beautiful Friendships and Loyalty.
-Lovely Boy.
You are stronger than you were, and faster than you were, and you, in this moment, are made for this moment.
The animal confronting you is both a wolf and not a wolf. And you—you are both a girl and not a girl. You are a hunter, and this wolf, though he thinks he is the predator, is your prey.
What is Red Hood about?
Bisou, a girl with a dark past, currently lives in Seattle with her grandmother, after her mother was mysteriously murdered many years ago.
On the night of the homecoming dance the high school is full of friends Bisou will never have for her lack of trust in others and in herself, but, even so, she feels she doesn't need anyone but James, her boyfriend. A popular boy and player in the high school basketball team.
In the middle of adolescence the hormones are in full bloom, and Bisou wants to experience new things. Therefore, when James and Bisou leave the party, they decide that they want the night to last a little longer, and they are wrapped in an atmosphere of passion and pleasure in the privacy of the car. But the moment is interrupted by a situation that Bisou didn't expect, her period has come, and at the worst time. Shame and panic take over her and flees to the forest without looking back.
Lost in the dark, her senses develop and she notices that something follows her. An animal. Bisou keeps running but her captor is faster, she has no way out, until Bisou has to decide between dying without fighting or trying to defeat the great wolf that stands before her.
The next morning, Bisou has too many things on her mind of what happened last night.
Her period has finally come.
Her boyfriend knows it too.
She killed a wolf.
She survived.
And when she arrives at the high school and learns that a dead body of a boy has appeared in the middle of the forest near there, knows that her problems have only just begun.
After all, she killed a wolf, right?
|Español|
No sabía que necesitaba este libro. Quiero decir, yo pedí un ARC de este libro a la editorial, esperándome algo completamente diferente, un libro que me hiciera disfrutar de la lectura como todos, pero este libro ha ido más allá, me ha hecho sentir muy bien.
¿Por qué?
Bien.
Ha sido por el hecho de que todos mis ideales se ven representados en esta novela, todas las reivindicaciones que hago día a día se plasman en este libro, y de la mejor manera, haciendo ver y explicando el porqué aún algunos humanos deben de cambiar en tantas cosas.
Lo que encontrareis en esta novela:
-Menstruación. Ya era hora de que leyera un libro donde habla de la regla como lo que es. Algo normal, no un tabú.
-Acoso sexual y intentos de violación.
-Violencia de género.
-Asesinatos.
-Escenas de sexo. (No muy descriptivas)
-Escenas de lucha, violencia y derramamiento de sangre.
-Reivindicación feminista.
-Bullying.
-Lazos familiares fuertes.
-Amistad y lealtad.
-Un chico encantador.
¿De qué va este libro?
Bisou, una chica con un pasado oscuro, vive actualmente en Seattle con su abuela, después de que asesinaran a su madre misteriosamente muchos años atrás.
En la noche del baile de bienvenida el instituto está repleto de los amigos que Bisou nunca tendrá por su falta de confianza en los demás y en sí misma, aún así, ella siente que no necesita a nadie más que a James, su novio. Un chico popular y jugador en el equipo de baloncesto del instituto.
En plena adolescencia las hormonas están a flor de piel, y Bisou quiere experimentar cosas nuevas. Por eso, cuando James y Bisou se marchan de la fiesta en dirección al coche deciden que quieren que la noche dure un poco más, y se envuelven en una atmósfera de pasión y placer. Pero el momento es interrumpido por una situación que Bisou no esperaba, su período ha llegado, y en el peor momento. La vergüenza se apodera de ella y presa del pánico huye al bosque, sin mirar atrás.
Perdida en la oscuridad sus sentidos se desarrollan y presiente que algo la sigue, un animal. Bisou sigue corriendo pero su captor es más veloz, no tiene salida, hasta que Bisou tiene que decidir entre morir sin luchar o intentar derrotar al gran lobo que se encuentra ante ella.
A la mañana siguiente, Bisou tiene demasiadas cosas en la cabeza de lo que pasó la noche anterior.
Su período ha llegado por fin.
Su novio también lo sabe.
Mató a un lobo.
Sobrevivió.
Y cuando llega al instituto y se entera de que ha aparecido un cuerpo en mitad del bosque cerca de allí, sabe que sus problemas solo acaban de comenzar.
Al fin y al cabo ella mató a un lobo, ¿no?
**I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.**
February 26, 2020
I requested this book for one reason only : because of DAMSEL. It's a book a lot of people hate, or dislike, or just feel uncomfortable about. And I don't begrudge anyone their feelings. But somehow it just worked for me. So when I saw yet another feminist sorta-retelling by the same author? I wanted it.
While this saying a lot of things, and unpacking all the societal gender issues, it just didn't quite work as a story. It felt very literal, the good girls killed by the wolves aren't good girls at all, it's whispered, and yet no one questions the motives of the wolf. And this leaned very heavily on menstruation and dealing with those changes, all of which is great, and not often touched on. We also had a very strong female friendship that develops, between girls who wouldn't normally have found each other, or maybe given each other a chance to be friends, in addition to a very sweet, very genuine, romance, but.
But.
I don't know, it was a push to get through this, I wasn't feeling motivated to read it, despite all the good in the story and what it was saying.
I think people who disliked DAMSEL will enjoy this because it's a little less wild, a little less out there, and again, the dialogue is relevant and strong. So if you were put off by the author's other works, but want to explore this kind of story, I would suggest giving this a try.
** I received an ARC from Edelweiss and the publisher (thank you!) in exchange for an honest review. **
---
This review can also be found at A Take From Two Cities.
While this saying a lot of things, and unpacking all the societal gender issues, it just didn't quite work as a story. It felt very literal, the good girls killed by the wolves aren't good girls at all, it's whispered, and yet no one questions the motives of the wolf. And this leaned very heavily on menstruation and dealing with those changes, all of which is great, and not often touched on. We also had a very strong female friendship that develops, between girls who wouldn't normally have found each other, or maybe given each other a chance to be friends, in addition to a very sweet, very genuine, romance, but.
But.
I don't know, it was a push to get through this, I wasn't feeling motivated to read it, despite all the good in the story and what it was saying.
I think people who disliked DAMSEL will enjoy this because it's a little less wild, a little less out there, and again, the dialogue is relevant and strong. So if you were put off by the author's other works, but want to explore this kind of story, I would suggest giving this a try.
** I received an ARC from Edelweiss and the publisher (thank you!) in exchange for an honest review. **
---
This review can also be found at A Take From Two Cities.
Want to read
July 4, 2019I desperately want Elana K. Arnold to focus the rest of her writing on endless feminist fairytale retellings ♥
April 15, 2021
A fun, feminist retelling of red riding hood primarily focusing on rape culture and the connections women create with one another to support and uplift another.
Towards the end, the story dragged and could have been edited down a bit. I also felt as though the protagonist's romance was thrown into the mix to lighten the darkness of this plot rather than being a pivotal piece of the story. Her relationship felt unimportant and was quickly forgotten when we got into the heart of the story, so I was confused as to why it was so consuming at the beginning of the tale and was nearly abandoned towards the end.
All in all, I enjoyed my time with this audiobook and sped through listening to it. The plot was engaging enough to keep me listening, the mystery was intriguing, and I loved the connections the protagonist formed with other girls in town. Their friendship was wonderful and uplifting, but, overall, the novel's pacing was what threw me off and made me wish it was edited down and restructured to be more compelling.
TW: Extensive discussions about menstruation, sexual assault, sexual harassment, stalking domestic violence, abuse
Towards the end, the story dragged and could have been edited down a bit. I also felt as though the protagonist's romance was thrown into the mix to lighten the darkness of this plot rather than being a pivotal piece of the story. Her relationship felt unimportant and was quickly forgotten when we got into the heart of the story, so I was confused as to why it was so consuming at the beginning of the tale and was nearly abandoned towards the end.
All in all, I enjoyed my time with this audiobook and sped through listening to it. The plot was engaging enough to keep me listening, the mystery was intriguing, and I loved the connections the protagonist formed with other girls in town. Their friendship was wonderful and uplifting, but, overall, the novel's pacing was what threw me off and made me wish it was edited down and restructured to be more compelling.
TW: Extensive discussions about menstruation, sexual assault, sexual harassment, stalking domestic violence, abuse
September 3, 2020
I am sad - and furious - that so many women have internalized misogyny to such an extent that they deem this book an attack on men. There are brave, progressive, feminist men in this book - men as heroes and accomplices to women wronged. And even if there hadn’t been, the fact that I’m sitting here watching women label this book as misandry - when every man killed is slain by women defending themselves from a murderous attack — is appalling. Every young woman should read this book. We can expand on how such a narrative that involves menstruation speaks to trans and non binary people or could include them, but this is a story of one specific, tight knit group of four women facing male predators. And you all feel sorry for the men who were about to rip their throats open? It makes me a little ill. Y’all will read dystopian thrillers or high fantasy cheering on young women who take on the role of soldier, in allegiance to a monarchy or an abstract code of honor, but killing rapists mid-attack to save a life is too much. The hypocrisy, it stinks.
March 28, 2020
4.5 stars
June 10, 2020
"There isn't always a wolf," Mémé reminds you, "but there is always the threat of one."
I came into this prepared to be salty and infuriated like I was with Damsel . . . but instead was utterly blown away by the sheer power of this book. This was such a fierce piece of feminism wrapped in a well-known fairytale. To say I loved this would be an understatement, and to say this is powerful would also be a drastic understatement. This book doesn't pull any punches but neither is it overtly gratuitous. It says what it wants to say as precisely as possible, but also feels like a modern poetic ode to the power of women.
Again, I wasn't a fan of this author's previous work, Damsel, so I was blown away with how different my feelings were about this book because it is so much better in all possible ways. It is definitely a book that will resonate with many people and will not be easily forgotten in a good way.
I received a digital ARC from Balzer + Bray via Edelweiss. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Quotes are taken from an uncorrected ARC copy.
I came into this prepared to be salty and infuriated like I was with Damsel . . . but instead was utterly blown away by the sheer power of this book. This was such a fierce piece of feminism wrapped in a well-known fairytale. To say I loved this would be an understatement, and to say this is powerful would also be a drastic understatement. This book doesn't pull any punches but neither is it overtly gratuitous. It says what it wants to say as precisely as possible, but also feels like a modern poetic ode to the power of women.
Again, I wasn't a fan of this author's previous work, Damsel, so I was blown away with how different my feelings were about this book because it is so much better in all possible ways. It is definitely a book that will resonate with many people and will not be easily forgotten in a good way.
I received a digital ARC from Balzer + Bray via Edelweiss. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. Quotes are taken from an uncorrected ARC copy.
February 29, 2020
I'm going to be honest - I actually read 50% of the book and then skimmed the rest because I just couldn't do it anymore.
This book was very problematic for me. In my opinion, it was written to make you uncomfortable. From the second person perspective to the very graphic and detailed descriptions about blood and periods and sexual experiences. I feel like this is the type of book you either "get" and love or don't get at all.
Unfortunately, I am the latter category. I didn't get it and I didn't like it. It was not for me. That's not to say there aren't people out there who won't enjoy it - I'm just not that person. I found Bisou's obsession with her period to be off-putting - Nothing against having a period but I don't necessarily want to read about it in that great of detail.
I will say that I am really surprised that this is marketed as a YA book. I personally think some aspects are too graphic and mature for young teens.
Finally, men-bashing/violence against men (no matter what kind of moral character they have) in order to "get back your power" is not my kind of feminism. Feminism should be about equality - not hating men. You can have an empowering feminist message without all the hate to men.
If you are considering reading it just be aware there is some subject matter that could be triggering.
I personally would not recommend this book.
(Advance Copy provided by HCC Frenzy in exchange for honest review.)
This book was very problematic for me. In my opinion, it was written to make you uncomfortable. From the second person perspective to the very graphic and detailed descriptions about blood and periods and sexual experiences. I feel like this is the type of book you either "get" and love or don't get at all.
Unfortunately, I am the latter category. I didn't get it and I didn't like it. It was not for me. That's not to say there aren't people out there who won't enjoy it - I'm just not that person. I found Bisou's obsession with her period to be off-putting - Nothing against having a period but I don't necessarily want to read about it in that great of detail.
I will say that I am really surprised that this is marketed as a YA book. I personally think some aspects are too graphic and mature for young teens.
Finally, men-bashing/violence against men (no matter what kind of moral character they have) in order to "get back your power" is not my kind of feminism. Feminism should be about equality - not hating men. You can have an empowering feminist message without all the hate to men.
If you are considering reading it just be aware there is some subject matter that could be triggering.
I personally would not recommend this book.
(Advance Copy provided by HCC Frenzy in exchange for honest review.)
February 26, 2020
Actual Rating: 4.5 Stars
Disclaimer: This book was sent to me by the publisher, Balzer + Bray, via Edelweiss+ for an honest review.
“I stumbled to me feet and took off running.
Well, dear, he chased, and I am sure you know where this story goes. It’s your story, too, after all.
I ran, and he chased, and soon I became aware that it was no longer a man who followed me – it was a beast, a wolf.”
“who’s afraid of the big bad wolf
i am afraid
of everything.”
Bisou Martel ran from the car to escape the bloody scene before her. The drops of blood running from his chin, mortifying her beyond repair. She wanted nothing more than to disappear, to vanish, so she ran into the woods. But the woods weren’t safe that night, especially for Bisou. For she was different now, and the wolf could smell it in the air. Could taste it in the turning leaves and the trickle of fear mixing with her sweat. So he prowled towards her, inch by inch, wanting to claim what was surely his. Bisou was scared, but she was also different now. So she steps out of the woods, but the wolf doesn’t.
“There is only one way to kill a wolf, dear heart.
Quickly.”
This isn’t a fluffy retelling of Little Red Riding Hood. The maiden is not a princess, the wolf is not a prince, and grandmother isn’t sitting in bed twiddling her thumbs. Red Hood is one of the most raw retellings I have come across. It’s unhinging how forceful it pushes your comfort zone into submission and forces you to eradicate those tainted ideas instilled in us of how a female should act at. It will force women to shed every frightened sense of modesty that they grip to their bodies like a towel, and give readers a new insight into the meaning of wolf and prey.
“Strange how a thing can strengthen one person and weaken another.”
Bisou lives with her grandmother and has been for since she was a child. Throughout the story there are hints at the trauma and mysteries surrounding her mother and their separation, and why her father isn’t in the picture either. The author blends poetry into the story as a glimpse into her mother’s past and her feelings, and it also gives Bisou a voice while she fights to gain control of what is happening in her town. Why boys are turning up dead, and if she has anything to do with it.
“I was alone
in the ghost room
waiting for it to end
alone
hoping he wouldn’t find me
he came
and blew down everything
the moon was made of blood
your bed was full of blood
when he touched you
with his fists and fangs
he could have kept you safe
but he didn’t want to.”
But let’s get real about this.
This book is going to make you uncomfortable. It wouldn’t be an Elana K. Arnold book if it didn’t. But it’s okay if it does, and it’s to be expected. Our culture has been raising women in a world where they should feel shame for their bodies. For not being pretty enough, sweet enough, interesting enough. We are made to feel unworthy, unclean. Taught to take up less space, make less noise, need less and be less. So that is why you will be uncomfortable reading this. Because Elana just did everything society didn’t want her to do.
She made a group of strong, intelligent, driven, fierce and vocal women. Who pry and push their way towards their goals, damning the consequences. She gave their bodies truth. Showcasing them like the beautiful vessels they are. Full of awkward limbs, colors, textures and sizes. But best of all, she talked about that one special thing that makes women feel dirty. The one thing that men have made them hide and feel ashamed for – their periods.
Yeah, I said it.
P–E–R–I–O–D–S.
In this story, the men and boys who wish harm to women – both physically and sexually – turn into wolves, lurking and stalking their prey. But Bisou, like her grandmother, is bestowed with a certain special sense or ability upon her first bleeding – PERIOD. I can’t say more without giving all the key elements away, but just know, this book is going to talk about periods and you’re just going to have to embrace it.
Because the layers of messages that this author weaves throughout this tale is so inspiring and beautiful. She wants you to embrace your body, to love this squishy and unique form that you have grown into and gotten to know your entire life. This flesh, bone and blood that is YOURS and yours alone. The frame that holds your heart, hopes and dreams…and the foundation of what holds you up. The author wants you to look at YOU, and feel good. To feel at home and to love it there. To feel safe, comfortable and happy that THIS BODY is YOURS!
“…now – here – you are your body.”
But the other HUGE aspects of this story are the toxic masculinity, the fear that women face on a day to day basis, and the unjust expectations and labels that are placed upon women and not men. How women are held to a higher standard in how the act and dress, being labeled a slut or said she was “asking for it” if she does not stick within those straight lines she is pushed into. And how men are able to dress and act how they please, with little to no consequences and zero labels following them around like a shameful reminder.
“Later I learned that she had a bad reputation – she was a drinker, they said, and had a liking for short skirts and halter tops. She liked men, they said – emphasis on “men”, not boys.
Nothing was said of the fact that “men” obviously liked her, too.”
This book sheds light on a lot of REALLY important topics that NEED to be talked about. Rape, harassment, abuse and unfair labels. As the story progresses we see Bisou and her female friends start out quiet and docile, and end up being forces of nature. They find their voices and fight tooth and nail for one another and themselves. I found it to be empowering and an incredibly unique way to approach these issues. I really recommend it to everyone to read, because we need to stop shying away from topics and face them head on.
“…
I can break things
I can make things, too.
I stand
On two strong legs
I kill
With two strong hands
I bleed
From one strong womb
I wish
With one red heart
That you could see me now.”
“Who’s afraid of the big bad wolf?
Not me. Fuck the wolf.”
Disclaimer: This book was sent to me by the publisher, Balzer + Bray, via Edelweiss+ for an honest review.
“I stumbled to me feet and took off running.
Well, dear, he chased, and I am sure you know where this story goes. It’s your story, too, after all.
I ran, and he chased, and soon I became aware that it was no longer a man who followed me – it was a beast, a wolf.”
“who’s afraid of the big bad wolf
i am afraid
of everything.”
Bisou Martel ran from the car to escape the bloody scene before her. The drops of blood running from his chin, mortifying her beyond repair. She wanted nothing more than to disappear, to vanish, so she ran into the woods. But the woods weren’t safe that night, especially for Bisou. For she was different now, and the wolf could smell it in the air. Could taste it in the turning leaves and the trickle of fear mixing with her sweat. So he prowled towards her, inch by inch, wanting to claim what was surely his. Bisou was scared, but she was also different now. So she steps out of the woods, but the wolf doesn’t.
“There is only one way to kill a wolf, dear heart.
Quickly.”
This isn’t a fluffy retelling of Little Red Riding Hood. The maiden is not a princess, the wolf is not a prince, and grandmother isn’t sitting in bed twiddling her thumbs. Red Hood is one of the most raw retellings I have come across. It’s unhinging how forceful it pushes your comfort zone into submission and forces you to eradicate those tainted ideas instilled in us of how a female should act at. It will force women to shed every frightened sense of modesty that they grip to their bodies like a towel, and give readers a new insight into the meaning of wolf and prey.
“Strange how a thing can strengthen one person and weaken another.”
Bisou lives with her grandmother and has been for since she was a child. Throughout the story there are hints at the trauma and mysteries surrounding her mother and their separation, and why her father isn’t in the picture either. The author blends poetry into the story as a glimpse into her mother’s past and her feelings, and it also gives Bisou a voice while she fights to gain control of what is happening in her town. Why boys are turning up dead, and if she has anything to do with it.
“I was alone
in the ghost room
waiting for it to end
alone
hoping he wouldn’t find me
he came
and blew down everything
the moon was made of blood
your bed was full of blood
when he touched you
with his fists and fangs
he could have kept you safe
but he didn’t want to.”
But let’s get real about this.
This book is going to make you uncomfortable. It wouldn’t be an Elana K. Arnold book if it didn’t. But it’s okay if it does, and it’s to be expected. Our culture has been raising women in a world where they should feel shame for their bodies. For not being pretty enough, sweet enough, interesting enough. We are made to feel unworthy, unclean. Taught to take up less space, make less noise, need less and be less. So that is why you will be uncomfortable reading this. Because Elana just did everything society didn’t want her to do.
She made a group of strong, intelligent, driven, fierce and vocal women. Who pry and push their way towards their goals, damning the consequences. She gave their bodies truth. Showcasing them like the beautiful vessels they are. Full of awkward limbs, colors, textures and sizes. But best of all, she talked about that one special thing that makes women feel dirty. The one thing that men have made them hide and feel ashamed for – their periods.
Yeah, I said it.
P–E–R–I–O–D–S.
In this story, the men and boys who wish harm to women – both physically and sexually – turn into wolves, lurking and stalking their prey. But Bisou, like her grandmother, is bestowed with a certain special sense or ability upon her first bleeding – PERIOD. I can’t say more without giving all the key elements away, but just know, this book is going to talk about periods and you’re just going to have to embrace it.
Because the layers of messages that this author weaves throughout this tale is so inspiring and beautiful. She wants you to embrace your body, to love this squishy and unique form that you have grown into and gotten to know your entire life. This flesh, bone and blood that is YOURS and yours alone. The frame that holds your heart, hopes and dreams…and the foundation of what holds you up. The author wants you to look at YOU, and feel good. To feel at home and to love it there. To feel safe, comfortable and happy that THIS BODY is YOURS!
“…now – here – you are your body.”
But the other HUGE aspects of this story are the toxic masculinity, the fear that women face on a day to day basis, and the unjust expectations and labels that are placed upon women and not men. How women are held to a higher standard in how the act and dress, being labeled a slut or said she was “asking for it” if she does not stick within those straight lines she is pushed into. And how men are able to dress and act how they please, with little to no consequences and zero labels following them around like a shameful reminder.
“Later I learned that she had a bad reputation – she was a drinker, they said, and had a liking for short skirts and halter tops. She liked men, they said – emphasis on “men”, not boys.
Nothing was said of the fact that “men” obviously liked her, too.”
This book sheds light on a lot of REALLY important topics that NEED to be talked about. Rape, harassment, abuse and unfair labels. As the story progresses we see Bisou and her female friends start out quiet and docile, and end up being forces of nature. They find their voices and fight tooth and nail for one another and themselves. I found it to be empowering and an incredibly unique way to approach these issues. I really recommend it to everyone to read, because we need to stop shying away from topics and face them head on.
“…
I can break things
I can make things, too.
I stand
On two strong legs
I kill
With two strong hands
I bleed
From one strong womb
I wish
With one red heart
That you could see me now.”
“Who’s afraid of the big bad wolf?
Not me. Fuck the wolf.”
March 4, 2020
2.5 stars.
My expectations were a bit too high after reading Damsel. That was a damn near perfect book and after learning Elana would come out with a Red Riding Hood inspired novel, my expectations were high. However, the first sign of trouble started off when I learned this would be written in 2nd POV. Which... OK, it may not be my cup of tea but I hoped the story would be good. That was the second sign of trouble.
Needless to say, Red Hood was mediocre at best. The positives are outweighed by the negatives, meaning that the few parts I did enjoy were just that, few.
Red Hood is a story inspired close to Red Riding Hood. The main character, Bisou, was going to have sex with her boyfriend in his car after attending their homecoming dance until she has her period. Her first one. Embarrassed, she runs out of the car and into the woods where she runs into a wolf. Some primal urge takes over Bisou and she fights the wolf, killing it in the process. After, she learns more about herself, her grandmother, and the wolves that roam the woods and kills women.
This is a feminist story much like Damsel and the messages are clear to see. With that being said, much of the story and the character of Bisou were not as developed as I wanted to be. Plus, there is an issue with the brand of feminism Elana presented that some people have an issue with.
The structure of the story, it is told from 2nd perspective, was a big flaw for me because reading from that perspective made Bisou feel like some sort of insert character into a fanfic that had little to almost no distinct personality. Had it been written in the 1st or 3rd perspective, I would've liked it a lot more. If it was written the way it was so we can get a more in-depth look at Bisou, it did a bad job because I can't think of anything remotely interesting about Bisou.
The story itself wasn't that bad, but it was also lacking, not to mention slow at some parts. We have a story who kills wolves and it falls flat. The only times where my interest was piqued was when we got to learn more about Bisou, her grandmother, and the wolves. That also includes the wolf killings because those were descriptive. Outside of those moments, the story was slow and felt more like a contemporary than it did a paranormal.
So, here's the part where it could divide the people on their opinion of how Elana presented her brand of feminism. Particularly, this review, though short, does explain why some are bothered with Elana's brand of feminism presented in her story.
My high expectations for Red Hood was what lead me to a disappointing read. A shame really because I adore Damsel.
My expectations were a bit too high after reading Damsel. That was a damn near perfect book and after learning Elana would come out with a Red Riding Hood inspired novel, my expectations were high. However, the first sign of trouble started off when I learned this would be written in 2nd POV. Which... OK, it may not be my cup of tea but I hoped the story would be good. That was the second sign of trouble.
Needless to say, Red Hood was mediocre at best. The positives are outweighed by the negatives, meaning that the few parts I did enjoy were just that, few.
Red Hood is a story inspired close to Red Riding Hood. The main character, Bisou, was going to have sex with her boyfriend in his car after attending their homecoming dance until she has her period. Her first one. Embarrassed, she runs out of the car and into the woods where she runs into a wolf. Some primal urge takes over Bisou and she fights the wolf, killing it in the process. After, she learns more about herself, her grandmother, and the wolves that roam the woods and kills women.
This is a feminist story much like Damsel and the messages are clear to see. With that being said, much of the story and the character of Bisou were not as developed as I wanted to be. Plus, there is an issue with the brand of feminism Elana presented that some people have an issue with.
The structure of the story, it is told from 2nd perspective, was a big flaw for me because reading from that perspective made Bisou feel like some sort of insert character into a fanfic that had little to almost no distinct personality. Had it been written in the 1st or 3rd perspective, I would've liked it a lot more. If it was written the way it was so we can get a more in-depth look at Bisou, it did a bad job because I can't think of anything remotely interesting about Bisou.
The story itself wasn't that bad, but it was also lacking, not to mention slow at some parts. We have a story who kills wolves and it falls flat. The only times where my interest was piqued was when we got to learn more about Bisou, her grandmother, and the wolves. That also includes the wolf killings because those were descriptive. Outside of those moments, the story was slow and felt more like a contemporary than it did a paranormal.
So, here's the part where it could divide the people on their opinion of how Elana presented her brand of feminism. Particularly, this review, though short, does explain why some are bothered with Elana's brand of feminism presented in her story.
My high expectations for Red Hood was what lead me to a disappointing read. A shame really because I adore Damsel.
February 25, 2020
The first word I thought of to describe ‘Red Hood’ is outstanding. It holds a potent message of female empowerment and gives us a whole new image of ‘Little Red Hiding Rood,’ and it’s coated in so much blood it feels like a murder-mystery. If just that makes you uncomfortable or woozy, you probably won’t be able to handle all the intense themes and topics* that author Elana K. Arnold weaves into this hypnotic coming-of-age tale. But if you love a brave story where cruel realities meet bold fantasy and aren't afraid to enter the woods, you should definitely proceed.
There are countless stories where women and girls are at the mercy of men, of predators, where they are abused and assaulted, and it takes a lot for retribution to happen. Sometimes it never does. They are stories that mirror reality and they are hard to read and hear because they are too familiar to many of us.
'Red Hood' flips that story on its tail, with Bisou discovering her birthright when she gets her first period at the light of the full moon on Homecoming night; she suddenly has the otherworldly power to fight and kill the predators she can now sense in the dark Seattle woods. Bisou can sense when the wolves, these broken boys, are attacking their prey, and she is compelled by her own past, her bloodline, to protect and save these young women, these girls, and go on the hunt.
With a story loaded with an emotional hot-button issue like sexual assault (and revenge-killing) in a social climate where the #MeToo movement is on everyone's radar, this book is sure to catch the attention of a lot of readers. And it will be the reason some have to stay away; that's fine, we know our limits.
There will be discussion over whether 'killing the wolf' (and whether an 'eye for an eye') is justified. But I liken this kind of justice to that of other vigilantes out there in our fantasy worlds, our superheroes, Batman, Arrow, Hawkeye. I have to wonder if this kind of vengeance is called into question further because it's a woman carrying it out and because of the connection to sex. And no, I don't think we have to answer how the 'boy became the wolf' because that's a whole other story, and not for Bisou's tale. We don't always have to answer where the evil comes from to know that we have to get rid of it.
I struggled to write this review, as I often have when a book really blows me away. I’d been lost for words since I read it, but thought about it a lot, and had somewhat pointlessly ‘written’ a review in my mind several times. I just want others to feel the way I did when I read it, clinging to every word.
Last year, it was ‘The Grace Year’ by Kim Liggett that did the same thing for me. Both books portray women finding their place, their truth, and their power, albeit through very different stories and means, but both left me feeling that women can change their circumstances, they can be emboldened and empowered, and that they are ENOUGH. 'Red Hood' is magical and profound. It's also an intimate tale of one girl's discovery of her tragic past and her personal power. And as I said, it's outstanding.
*Aside from sexual assault, murder, revenge-killing and rape, some themes and topics raised: sexual intercourse (including loss of virginity, and teen sex), drug and alcohol use, menstruation, abuse, bullying, suicide, self-harm, stalking, toxic masculinity, harassment.
~Thank you to Harper Teen for providing me with a review copy of this book for early reading. This did not influence my rating of the book.
There are countless stories where women and girls are at the mercy of men, of predators, where they are abused and assaulted, and it takes a lot for retribution to happen. Sometimes it never does. They are stories that mirror reality and they are hard to read and hear because they are too familiar to many of us.
'Red Hood' flips that story on its tail, with Bisou discovering her birthright when she gets her first period at the light of the full moon on Homecoming night; she suddenly has the otherworldly power to fight and kill the predators she can now sense in the dark Seattle woods. Bisou can sense when the wolves, these broken boys, are attacking their prey, and she is compelled by her own past, her bloodline, to protect and save these young women, these girls, and go on the hunt.
With a story loaded with an emotional hot-button issue like sexual assault (and revenge-killing) in a social climate where the #MeToo movement is on everyone's radar, this book is sure to catch the attention of a lot of readers. And it will be the reason some have to stay away; that's fine, we know our limits.
There will be discussion over whether 'killing the wolf' (and whether an 'eye for an eye') is justified. But I liken this kind of justice to that of other vigilantes out there in our fantasy worlds, our superheroes, Batman, Arrow, Hawkeye. I have to wonder if this kind of vengeance is called into question further because it's a woman carrying it out and because of the connection to sex. And no, I don't think we have to answer how the 'boy became the wolf' because that's a whole other story, and not for Bisou's tale. We don't always have to answer where the evil comes from to know that we have to get rid of it.
I struggled to write this review, as I often have when a book really blows me away. I’d been lost for words since I read it, but thought about it a lot, and had somewhat pointlessly ‘written’ a review in my mind several times. I just want others to feel the way I did when I read it, clinging to every word.
Last year, it was ‘The Grace Year’ by Kim Liggett that did the same thing for me. Both books portray women finding their place, their truth, and their power, albeit through very different stories and means, but both left me feeling that women can change their circumstances, they can be emboldened and empowered, and that they are ENOUGH. 'Red Hood' is magical and profound. It's also an intimate tale of one girl's discovery of her tragic past and her personal power. And as I said, it's outstanding.
*Aside from sexual assault, murder, revenge-killing and rape, some themes and topics raised: sexual intercourse (including loss of virginity, and teen sex), drug and alcohol use, menstruation, abuse, bullying, suicide, self-harm, stalking, toxic masculinity, harassment.
~Thank you to Harper Teen for providing me with a review copy of this book for early reading. This did not influence my rating of the book.
July 30, 2022
Nice is different than good.
I will read everything Elana K. Arnold writes forever. I really loved our main cast, and I loved the second person POV. My one complaint is that I wish it had talked about how not every woman has a period, and not everyone who has a period is a woman; due to the focus on periods in this.
(Side note: can't believe I had this review up for TWO YEARS without realizing there was a typo in the second sentence lmao)
I will read everything Elana K. Arnold writes forever. I really loved our main cast, and I loved the second person POV. My one complaint is that I wish it had talked about how not every woman has a period, and not everyone who has a period is a woman; due to the focus on periods in this.
(Side note: can't believe I had this review up for TWO YEARS without realizing there was a typo in the second sentence lmao)
August 26, 2019
If I could give this 500 stars, I would.
This book is incredible. The dreamy-like quality of the second-person narration; the clever callbacks to fairy tales of yesteryear; the amazing feminist undertones and overtones; the character- and story-building; even the chapter headings and moon cycle illustrations are strategic and on-point.
I hope this book finds its way into the hands of teenage girls everywhere, so they can begin to unlearn the culture of toxic masculinity in which we’ve all been brought up, and start learning the truth—that women MUST lift each other up if we are *ever* going to topple the dangerous hierarchy that’s been created for us. (AGAINST us, actually).
I read and loved Damsel. I love this one even more. The badassery of Elana Arnold knows no bounds.
This book is incredible. The dreamy-like quality of the second-person narration; the clever callbacks to fairy tales of yesteryear; the amazing feminist undertones and overtones; the character- and story-building; even the chapter headings and moon cycle illustrations are strategic and on-point.
I hope this book finds its way into the hands of teenage girls everywhere, so they can begin to unlearn the culture of toxic masculinity in which we’ve all been brought up, and start learning the truth—that women MUST lift each other up if we are *ever* going to topple the dangerous hierarchy that’s been created for us. (AGAINST us, actually).
I read and loved Damsel. I love this one even more. The badassery of Elana Arnold knows no bounds.
January 7, 2020
Originally published on The Nerd Daily | Review by Nathalie DeFelice
This story can be described as bloody and brilliant. My favourite thing about Elana K. Arnold’s books is that they’re so unapologetically meant for the empowerment of young women. I relished diving into the world of Red Hood after reading Damsel, because I couldn’t wait to see what world Arnold would craft for us. She manages to turn the narrative of the Little Red Riding Hood and imbues it with the strength of a woman instead of a man. If you’re not here to see fierce women take down toxic masculinity, this might not be the book for you. However, if you’re here to see women dismantle a hostile system never meant to empower them in the first place, then you’ve come to the right place. Now, if you’re easily triggered by themes of sexual assault and murder, you might approach this book with caution. I loved this book, but I will admit that it does come on strong, but if you think you can handle it, I highly recommend that you add this to your TBR.
Bisou Martel has been in her grandmother’s care since she was four years old. They’ve lived a nice and quiet life in Seattle, but on the night of Homecoming, she finds herself running for her life in the woods, chased by a wolf with a mouth full of teeth and vicious claws. Bisou fights back, and as the new moon rises, so do questions about the blood in her veins and on her hands. She’ll navigate through broken boys and vicious wolves, and the lost girls who are afraid, but not alone. This isn’t the bedtime story that I grew up reading, that’s for certain.
Despite the modern setting, Red Hood holds a similar storytelling to Damsel, one that makes you feel as though you’re in a dream. Our narrator, Bisou, is getting ready for the Homecoming Dance with her boyfriend of six months. Parties aren’t really her thing, and she doesn’t care for some of the guys that on her boyfriend’s basketball team, but she’s willing to put that to the side to hang out with him. After the dance she and her boyfriend head into the woods where things begin to get heated, but it’s at that moment that she starts her period. It is at this moment that the true story begins, as she runs out of the car mortified, into the woods, where she encounters the vicious wolf and finds the strength to fight back. The next day, she finds out that one of the boys at her school has been killed in the woods, but it can’t have been Bisou…can it?
I honestly can’t go into too much more of this story without spoiling some major plot points, but what I can tell you is that it is a story that sinks its claws in and doesn’t let go. Arnold doesn’t hesitate in viscerally describing a young woman’s menstrual cycle. There is no shame in the act, and I found something so liberating about seeing how this is used as an empowering tool throughout the story. Bisou is learning about her body, and that is completely okay. Consent is another topic that is also thoroughly discussed in this book, and let me tell you, I was definitely here for some of the softer boys that Elana K. Arnold presented to us.
This story handles the topic of toxic masculinity very well in my opinion, particularly in how it affects young women. From vilifying young women for their sexual nature or for speaking out against their aggressors, we get to focus on how it affects women. More importantly, I got to see what happens when women support each other in the face of this. It was so strengthening to see the female friendships develop in this way. There were a couple of moments that I found questionable,but overall, this story was amazing.
Something that I didn’t love about this story was in the way that something was addressed. I honestly can’t say more than this without spoiling the story, but I just think if it had been framed in a different way it might have made the story better. While I loved how this story is told, I can also say that it may be off-putting to some readers. Which is okay, but I think everyone who is even remotely interested and wouldn’t be triggered should read this.
This story is a 9/10 for me. It’s captivating and empowering, striving to show women to support one another and fight alongside each other in the face of toxic masculinity. I urge you to pick it up if you can, and definitely comment of contact me if you’d love to scream about it alongside me. Add it to your TBR!
This story can be described as bloody and brilliant. My favourite thing about Elana K. Arnold’s books is that they’re so unapologetically meant for the empowerment of young women. I relished diving into the world of Red Hood after reading Damsel, because I couldn’t wait to see what world Arnold would craft for us. She manages to turn the narrative of the Little Red Riding Hood and imbues it with the strength of a woman instead of a man. If you’re not here to see fierce women take down toxic masculinity, this might not be the book for you. However, if you’re here to see women dismantle a hostile system never meant to empower them in the first place, then you’ve come to the right place. Now, if you’re easily triggered by themes of sexual assault and murder, you might approach this book with caution. I loved this book, but I will admit that it does come on strong, but if you think you can handle it, I highly recommend that you add this to your TBR.
Bisou Martel has been in her grandmother’s care since she was four years old. They’ve lived a nice and quiet life in Seattle, but on the night of Homecoming, she finds herself running for her life in the woods, chased by a wolf with a mouth full of teeth and vicious claws. Bisou fights back, and as the new moon rises, so do questions about the blood in her veins and on her hands. She’ll navigate through broken boys and vicious wolves, and the lost girls who are afraid, but not alone. This isn’t the bedtime story that I grew up reading, that’s for certain.
Despite the modern setting, Red Hood holds a similar storytelling to Damsel, one that makes you feel as though you’re in a dream. Our narrator, Bisou, is getting ready for the Homecoming Dance with her boyfriend of six months. Parties aren’t really her thing, and she doesn’t care for some of the guys that on her boyfriend’s basketball team, but she’s willing to put that to the side to hang out with him. After the dance she and her boyfriend head into the woods where things begin to get heated, but it’s at that moment that she starts her period. It is at this moment that the true story begins, as she runs out of the car mortified, into the woods, where she encounters the vicious wolf and finds the strength to fight back. The next day, she finds out that one of the boys at her school has been killed in the woods, but it can’t have been Bisou…can it?
I honestly can’t go into too much more of this story without spoiling some major plot points, but what I can tell you is that it is a story that sinks its claws in and doesn’t let go. Arnold doesn’t hesitate in viscerally describing a young woman’s menstrual cycle. There is no shame in the act, and I found something so liberating about seeing how this is used as an empowering tool throughout the story. Bisou is learning about her body, and that is completely okay. Consent is another topic that is also thoroughly discussed in this book, and let me tell you, I was definitely here for some of the softer boys that Elana K. Arnold presented to us.
This story handles the topic of toxic masculinity very well in my opinion, particularly in how it affects young women. From vilifying young women for their sexual nature or for speaking out against their aggressors, we get to focus on how it affects women. More importantly, I got to see what happens when women support each other in the face of this. It was so strengthening to see the female friendships develop in this way. There were a couple of moments that I found questionable,but overall, this story was amazing.
Something that I didn’t love about this story was in the way that something was addressed. I honestly can’t say more than this without spoiling the story, but I just think if it had been framed in a different way it might have made the story better. While I loved how this story is told, I can also say that it may be off-putting to some readers. Which is okay, but I think everyone who is even remotely interested and wouldn’t be triggered should read this.
This story is a 9/10 for me. It’s captivating and empowering, striving to show women to support one another and fight alongside each other in the face of toxic masculinity. I urge you to pick it up if you can, and definitely comment of contact me if you’d love to scream about it alongside me. Add it to your TBR!
May 5, 2021
4 Stars for Red Hood (audiobook) by Elena K. Arnold read by January LaVoy. This was a really twisted tale. It was oddly gory, dark and violent. But I still liked it. I don’t know who I would recommend it too though. My favorite part was the narration. January LaVoy always does a wonderful job.
April 18, 2020
Gross.. so gross, but weirdly good?
Red Hood was an interesting retelling book. In it, you will meet Bisou who lives with her grandmother in Seattle. At first, I was a bit shocked with what was happening but then I quickly got over that and was fully invested in this book.
It all begins with Homecoming night. Like all good stories, Bisou is being running for her life in the woods. She is being chased by a vicious wolf.. or so it seems. Let's backtrack though, she went to the dance with her boyfriend of six months. They leave to go to the woods, because who wouldn't?, and things start to get hot and heavy. Or do they?
Sucks to suck but this girl starts her period right then and there. I would've been extremely embarrassed, like she was, and probably would've ran away like she did. Now that we are all caught up, she is being chased by a wolf. She eventually finds a way to defeat the wolf and goes home to an unsuspected grandmother.
Trust me guys, this book was so good. Again, weirdly good. It was definitely interesting to see these guys turn into vicious wolves when it comes to girls. Then to see them support and stand up with one another when it came to these decisions put a smile on my face. I, of course, had questions about some stuff happening in this book but I don't want to spoil too much of it.
In the end, definitely happy I got my hands on this book!
Red Hood was an interesting retelling book. In it, you will meet Bisou who lives with her grandmother in Seattle. At first, I was a bit shocked with what was happening but then I quickly got over that and was fully invested in this book.
It all begins with Homecoming night. Like all good stories, Bisou is being running for her life in the woods. She is being chased by a vicious wolf.. or so it seems. Let's backtrack though, she went to the dance with her boyfriend of six months. They leave to go to the woods, because who wouldn't?, and things start to get hot and heavy. Or do they?
Sucks to suck but this girl starts her period right then and there. I would've been extremely embarrassed, like she was, and probably would've ran away like she did. Now that we are all caught up, she is being chased by a wolf. She eventually finds a way to defeat the wolf and goes home to an unsuspected grandmother.
Trust me guys, this book was so good. Again, weirdly good. It was definitely interesting to see these guys turn into vicious wolves when it comes to girls. Then to see them support and stand up with one another when it came to these decisions put a smile on my face. I, of course, had questions about some stuff happening in this book but I don't want to spoil too much of it.
In the end, definitely happy I got my hands on this book!
February 10, 2020
2.5
Issues I Had With This Book
* Why the 2nd Person?: I feel like if you are going to write a book in 2nd person, there should be some impact but I didn't feel it here.
* I See What You're Doing Here: My friend and I were reading this at the same time and she pointed out how Arnold is teaching teens how to do stuff such as make tea and put on a condom. And although some teens do get sex ed in books and I didn't find anything wrong with teaching, I just wish Arnold could have found a more clever way of doing this.
-Arnold also used her protagonist to teach girls that it's okay to like sex and bread and once again, great on the message but it was painfully obvious what she was doing which made the writing simple. I know I'm an adult reading a teen book but books should transcend age and the writing is too simple and it won't challenge readers of any age. Maybe it's not supposed to challenge us, I don't know.
-I've never read anything else by Arnold but I'm guessing she likes to shock people to get them to pay attention. I'm a teen librarian and I don't think teens need shock value to make them pay attention or feel secure in the fact that they menstruate and that it's not gross. Once again, THERE MUST BE A BETTER WAY TO TALK ABOUT THIS.
Basically, I'm saying that I didn't like the writing style.
* That Message Tho: I had a problem with the message of, just kill them and that will eliminate your problem. I have a bit of an unhealthy obsession with serial killers and one thing they have in common is that they kill people with no remorse. So when I read books about people/teens who kill with no remorse, I instantly think they are a serial killer and I feel no sympathy for their character. I'm not justifying what the boys did but THERE MUST BE A BETTER WAY TO SEEK JUSTICE. Bisou at one point says something like we should teach boys not to become wolves-YES!!! YESS!! Go with that, please. But no, that line was in there because someone had to say it and get that out of the way to make room for more killing.
What I Liked About This Book
* I appreciate the attempt
Overall
This book was incredibly slow, I didn't like any of the characters, the writing was not special, and I hated the message. I don't think I will buy this book for my collection because I didn't like the message. I read another book about toxic masculinity written by a man, Lamar Giles, and it was much better than this one.
Issues I Had With This Book
* Why the 2nd Person?: I feel like if you are going to write a book in 2nd person, there should be some impact but I didn't feel it here.
* I See What You're Doing Here: My friend and I were reading this at the same time and she pointed out how Arnold is teaching teens how to do stuff such as make tea and put on a condom. And although some teens do get sex ed in books and I didn't find anything wrong with teaching, I just wish Arnold could have found a more clever way of doing this.
-Arnold also used her protagonist to teach girls that it's okay to like sex and bread and once again, great on the message but it was painfully obvious what she was doing which made the writing simple. I know I'm an adult reading a teen book but books should transcend age and the writing is too simple and it won't challenge readers of any age. Maybe it's not supposed to challenge us, I don't know.
-I've never read anything else by Arnold but I'm guessing she likes to shock people to get them to pay attention. I'm a teen librarian and I don't think teens need shock value to make them pay attention or feel secure in the fact that they menstruate and that it's not gross. Once again, THERE MUST BE A BETTER WAY TO TALK ABOUT THIS.
Basically, I'm saying that I didn't like the writing style.
* That Message Tho: I had a problem with the message of, just kill them and that will eliminate your problem. I have a bit of an unhealthy obsession with serial killers and one thing they have in common is that they kill people with no remorse. So when I read books about people/teens who kill with no remorse, I instantly think they are a serial killer and I feel no sympathy for their character. I'm not justifying what the boys did but THERE MUST BE A BETTER WAY TO SEEK JUSTICE. Bisou at one point says something like we should teach boys not to become wolves-YES!!! YESS!! Go with that, please. But no, that line was in there because someone had to say it and get that out of the way to make room for more killing.
What I Liked About This Book
* I appreciate the attempt
Overall
This book was incredibly slow, I didn't like any of the characters, the writing was not special, and I hated the message. I don't think I will buy this book for my collection because I didn't like the message. I read another book about toxic masculinity written by a man, Lamar Giles, and it was much better than this one.
October 24, 2019
Spectacular!
I received an e-ARC from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. Review can be found on *Milky Way of Books*
Dear Lord this review is a hard one to write. Not because the book was bad, but because it was SO DAMN GOOD!
I knew after reading "Damsel" that Elana would do the same with Red Hood too: deconstruct the fairytale and give to the readers the spirit of the story set in the real world: that everywhere there are predators and sometimes women have to fight back and become equally as predatory as the ones who hunt them.
Bisou Martel lives with her grandmother in a quiet town. She has a loving boyfriend but when at the party of her high school something goes wrong, Bisou wakes up the next day with the news that a boy from her school was killed in the woods.
But Bisou had only seen a wolf hunting her.
This story is about rights: the right to love your body as it is, the right to defend yourself, the right to have friends despite the different backgrounds. And above all? The right to your body from having your period to deciding when you want to make love with the one you choose to.
Bisou passes through the emotional rollercoaster any teenager has been through but in a toxic environment in school. With boys feeling entitled to anything they want, quiet girls trying to overcome trauma and sweet boyfriends who are supportive.
The grandma was also a surprise as we also get to read her story too. The entire book is written in the second POV and personally I didn't mind because I felt like I was being the one addressed to.
I loved the symbolism and the slight touch of paranormal in the plot, which made it even more realistic and damn scary. Because all of you know that the world isn't always as safe as we hope it is and that you can never know what can happen to any of us.
Red Hood is a spectacular symbolic story and Elana has again outdone herself in this one!
I received an e-ARC from Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review. Review can be found on *Milky Way of Books*
Dear Lord this review is a hard one to write. Not because the book was bad, but because it was SO DAMN GOOD!
I knew after reading "Damsel" that Elana would do the same with Red Hood too: deconstruct the fairytale and give to the readers the spirit of the story set in the real world: that everywhere there are predators and sometimes women have to fight back and become equally as predatory as the ones who hunt them.
Bisou Martel lives with her grandmother in a quiet town. She has a loving boyfriend but when at the party of her high school something goes wrong, Bisou wakes up the next day with the news that a boy from her school was killed in the woods.
But Bisou had only seen a wolf hunting her.
This story is about rights: the right to love your body as it is, the right to defend yourself, the right to have friends despite the different backgrounds. And above all? The right to your body from having your period to deciding when you want to make love with the one you choose to.
Bisou passes through the emotional rollercoaster any teenager has been through but in a toxic environment in school. With boys feeling entitled to anything they want, quiet girls trying to overcome trauma and sweet boyfriends who are supportive.
The grandma was also a surprise as we also get to read her story too. The entire book is written in the second POV and personally I didn't mind because I felt like I was being the one addressed to.
I loved the symbolism and the slight touch of paranormal in the plot, which made it even more realistic and damn scary. Because all of you know that the world isn't always as safe as we hope it is and that you can never know what can happen to any of us.
Red Hood is a spectacular symbolic story and Elana has again outdone herself in this one!
June 7, 2020
Poetic, unusual, powerful. A gritty Little Red Riding Hood with strong messages of consent, and the power of friendship as well as the power of femininity. If you think about it too hard, with regards to world-building, as you would with a regular fantasy, it doesn't answer a lot of "How" questions. But that's irrelevant. It's more of a prose poem about womanhood than anything else.
But although I am all for demystifying periods, I really, and I mean really, do not need actual details about changing tampons. I mean, for teenage girls who might be wondering "Is this normal?" sure. Judy Blume never gave me THESE kinds of details. But where I am in life, and with my frequently reading while I eat, I was not the biggest fan of a couple of the, um, gory details. So just consider yourself warned.
This is definitely for older teens, content-wise, but NOT just for girls. The frank talk about consent, not to mention the double standard exhibited, and talk about "incels" and stalking, is for everyone.
But although I am all for demystifying periods, I really, and I mean really, do not need actual details about changing tampons. I mean, for teenage girls who might be wondering "Is this normal?" sure. Judy Blume never gave me THESE kinds of details. But where I am in life, and with my frequently reading while I eat, I was not the biggest fan of a couple of the, um, gory details. So just consider yourself warned.
This is definitely for older teens, content-wise, but NOT just for girls. The frank talk about consent, not to mention the double standard exhibited, and talk about "incels" and stalking, is for everyone.
February 28, 2021
Brilliant
This was incredible. I love all Elana K. Arnold's book, of course. But I really enjoyed this one.
The rage this book has.
And the way it viscerally deals with menstruation!
Incredible.
I've seen reviews that argue this book is encouraging violence against men and/or rapists, and that it's transphobic.
It's really, really not. Do some rapists and abusers die? Yeah. But they die while (and this is, I feel, the important part) hurting women, and they die because Bisou is trying to save herself, or others. It's not anywhere near as simple as these reviewers make it out to be, I would argue. And I'm saying that, as a CSA survivor, while I wouldn't want my abuser murdered by a wolf-hunter, personally, I wouldn't blame those who WOULD and DO want THEIR abusers dead. You know? I'm reminded of that Mona Eltahawy question: how many rapists must we kill before THEY'RE afraid of US? Not necessarily advocating violence, and yet.
Also, the transphobia thing...like, if you're a trans person, and you felt it was transphobic? I'm listening. But you cis reviewers...it feels like you're trying to gain points. Which is maybe unfair. But as a trans person who used to menstruate, I didn't think the connection between Bisou's powers and her period was transphobic for one reason. Never is it implied that women = periods = women. So maybe that's a thing that you personally have to get over. Within the context of the book, there's no reason to think that trans people couldn't have these powers.
Do I wish this included trans people? Maybe. But also... I'd feel weird about a cis author writing something like this book about trans people. It feels like that sort of story should BE for trans people.
But to get back to the actual book? I loved it. I loved the rage at what men get away with, I loved the female friendship, I loved the intergenerational love, just, man, everything about Red Hood was great.
Is it my new favourite? I'm not sure. But that's really not a fair judgement to make, because I love all her books since Infandous equally, in so many different ways.
This was incredible. I love all Elana K. Arnold's book, of course. But I really enjoyed this one.
The rage this book has.
And the way it viscerally deals with menstruation!
Incredible.
I've seen reviews that argue this book is encouraging violence against men and/or rapists, and that it's transphobic.
It's really, really not. Do some rapists and abusers die? Yeah. But they die while (and this is, I feel, the important part) hurting women, and they die because Bisou is trying to save herself, or others. It's not anywhere near as simple as these reviewers make it out to be, I would argue. And I'm saying that, as a CSA survivor, while I wouldn't want my abuser murdered by a wolf-hunter, personally, I wouldn't blame those who WOULD and DO want THEIR abusers dead. You know? I'm reminded of that Mona Eltahawy question: how many rapists must we kill before THEY'RE afraid of US? Not necessarily advocating violence, and yet.
Also, the transphobia thing...like, if you're a trans person, and you felt it was transphobic? I'm listening. But you cis reviewers...it feels like you're trying to gain points. Which is maybe unfair. But as a trans person who used to menstruate, I didn't think the connection between Bisou's powers and her period was transphobic for one reason. Never is it implied that women = periods = women. So maybe that's a thing that you personally have to get over. Within the context of the book, there's no reason to think that trans people couldn't have these powers.
Do I wish this included trans people? Maybe. But also... I'd feel weird about a cis author writing something like this book about trans people. It feels like that sort of story should BE for trans people.
But to get back to the actual book? I loved it. I loved the rage at what men get away with, I loved the female friendship, I loved the intergenerational love, just, man, everything about Red Hood was great.
Is it my new favourite? I'm not sure. But that's really not a fair judgement to make, because I love all her books since Infandous equally, in so many different ways.
December 5, 2020
Imagine if you just barely escaped one of the most embarrassing moments of your life to find yourself at the mercy of claws and teeth. You're running through the forest, but you know in your heart that you aren't fast enough to escape the wolf. You turn around and make a stand as adrenaline courses through your veins and a sense of purpose washes over you. The wolf is dead at your feet.
The first thing that stood out to me about this book was the second person POV. Very few books I have ever read have done a second person POV well, and I'm not sure if this was the best one I've ever read, but it was damn well interesting.
That hint of mystery and intrigue that automatically comes with a point of view that puts you in the shoes of the narrator coupled with the message of the book drew me in instantly. I could not firmly say whether I thought that all aspects of the book were amazing; neither would I advocate for everybody to read this book. I don't think everyone will appreciate it. But I sure as hell got something from it, and I think a lot of people will as well.
I wouldn't label this book as satisfying either. I came out of it feeling slightly unsettled. But I definitely didn't dislike that feeling. Ultimately it is up to you whether you're willing to push your boundaries a little, especially if you go in expecting a werewolf YA book. It's not that. However, if you go in with an open mind, you'll come out of it with something new.
And I'm out.
The first thing that stood out to me about this book was the second person POV. Very few books I have ever read have done a second person POV well, and I'm not sure if this was the best one I've ever read, but it was damn well interesting.
That hint of mystery and intrigue that automatically comes with a point of view that puts you in the shoes of the narrator coupled with the message of the book drew me in instantly. I could not firmly say whether I thought that all aspects of the book were amazing; neither would I advocate for everybody to read this book. I don't think everyone will appreciate it. But I sure as hell got something from it, and I think a lot of people will as well.
I wouldn't label this book as satisfying either. I came out of it feeling slightly unsettled. But I definitely didn't dislike that feeling. Ultimately it is up to you whether you're willing to push your boundaries a little, especially if you go in expecting a werewolf YA book. It's not that. However, if you go in with an open mind, you'll come out of it with something new.
And I'm out.
June 8, 2020
Three reasons to not give 3 stars:
1. Second person POV. (Really I can't bear the second person narrations).
2. Start was so slow.
3. Couldn't bring myself to agree with the feminism part which the author tries to narrate through this story.
1. Second person POV. (Really I can't bear the second person narrations).
2. Start was so slow.
3. Couldn't bring myself to agree with the feminism part which the author tries to narrate through this story.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 993 reviews