Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Europe and the Roma: A History of Fascination and Fear

Rate this book
‘A magisterial contribution to the understanding of the cultural position of Romani people in Europe. … nothing short of astounding’ Literary Review

This remarkable book describes a dark side of European the rejection of the Roma from their initial arrival in the late Middle Ages to the present day. To Europeans, the Roma appeared to be in complete contradiction with their own culture, because of their mysterious origins, unknown language and way of life. As representatives of an oral culture, for centuries the Roma have left virtually no written records of their own. Their history has been conveyed to us almost exclusively through the distorted images that European cultures project.

Persecuted and shunned, the Roma nonetheless spread out across the continent and became an important, indeed indispensable element in the European imagination. It is impossible to conceive of the culture of Spain, southern France and much of Central Europe without this pervasive Romani influence.

Europe and the Roma brilliantly describes the 'fascination and fear' which have marked Europeans' response to the Romani presence. Countless composers, artists and writers have responded to Romani culture and to fantasies thereof. Their projections onto a group whose illiteracy and marginalization gave it so little direct voice of its own have always been a very uneasy mixture of the inspired, the patronizing and the frighteningly ignorant. The book also shows the link between cultural violence, social discrimination and racist policies that paved the way for the genocide of the Roma.

608 pages, Hardcover

Published September 29, 2023

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Klaus-Michael Bogdal

28 books1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7 (25%)
4 stars
9 (32%)
3 stars
9 (32%)
2 stars
2 (7%)
1 star
1 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews
Profile Image for Pedram.
20 reviews
January 14, 2026
Terrific book about the most forgotten group in Europe and their (in some countries ongoing) system exclusion and expulsion. Sometimes deeply depressing but mostly deeply interesting.
Profile Image for Jess.
49 reviews9 followers
October 13, 2025
I’d been waiting for the English translation of this book for a while and it’s pretty good! Some typos and odd grammatical structures here and there but in general I think Jefferson Chase did a good job with it.

This book is immensely well researched. It’s dense, but that’s a reflection of the seriousness of the topic.

Satan’s minions is a particularly sharp chapter with an erudite range of sources consulted. It leads very well into the next chapter focusing on gendered stereotypes and the typical sexualisation of women. Dense with detail, rich with feeling, it could easily be a superb standalone monograph. The same goes for the chapter on Europe’s romanticism of gypsies, which is equally powerful. A clear image emerges of the way Europeans have, in the last 600 years, thought about the other, which is the real beating heart of this study.

Tracing the early slide into anti-gypsy rhetoric emerging across early modern literature, Bogdal says:

‘The pamphlets reinterpret what in historical reality was a process of stigmatisation into self-stigmatisation. Depicting them exclusively as engaging in deceitful and criminal practices – soothsaying, quack doctoring, moral transgressions, promiscuity and blasphemy – suggested that the lives of this marginalised group were inherently inimical to the values of Christian society and that it indeed revelled in disregard for and mockery of Christianity.’

This is, I think, a neat encapsulation of what this book is showing and what it’s for. It doesn’t matter whether the societal values in question are Christian, rationalist, nationalist, or whether the behaviour of gypsies was purposely transgressive or a symptom of personal, moral, or societal failure.

Marginalised groups rarely have the chance to speak for themselves. Who they are and what they represent becomes determined by the majority, and the majority are cruel. They are patronising and suspicious and angry and lustful. They create the underlying sense that the other lies, without giving them the chance to do so in the first place.

Bogdal shows time and time again that the mainstream didn’t much care whether the story of Roma having an Egyptian origin is true or not. Realistically, it doesn’t actually matter – cultural and ethnic origin are largely social stories, and the Roma were not permitted to control their own story. Without response, then, the European paranoia feeds a cycle of growing hate and a sense of ahistorical predictability. It was always like this. They were always like that. We’ve always been the victim.

Wherever there is hate, there is always there’s that through-line of fascination.

Cervantes’ free and passionate Little Gypsy Girl is Crusoe’s noble savage Friday is Puccini’s tragic and submissive Madame Butterfly. They’re desirable, doomed, and defined entirely by European fantasy. The mainstream who control the narrative revel in being subversive and using these marginalised figures to explore the fantasies and concerns of a literate, mostly urban, overwhelmingly male audience.

Did gypsies read Cervantes? Did they identify with the idea that to be a gypsy gives a freedom from modern concerns?

Bogdal’s cutting analysis shows that even progressive, sympathetic views come from the same milieu of fascination and fear combined. In a society that uses gypsies as a stock image through which to explore the mainstream’s concerns, integrationists saw them as souls to save or societal problems to solve. There were also those who held them up as guardians of some esoteric magics or font of a more primitive, pure life.

These mystical woo-ey types of authors were surely not motivated by hate in the crudest sense, not like the more mask-off racists Bogdal also covers. But consider the casual dehumanisation of ascribing a single function – guardian of magics or pure folklore – to a real and diverse cultural group. Compare it to the patronising elements underlying the ‘magical negro’ or ‘magical disabled’ tropes. This lionisation doesn’t come from a genuine place. It doesn’t centre the Roma people and their culture. It creates a flattening mono-cultural myth to uphold what’s important to the non-Roma repeating it.

Once Bogdal gets to eras with a strong documented history, the early 1800s and beyond, a new dimension emerges. Through the first half of the book, Bogdal is concerned with the image of gypsies in the European mind which is why his survey is so heavy on literature. He’s not concerned with answering the question of genuine ethnic roots or anything like that. He is interested in what beliefs about those roots were, how they manifested, how they added to or changed the way people thought about Roma. But once we reach the 1800s a new kind of story starts to be introduced. This starts with Maximilian Heine, a German doctor who wrote in a travelogue about buying a ten year old Roma girl in Bulgaria.

These real stories, dropped in amongst Bogdal’s analysis of poems and novels, are deeply horrifying. They start to underscore how dehumanising the construction of the gypsy in literature was, and what such an unreal caricature did to the European minds consuming them.

Bogdal’s unrelenting narrative puts these horrors of racism, human trafficking, and societal violence right in front of you, and you cannot duck out of the way.

You’re really confronted with the way people can think and speak about other people while feeling completely justified and supported by the legal and educational structures in place in their society. So Johann Schwicker, a professor, historian, and member of the Hungarian parliament who was considered groundbreaking in his study of gypsies in Hungary could say un-self consciously:

‘When judging the intellectual and moral conditions of a people without culture, the cultured person quickly runs the risk of reaching slanted conclusions because it is thoroughly difficult to put oneself on the level of “primitive natural people” to be evaluated.’

And he could go on to dismiss Roma as being possessed of an:

‘…expression of dullness, lack of intellectual activity and absence of emotion that naturally appears in the animalistic nature of such a crude people.’

The careful research to compile example after example means that it’s impossible to dismiss the ideas being presented as peculiar to one particular person or country. Bogdal has put in the effort and it really shows, and hurts, and is hard to read.

When it especially starts hitting is the chapter Enemies of Society.

Generally speaking, Bogdal doesn’t give any historical context and focuses hard on literary development. He is talking about an unreal, imagined people in the world of literature, the ‘gypsy’. In this chapter, though, he starts talking about how that literature fed into Nazi ideology and he suddenly switches to using the term Roma.

It all kind of crashes down that all the hundreds of literary gypsies discussed through the book were building up to and informing this nadir of extermination and hate. Because the literary figures being hurt and killed and hated are gypsies, characters in a fantasy land, but the real people being exterminated are Roma. When the Nazis set up a ‘Reich Centre for Gypsy Affairs’ and classified people as ‘racially pure Gypsies’, ‘half-breeds’ and ‘vagabond people in the Gypsy sense’ they are talking about a fantasy image of an invented racial group. But this research, and the identification documents they produced, ‘would be used later to intern Romani people in concentration camps and send them to Auschwitz-Birkenau’ for real.

Bogdal makes the point that though there is a ‘growing fictional interest in Romani history since the start of the 1960s’, this interest is hardly based in real interest in the plight of the people. Modern works harken back to the tired tropes of a nomadic, mystical, ethnically and psychologically alien people on the fringes of society. Stories are most often set conspicuously pre-war and the gypsy is still used as a fantastical figure, even when positively portrayed, to criticise modernity or industrialisation. Worse, they are sometimes used as a sympathetic outsider group to discriminate against other groups, such as in Cramer where positive depictions of gypsies are used as a way to launder anti-semitism.

European writers generally fail to preserve or explore memories of the post-war persecution and genocide of Roma for their own sake. Clearly there’s the genre of genocide-denial, but Bogdal also criticises nominally sympathetic works for falling into traps such as echoing ethnological lore or romanticising the supposed hardiness of gypsy life. Though anti-semitic cliches became taboo in the mainstream following the Second World War, people continued to use gypsy stereotypes uncritically. Zoli, as an example of a deeply sympathetic and careful work by a non-Roma author, receives an extended analysis but despite the positives Bogdal also sees a raft of limitations, unconscious signals from an author seeing gypsies as a stereotyped monoculture and personal liberation as in conflict with authenticity.

The final chapter concludes with real passion on the importance of centring living voices to reshape the narrative and break away from the false gypsy literature figure. Bogdal shows a gentle consideration of cases where Roma are not able to speak for themselves, whether because of the pain of dragging up traumatic memories, the fear of vulnerability, concern about unreceptive or aggressive audience, or a wish to remain positive. He is even careful with cases of Roma who outright destroyed evidence and records of what had been done to them, citing the case of the attorney of the Central Council of Sinti and Roma in Germany who destroyed tapes recording Roma Holocaust survivors’ stories. In his words:

‘…remembrance is not just the recollection of past events, but an arena of conflict concerning the interpretation of history and the finding of individual and collective identity.’

Further, unlike other groups targeted in the Holocaust, the two figures most responsible for the persecution of the Roma, Ritter and Justin, continued to work after the war and were never charged with their crimes. In Ritter’s case, in 1949 an investigation into his crimes was started in Frankfurt but the case was dismissed as it was concluded that statements made by gypsies should not be believed. Planned charges against Justin in 1960 and 1964 were dropped due to the statute of limitations and ‘insufficient evidence’. If Roma could not trust society to treat them fairly in the wake of a documented, brutal, and targeted genocide, why should they trust an outsider with their stories? How might an outsider twist what they have to say, and even use their own words to hurt them further?

Therefore many Roma have collectively felt deep shame over the way they have been treated in the last century and feared sharing their experience. They may have chosen, as Otto Rosenberg first advised his daughter Marianne, to hide their heritage and never speak of what had happened. However, over the decades and spurred by the civil rights movement in Germany there is now a powerful body of remembrance literature to engage with, which Bogdal treats sensitively and at length. Even in recent works, persecution, genocide, and fear of loss are repeated themes, as is the sense that what was done to the Roma people has created a generational trauma that dislocated people and communities so thoroughly that the victims’ childrens’ children still suffer. It is hard, hard reading.

I tried to take this book on holiday but the second I started reading about Holocaust literature on the plane I felt sick and couldn’t touch it for the whole week. Be wary.

I would have loved a little more analysis on why and how cultural attitudes towards Roma shifted so quickly from towns offering to bury nearby deceased ‘little Egyptian Lords’ to ‘I will kill you with a gun for being poor’. There’s also definitely room for some interrogation of how the Reformation shifted the cultural onus from charity and good works to personal qualities and poverty as a choice rather than a social problem.

A bit more historical context in the early phases would have also strengthened Bogdal’s arguments because it underlines the difference between the treatment of Roma and Jews, who were singled out by both Reformation and Counter-Reformation forces as special targets via ghettoisation and censorship. Jews were seen as a nation within a nation and feared for their encroachment on middle class – even highly respected – professions. Roma were seen as liars and tricksters who claimed no nationhood, and were hated because of a horror of an urban underclass that did not aspire to join society.

Equally, though sprinkled mention to the treatment of Jews, black people, Polynesians, and native Americans are useful, they don’t add any depth – yet.

I fully accept that to do any kind of true comparative analysis is well beyond the scope of this book. Indeed, Bogdal’s book will be crucial source material on which many future scholars will draw in order to make those deeper historical or cross-cultural analyses I’m looking for. It’s really a testament to Bogdal’s learnedness that I wanted him to write the dozen books that must surely spinoff from his research already. Give me more!

This book is also inevitably quite German-centric and especially once the narrative hits the 20th century it becomes almost completely focussed on German art and literature. For example, in the last chapter Bogdal makes a really interesting point that later autobiographical works by European Roma who lived outside the grip of the Nazis, such as English Roma Silvester Boswell, do not mention the Holocaust or seem interested in what was happening to their fellow Roma during that time period. This is despite the fact that it was the stuttering progressive movements that developed in reaction to the horror of WW2 that created a cultural landscape where Roma authors could publish their autobiographies. However, Bogdal doesn’t go any further into this idea other than to mention it in the first place, which is a real shame. It’s surely quite interesting that there would be a split between those who see their Roma-ness as a collective identity and collective struggle versus those who see it as very much local and clan-centric.

There’s so much more to review and pick from out of this era so I understand the need to be selective; it just narrows the focus a little. Once again, though, this isn’t so much of a weakness of Bogdal’s work as it is making room for parallel works that will focus on, for example, the Roma in England 1900-2025.

The narrative, especially in the early chapters, jumps around eras a little too readily, as can be expected for a literature survey book. Sometimes two examples are given to show a certain developing attitude, but the centuries between them make it a little bit of a false comparison.

I wish Chase or Bogdal or whoever made this decision didn’t translate the names of all the works cited because trying to look something up would be made more difficult because no one calls it that. And god, did I appreciate that the translator has tried to retain the verse/rhyming elements of many of the original texts? Did I fuck.

Trying to do this often renders the quoted content unspeakably mangled. If you find yourself rhyming ‘peace’ with ‘communities’, stop it. Get some help.

If you’re not ready to confront some things in literature you may love dearly, this is going to be an impossible read.

The gypsy trope is so widespread and has such a history, as laid out repetitively and mercilessly through this book, that it’s infected multiple genres through and through. One of the genres most commonly afflicted in modern writing is fantasy, where the gypsy is a common archetype – caravan, drums, and mysticism in hand.

For me it was almost with a sense of dread that I kept being reminded of the depiction of the Tuatha’an in the Wheel of Time. They, and their relationship to and history shared with the Aiel, is genuinely one of my favourite bits about probably my favourite series of all time.

So to constantly have it hammered home how much the tropes and literary elements of the Tuatha’an culture are based on centuries of awful anti-Roma racism was painful.

Jordan wasn’t consciously choosing tropes to be harmful, nor would he have known what sources he was drawing on, I think, but Bogdal’s point is very clear. Few writers are versed in the complete literature history of their subjects. Most only reflect a cultural milieu of ideas. Where that culture is violent and awful, the depictions of certain groups will most often reflect that even when the author themselves is thoughtful and not filled with hate. Bogdal also doesn’t sugarcoat anything and is quite openly dismissive of writers who rely on the tropes he describes. In places he refers to them as second-rate writers, or lazy.

It really hurts to have the veil so forcibly pulled back. If you’re not ready to think about your favourite fantasy novels too closely, you’re not ready for this book. You’ll probably feel that it makes its point too often and too forcefully, and hey – what if an author uses a trope but what they write is actually good? Is that such a crime? God, can anyone even write anything anymore?

This is a ferocious piece of scholarship. It’s relentless, unapologetically sharp, and unflinching in its pursuit of uncomfortable truths.

Rather than offering a gentle cultural history, Bogdal dissects centuries of European literature, art, and pseudoscience to expose the persistent construction of the literary gypsy as a convenient fantasy figure. Rather than a history of the Roma people, it’s a history of how Europe imagined and used them, often cruelly, to define itself.

What makes this book truly impactful is how utterly uncompromising it is. Bogdal doesn’t pull punches or hide behind academic detachment. Even progressive or Romantic portrayals are shown to stem from the same system of objectification and control. It’s a tough, often painful read, especially for those who may be unwilling to examine how these narratives still echo today. But it’s also a vital one. Consider this absolutely essential for anyone ready to confront how deep anti-Roma racism runs in Europe’s cultural DNA.

See my full review here: https://open.substack.com/pub/jesswal...
Profile Image for History Today.
321 reviews221 followers
Read
October 11, 2023
Ethnic and cultural difference was, in late 19th-century Europe, of keen interest to scholars and the public alike. When, for instance, a Roma group made camp near Berlin in 1885, tourists sought it out, driven by curiosity. The Berlin camp was not unique; across Europe photographers, artists, grammarians and others took interest in the Roma. In Hungary and Romania, folklorists took the summer air and observed Roma life. In Britain, a travelling Romani family found themselves the focus of so much attention that they struggled to keep visitors out of their tents at mealtimes. One member of this family, Lazzy Smith, decided to make Romani culture visible to non-Romanies on his own terms by offering a pay-to-view experience. He famously appeared at the 1886 Liverpool International Exhibition and published an accompanying pamphlet.

Klaus-Michael Bogdal’s Europe and the Roma is, largely, a history of the Roma people’s battle to tell their own story on their own terms. And it is a battle: who these people were, what it meant to be Roma, and what that meant for the rest of society are questions that have been perennially caught in the tides of European politics since the late Middle Ages. For at least 600 years, diverse groups such as the Sinti, Calé, Manouches and Kalderash have been categorised, simply, as ‘gypsies’ and alien to European civilisation. (Bogdal uses a lowercase ‘g’ to indicate an exonymous cultural construction, but ‘Gypsy’ refers to a legally recognised ethnicity in the UK and is usually capitalised.) The book pushes against the tired assumption that the Roma then, as now, face a simple choice: assimilate, or suffer as outsiders.

Read the rest of the review at HistoryToday.com.

Jodie Matthews is Professor of Literature at the University of Huddersfield.
Profile Image for Petras.
83 reviews66 followers
November 18, 2025
It turned out that the book was mostly a review if how Roma people are portrayed in Western European literature, while I was expecting a wider historical research.
Profile Image for Manuel.
136 reviews1 follower
August 5, 2026
More of an overview of literature about Roma than a history. Interesting, but at times (understandably given the continuous discrimination against Roma) monotonous.
Displaying 1 - 7 of 7 reviews