Reviews of: Il Diavolo by Andrea Joy, Caged in Shadows by Amy Thorn, His Revenge by Amy Davies, Nightingale by Laura Lascarso, and Below the Belt by Andi Rhodes.
Il Diavolo by Andrea Joy - 3.5 stars
This novella is hot, even if it doesn’t always make sense. The two main characters are Skyler, who appears to be part of some sort of mafia family, and Ashton, who exists on the periphery of a MC club. The novella starts with Skyler kidnapping Ashton. Why? For what purpose? As the story goes on, we find out more.I have very mixed feelings about this one. What I liked: It started out strong. The writing itself, sentence to sentence, was pretty solid. The novella was also super hot and kinky, including dubious consent, orgasm denial, and forced orgasms, among other things. Wow! The emotional connection between the characters and the sense of their shared past was really strong and moving, too. What I didn’t like: This novella was also kind of all over the place. I never fully understood the context and we were provided with way too much information about the two characters’ pasts, information that didn’t even feel relevant sometimes. Same thing with the introduction of unnecessary secondary characters and references to what is clearly other books that I haven’t read. This doesn’t make me want to read them, it just annoys me. Look, I really liked the basic story, but everything else was too much for the length and confused me. Keep. It. Simple. Please.
Caged in Shadows by Amy Thorn - 3.5 stars
This was an MC romance that felt like it was part of a bigger context. Fortunately, it was still easy enough to understand. The two main characters are Shakespeare, a member of an MC whose wife and children were killed horribly by a drunk driver. Shakespeare impulsively decides to kidnap the son of that driver, a young man named Liam. However, he soon realizes that Liam is not his father, but actually has suffered too. The two of them develop feelings for each other… Even though I love MC romances, this was the gritty and OTT kind I’m not so fond of. Is the subject matter serious? Yes, there’s references to past childhood abuse and alcoholism, plus Shakespeare’s whole family was killed (including kids), there are mentions of human trafficking, etc. So it’s a mystery why in that context I could still find myself rolling my eyes. But I did. Something about the storytelling made me have trouble taking it seriously and jerked me out of the narrative. Sure, this kept my attention and I felt like it delivered, but at the same time, I’m not exactly eager for more. I’m just not convinced that the subject matter was handled the way it deserves to be.
His Revenge by Amy Davies - 3 stars
“His Revenge,” by Amy Davies, is an intense, graphic, and dramatic romance between a mafia boss, Piero, and a damaged man who works at a restaurant Piero frequents. That man, Eli, suffered abuse as a teenager at a camp his religious parents sent him to when they found out he was gay. Piero and Eli are drawn to each other from the beginning, and the plot is mostly just the two of them coming to understand each other better and explaining their relationship. It’s a dark romance, but definitely still a romance.This starts out like a punch to the gut, with a flashback from Eli’s time at the camp. The author doesn’t hold back here or with the torture scenes that Piero commits. I actually had to skip Eli’s second dream/flash-back. This novella wasn’t what I was expecting. I thought that this would be about a damaged young man who needs coddling and the alpha male who protects him. Wrong. Eli has a dirty mouth and zero hesitation to stand up for himself or others. He’s definitely a match for Piero. I liked Piero less than Eli, mostly because he felt like a bit of a caricature of a mafia boss. Piero feels the need to always be telling us how evil he is, plus there’s an obligatory torture scene towards the beginning just to prove the point, I guess. All the talk of his “demons” got tiresome, though the “demons” metaphor did work for me when it was used to explain his emotional connection with Eli and what made them work as a couple. Unfortunately, at some point, the plot began to drag. And for a novella titled “His Revenge,” the revenge part doesn’t really kick in until the epilogue, though let me tell you, it was satisfying.
Nightingale by Laura Lascarso - 5 stars
Loved this one! It was SO good. Great writing, the way the story unfolded and we got to know the characters was perfect. This one is about two men who grew up together, beginning in an orphanage, and now have different roles in the same crime syndicate. The narrator, Kahlil, is an accountant, and he describes his relationship with Julian, the “Nightingale,” in a way that is immediate and compelling (I loved Julian so much, excellent characterization there). I really don’t want to give much away here. Let’s just say that everything from the gripping plot to the religious imagery to the bad mafia-themed jokes was amazing.
Below the Belt by Andi Rhodes - DNF
A main character who casually has homeless people killed for profit and entertainment? Just couldn’t get into that. I gave up somewhere in chapter 3.
**I received a copy of this book from Gay Romance Reviews and this is my honest review**