I’ve been trying more indie fantasy lately and asked for this one for Christmas. The Facebook advertisement I saw promised it would be Lord of the Rings meets Redwall, which is true. Unfortunately, I thought the book would lean more towards Lord of the Rings and be more of a complex, adult fantasy, but Marchwood is very much a juvenile book. The story is extremely simple and there are repetitions of character descriptions, relationships, and races in every single chapter. And I don’t just mean once or twice. EVERY time a character is mentioned for the first time in any given chapter, they are reintroduced. Same with plot points, locations, etc. I mean, I know this is a mark of juvenile fiction for especially younger readers, but as an adult reading this book, it felt extreme. I think I was just kind of shocked, and I wish the book description has made it clearer that this was a story geared towards juvenile readers.
The plot itself is simple, but also soothing as a longtime reader of fantasy. It made me nostalgic for the fantasy books I grew up reading and put me in the mood for more journey fantasies. It’s a classic tale of young friends leaving a cozy home to face dangers and rouse an army before an evil army invades. The fact this story is labeled as “cozy,” however, means not too much actually happens in this book to advance this plot. Definitely don’t expect much in the way of battles, and any fighting that does happen ends up feeling more cutesy than intense. (Picture pots banging on top of heads and such.) There are many celebrations, feasts, and travel sections, but little plot advancement towards raising armies, repairing defenses, or actually meeting any of the villains in a meaningful way. This book is definitely NOT self-contained, and one will need to read the sequels to get any kind of plot advancement.
None of this is to say Marchwood is a bad book. It is well-written, cozy, and nostalgic. However, I would only recommend it for juvenile readers or adults looking for a Redwall fix. Definitely know what you are getting into, and you will have a good time. It just wasn’t the kind of story I was looking for.