What do you think?
Rate this book
Modern Crofton #5
Starting Again at Crofton Hall
After making a decision that will change his life forever, Robin Flint arrives at Crofton Hall, looking for a place to recover and start again. Love is not enough to continue living a lie, and he now needs to decide what to do to have the future he wants and deserves.
An unexpected meeting where sparks fly was meant to be a one off, but Simon MacLove is just too wonderful to cast aside. But since Robin hadn't intended to continue things, he'd not been so forthcoming about who he really is so Simon, a local police officer, doesn't know Robin is a millionaire trust fund baby and the future Viscount Whetford. Robin has a lot of baggage, and so does Simon, so whether they can carry it together and is very much up in the air, especially as Robin’s now ex-boyfriend, movie star Dorian Marsten, hasn’t accepted things are truly over between.
Meanwhile, Ben and Ashley are still enjoying their post-honeymoon bliss, and have decided to work on the next generation of Redbourns. Only it’s not so easy when neither of them have the necessary biological equipment, meaning the road to them becoming parents isn’t going to be straightforward.
This is the fifth Modern Crofton novel. Each story features a new couple falling in love at Crofton Hall, with the continuing life and love of Ben Redbourn, 16th Earl of Crofton, and the man of his dreams, Ashley (was Niven now Redbourn).
An unexpected meeting where sparks fly was meant to be a one off, but Simon MacLove is just too wonderful to cast aside. But since Robin hadn't intended to continue things, he'd not been so forthcoming about who he really is so Simon, a local police officer, doesn't know Robin is a millionaire trust fund baby and the future Viscount Whetford. Robin has a lot of baggage, and so does Simon, so whether they can carry it together and is very much up in the air, especially as Robin’s now ex-boyfriend, movie star Dorian Marsten, hasn’t accepted things are truly over between.
Meanwhile, Ben and Ashley are still enjoying their post-honeymoon bliss, and have decided to work on the next generation of Redbourns. Only it’s not so easy when neither of them have the necessary biological equipment, meaning the road to them becoming parents isn’t going to be straightforward.
This is the fifth Modern Crofton novel. Each story features a new couple falling in love at Crofton Hall, with the continuing life and love of Ben Redbourn, 16th Earl of Crofton, and the man of his dreams, Ashley (was Niven now Redbourn).
- GenresM M Romance
339 pages, Kindle Edition
Published February 2, 2023
11 people are currently reading
43 people want to read
About the author
Rebecca Cohen
52 books228 followersREBECCA COHEN spends her days dreaming of living in a Tudor manor house, or a Georgian mansion. Alas, the closest she comes to this is through her characters in her historical romance novels. She also dreams of intergalactic adventures and fantasy realms, but because she’s not yet got her space or dimensional travel plans finalised, she lives happily in leafy Hertfordshire, England, with her husband and young son. She can often be found with a pen in one hand and sloe gin with lemon tonic in the other.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews
January 18, 2023
Robin Flint is not who you think he is.
From previous appearances in the Modern Crofton novels we may have been given the impression of a guy who floats around behind his Hollywood film star secret boyfriend, hiding in the role of Dorian's PA, and not really caring much.
But Robin's not that at all. He's a deeply wounded soul and has dealt with some serious trauma in his past which has meant he's basically pushed aside a lot of his natural personality to live in Dorian's shadow.
Here we finally get the background of how Robin ended up in LA working as Dorian's PA, the pain behind his fall from grace and just how much is too much when push comes to shove.
The story opens with a massive blow out between Robin and Dorian when the film star announces he's fake marrying his fake girlfriend who's also hiding behind her relationship because she's got her own secret girlfriend.
Robin hightails it out of Dorian's house and to a flat his family own in LA before eventually getting in touch with Ben and Ashley and heading to Crofton Hall. What follows then is a romance which is the opposite of everything Robin's ever known as he meets a local man, Simon, and discovers the joy that comes from being able to publicly demonstrate your feelings for someone.
I absolutely love the modern Crofton books (I love the historical ones too as well!) and the way Rebecca has gathered together a found family to go along with Ben's aristocratic blood one. With his staff finding love at the Hall, it's now time for his friend Robin to do the same.
With all the usual suspects on hand and a secondary plot which revolves around an incident at the Hall, what you get in this book is an exploration of how someone can take control back of their own destiny and begin to find their feet again.
It's super sweet, Simon has his own bruised spots which Robin is more than happy to make him feel good about and they're actually a brilliant pairing, each bringing their own strengths to the partnership.
We also get to meet Robin's family and I absolutely adore off of them, as well as get a glimpse into Simon's long distance ancestral past which brings a touch of humour to proceedings.
This is another great entry in the series and I'm really glad that Robin was able to come out from the toxic relationship he and Dorian had ended up in. Now I wait eagerly to see if Rebecca can rehabilitate and redeem the film star himself so he can find his own happy ending.
As ever, I beta read this book.
#ARC kindly received from the author in return for an honest and unbiased review
From previous appearances in the Modern Crofton novels we may have been given the impression of a guy who floats around behind his Hollywood film star secret boyfriend, hiding in the role of Dorian's PA, and not really caring much.
But Robin's not that at all. He's a deeply wounded soul and has dealt with some serious trauma in his past which has meant he's basically pushed aside a lot of his natural personality to live in Dorian's shadow.
Here we finally get the background of how Robin ended up in LA working as Dorian's PA, the pain behind his fall from grace and just how much is too much when push comes to shove.
The story opens with a massive blow out between Robin and Dorian when the film star announces he's fake marrying his fake girlfriend who's also hiding behind her relationship because she's got her own secret girlfriend.
Robin hightails it out of Dorian's house and to a flat his family own in LA before eventually getting in touch with Ben and Ashley and heading to Crofton Hall. What follows then is a romance which is the opposite of everything Robin's ever known as he meets a local man, Simon, and discovers the joy that comes from being able to publicly demonstrate your feelings for someone.
I absolutely love the modern Crofton books (I love the historical ones too as well!) and the way Rebecca has gathered together a found family to go along with Ben's aristocratic blood one. With his staff finding love at the Hall, it's now time for his friend Robin to do the same.
With all the usual suspects on hand and a secondary plot which revolves around an incident at the Hall, what you get in this book is an exploration of how someone can take control back of their own destiny and begin to find their feet again.
It's super sweet, Simon has his own bruised spots which Robin is more than happy to make him feel good about and they're actually a brilliant pairing, each bringing their own strengths to the partnership.
We also get to meet Robin's family and I absolutely adore off of them, as well as get a glimpse into Simon's long distance ancestral past which brings a touch of humour to proceedings.
This is another great entry in the series and I'm really glad that Robin was able to come out from the toxic relationship he and Dorian had ended up in. Now I wait eagerly to see if Rebecca can rehabilitate and redeem the film star himself so he can find his own happy ending.
As ever, I beta read this book.
#ARC kindly received from the author in return for an honest and unbiased review
February 5, 2023
3 stars
This is a part of a series and really should be read in order to understand anything with the other characters or backstory for the MCs.
A midrange angsty, hurt/comfort romance, with a bit of mystery thrown in, that had me rooting for these two guys to push through their past traumas to get their HEA. Both Robin and Simon bring so much baggage to their relationship and wading through it isn’t easy for either of them. I so enjoyed seeing them pull through and put each other and their newfound love ahead of everything else.
I have enjoyed each book in this series and this is definitely no exception.
This is a part of a series and really should be read in order to understand anything with the other characters or backstory for the MCs.
A midrange angsty, hurt/comfort romance, with a bit of mystery thrown in, that had me rooting for these two guys to push through their past traumas to get their HEA. Both Robin and Simon bring so much baggage to their relationship and wading through it isn’t easy for either of them. I so enjoyed seeing them pull through and put each other and their newfound love ahead of everything else.
I have enjoyed each book in this series and this is definitely no exception.
January 23, 2023
This is part of a series, and it definitely helps to have read previous books, not least because the way these books are structured blends a new romance with updates on an established couple, Ben (the earl) and Ashley (his now-husband). I’ve had my ups and downs with Ben and Ashley— in some books, they’re A LOT, and not always in a good way, but they both shine here, in their relationship to each other (remarkably healthy and full of open communication) and as friends to Robin, who’s definitely at a place in life to need all the friends he can get.
The new romance here is between Robin (rich, titled, plenty of baggage from the very recent end of a very toxic relationship) and Simon (policeman, not rich or titled, but has his own baggage from a past very toxic relationship). I can say all the good things in the world about Simon. He’s kind, insightful, patient, and while I wish he stood up for himself more sometimes, I understand why it’s hard for him to do so. Team Simon for days. Robin? Robin I have complicated feelings about, although he definitely gets better toward the end of the book.
At the beginning, however, he can be rough going. I found something about the caution with which Robin approaches his relationship with Simon to be wearyingly excessive. On one hand, it’s great and mature and super realistic to be reminding himself and everyone else (incessantly) that it’s “early days”and things might not work out but…this is a romance novel, and part of the joy of a romance is surely the process of falling in love? It’s often difficult, under all the pragmatism and hedging, to see evidence of that joy on Robin’s part. In real life, rebound romances after deeply complicated relationships are…often problematic. It’s good and realistic that the author grasps that, but that focus doesn’t always make what develops between Simon and Robin feel like a particularly good idea, for either of them.
Also, not to be uncharitable to Robin, but he is, to a much greater degree than he acknowledges to himself, a product of privilege. His worries about their different economic and social backgrounds often come off as more self-interest than genuine sensitivity, and I honestly wanted to roll my eyes at his initial worrying about designer label disparity and his family’s potential reaction to him dating someone “not who they expected.” In some ways, Robin at the start is more like Simon’s abusive ex than he should be, in that he, however unintentionally, ends up sometimes treating Simon like an inconvenience, or just generally less-than. It’s good luck for him that Simon has the patience of a saint, and that various other figures in Robin’s life are willing to call him out on his behavior. Also to his credit, Robin, once called out, is retroactively remorseful and determined to get things right, and he does absolutely come into his own when he actively invests in being a partner to Simon, and in trying to help Simon deal with the legacy of his own past relationship. Overall, I ended up liking them together, and interested to see what would be next for Crofton Hall and those who inhabit/visit/exist in its orbit.
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
The new romance here is between Robin (rich, titled, plenty of baggage from the very recent end of a very toxic relationship) and Simon (policeman, not rich or titled, but has his own baggage from a past very toxic relationship). I can say all the good things in the world about Simon. He’s kind, insightful, patient, and while I wish he stood up for himself more sometimes, I understand why it’s hard for him to do so. Team Simon for days. Robin? Robin I have complicated feelings about, although he definitely gets better toward the end of the book.
At the beginning, however, he can be rough going. I found something about the caution with which Robin approaches his relationship with Simon to be wearyingly excessive. On one hand, it’s great and mature and super realistic to be reminding himself and everyone else (incessantly) that it’s “early days”and things might not work out but…this is a romance novel, and part of the joy of a romance is surely the process of falling in love? It’s often difficult, under all the pragmatism and hedging, to see evidence of that joy on Robin’s part. In real life, rebound romances after deeply complicated relationships are…often problematic. It’s good and realistic that the author grasps that, but that focus doesn’t always make what develops between Simon and Robin feel like a particularly good idea, for either of them.
Also, not to be uncharitable to Robin, but he is, to a much greater degree than he acknowledges to himself, a product of privilege. His worries about their different economic and social backgrounds often come off as more self-interest than genuine sensitivity, and I honestly wanted to roll my eyes at his initial worrying about designer label disparity and his family’s potential reaction to him dating someone “not who they expected.” In some ways, Robin at the start is more like Simon’s abusive ex than he should be, in that he, however unintentionally, ends up sometimes treating Simon like an inconvenience, or just generally less-than. It’s good luck for him that Simon has the patience of a saint, and that various other figures in Robin’s life are willing to call him out on his behavior. Also to his credit, Robin, once called out, is retroactively remorseful and determined to get things right, and he does absolutely come into his own when he actively invests in being a partner to Simon, and in trying to help Simon deal with the legacy of his own past relationship. Overall, I ended up liking them together, and interested to see what would be next for Crofton Hall and those who inhabit/visit/exist in its orbit.
*I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book.
February 8, 2023
Robin Flint has finally made a decision that hurts his heart. He’s left the selfish, in denial, closeted Dorian Marston, for good. Robin has had his issues in the past, but no longer uses drugs. He doesn’t really need Dorian’s lies anymore. Robin is successful in his own right, as the future Viscount Whetford and he has the opportunity to return to Oxford. Also, he would like to be part of his father’s new venture. He just has too much going for himself, instead of wasting it on Dorian. Dealing with the break-up, he’s leaving NY and going home to the UK. To prevent dealing with his family right away, he calls Ashley who invites him to stay at Crofton Hall.
As Ashley joins up with his running club, he meets someone new and it makes him a little nervous and it makes Simon suspicious. Simon MacLove is a Detective Inspector, who transferred from Essex to the Hertsfordshire Constabulary. He’s dealt with a verbally abusive marriage and now divorced for two months. He really needed the change and hopes it all works for him.
The run ends at the Red Lion Pub, where Ashley introduces Simon to Dara Callahan and Chris Gambling. The Red Lion Pub is certainly the hottest spot in town. On a day off Simon is once again at the pub and runs into Chris and another new comer Robin. As Chis needs to meet Dara, Simon and Robin are left alone. Robin is still thinking about his conversation with Ashley. After long conversations both have but a single thing on their minds and things get heated! Is that what they both need to heal from the long hurtful relationships they both endured or is will this be a mistake on both their parts?
Crofton Hall is never at a loss with all types of situations. Jack has a plan for Chris’ celebration and is driving Ashley crazy. Chris and Jack have kittens! Chris is still working on the script and Dara is digging deep into the archives, as the name of MacLove turns into something of a mystery.
In the meantime, Ben and Ashley are making baby decisions. Elena , Ben’s mother, want’s a first grandchild that she can spoil. Thinking about surrogates and how it all works, Ben has his doubts. He’s worried about his first born and the bloodline of the Redbourns. Will he be able to reason with himself and make the right decision?
And Dorian Marston just can’t get over himself!
Rebecca Cohen brings another wonderful, drama filled, chaotic and humorous story from Crofton Hall. One thing that readers can count on there’s more than one couple with a story to tell every time. “Starting Again At Crofton Hall” will bring Robin Flint and Simon MacLoves tale; Ben and Ashley’s continuing story and just a tad bit of Chris and Jack. And of course the woes of Dorian Marston. There’s also a murder that will have Ashley nervous and expose Robin.
As for Simon and Robin, there’s concerns about money and status. Robin tends to bring the old ways of him and Dorian into this new relationship. He forgets to give Simon credit for being able to make his own decisions. Decisions and doubts are stumbling blocks along the way.
Once thing for sure, there’s always a well rounded support system no matter what the issues are for each character. In this novel the ladies really get involved: Ben’s sister Caitlin and his mother Elena; Marchant’s sister Lady Lily Winters; Robin’s mother Virginia, sisters Delia and Florence; and Simon’s sister Michelle. From babies to protecting their friends and brothers they all have an opinion.
I highly recommend “Starting Again At Crofton Hall,” in fact the entire series “Modern Crofton” is entertaining and Rebecca Cohen always creates new and exciting tales each time to go along with some very appealing characters. I don’t know how she does it, but I’m hooked and ready for the next novel from Crofton Hall.
As Ashley joins up with his running club, he meets someone new and it makes him a little nervous and it makes Simon suspicious. Simon MacLove is a Detective Inspector, who transferred from Essex to the Hertsfordshire Constabulary. He’s dealt with a verbally abusive marriage and now divorced for two months. He really needed the change and hopes it all works for him.
The run ends at the Red Lion Pub, where Ashley introduces Simon to Dara Callahan and Chris Gambling. The Red Lion Pub is certainly the hottest spot in town. On a day off Simon is once again at the pub and runs into Chris and another new comer Robin. As Chis needs to meet Dara, Simon and Robin are left alone. Robin is still thinking about his conversation with Ashley. After long conversations both have but a single thing on their minds and things get heated! Is that what they both need to heal from the long hurtful relationships they both endured or is will this be a mistake on both their parts?
Crofton Hall is never at a loss with all types of situations. Jack has a plan for Chris’ celebration and is driving Ashley crazy. Chris and Jack have kittens! Chris is still working on the script and Dara is digging deep into the archives, as the name of MacLove turns into something of a mystery.
In the meantime, Ben and Ashley are making baby decisions. Elena , Ben’s mother, want’s a first grandchild that she can spoil. Thinking about surrogates and how it all works, Ben has his doubts. He’s worried about his first born and the bloodline of the Redbourns. Will he be able to reason with himself and make the right decision?
And Dorian Marston just can’t get over himself!
Rebecca Cohen brings another wonderful, drama filled, chaotic and humorous story from Crofton Hall. One thing that readers can count on there’s more than one couple with a story to tell every time. “Starting Again At Crofton Hall” will bring Robin Flint and Simon MacLoves tale; Ben and Ashley’s continuing story and just a tad bit of Chris and Jack. And of course the woes of Dorian Marston. There’s also a murder that will have Ashley nervous and expose Robin.
As for Simon and Robin, there’s concerns about money and status. Robin tends to bring the old ways of him and Dorian into this new relationship. He forgets to give Simon credit for being able to make his own decisions. Decisions and doubts are stumbling blocks along the way.
Once thing for sure, there’s always a well rounded support system no matter what the issues are for each character. In this novel the ladies really get involved: Ben’s sister Caitlin and his mother Elena; Marchant’s sister Lady Lily Winters; Robin’s mother Virginia, sisters Delia and Florence; and Simon’s sister Michelle. From babies to protecting their friends and brothers they all have an opinion.
I highly recommend “Starting Again At Crofton Hall,” in fact the entire series “Modern Crofton” is entertaining and Rebecca Cohen always creates new and exciting tales each time to go along with some very appealing characters. I don’t know how she does it, but I’m hooked and ready for the next novel from Crofton Hall.
February 9, 2023
my favorite in a fabulous series
Rating: 5🌈
I’m so delighted that Rebecca Cohen continues to add to her amazing Crofton series, both past and present. With each new release, I seem to find myself loving the new book and with it, the latest couple it’s centered around.
In this case, half of which we’ve already met before. That’s Robin Flint, friend of Ben Redbourn, 16th Earl of Crofton, and a future Viscount Whetford in his own right. He’s been in a hidden relationship and he’s done. Robin is so relatable on multiple levels. He’s had a some truly bad judgments he’s made in his past, but you can understand why he made them when you get the reasons and the emotions of the situation at the moment. He’s just so human, even with his upbringing and financial portfolio. He’s been hurt and he’s so unsure about himself.
Then there’s DI Simon MacLove. Recently divorced, and relocated to the area, Simon has his share of damage done to him by his ex. Bruised, insecure about what he brought to the partnership, Simon’s in recovery as well . He’s a wonderful mixture of competent law enforcement, compassionate and understanding man who’s attracted to Robin, and questioning adult with a damaged relationship in the past.
These men are so wonderful to read about as they maneuver through the tricky course of their current lives and their painful pasts to head to their HEA. That it includes a murder, a mystery, several scary sisters on both sides, and their friends makes this a journey of depth, full of discussion, discovery, laughter, hot sex, and lots of love.
Plus Ben and Ashley are never far from center with their own issues and thoughtfully worked through resolutions. Much to our delight.
This is probably one of my favorites in this series. I absolutely adored every single second I spent inside Crofton and nearby locations. It’s really an addiction by now.
I’ve listed all the books by era below. I’m highly recommending them all. They must be read in order to understand all the characters, their personalities and relationships as well as events that are referenced to.
The writing is crisp, plotting superb, and the characters are always full of life and energy! Just amazing.
“The Crofton Universe :
The Crofton Chronicles–Historical (Elizabethan/ Early Stuart):
🔷The Actor and the Earl #1
🔷Duty to the Crown #2
🔷Forever Hold His Peace #3
Available as a Complete Series Boxset
Plus:
“The Love and the Anger “
Historical (Elizabethan/ Early Stuart)–Sebastian/ Anthony 10 years together
The Earls of Crofton–Historical: (Different eras–can be read as individual standalone novels): Anthony, Earl of Crofton (Early Stuart) James, Earl of Crofton (Restoration) Charles, Earl of Crofton (Regency)
The Modern Crofton–Contemporary: 🔷Saving Crofton Hall #1
🔷Making History at Crofton Hall #2
🔷Below Stairs at Crofton Hall #3
🔷Getting Married at Crofton Hall #4
🔷Starting Again at Crofton Hall #5
Rating: 5🌈
I’m so delighted that Rebecca Cohen continues to add to her amazing Crofton series, both past and present. With each new release, I seem to find myself loving the new book and with it, the latest couple it’s centered around.
In this case, half of which we’ve already met before. That’s Robin Flint, friend of Ben Redbourn, 16th Earl of Crofton, and a future Viscount Whetford in his own right. He’s been in a hidden relationship and he’s done. Robin is so relatable on multiple levels. He’s had a some truly bad judgments he’s made in his past, but you can understand why he made them when you get the reasons and the emotions of the situation at the moment. He’s just so human, even with his upbringing and financial portfolio. He’s been hurt and he’s so unsure about himself.
Then there’s DI Simon MacLove. Recently divorced, and relocated to the area, Simon has his share of damage done to him by his ex. Bruised, insecure about what he brought to the partnership, Simon’s in recovery as well . He’s a wonderful mixture of competent law enforcement, compassionate and understanding man who’s attracted to Robin, and questioning adult with a damaged relationship in the past.
These men are so wonderful to read about as they maneuver through the tricky course of their current lives and their painful pasts to head to their HEA. That it includes a murder, a mystery, several scary sisters on both sides, and their friends makes this a journey of depth, full of discussion, discovery, laughter, hot sex, and lots of love.
Plus Ben and Ashley are never far from center with their own issues and thoughtfully worked through resolutions. Much to our delight.
This is probably one of my favorites in this series. I absolutely adored every single second I spent inside Crofton and nearby locations. It’s really an addiction by now.
I’ve listed all the books by era below. I’m highly recommending them all. They must be read in order to understand all the characters, their personalities and relationships as well as events that are referenced to.
The writing is crisp, plotting superb, and the characters are always full of life and energy! Just amazing.
“The Crofton Universe :
The Crofton Chronicles–Historical (Elizabethan/ Early Stuart):
🔷The Actor and the Earl #1
🔷Duty to the Crown #2
🔷Forever Hold His Peace #3
Available as a Complete Series Boxset
Plus:
“The Love and the Anger “
Historical (Elizabethan/ Early Stuart)–Sebastian/ Anthony 10 years together
The Earls of Crofton–Historical: (Different eras–can be read as individual standalone novels): Anthony, Earl of Crofton (Early Stuart) James, Earl of Crofton (Restoration) Charles, Earl of Crofton (Regency)
The Modern Crofton–Contemporary: 🔷Saving Crofton Hall #1
🔷Making History at Crofton Hall #2
🔷Below Stairs at Crofton Hall #3
🔷Getting Married at Crofton Hall #4
🔷Starting Again at Crofton Hall #5
February 4, 2023
Independent reviewer for Gay Romance Reviews, I was gifted my copy of this book.
This is book five in the Modern Crofton series, and you really should read the previous 4 books before this one.
I asked in my review for book 4, Getting Married at Crofton Hall, did Robin and Dorian get a HEA? Well, Robin does, here but Dorian is still in a world of hurt.
After Dorian does what he does, Robin runs across the world, to his best friend, Ben's home. He knows he has to be strong and not give into Dorian, but after so many years together, it's hard. Finding a friends with benefits type thing with Simon is perfect. Until Robin's past threatens their budding relationship.
I enjoyed this FAR more than the previous two books. I'm not sure if it's because I thought Ben and Ashley had less page time, or because that pair already have their HEA, all married and everything. Things are progressig on their family plans though, and I love LOVE those women around them offering what they do.
Either way, Robin and Simon are front and centre and I loved that they were.
Both men come with some emotional baggage. Robin's is more visual: he has been hiding for so long, being out and about with Simon is difficult but Simon's is no less painful, after his divorce. Together, though, they find their footing.
I'm curious as to Simon's history, given what was discovered here!
I'm again wondering if Dorian will get a HEA. He really hurts Robin here, but he does eventually see what they were doing was not good for Robn, nor Dorian, either, but he hasn't quite seen the light there. He needs to be happy, but it will take someone very special.
Everyone else from the series pops up at some point, and I loved catching up with them.
This series is not finished, Dorian needs to be happy, but Ben's brother Harry too!
Not overly explicit, Robin and Simon do most of their thing behind closed doors, and I liked that here.
4 good solid stars
*same worded review will appear elsewhere
This is book five in the Modern Crofton series, and you really should read the previous 4 books before this one.
I asked in my review for book 4, Getting Married at Crofton Hall, did Robin and Dorian get a HEA? Well, Robin does, here but Dorian is still in a world of hurt.
After Dorian does what he does, Robin runs across the world, to his best friend, Ben's home. He knows he has to be strong and not give into Dorian, but after so many years together, it's hard. Finding a friends with benefits type thing with Simon is perfect. Until Robin's past threatens their budding relationship.
I enjoyed this FAR more than the previous two books. I'm not sure if it's because I thought Ben and Ashley had less page time, or because that pair already have their HEA, all married and everything. Things are progressig on their family plans though, and I love LOVE those women around them offering what they do.
Either way, Robin and Simon are front and centre and I loved that they were.
Both men come with some emotional baggage. Robin's is more visual: he has been hiding for so long, being out and about with Simon is difficult but Simon's is no less painful, after his divorce. Together, though, they find their footing.
I'm curious as to Simon's history, given what was discovered here!
I'm again wondering if Dorian will get a HEA. He really hurts Robin here, but he does eventually see what they were doing was not good for Robn, nor Dorian, either, but he hasn't quite seen the light there. He needs to be happy, but it will take someone very special.
Everyone else from the series pops up at some point, and I loved catching up with them.
This series is not finished, Dorian needs to be happy, but Ben's brother Harry too!
Not overly explicit, Robin and Simon do most of their thing behind closed doors, and I liked that here.
4 good solid stars
*same worded review will appear elsewhere
February 1, 2023
I've really enjoyed this series so far, especially that we keep up with Ben and Ashley (MC's from book one) with them popping in with their own chapters once in a while. Their relationship is fun to read as Ashley is not afraid to put Ben in his place, even with him being Lord of the Hall. Their really supportive friends to everyone who has come through and stayed with them across the series and Robin is no different.
Robin visited Crofton Hall in the previous book with his partner but this time he's alone having made a big decision about how he wants to live his life. Robin and Simon both have their recent painful histories when it comes to relationships and are in a place where they can offer themselves for comfort and fun but Simon is built for long term. Robin has to think on if he's ready to try something new, something out and shared with everyone which he couldn't do with his ex. They click really well together, considering how they come from such different backgrounds in pretty much every way. I really like that Simon isn't afraid to say what he wants and needs, and isn't overwhelmed when it comes to Robin's title and position. I feel for Robin considering he's had to hide himself for the past few years and Simon is a good man for him, liking him for himself before he was even aware of money, land, titles. Now he has to relearn accepting the love and support of someone when out in public
A good story of two men getting a second chance at their HEA, alongside two men continuing to build their family, both blood and found. Though he caused some issues in this book and the last, I'm hoping that Dorian gets his day to experience love and his own happiness.
I received an ARC and am happily giving a review.
Robin visited Crofton Hall in the previous book with his partner but this time he's alone having made a big decision about how he wants to live his life. Robin and Simon both have their recent painful histories when it comes to relationships and are in a place where they can offer themselves for comfort and fun but Simon is built for long term. Robin has to think on if he's ready to try something new, something out and shared with everyone which he couldn't do with his ex. They click really well together, considering how they come from such different backgrounds in pretty much every way. I really like that Simon isn't afraid to say what he wants and needs, and isn't overwhelmed when it comes to Robin's title and position. I feel for Robin considering he's had to hide himself for the past few years and Simon is a good man for him, liking him for himself before he was even aware of money, land, titles. Now he has to relearn accepting the love and support of someone when out in public
A good story of two men getting a second chance at their HEA, alongside two men continuing to build their family, both blood and found. Though he caused some issues in this book and the last, I'm hoping that Dorian gets his day to experience love and his own happiness.
I received an ARC and am happily giving a review.
February 6, 2023
I've enjoyed this series, but it's definitely one to read in order if you can, as each volume continues the story of Ben, the earl, and his partner Ashley in addition to putting together another pair of attractive men.
This volume, more than most, continues from the previous, as Robin, long-suffering secret boyfriend of movie star Dorian, finally says enough and breaks up with the actor when he refuses to come out of the closet. Coming to stay with Ben gives Robin, also from the privileged class, a chance to lick his wounds and, of course, find new love.
We also catch up with Jack (Ashley's best friend) and his boyfriend Chris (scriptwriter and historian). There's a lot going on here, I'm saying, and it was all fun and frothy, with just enough conflict to keep things interesting. And there's an underlying theme with a bit more depth, about approaching a new relationship while shaking off the bad habits of the past.
I really liked new character Simon, Robin's love interest, a recently divorced detective inspector new to town, as well as Robin's sisters, who are very determined. That Robin is hiding his wealth and family, wanting to be taken on his own, is the kind of lightweight drama that gives the couple something to work through for their eventual happy ending.
(I'd give this five stars if it weren't for the fact I personally am allergic to "now we're happy, we must have kids" plot lines. I was given an advance digital review copy for the purpose of review.)
This volume, more than most, continues from the previous, as Robin, long-suffering secret boyfriend of movie star Dorian, finally says enough and breaks up with the actor when he refuses to come out of the closet. Coming to stay with Ben gives Robin, also from the privileged class, a chance to lick his wounds and, of course, find new love.
We also catch up with Jack (Ashley's best friend) and his boyfriend Chris (scriptwriter and historian). There's a lot going on here, I'm saying, and it was all fun and frothy, with just enough conflict to keep things interesting. And there's an underlying theme with a bit more depth, about approaching a new relationship while shaking off the bad habits of the past.
I really liked new character Simon, Robin's love interest, a recently divorced detective inspector new to town, as well as Robin's sisters, who are very determined. That Robin is hiding his wealth and family, wanting to be taken on his own, is the kind of lightweight drama that gives the couple something to work through for their eventual happy ending.
(I'd give this five stars if it weren't for the fact I personally am allergic to "now we're happy, we must have kids" plot lines. I was given an advance digital review copy for the purpose of review.)
January 23, 2023
4.5 stars
This is the 5th in the Modern Crofton series, and as ever it follows a new couple but also picks up the tread of Ben and Ashley's life. For that reason, I'd recommend reading this as part of a series although you could also enjoy it as a standalone. This is Robin and Simon's story, and it's around half and half with Ben and Ashley. I did wonder how Robin's story would unfold, we met him in the last book and he wasn't in a good place then. I needn't have worried, it all unfolded wonderfully well.
I loved the development of the relationship between Robin and Simon, from the initial meeting right all the way through. Both men have been through a lot and while it was probably quite soon for Robin, it was good to see him willing to take a chance. They were so good together, they just fitted. I like them both, actually. There was a fair bit of heat there too, and I liked that Robin really took his time before jumping in to another relationship right away. The supporting cast as ever is great, it's always good to revisit the other couples in the series and see how they're getting on too.
I also liked Ashley and Ben's storyline here too, it seemed like such a natural progression for them and it made me happy to see. The only thing that brings it down a little is I felt the murder on the grounds was rather pushed to the side, I thought it might be a bigger part of the story. But that's pretty minor in the grand scheme of things.
I look forward to more.
I received an ARC and this is my honest review.
This is the 5th in the Modern Crofton series, and as ever it follows a new couple but also picks up the tread of Ben and Ashley's life. For that reason, I'd recommend reading this as part of a series although you could also enjoy it as a standalone. This is Robin and Simon's story, and it's around half and half with Ben and Ashley. I did wonder how Robin's story would unfold, we met him in the last book and he wasn't in a good place then. I needn't have worried, it all unfolded wonderfully well.
I loved the development of the relationship between Robin and Simon, from the initial meeting right all the way through. Both men have been through a lot and while it was probably quite soon for Robin, it was good to see him willing to take a chance. They were so good together, they just fitted. I like them both, actually. There was a fair bit of heat there too, and I liked that Robin really took his time before jumping in to another relationship right away. The supporting cast as ever is great, it's always good to revisit the other couples in the series and see how they're getting on too.
I also liked Ashley and Ben's storyline here too, it seemed like such a natural progression for them and it made me happy to see. The only thing that brings it down a little is I felt the murder on the grounds was rather pushed to the side, I thought it might be a bigger part of the story. But that's pretty minor in the grand scheme of things.
I look forward to more.
I received an ARC and this is my honest review.
January 16, 2023
Sweet sweet Robin. He has finally had enough of Dorian and has walked out on him, going back to England and staying with Ben and Ashley at Crofton Hall. I love the found family that has started calling Crofton Hall home. I enjoy how we keep seeing the same characters and their relationships grow. Ben and Ashley are still my favorite though. One of the things I love about these guys is they talk it out. Ashley and Ben continue to grow and now we have Simon and Robin. Both of these men have some serious relationship trauma but they figure out a way to make their new relationship work. Both Robin and Simon deserve so much better than they have gotten in the past. I also love how Ben refuses to take sides and calls Dorian out on his bulls*$(. I would actually enjoy seeing Dorian grow in the future, but Robin has certainly made a decision that is the best for him and his life. Him and Simon are going to be absolutely perfect for each other.
“If we wait for everything to be perfect then we will risk missing out on something special. I need to figure out a lot of things, but what we’re doing isn’t one of them. I want to move forward in my life and I hope that I can do that with you.”
“If we wait for everything to be perfect then we will risk missing out on something special. I need to figure out a lot of things, but what we’re doing isn’t one of them. I want to move forward in my life and I hope that I can do that with you.”
January 30, 2023
Whilst the book does have romance and some humour, I would say the romance takes a back seat to other events going on in the story. The book is more focused on Robin's past troubles and ex toxic relationship, as opposed to his developing relationship with Simon in the present. Simon also has his own problems, but I found him a much more sympathetic and relatable persona than Robin. Simon is such a sweetheart, and has the patience of a saint.I also found Robin's preoccupation with how his family would react to Simon, social position and all that, somewhat annoying. Fortunately, Robin finally gets himself into gear, finally facing up to his past and exorcises some demons, providing Simon with some much needed emotional support. Given the subject matter mentioned, the story here is certainly not all light and fluffy, however, there is still enough humour in the book so as for it not to feel depressing or dreary. There's also a back story involving Ben and Ashley from a previous book in the series, running through the book. I enjoyed their story, and the conclusion. I also liked the way in which they helped Simon and Robin along the way. Well written, with a beautiful ending.
February 5, 2023
Crofton has been the scene of a few love stories in the present and in the past. They are not without their complications but they do find a way. Robin and Simon's story is no different. Both men are dealing with the baggage left over from relationships that were not good for them. Robin is a friend of Ben, the earl of Crofton Hall. He has come to Crofton Hall to get away from his toxic, closeted boyfriend. He has had it and is ready to move on. Simon is so different from the toxic boyfriend that Robin is done with. They are different in a few ways, Robin is wealthy and indulged. Simon is a good guy that is likeable from the word go. Both Robin and Simon deserve one another as each is an upgrade from what they have gotten recently. There is some drama with Robin's ex but it was good that he moved on and meant it. It was also nice getting to see how things are going with Ben and Ashley post the wedding. This couple was going strong in this story as they were working on the how to start a family chapter in their story. I like my visits to Croton Hall and hope they continue for a few more books.
I received an ARC from GRR and am voluntarily leaving a review.
I received an ARC from GRR and am voluntarily leaving a review.
February 2, 2023
It's time for Ben and Ashley to turn their attention to starting a family! As with the previous books in this series, Rebecca Cohen interweaves their ongoing story with a complete HEA for two other characters...
This time it's Robin's turn. After breaking up with Damon for good (finally!) he gets to explore a sweet and steamy relationship with the new police detective in town and it was sweet to watch him come into his own and really figure out who he was outside of his past relationship. This was a steamy, second chance romance for both men and a chance to heal some old wounds.
I love catching up with everyone at Crofton and watching each new couple find their HEA. I don't recommend reading this standalone, but as a continuing part of the Crofton world, Starting Again At Crofton Hall is an excellent addition.
This time it's Robin's turn. After breaking up with Damon for good (finally!) he gets to explore a sweet and steamy relationship with the new police detective in town and it was sweet to watch him come into his own and really figure out who he was outside of his past relationship. This was a steamy, second chance romance for both men and a chance to heal some old wounds.
I love catching up with everyone at Crofton and watching each new couple find their HEA. I don't recommend reading this standalone, but as a continuing part of the Crofton world, Starting Again At Crofton Hall is an excellent addition.
February 5, 2023
Secrets like lies? Excellent follow-on addition to the series. Robin, comes to Crofton Hall, to rechare his batteries and escape betrayal. We hear from old friends and learn about new adventures. Robin and Simon meet in a time when they are both in emotional flux. Simon, is a local police person, Robin is keeping big secrets from Simon which definitely could influence any developments in their relationship. If they start a relationship, will it be honest? Can they embrace their here and now? Can they communicate openly? Good return of old friends with whom we can followup. Robin and Simon are nice guys who need a little moret time developing. Will they take the time and do what's necessary? Good story. Nicely done. I received an ARC and am voluntarily leaving a review.
February 2, 2023
Wonderful addition to the Crofton Hall series. I love these series/world and the expanding cast of characters, growth of existing characters, new challenges and new loves. I love Ben and Ashley and how they support and are a sounding board (sometimes critically) for their friends. I loved Robin and Simon, two men with their share of past drama and baggage, and how they find their way to each other and love. I hope the author doesn't run out of ideas for Crofton Hall and that the expansion of found family will continue.
I received an ARC through GRR and am voluntarily leaving this honest review.
I received an ARC through GRR and am voluntarily leaving this honest review.
January 25, 2023
This book just made me happy. Robin with his break up was sad yet he powered on and found Simon. A match made in all the right places. Though Dorian was a right putz I could see his dilemma and felt sorry for him a bit. On to the rightness of this story. I absolutely adored reading it and found the chemistry, the fit between the m/c’s, spot on. Crofton Hall is a place where we’d all like to be a part of both the setting and the friendships that live there. The reading of this was a delight that I can encourage others to engage in with all my heart. I voluntarily reviewed an arc of this book.
February 4, 2023
Starting Again at Crofton Hall is the 5th in the Modern Crofton series, and as ever it follows a new couple but also picks up the tread of Ben and Ashley's life.
This is Robin and Simon's story. From beginning to end I loved the development of the relationship between Robin and Simon.
They fit together, as if made for each other.
Their chemistry and connection is wonderful.
There's also a back story involving Ben and Ashley from a previous book in the series, running through the book. I enjoyed their story, and the conclusion.
February 5, 2023
Always wonderful to catch up with Ben and Ashley and see their relationship deepening and evolving and the plans for children getting serious. The couple in focus here is Robin and Simon and they have some hurdles along the way including class differences, Robin's ex- who won't accept that Dorian and other baggage they must unpack if they are going to have a future. As always, the setting of Crofton Hall is a character in the book and that setting and all the characters leap off the page and become real people in this book as in all the others.
February 15, 2023
After four books, reading about Crofton Hall seems like visiting with old friends. I had really hoped that Dorian would have woken up and decided to become the man that Robin deserves but that is not what was meant to happen. It did my heart good to see Robin stand up for himself. And I am so happy to read about Ben and Ashley taking their next big step to grow their family, I am hoping that we will get Dorian's story soon.
May 24, 2023
There are several different stories going on in this book. Robin, beginning his life again in the UK, and Ben and Ashley trying to start a family. It was a wonderful book and I enjoyed it very much. I hope to read more about Crofton Hall and all their goings on. The story was well written and the characters are like old friends that you are visiting for a few hours. Recommend this series and this book.
February 5, 2023
He is going to change his life and going there was the first step. He did not give his real name so when he meets someone, he does not expect it to last long. It seems it may just become more but they are a sheriff and he has not even told them who he really is. What will he do? Will he take that next step? How will they react when they find out who he is? See what is going to happen for him next
August 22, 2023
Lots of reformed rakes in this one!
Ben still at bit Lordy at times but Ashley does keep him down to earth.
Robin is back - and in a mess. But new interest Simon is also on the rebound and doesn’t let Robin get away with being high and mighty.
Lots of dramatics and some good news
Oh and a murder thrown in for a pinch of spice
Ben still at bit Lordy at times but Ashley does keep him down to earth.
Robin is back - and in a mess. But new interest Simon is also on the rebound and doesn’t let Robin get away with being high and mighty.
Lots of dramatics and some good news
Oh and a murder thrown in for a pinch of spice
June 12, 2024
The PA and the DI
I really enjoyed this story. So much better than the previous couple of books in the series. Robin and Simon were both great characters and I really enjoyed their story. Even the editing is better, although there are still mistakes and I do wish the author would learn when to use he and him
I really enjoyed this story. So much better than the previous couple of books in the series. Robin and Simon were both great characters and I really enjoyed their story. Even the editing is better, although there are still mistakes and I do wish the author would learn when to use he and him
February 4, 2023
I will never get enough of these books! It almost feels as if the house is alive and has drawn me in. All of the characters are wonderful, the stories are fantastic and I cannot wait for the next 10 or so.
February 10, 2023
First, you HAVE to read the previous books in the series. There are just so many little details that made reading this book so much sweeter. Second, I can not put this series down. You wont regret picking it up.
January 28, 2023
I would definitely recommend reading the books before this one in the series to enjoy this lovely book at its fullest!
I adored Simon and loved how his and Robin's story unfolded.
I adored Simon and loved how his and Robin's story unfolded.
February 5, 2023
Good and sweet
Robin and Simon's story, From beginning i enjoyed the development of the relationship between them, this was a sweet read.
Robin and Simon's story, From beginning i enjoyed the development of the relationship between them, this was a sweet read.
February 10, 2023
I love the early Crofton series and this series. They are my favorite re reads.
February 3, 2023
Robin has finally had enough of hiding his relationship with Dorian Marsten. He’s reached his breaking point and needs a place to plaster over the holes in his heart. Dorian has hurt him for the last time. Ben offers Crofton Hall and Robin accepts. Simon is the new detective in the area and he is recovering from a divorce from his husband.
They are brought together by a chance meeting. Both realize that they are attracted to each other. What starts as a hookup grows into a relationship. We are introduced to both families and Simon’s sisters are a hoot. This was a story that easily flowed. I was caught up in the whole story that Rebecca wrote.
We watch them reach to each other and then we get to see them actually see talk to each other and grow. They know that change is what they need to do to keep each other. The are so sweet together and their chemistry is so good.
This book can be read as a standalone but to get the full story experience it would help to have read the other books.
They are brought together by a chance meeting. Both realize that they are attracted to each other. What starts as a hookup grows into a relationship. We are introduced to both families and Simon’s sisters are a hoot. This was a story that easily flowed. I was caught up in the whole story that Rebecca wrote.
We watch them reach to each other and then we get to see them actually see talk to each other and grow. They know that change is what they need to do to keep each other. The are so sweet together and their chemistry is so good.
This book can be read as a standalone but to get the full story experience it would help to have read the other books.
May 22, 2023
I really enjoyed this installment of the Crofton Hall chronicles, this time between Detective Inspector Simon MacLove and Robin Flint, the future Viscount Whetford. Their story is one of hurting hearts moving cautiously toward an HEA they both want but aren't sure they're suited for with each other. Robin's status gives Simon pause, and many of the hiccups in their budding relationship are due to Simon's knee-jerk behaviors, learned over six years of hiding his boyfriend status to movie star Dorian Forbes under the guise of being his PA. Both men must learn to trust each other not to be like their exes. In addition to this main story is the secondary tale of Ben and Ashley starting the process of becoming fathers. An altogether lovely story, complete with bossy older sisters, protective fathers, and supportive, straight-talking friends. Only one fault...despite the author's disclaimer regarding her spelling and punctuation being British, not American, I found far too many commas being used as full stops (yes, I know what periods are called in British punctuation because I was educated in the British way). There's just NO excuse for that, and I deducted a whole star for that travesty!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 30 reviews