This is a frustrating book to review, because it was excellent, but not the book I thought I was reading. I’d give it five stars if it wasn’t for the blurb about being a perfect girlfriend and finding true love. That just set my expectations wrong, and I spent the book waiting for something that didn’t come.
So let’s rewrite the blurb to be about finding yourself, who you are and equally importantly who you’re not, finding and being a great friend instead of a perfect girlfriend, finding a way out of incapacitating grief and the missteps it brings on, finding the depth in every person around you… there was a lot to love in this story, it just wasn’t about perfect girlfriends and only barely scratched the surface of true love. I mean, there were plenty of relationships in the story… the main ones just didn’t get sorted until very very very late, and as a result didn’t feel like the focus. It seemed to be a book about the journey more than the destination.
In any case, I thought the characters were outstanding, and nearly all of them got both depth and development… you can’t always be quick to trust your first (or even second) impression. The rafting action was generally excellent, though I did find that Ghostrider didn’t quite live up to the build-up that it received. About the only part that really threw me was when a third-party turned up some critical information, it seemed nearly magical — not a bit on how they did it and I wasn’t even convinced the time sequence allowed them the advance notice required to do so? Sure, I suspended disbelief because it kept the story moving, but that was the one time I actually noticed myself doing so.
So… if you introduced this to me as a book about friendship, finding yourself, life-changing experiences, working through grief, and etc. it would be a clear five stars. Well-written, insightful, and fun to read with beautiful characters and entertaining action sequences. Maybe I’ll read it again with better expectations and bump my rating up? This first read, though, it didn’t really deliver on what I thought I was supposed to be waiting for.