Hmm... my mistake was in thinking this was an Amish romance, like the Harlequin kind. I didn't realize it was more like an Amish family story, so it felt really long and slow-moving to me, especially at the start, and I was surprised at the halfway point to realize the story wasn't over yet.
That being said, I did care about the characters. Even the stepson who started out bratty, I'm glad he eventually grew up and seems like his crush at the end will help him settle down.
Boo on all the hunting stuff. Boo on sports hunting in general, though I guess coz they're Amish, they'll actually eat the animals they kill and not just use as trophies like the super rich people do? Still, boo on how excited that stepson is about all the killing. The poor mountain lion. (Fortunately, nothing graphic and no kill scenes even in the book.)
I did feel the heroine was kinda snobby towards her eventual husband at the start. Like just coz he's rough and tumble doesn't mean she has to be so miserable about him and about the prospect of living in his quiet countryside. Though I guess I can relate.
Still, overall, nice family story and nice to see things work out for the heroine.
Also kinda cool coz I often see Amish romances but rarely Amish stories, like lit fic type. The writing and story reminded me kinda of Anne of Green Gables, but maybe that's just coz of the old-fashioned lifestyle of the characters.