Kubo won’t let Shiraishi be invisible, but, sad to say, neither of them is doing much for keeping the story terribly interesting either.
With the addition of the new friends, this series is really turning into the photocopier version of Shikimori’s Not Just A Cutie!. But like most copies, it doesn’t have a patch on the original (and with releases here being what they are, Kubo might have come first, I admit).
The problem is with the friends themselves, for starters. They get the job done here, sure, but the delightfully pronounced oddball crew in Shikimori brought that series to life. They just help this one stay on life support.
It’s a sad truth that this series has just absolutely stalled out at the notion of moving Kubo and Shiraishi on to the confession stage, which does make sense given Shiraishi’s disposition, but that’s just leaving lots of lots of stolen glances and precious little else.
Yes, the friends being quite happy to jockey for ringside seats to the imminent coupling while they cheer our leads on is cute. Their banter is simply the usual stuff, nothing injury in the slightest. Shiraishi stepping up for Kubo when she gets scared is cute. But there’s about as much presence here as Shiraishi himself.
And even on its own merits, this is a boring volume. Now that people are noticing Shiraishi, the problem of removing the one interesting thing about your character now rears its head. Shiraishi is just boring when he’s not wallpaper. If you want more slices of this particular life, sure, it’s perfectly perfunctory, but it stops there.
I hate to keep bringing up Shikimori, but Shikimori never removed what was interesting about Izumi in that story. She complimented it, was strong where he needed it, and helped him see that he was better than he thought. Shiraishi just doesn’t have anything like that.
Don’t get me wrong, this story doesn’t have a mean bone in its body. It’s perfectly functional and has its moments, but they’re far more ‘yeah, that’s okay’ than any ‘wow’. It’s a cozy read leaning more toward sedative than it should be.
3 stars - I mean, it’s doing what it wants to do, so fair play to it. It’s just hard to recommend when a better example of this (minus that brutal first volume) is literally right over there waiting in the wings.