I’ll admit straight up that whilst I read and studied many Shakespeare plays in high school, Much Ado About Nothing wasn’t one of them. Nor have I seen the 1993 movie adaptation with Kenneth Branagh and Emma Thompson that this book describes in great detail. To be honest, I saw rather enough adaptations starring Mr Branagh and have very little desire to see any more. So when I read this book, which was my online book club’s June pick, it was only with the vaguest of understandings about Much Ado’s plot. But if like me, you haven’t seen the movie either, don’t worry. The book describes it enough that it’ll feel like you have.
Willa lives and works in inner Sydney. She works for a family owned company comprising of the family patriarch, four strapping sons, her and also her cousin Imogen, whom Willa recruited as the receptionist. The company is a publishing one, producing mainly technical manuals but Willa herself has managed to branch out sideways into publishing romance novels. She handles all sides of the business – she chooses the novels to publish, deals with the authors, does the covers and sets the book and outsources some of the editing the freelancers. It’s actually doing very well and is probably the only part of the business that is truly profitable. The rest of it doesn’t need to be as such, as the family behind it are stinking rich.
I think people who know the Shakespeare play will be able to pick several of the key plot points during this novel. I didn’t obviously but I felt like the book gave enough of a clue for how one big moment was going to play out and so I wasn’t that shocked when it did. However, I also think that it dropped the ball a bit on the fallout. So much of the first half of the book revolved around the lead up to this event and then there’s the actual moment and then it kind of just……fizzles. The event and moment aren’t about the main character but she’s so intimately involved that to be honest, it seemed like there should’ve been much more. And this in essence, is why I feel like the eventual romance (which literally barely exists until the final chapter) would never work in reality. Because how would the main character ever really interact with anyone from this particular family ever again? How would their families ever interact? If they got married in the future, honestly, it feels like recipe for a disaster. That was just one of the ways in which this book didn’t work for me. I didn’t much like the eventual love interest, I don’t think he was even in a place in his life to be declaring stuff that he declared when he declared it either.
Willa is a tough character too. She is at times, a truly terrible friend. She’s childfree by choice and so is her best friend although they have another friend who has three children, a 9yo girl and twin toddlers and their life is depicted as being chaotic verging on the point of insanity. When something happens concerning Willa’s best friend, she makes a very thoughtless and hurtful comment. Look, to her credit she does apologise for it and seems genuinely remorseful for hurting her friend’s feelings but she never apologises for the way she treats her friend’s partner. She views him as this temporary inconvenience, ignoring all the signs that he and her friend are developing into quite a serious relationship and is casually dismissive of him as a person for the most unfair of reasons.
I didn’t mind the fact that Willa lived a lot of her life like she was in a romance novel, or waiting for the romance novel plot to happen to her. I thought it was interesting that she chose the novels she published based on if they gave her the same feeling that watching the adaptation of Much Ado About Nothing gave her. I think a lot of people who enjoy romance have a core movie or book that was their gateway into the genre and gives them a similar feeling to the one Willa experienced. I thought she showed initiative in developing her own imprint and choosing and publishing books that she enjoyed also. She seemed quite good at her job, coming at it from a different angle. I also didn’t judge her for not resigning immediately because look, when you got bills to pay you can’t always afford to take the high road. I also appreciated that she called out the patriarch (who was also her boss) on the misconceptions he seemed determined to have but the side moment with the eldest son was a bit bizarre and like I mentioned earlier, the romance, when it appeared, was not at all something I was on board with. I didn’t think they had any chemistry whatsoever, he was rebounding from a rebound and she seemed to only really decide what she wanted at the last possible moment and the idea of any future was really difficult for me to see clearly. I wanted so much more! I know it’s a mimic of the play but its not the 1500s anymore.
There was some humour and fun moments in this (I really enjoyed Willa’s family, particularly her grandmother) but a lot of the very important parts of the plot unfortunately were not enjoyable for me personally.