What do you think?
Rate this book
Journal Through Time Mysteries #2
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree
He chases crooks. She researches the past. When a financier is found hanged, can they solve his death?
Vancouver, 1897. Detective Jack Winston investigates a body at a popular landmark and realizes the man’s business is as hollow as the tree near where he was found.
Vancouver, 2017. Archivist Riley Finch throws herself into a new project at the museum while preparing for her sister’s wedding and steering their mother from a suspicious investment deal.
With more suspects than answers, Jack again turns to Riley for help through the journal that connects the time-crossed duo.
Can the pair unravel another mystery?
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree is the second book in the Journal Through Time historical mystery series. If you like time-bending mysteries, you’ll love this twisting tale.
Vancouver, 1897. Detective Jack Winston investigates a body at a popular landmark and realizes the man’s business is as hollow as the tree near where he was found.
Vancouver, 2017. Archivist Riley Finch throws herself into a new project at the museum while preparing for her sister’s wedding and steering their mother from a suspicious investment deal.
With more suspects than answers, Jack again turns to Riley for help through the journal that connects the time-crossed duo.
Can the pair unravel another mystery?
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree is the second book in the Journal Through Time historical mystery series. If you like time-bending mysteries, you’ll love this twisting tale.
310 pages, Paperback
First published August 12, 2022
10 people are currently reading
69 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews
October 6, 2024
3.5/5 rounded up
I am enjoying this series set in Vancouver during two time periods - the two protagonists are separated in time but can communicate via a kind of magical journal. I like the historical mystery more than the modern day storyline generally but they tied together nicely. I’m going to continue with this series.
I am enjoying this series set in Vancouver during two time periods - the two protagonists are separated in time but can communicate via a kind of magical journal. I like the historical mystery more than the modern day storyline generally but they tied together nicely. I’m going to continue with this series.
August 30, 2022
I’m so sad I didn’t enjoy this one as much as the first one! I don’t remember much of the first one (read it past september right before our move wich was a very busy time, so it’s not because the story didn’t stick haha!), but I do remember being positively surprised by how the connection between Riley & Jack was build and used. And I kinda missed that in this one? I feel like their connection wasn’t as meaningfull or usefull this time around, and was kinda sad we didn’t get a finished ending to events that where happening in Riley’s life at the time of the book. I am however still curious about book 3 and will read it with as much enthusiasm as I started this one, they don’t all have to be my cup of tea. I can’t wait!
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for a review. My opinion however is entirely my own.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for a review. My opinion however is entirely my own.
August 23, 2022
I loved this second installment of The Journal Through Time Mysteries.
The premise of this traditional mystery series is fresh and original with well-rounded, intriguing characters. I can't wait to find out what happens next.
The premise of this traditional mystery series is fresh and original with well-rounded, intriguing characters. I can't wait to find out what happens next.
July 8, 2022
Description
The body of an influential businessman discovered hanging from a tree in Stanley Park finds Detective Jack Winston carefully navigating polite society in turn-of-the-century Vancouver. In the modern era, Riley Finch faces her own difficulties when her mother arrives in town with some astonishing news.
Setting
Vancouver shines for a second time as the backdrop to the mysteries. Stephen expands on her descriptions from her introductory novel and again brings both old and current Vancouver to life. Though the author doesn't identify exact locations for particular residences, it is fun to speculate which buildings she had used as inspiration.
Characters
From the first novel into this new story, Jack and Riley remain constant in habits and mannerisms. The supporting cast develops their personalities while the reader has the opportunity to reconnect with the main characters.
Plot Mechanics
The journal that links Jack and Riley continues to be the mechanism linking them across the years. Writing (rather than speaking aloud) their thoughts clarifies the characters' motives for themselves, each other, and the reader. In turn, there is a richer account of the happenings enhancing the reading experience.
Final Thoughts
I was delighted to see this book available for review. Everything about this series charms me. It never fails to transport me to my happy place. The cover is gorgeous and would captivate me even if I didn't already adore these books.
Recommended. Highly!
Many thanks to BookSirens and Sarah M. Stephen for this complimentary e-ARC. As always, my opinions are my own, honest and true.
The body of an influential businessman discovered hanging from a tree in Stanley Park finds Detective Jack Winston carefully navigating polite society in turn-of-the-century Vancouver. In the modern era, Riley Finch faces her own difficulties when her mother arrives in town with some astonishing news.
Setting
Vancouver shines for a second time as the backdrop to the mysteries. Stephen expands on her descriptions from her introductory novel and again brings both old and current Vancouver to life. Though the author doesn't identify exact locations for particular residences, it is fun to speculate which buildings she had used as inspiration.
Characters
From the first novel into this new story, Jack and Riley remain constant in habits and mannerisms. The supporting cast develops their personalities while the reader has the opportunity to reconnect with the main characters.
Plot Mechanics
The journal that links Jack and Riley continues to be the mechanism linking them across the years. Writing (rather than speaking aloud) their thoughts clarifies the characters' motives for themselves, each other, and the reader. In turn, there is a richer account of the happenings enhancing the reading experience.
Final Thoughts
I was delighted to see this book available for review. Everything about this series charms me. It never fails to transport me to my happy place. The cover is gorgeous and would captivate me even if I didn't already adore these books.
Recommended. Highly!
Many thanks to BookSirens and Sarah M. Stephen for this complimentary e-ARC. As always, my opinions are my own, honest and true.
August 13, 2022
I feel like this book (series) was written for me! Historian helps police officer solve crime? Yes. Policeman lives in the past while historian is contemporary, oh yes! I'm a huge fan of historical fiction and police procedurals, so this ticks so many boxes.
This is actually book two of an ongoing series, so while I hadn't read the first book, it was pretty easy to jump in and understand what was going on. Author Sarah M Stephen writes well and both main characters are very likeable.
I really liked the structure of the story--it has two timelines, Jack Winston's in 1897, and Riley Finch's in 2017. As they write to one another using a mysterious journal, they work together to solve a murder. After Jack would write to Riley, the story would stay in her timeline until she wrote back to Jack. It was a clever device and actually made me want to read the first novel in the series as well.
Overall I enjoyed Riley's timeline more, as Riley and her family prepare for her sister's upcoming wedding and address a mystery of their own. I felt that the murder mystery got a bit convoluted at times, but came to a satisfying conclusion.
In all this was an enjoyable read and I'm looking forward to the next installment!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This is actually book two of an ongoing series, so while I hadn't read the first book, it was pretty easy to jump in and understand what was going on. Author Sarah M Stephen writes well and both main characters are very likeable.
I really liked the structure of the story--it has two timelines, Jack Winston's in 1897, and Riley Finch's in 2017. As they write to one another using a mysterious journal, they work together to solve a murder. After Jack would write to Riley, the story would stay in her timeline until she wrote back to Jack. It was a clever device and actually made me want to read the first novel in the series as well.
Overall I enjoyed Riley's timeline more, as Riley and her family prepare for her sister's upcoming wedding and address a mystery of their own. I felt that the murder mystery got a bit convoluted at times, but came to a satisfying conclusion.
In all this was an enjoyable read and I'm looking forward to the next installment!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 5, 2022
Book Sirens eARC. This second entry in the Journal Through Time series was as enjoyable as the first. Detective Jack Winston in early day Vancouver and present day museum archivist Riley collaborate their crime solving via written communication in an enchanted journal. In the author's deft hands this unusual premise remains grounded in the historical mystery not seeming too outwordly. In this outing they investigate the hanging death of a prominent businessman. They begin to suspect financial fraud and uncover an early Ponzi scheme with dire consequences. Jack and Riley and the supporting cast in both times are engaging and the historical tidbits add interest. The plotting is solid and well developed . I recommend this to anyone who enjoys a semi-cozy historical crime novel.
August 23, 2022
OK I feel like this was written with me in mind. I mean it's a mystery, it has an essence of time travel, dual timelines and multiple POVs. Fits me perfectly.
This is book 2 in the Journal Through Time Mysteries and while this story isn't the same mystery as the first one, I missed out on HOW this duo came to utilize their skills and actually "meet" and help solve cases. It's entirely my own fault as I rarely read a synopsis 😂 Guess I need to go back and snag the first book now. It's definitely worth it.
This was a very interesting mystery and I love the dynamic between Riley and Jack. The method of their communication is unique to me and it's a fun twist to how the crime is solved. Definitely recommend this one for historical fiction fans, mystery lovers and cozy mystery dabblers.
I sincerely appreciate the publisher and Book Sirens for providing me with a review copy. All opinions expressed herein are mine and mine alone.
This is book 2 in the Journal Through Time Mysteries and while this story isn't the same mystery as the first one, I missed out on HOW this duo came to utilize their skills and actually "meet" and help solve cases. It's entirely my own fault as I rarely read a synopsis 😂 Guess I need to go back and snag the first book now. It's definitely worth it.
This was a very interesting mystery and I love the dynamic between Riley and Jack. The method of their communication is unique to me and it's a fun twist to how the crime is solved. Definitely recommend this one for historical fiction fans, mystery lovers and cozy mystery dabblers.
I sincerely appreciate the publisher and Book Sirens for providing me with a review copy. All opinions expressed herein are mine and mine alone.
July 19, 2022
Actual rating 4.5 stars rounded up to 5.
I thoroughly enjoyed this second book in the Journal Through Time series by Sarah Stephens. In this novel, The Hanging at the Hollow Tree, Stephens has given readers another well-crafted semi-cozy mystery that is even better than the first, which I also enjoyed immensely.
This second book gives us more insight and background on both Riley Finch's and Jack Winston's characters, so that they are becoming "real people." And there are some truly interesting secondary characters who are becoming more well rounded as well. I especially like the character development of Jack's constable, Thomas Miller. The mentor/protege relationship between these two men is quite satisfying to read about, and I expect (hope) that this continues to develop further. It's often frustrating in mysteries when you have a main detective who seems so irritatingly brilliant surrounded by inept or clueless underlings that there's no room for real character growth. Stephens has avoided this and given readers a respectful and collegial partnership, as well as a main detective who freely admits he is also learning his craft.
The mystery itself was intriguing and complex, and, while I had my suspicions about the person who was finally shown to be the perpetrator, there were enough plausible alternative suspects to make the final revelation not a foregone conclusion. I very much liked that there was a parallel situation going on in Riley's time that made her research for Jack's investigation all that more relevant and urgent. It added another layer to Riley's research activities and to the connection between these two distant partners.
I am eager to see how Riley's friendship deepens with Johnny Winston, Jack's great grandson. This could present some interesting issues in a later novel: will Johnny find out about Riley's magical communication with his ancestor, and what effect could that have on their relationship? And what if Jack learns of Riley's friendship with his descendant? Would it make their relationship more awkward or make them closer?
I found the writing and plotting effective. Stephens has a way with descriptions that really helps to set the scene well without being overwhelming, and the alternating timelines were not confusing to keep track of because of the connecting thread of the journal communication and the way the mystery unraveled. The writing is smooth; it doesn't get bogged down with overly complex sentence structures that make it hard to decipher what's going on or what is meant. I did see a couple of places with structural errors or missing words, but as this is an ARC, I assume (hope) these will be caught in a final proofreading pass.
My only quibble (hence the 1/2 star deduction) is feeling that a loose end was left hanging regarding how and why Reginald Sawyer became so prominent and wealthy - there was only a vague reference, and I was hoping for a bit more. But this does not detract from what is an enjoyable and intriguing mystery, and I look forward to the next in the series.
Thank you to Book Sirens and Sarah Stephens for the opportunity to read this Advanced Review Copy, which I received for free, and for which am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
I thoroughly enjoyed this second book in the Journal Through Time series by Sarah Stephens. In this novel, The Hanging at the Hollow Tree, Stephens has given readers another well-crafted semi-cozy mystery that is even better than the first, which I also enjoyed immensely.
This second book gives us more insight and background on both Riley Finch's and Jack Winston's characters, so that they are becoming "real people." And there are some truly interesting secondary characters who are becoming more well rounded as well. I especially like the character development of Jack's constable, Thomas Miller. The mentor/protege relationship between these two men is quite satisfying to read about, and I expect (hope) that this continues to develop further. It's often frustrating in mysteries when you have a main detective who seems so irritatingly brilliant surrounded by inept or clueless underlings that there's no room for real character growth. Stephens has avoided this and given readers a respectful and collegial partnership, as well as a main detective who freely admits he is also learning his craft.
The mystery itself was intriguing and complex, and, while I had my suspicions about the person who was finally shown to be the perpetrator, there were enough plausible alternative suspects to make the final revelation not a foregone conclusion. I very much liked that there was a parallel situation going on in Riley's time that made her research for Jack's investigation all that more relevant and urgent. It added another layer to Riley's research activities and to the connection between these two distant partners.
I am eager to see how Riley's friendship deepens with Johnny Winston, Jack's great grandson. This could present some interesting issues in a later novel: will Johnny find out about Riley's magical communication with his ancestor, and what effect could that have on their relationship? And what if Jack learns of Riley's friendship with his descendant? Would it make their relationship more awkward or make them closer?
I found the writing and plotting effective. Stephens has a way with descriptions that really helps to set the scene well without being overwhelming, and the alternating timelines were not confusing to keep track of because of the connecting thread of the journal communication and the way the mystery unraveled. The writing is smooth; it doesn't get bogged down with overly complex sentence structures that make it hard to decipher what's going on or what is meant. I did see a couple of places with structural errors or missing words, but as this is an ARC, I assume (hope) these will be caught in a final proofreading pass.
My only quibble (hence the 1/2 star deduction) is feeling that a loose end was left hanging regarding how and why Reginald Sawyer became so prominent and wealthy - there was only a vague reference, and I was hoping for a bit more. But this does not detract from what is an enjoyable and intriguing mystery, and I look forward to the next in the series.
Thank you to Book Sirens and Sarah Stephens for the opportunity to read this Advanced Review Copy, which I received for free, and for which am leaving this honest review voluntarily.
August 4, 2022
I was delighted to be one of the ARC reviewers for Sarah M Stephens second book in the Journal through Time series. This book was available thru Book Sirens, with no obligation.
I was interested in this book because I love time travel mysteries. Vancouver, Canada, was the filming location for the XFILES and the city has interested me since then.
The author presents a double viewpoint of a historic landmark that exists in the real world…The Hollow Tree! She does a great job of lining up the setting of investigations by Jack & Riley in two time periods so that the reader doesn’t get confused. The theme of the investigations is investment fraud ; the initial plot revolves around the alleged suicide of a investment broker who is found hanging in a tree next to the public landmark of the Hollow Tree. Jack Winston isn’t convinced the man had sufficient motive for suicide & starts a murder investigation. His uncle, the police chief, thinks Jack is wasting his time & would prefer to end the investigation. Jack is perplexed at his uncles’ attitude & journals Riley about the situation.
Riley is delighted to receive new messages from Jack ; she needs some ideas for a new museum exhibit. She proposes Financial Business Leaders of Vancouver to her boss & gets it approved. Riley starts off her research with the names of the men involved in Winston’s case. Oddly enough, she can’t find much information about the man who died- Arthur Pierce. Then her own mystery begins when her mother decides to join an investment group , whose leader she is dating! Riley’s sister Lucy is upset that her mother is investing a large sum of money for her wedding present.
The two investigations are handled through the journal writing process; the family involvement is the subplot that anchors each person in their time period. Jack has worries about his uncles’ reluctance to discuss a murder theory. Riley has worries that her mother is being scammed during the excitement of Lucy’s wedding. I loved the details of Winston’s visits with the Pierce & Sawyer families. The sisters are described so well I could picture them clearly in my mind! Lucy’s wedding worries are occasionally humorous & define the differences between her & Riley.
The ending was well though out & completely satisfying! The only loose end that was not completely tied up was that the museum exhibit was not completed in the story. I can see why this might have been anticlimactic, but I’m a big fan of museums & maybe missed the job involvement a little. That is a very small point in a very interesting story!
I was interested in this book because I love time travel mysteries. Vancouver, Canada, was the filming location for the XFILES and the city has interested me since then.
The author presents a double viewpoint of a historic landmark that exists in the real world…The Hollow Tree! She does a great job of lining up the setting of investigations by Jack & Riley in two time periods so that the reader doesn’t get confused. The theme of the investigations is investment fraud ; the initial plot revolves around the alleged suicide of a investment broker who is found hanging in a tree next to the public landmark of the Hollow Tree. Jack Winston isn’t convinced the man had sufficient motive for suicide & starts a murder investigation. His uncle, the police chief, thinks Jack is wasting his time & would prefer to end the investigation. Jack is perplexed at his uncles’ attitude & journals Riley about the situation.
Riley is delighted to receive new messages from Jack ; she needs some ideas for a new museum exhibit. She proposes Financial Business Leaders of Vancouver to her boss & gets it approved. Riley starts off her research with the names of the men involved in Winston’s case. Oddly enough, she can’t find much information about the man who died- Arthur Pierce. Then her own mystery begins when her mother decides to join an investment group , whose leader she is dating! Riley’s sister Lucy is upset that her mother is investing a large sum of money for her wedding present.
The two investigations are handled through the journal writing process; the family involvement is the subplot that anchors each person in their time period. Jack has worries about his uncles’ reluctance to discuss a murder theory. Riley has worries that her mother is being scammed during the excitement of Lucy’s wedding. I loved the details of Winston’s visits with the Pierce & Sawyer families. The sisters are described so well I could picture them clearly in my mind! Lucy’s wedding worries are occasionally humorous & define the differences between her & Riley.
The ending was well though out & completely satisfying! The only loose end that was not completely tied up was that the museum exhibit was not completed in the story. I can see why this might have been anticlimactic, but I’m a big fan of museums & maybe missed the job involvement a little. That is a very small point in a very interesting story!
August 3, 2022
I really love historical set books. This book actually takes place between two time periods, 1897 and 2017. This is the second book in the Journal Through Time Mysteries series and I am excited to read the first one and any other ones to come.
The main story takes place in the past. A body is found at a famous landmark in Vancouver, the Hollow Tree, in Stanley Park, a large tree you that is hollowed out and attracts many tourists. A prominent businessman, Arthur Peirce, looks to have committed suicide. Detective Jack Winston is on the case with his assistant Constable Thomas Miller. As the case begins to unfold, and it is revealed that he has been murdered, they soon discover that Arthur Pierce was not who he represented himself to be and may have been pulling a Ponzi scheme.
The second part of the story takes place 100 years later and involves a museum curator named, Riley Finch. She and Jack solve cases together through a magical journal they are able to communicate through by writing each other. In the present day, Riley is investigating a financial scheme her mother has gotten involved in.
Throughout the book we see Jack and Riley communicating through the journal. Jack asking if she has any information on the death he's investigating and her giving him advice on how Ponzi schemes work. Riley has also managed to track down one of Jack descendants and she sees him on occasion.
I love the idea of being able to communicate with person from another time through a journal. We find out that the book has magic properties so there is a little suspension of belief but for me that doesn't affect the story. This being the second book in the series, I am most definitely looking forward to more mysteries with these two. The book is well written and clever in the revealing of who the murderer is. I can tell the author did a lot of research involving the history of the time and the setting of the book. The descriptions of the setting are vivid and really take you them. Specifically, the area surrounding the Hollow Tree, which is a real landmark(https://sites.google.com/site/history...).
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this series and very much look forward to more of Jack and Riley and their time traveling adventures. I received this book free from Booksirens for an honest review.
The main story takes place in the past. A body is found at a famous landmark in Vancouver, the Hollow Tree, in Stanley Park, a large tree you that is hollowed out and attracts many tourists. A prominent businessman, Arthur Peirce, looks to have committed suicide. Detective Jack Winston is on the case with his assistant Constable Thomas Miller. As the case begins to unfold, and it is revealed that he has been murdered, they soon discover that Arthur Pierce was not who he represented himself to be and may have been pulling a Ponzi scheme.
The second part of the story takes place 100 years later and involves a museum curator named, Riley Finch. She and Jack solve cases together through a magical journal they are able to communicate through by writing each other. In the present day, Riley is investigating a financial scheme her mother has gotten involved in.
Throughout the book we see Jack and Riley communicating through the journal. Jack asking if she has any information on the death he's investigating and her giving him advice on how Ponzi schemes work. Riley has also managed to track down one of Jack descendants and she sees him on occasion.
I love the idea of being able to communicate with person from another time through a journal. We find out that the book has magic properties so there is a little suspension of belief but for me that doesn't affect the story. This being the second book in the series, I am most definitely looking forward to more mysteries with these two. The book is well written and clever in the revealing of who the murderer is. I can tell the author did a lot of research involving the history of the time and the setting of the book. The descriptions of the setting are vivid and really take you them. Specifically, the area surrounding the Hollow Tree, which is a real landmark(https://sites.google.com/site/history...).
Overall, I thoroughly enjoyed this series and very much look forward to more of Jack and Riley and their time traveling adventures. I received this book free from Booksirens for an honest review.
July 17, 2022
I enjoyed this two-fold mystery, although it was not at all what I expected. It has a magical aspect that surprised me and will require some suspension of disbelief.
The primary mystery happens in Vancouver, Canada, in 1897. I know very little about Canadian history, so I found it interesting to learn more. The main character there is Jack Winston, a police detective investigating an unexpected death.
The secondary mystery occurs in the present day. Museum curator Riley Finch is looking into Jack’s mystery at the same time as she’s trying to learn the facts behind her mother’s new investments.
I should mention, Jack and Riley communicate by writing notes to each other in a magical journal.
I liked the historical portions of the novel best. Jack is handling a very delicate situation involving some of the city’s most important and influential people, including his uncle, who’s also his boss. The most interesting parts of the present day portions are the insights Riley can provide about the historical case, and the brief moments we get with Jack’s descendant.
I will admit that I went online and looked up the Hollow Tree, which was (and is) a real landmark in Vancouver. I didn’t look up any of the other locations mentioned, but doing so could add more depth to the experience of reading the book.
“The Hanging at the Hollow Tree” is the second book in Sarah M. Stephens’ Journal Through Time mystery series. I have not read the first book, and while there are some references to past events that I wondered at, it did not detract from my enjoyment of the book.
If you enjoy historical mysteries and don’t mind a little magic in the mix, I think you will like this story and its characters.
I received an advance reader copy for free. The opinions expressed here are my own.
The primary mystery happens in Vancouver, Canada, in 1897. I know very little about Canadian history, so I found it interesting to learn more. The main character there is Jack Winston, a police detective investigating an unexpected death.
The secondary mystery occurs in the present day. Museum curator Riley Finch is looking into Jack’s mystery at the same time as she’s trying to learn the facts behind her mother’s new investments.
I should mention, Jack and Riley communicate by writing notes to each other in a magical journal.
I liked the historical portions of the novel best. Jack is handling a very delicate situation involving some of the city’s most important and influential people, including his uncle, who’s also his boss. The most interesting parts of the present day portions are the insights Riley can provide about the historical case, and the brief moments we get with Jack’s descendant.
I will admit that I went online and looked up the Hollow Tree, which was (and is) a real landmark in Vancouver. I didn’t look up any of the other locations mentioned, but doing so could add more depth to the experience of reading the book.
“The Hanging at the Hollow Tree” is the second book in Sarah M. Stephens’ Journal Through Time mystery series. I have not read the first book, and while there are some references to past events that I wondered at, it did not detract from my enjoyment of the book.
If you enjoy historical mysteries and don’t mind a little magic in the mix, I think you will like this story and its characters.
I received an advance reader copy for free. The opinions expressed here are my own.
August 4, 2022
This is the second book in the Journal Through Time Mysteries. It is not necessary to read the first book The Dead of False Creek to enjoy this, although it might explain in more detail how the journal linking the two protagonists was found and operates. I was drawn in by the premise of this book and the striking cover. We have two timelines here separated by 120 years. In 1897 there is a police detective, Jack Winston, who is investigating the hanging alluded to in the title. A prominent businessman has been found hanged in Vancouver, Jack and the medical examiner think it was a murder but the chief constable wants the case treated as a suicide. In 2017 an archivist, Riley is researching into the early business history of Vancouver and is also helping her bridezilla sister’s wedding preparations. Jack and Riley are connected by a magical journal, in which they can each write to communicate with the other across the years.
This is a cozy historical murder mystery with a magical twist. The main characters are likeable and well fleshed out. The character development of Constable Miller under Jack’s tutelage is nicely done. On both timelines there are some dodgy Ponzi style schemes, in the 1890s this is connected to a device which allegedly helps gold prospectors and in the present day there is a dubious cryptocurrency that Riley’s mother has been enamored by. The pacing is good and it is an entertaining read.
Many thanks to BookSirens and Sarah M. Stephen for this complimentary e-ARC. I leave this honest review voluntarily.
Each word had the potential to alter history. Since they had first connected, she had taken great care not to reveal much about the future.
This is a cozy historical murder mystery with a magical twist. The main characters are likeable and well fleshed out. The character development of Constable Miller under Jack’s tutelage is nicely done. On both timelines there are some dodgy Ponzi style schemes, in the 1890s this is connected to a device which allegedly helps gold prospectors and in the present day there is a dubious cryptocurrency that Riley’s mother has been enamored by. The pacing is good and it is an entertaining read.
Many thanks to BookSirens and Sarah M. Stephen for this complimentary e-ARC. I leave this honest review voluntarily.
August 3, 2022
After reading the first book in the Journal Through Time mystery series, The Dead of False Creek last year, I have been waiting (mostly) patiently to get my hands on the next book in the series.
I am thrilled to say that it was worth the wait! It was exciting to see Jack and Riley working together once again through the magic of the journal. I found myself falling right back in love with Jack as I found out more about his family history and how that history influenced his decisions within the cases he investigated. The progression of the mystery mixed with the personal and historical elements made for a light and cozy read.
The shifting point of view between the past and the present was effortless. The journal connecting Riley and Jack helped to ensure that the switch was never jarring or hard to follow. Rather than distract from the mystery, it enhanced it by providing context by showing the differences between the historical and the modern.
Given that there are two timelines to focus on, there is a lot of information to process. This can make the pacing feel slow, but it also gives the characters a little bit of room to breathe as the information is also given to them.
The Hanging at the Hollow tree was a beautifully done cozy mystery that is perfect for anyone who loves having a link to the past while curling up with a good book.
4.5/5 stars
A huge thank you to Sarah M Stephen for a copy of this eARC in exchange for my honest opinions.
I am thrilled to say that it was worth the wait! It was exciting to see Jack and Riley working together once again through the magic of the journal. I found myself falling right back in love with Jack as I found out more about his family history and how that history influenced his decisions within the cases he investigated. The progression of the mystery mixed with the personal and historical elements made for a light and cozy read.
The shifting point of view between the past and the present was effortless. The journal connecting Riley and Jack helped to ensure that the switch was never jarring or hard to follow. Rather than distract from the mystery, it enhanced it by providing context by showing the differences between the historical and the modern.
Given that there are two timelines to focus on, there is a lot of information to process. This can make the pacing feel slow, but it also gives the characters a little bit of room to breathe as the information is also given to them.
The Hanging at the Hollow tree was a beautifully done cozy mystery that is perfect for anyone who loves having a link to the past while curling up with a good book.
4.5/5 stars
A huge thank you to Sarah M Stephen for a copy of this eARC in exchange for my honest opinions.
August 16, 2022
This is the second in the Journal Through Time mysteries. I haven’t read the first book (The Dead of False Creek), and I feel like I missed out on something. It is possible to enjoy this book without having read the first one, but it’s kind of like meeting folks who have a history together, and their quick explanations of things just aren’t the same as having been there yourself. I’m planning to buy and read that first book.
I appreciate that there’s no real explanation given for why the journal works – it just does. It’s obviously magical, but we don’t know how or why. I’m good with that. And I like this premise of having two people working on the same case across time. The characters are engaging, and I like the way they support each other through the knowledge available to each in their different times. It’s very creative. I had trouble putting this book down.
The basic premise of this story is one that seems to have been around since the dawn of time – the confidence game. It happened hundreds and thousands of years ago, and it’s still happening today. I really appreciated the treatment it was given in this book, showing the far-reaching effects on the individuals involved directly and on the periphery.
I look forward to reading more by this author.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I appreciate that there’s no real explanation given for why the journal works – it just does. It’s obviously magical, but we don’t know how or why. I’m good with that. And I like this premise of having two people working on the same case across time. The characters are engaging, and I like the way they support each other through the knowledge available to each in their different times. It’s very creative. I had trouble putting this book down.
The basic premise of this story is one that seems to have been around since the dawn of time – the confidence game. It happened hundreds and thousands of years ago, and it’s still happening today. I really appreciated the treatment it was given in this book, showing the far-reaching effects on the individuals involved directly and on the periphery.
I look forward to reading more by this author.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 28, 2022
Riley & Jack (and Sarah Stephen) have done it again! A page turner mystery to solve – but can they do it without effecting events of this and past centuries? As I stated after reading the first book in this series, the author has a unique approach to the idea of navigating the Space/Time Continuum. The detecting duo living over 100 years apart make an unusual but very effective crime solving team.
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree takes us into the world, both past and present, of financial investment fraud and those who prey on the financially and emotionally vulnerable. But what kind of forensic evidence can stand the test of not only time, but the politically powerful? Once again the characters are fully developed, the plot line fully researched and well thought out. The story comes to a full conclusion, yet we are left rooting for continued development in personal relationships both past and present.
While you can absolutely read this book as a stand-alone, I highly recommend reading the premier book “The Dead of False Creek” for the back story and a complete experience. You don’t want to miss out on one minute of the adventures of Riley & Jack!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree takes us into the world, both past and present, of financial investment fraud and those who prey on the financially and emotionally vulnerable. But what kind of forensic evidence can stand the test of not only time, but the politically powerful? Once again the characters are fully developed, the plot line fully researched and well thought out. The story comes to a full conclusion, yet we are left rooting for continued development in personal relationships both past and present.
While you can absolutely read this book as a stand-alone, I highly recommend reading the premier book “The Dead of False Creek” for the back story and a complete experience. You don’t want to miss out on one minute of the adventures of Riley & Jack!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 16, 2022
I'll be honest, this book took a bit to get in to as I had not read the first book in the series. The way the story is written, spanning two different time periods, if you are unfamiliar with the way the two characters, Jack and Riley, communicate then it takes a bit to get the hang of.
However, i was pleasantly surprised with this book! The two main characters, Jack - who is a detective in the late 1800's, and Riley - who is an archivist in the mid 2010's, are able to magically communicate via a journal that both have access to. Using this journal, and their everyday lives, Jack and Riley work to solve a mystery of a man who was found in Jack's time but has ties to the modern day world. The author, Sarah M Stephen, does a great job of tying the two vastly different worlds together, while also keeping things complex enough to keep you on the edge of your seat! I was unsure of who the murderer was until the very end of the book! I am definitely looking forward to the next book in the series!
However, i was pleasantly surprised with this book! The two main characters, Jack - who is a detective in the late 1800's, and Riley - who is an archivist in the mid 2010's, are able to magically communicate via a journal that both have access to. Using this journal, and their everyday lives, Jack and Riley work to solve a mystery of a man who was found in Jack's time but has ties to the modern day world. The author, Sarah M Stephen, does a great job of tying the two vastly different worlds together, while also keeping things complex enough to keep you on the edge of your seat! I was unsure of who the murderer was until the very end of the book! I am definitely looking forward to the next book in the series!
August 20, 2022
I don’t know how to feel :(
The first book in the series had been a favorite of last year, I loved it!! Really entertained me and I read it really fast! This book, however, wasn’t the case.
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree was a very slow read, it had way too many chapters and I feel like the ending could’ve come way sooner than it did if it weren’t because of how many different roads the book took.
I really liked that I got to know more of Riley, but even though Educoin was related to what was happening in Winston’s world, I don’t think it added too much to the story. Plus her confronting her mom’s “boyfriend” was too rushed for me. I would like to see more of Jake and what ends up happening between the two of them.
Saying this, it was a good book, not my favorite but it was an okay book. I did expect a bit more but I still want to read the book that’s coming out next year!
-
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
The first book in the series had been a favorite of last year, I loved it!! Really entertained me and I read it really fast! This book, however, wasn’t the case.
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree was a very slow read, it had way too many chapters and I feel like the ending could’ve come way sooner than it did if it weren’t because of how many different roads the book took.
I really liked that I got to know more of Riley, but even though Educoin was related to what was happening in Winston’s world, I don’t think it added too much to the story. Plus her confronting her mom’s “boyfriend” was too rushed for me. I would like to see more of Jake and what ends up happening between the two of them.
Saying this, it was a good book, not my favorite but it was an okay book. I did expect a bit more but I still want to read the book that’s coming out next year!
-
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 12, 2022
The Hanging Tree is Book 2 in A Journal Through the Time Mystery by Sarah M Stephen. I loved book 1 so much that I wasn't sure this book would be as enjoyable; but, I loved book 2! I think that having a journal that you can write on in 1897 by Jack and Riley read and write back from 2017 is creative. Jack is trying to solve a murder of Arthur Pierce who was found hanging by the Hollow Tree. This time, there was very little information for Riley to find and she and Jack work hard to solve this murder. I think Jack and Riley are wonderful characters and I feel that Sarah M Stephen writes great supporting characters along with a solid mystery to solve. I hope that book 3 is released soon so I can see what these friends over time will get into next. I received an arc for free and am leaving my review voluntarily.
July 29, 2022
I thoroughly enjoyed this unique murder mystery. The plot unfolds at a steady pace and is well thought out. I especially enjoyed the details of present-day Vancouver, Canada, and what it looked/felt like in the late 1800s. The notebook that allows the two main characters to communicate is an intriguing detail and one I devoured when it appeared in the story.
This is the second book in the series, and I read it first. It made perfect sense to me and I didn't feel as though I'd missed anything integral to the story. I would've liked to have known a bit more about Jack Winston, the detective from the past.
I plan on purchasing the first book in this series, just to find out how some of the details I read in this good book came to pass.
Well done, Sarah M. Stephen!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I'm leaving this review voluntarily.
This is the second book in the series, and I read it first. It made perfect sense to me and I didn't feel as though I'd missed anything integral to the story. I would've liked to have known a bit more about Jack Winston, the detective from the past.
I plan on purchasing the first book in this series, just to find out how some of the details I read in this good book came to pass.
Well done, Sarah M. Stephen!
I received an advance review copy for free, and I'm leaving this review voluntarily.
August 14, 2022
Thank you booksirens and Sarah M Stephen for this earc I got in exchange for an honest review.
Vancouver, 1897. Decective Jack Winston is investigating a case where a man is found hanging in Stanley Park.
Vancouver, 2017. Riley, an archivist, is working on a new project at the museum, while preparing for her sisters wedding. To top that off, her mom arrives with interesting news, that makes Riley worried.
Sadly, I didn’t enjoy this quite as much as the first book in the series. I loved the communication between Jack and Riley and that they can help each other out. I really enjoyed the mystery in Jack’s part of the book, but I don’t feel we really got an ending to Riley’s troubles and story. But hopefully we’ll get that in book 3. I will give this a solid 3 stars and I will definetely read the next book in the series. I can’t wait to see where Jack and Riley goes next.
Vancouver, 1897. Decective Jack Winston is investigating a case where a man is found hanging in Stanley Park.
Vancouver, 2017. Riley, an archivist, is working on a new project at the museum, while preparing for her sisters wedding. To top that off, her mom arrives with interesting news, that makes Riley worried.
Sadly, I didn’t enjoy this quite as much as the first book in the series. I loved the communication between Jack and Riley and that they can help each other out. I really enjoyed the mystery in Jack’s part of the book, but I don’t feel we really got an ending to Riley’s troubles and story. But hopefully we’ll get that in book 3. I will give this a solid 3 stars and I will definetely read the next book in the series. I can’t wait to see where Jack and Riley goes next.
September 6, 2022
I really like the unique premise of two people solving mysteries over nearly a century through a journal. Both Riley (an present-day archivist) and Jack (a detective in 1897) were fascinating in their own right, but add in two mysteries and you have quite an interesting tale.
I really enjoyed how the author wove the two tales together, even if fraud in 1897 and 2017 would not seem to overlap. the author really did a great job pulling the two stories together, giving you just enough background on early 19th century banking processes to make you want to do more research.
I also enjoyed the interactions between Riley and Jack which added perspective on the times and created an interesting backdrop to the story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I really enjoyed how the author wove the two tales together, even if fraud in 1897 and 2017 would not seem to overlap. the author really did a great job pulling the two stories together, giving you just enough background on early 19th century banking processes to make you want to do more research.
I also enjoyed the interactions between Riley and Jack which added perspective on the times and created an interesting backdrop to the story.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
August 14, 2022
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
An enjoyable read with a decent mystery. It was fun switching between time periods, and the author did a good job of not letting the transfer of knowledge make solving the mystery easy. There were some aspects of the character interactions that seemed “tell not show” rather than developing naturally, but that may be a result of being the second in a series. That being said, it was possible to follow and understand the world and characters, so the book can stand alone. Though I’ll probably look up the first book anyway.
An enjoyable read with a decent mystery. It was fun switching between time periods, and the author did a good job of not letting the transfer of knowledge make solving the mystery easy. There were some aspects of the character interactions that seemed “tell not show” rather than developing naturally, but that may be a result of being the second in a series. That being said, it was possible to follow and understand the world and characters, so the book can stand alone. Though I’ll probably look up the first book anyway.
August 26, 2022
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree did not disappoint! I loved the first book and had high hopes for this second book. And I loved it. The author has an easy-to-read writing style that I really like. The plot was very interesting. I love the dual timeline and the similarities between them. I found the story to be compelling, especially once I hit the halfway mark. I couldn't put it down. Highly recommend this series. I love Winston and Riley. I was glad to see a little bit more of the 'magic' that brings them together in this book too.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 13, 2022
I received an advanced review copy for free, and I am leaving an honest review voluntarily.
I absolutely loved this book. I love anything with time travel and this story wove two times in history together so beautifully. The characters were well created and I was drawn to both of them from page one.
As this was book 2 in this series, I am definitely going to have to get a copy
book one to read. I will also be following closely to Ms. Stephen and will definitely want to read all future books with Jack and Riley fighting crime and catching bad guys together in the past and the present!
I absolutely loved this book. I love anything with time travel and this story wove two times in history together so beautifully. The characters were well created and I was drawn to both of them from page one.
As this was book 2 in this series, I am definitely going to have to get a copy
book one to read. I will also be following closely to Ms. Stephen and will definitely want to read all future books with Jack and Riley fighting crime and catching bad guys together in the past and the present!
July 17, 2022
The Hanging at the Hollow Tree is propulsive reading. I look forward to Riley's and Jack's mysterious adventures and this one, is perhaps, the best one yet. Sarah M Stephen writes with such a deft hand, I did not figure out who-done-it until it was spelled out for me. There is such dichotomy in this series - the magic of the journal is in stark contrast to the real-life day-to-day activities of both Riley and Jack. That dichotomy and the multi-layered story, kept me enthralled from beginning to end. Excellent mystery! Thank you for my advance review copy, I am leaving this review voluntarily.
July 21, 2022
What an exciting and well written mystery full of an array of vibrant, colorful and of course scheming characters that will draw you into its mystery you cannot help but want to get acquainted with them more so.the mysterys enticing you with its intrigue covered in secrets, lies and manipulation while the plot carries you along throughout keeping you turning page after page .I couldn't place it to the side because I was so enraptured until arriving at the unexpected and climatic conclusion. Acquire " The Hanging at the Hollow Tree " for hours of enjoyable entertainment. 😯🤔🤨😏😀Kat
March 25, 2024
An easy read which allows you to escape
This book was an easy read that provided a nice escape to a different time and place. I am quite familiar with Vancouver, having family who lives there and visiting multiple times over decades. That said the touch of the familiar brought joy as I warmly remembered my Aunt, Cousins and I exploring these same places.
There is good character development and an interesting plot which kept me reading. Thank you to the author for providing a bit of my own “journal” during this read. Looking forward to reading the other 2 in the series.
This book was an easy read that provided a nice escape to a different time and place. I am quite familiar with Vancouver, having family who lives there and visiting multiple times over decades. That said the touch of the familiar brought joy as I warmly remembered my Aunt, Cousins and I exploring these same places.
There is good character development and an interesting plot which kept me reading. Thank you to the author for providing a bit of my own “journal” during this read. Looking forward to reading the other 2 in the series.
August 16, 2022
I love this series! It’s unusual and heartfelt! Riley is an archivist working in the present and she works with Detective Jack Winston in the past on his cases. I love the magical aspect of the mysteries and the relationship between Jack and Riley will keep me reading. The author weaves them together in a magical way with a great mystery for them to solve! I can’t wait to see where it goes next! Thank you to Book Sirens for the advanced reader copy.
October 11, 2022
I liked the first one The Dead of False Creek enough to want to read the second book and hope that the writing improved. It didn't. Stephen has two really good characters, Jack Winston, a Vancouver police detective in the 1897, and Riley Finch, an archivist in 2017, who discover they can communicate through the pages of a journal. Unfortunately, the author still doesn't seem sure what to do with them (and the fact that she's made Jack's grandson Riley's sort-of maybe love interest, even while Riley is clearly pining for Jack, still just a bit eeewwwww).
The story in each of the timelines are similar. Jack is called to investigate the apparent suicide of a local financier who has been very popular among Vancouver's movers and shakers by promising them incredible returns on their investments. Riley's mom is singing the praises of some investments she's made with a mysterious man. Jack becomes convinced the suicide was really murder, and Riley becomes convinced her mom's being duped. So far so good. But there's a total lack of real connection between the stories. While Riley offers Jack some (very) basic info about how to spot a scam artist, there's no a-ha! moment. Nor does anything Jack does help Riley. There's no STORY connection between the two. Their only connection is to let off steam to one another, but it fails to build any kind of tension. (The biggest tension is what's going to happen when they run out of pages in the journal.)
Meanwhile, the writing continues to just be so clunky as to be painful - especially when you've just finished reading Elizabeth George and William Kent Kreuger. Every action is overexplained.
"A flutter in his stomach reminded him he need to tread carefully."
"Her fingers tingled and her heart rate picked up as she typed Pierce's name into the directory." (Oooh, way to add excitement!)
"He [the victim lying on a morgue table] was unclothed. Where had they taken his clothes? Winston made a mental note to find them and search the dead man's pockets for clues." (Just stop after the question. What else would Jack do with that information?)
As he spoke, he knew he needed to slow down to allow the Sawyers tor each to each question."
Groan. This is a good series in serious need of a good editor.
The story in each of the timelines are similar. Jack is called to investigate the apparent suicide of a local financier who has been very popular among Vancouver's movers and shakers by promising them incredible returns on their investments. Riley's mom is singing the praises of some investments she's made with a mysterious man. Jack becomes convinced the suicide was really murder, and Riley becomes convinced her mom's being duped. So far so good. But there's a total lack of real connection between the stories. While Riley offers Jack some (very) basic info about how to spot a scam artist, there's no a-ha! moment. Nor does anything Jack does help Riley. There's no STORY connection between the two. Their only connection is to let off steam to one another, but it fails to build any kind of tension. (The biggest tension is what's going to happen when they run out of pages in the journal.)
Meanwhile, the writing continues to just be so clunky as to be painful - especially when you've just finished reading Elizabeth George and William Kent Kreuger. Every action is overexplained.
"A flutter in his stomach reminded him he need to tread carefully."
"Her fingers tingled and her heart rate picked up as she typed Pierce's name into the directory." (Oooh, way to add excitement!)
"He [the victim lying on a morgue table] was unclothed. Where had they taken his clothes? Winston made a mental note to find them and search the dead man's pockets for clues." (Just stop after the question. What else would Jack do with that information?)
As he spoke, he knew he needed to slow down to allow the Sawyers tor each to each question."
Groan. This is a good series in serious need of a good editor.
August 26, 2023
I love the idea of a detective in the past being linked to a researcher in the future through a journal. The researcher tries to help the detective without changing the past and future. I was sure that Riley sending some info back would change the past but somehow they worked it out. Interesting that Riley's situation in the present was similar to the case Jack was working on in the past. Can't wait for more about Johnny.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 36 reviews