Ugh, wow. This was a BAD book.
A bad book in general, and a terrible, terrible romance.
Caution, spoilers (and a rant) ahead...
If you pick up Alaskan Holiday like I did, not knowing anything about it, and simply read the back, you would be totally mislead.
The back cover describes two people (Josie and Palmer) who meet in a tiny Alaskan town so far removed from civilization that a bulk of the area's population leaves before winter sets in. The back cover describes Josie coming to the town of Ponder for the summer, to work in the kitchen of the town's lodge before starting her dream job as a sous chef in Seattle. The back cover says she and Palmer (who is a local and a swordsmith) grow close during the summer months...and so based on the back cover you, the reader, would naturally assume we're going to see this city gal from the lower 48 settle into this wilderness town and adapt to it's "off the map" society while getting cozy with a local mountain man...and you would be sorely disappointed.
Because when the book starts, you quickly realize before the end of the first paragraph that summer has passed, the meet-cute described on the back of the book has already taken place, and Palmer is apparently so in love with Josie that he is planning on proposing to her THE DAY BEFORE she is supposed to fly back to Seattle to start her dream job.
This, right here, sent the warning bells ringing that I was in store for a badly written romance novel.
I don't think I'm alone when I say that part of what makes a romance enjoyable is seeing the entire "couple falling in love" process. To be told right at the beginning that they are already dating took away both the fun of seeing their courtship begin, but it also made me care very little about their already established "relationship". I'm *told* that Palmer is in love with Josie, so much so that he wants her to stay in Ponder and marry him...I'm not *shown* it. And therefore because I wasn't shown this love story emerging, I can't deny that I'm completely on Josie's side when she (spoiler) turns him down.
Ugh, and then things get tedious.
A lot of people have commented on Palmer's awkward and disastrous proposal, which in all honesty, is REALLY bad. But I still couldn't get over the fact that he decided to do it THE NIGHT BEFORE she was meant to leave. And clearly the love he thought they shared didn't have quite the same impact on Josie because she's totally taken by surprise, and the fact that she says "no" to him because again, her entire focus is on her dream job. Even when Josie misses the boat the following morning to leave Ponder, she makes it VERY clear to various people, including Palmer, she didn't stay because of him, and she wants to get out of dodge as soon as possible.
This does not bode well for a happily ever after.
And so we encounter another story where the woman's career becomes the "evil entity" that is keeping the couple apart. Even the woman Josie goes to to receive relationship advice doesn't help matters by telling Josie that she had once been in her shoes, attending school thousands of miles away but all she could think about was the guy she left behind back in Alaska, and so her grades suffered to the point that she barely managed to graduate. And in both cases of Josie's story and this other woman's, the men COULD NEVER leave Alaska behind.
Now compromise is key in making a relationship work, and both parties have to be willing to do some giving. But in Alaskan Holiday it feels that it's only the women who are doing the giving and the men get to have their cake and eat it to. Because Palmer hates big cities and crowds and likes rural spaces and therefore the idea of him moving out of Alaska, let alone moving into a big city like Seattle for Josie, is out of the question. While he doesn't present this as a "threatening ultimatum", he does tell her point blank, "I can never live in a city" putting the kibosh on any compromise *before* she leaves Alaska for Seattle.
So...if Josie wants this relationship to work in any way, shape, or form, SHE is going to have to give things up. And she does struggle with this, because A) she worked really, really hard to earn her culinary degree, B) she loves what she does, and C) with the possible exception of cities in Alaska, there aren't that many opportunities for her to do what she loves, especially in a place like Ponder. So the ball is ENTIRELY in Josie's court on whether this relationship can be salvaged or not, and that's not fair in the slightest. She's put into a corner and she will have to ultimately choose between love for Palmer or love for her dreams.
But have no fear, Debbie Macomber solves this "crisis" by making Josie's dream job a nightmare. The chef she works for turns out to be a jerk and a sleazebag, and makes her brief months working in his kitchen so hellish that by the end of the book she realizes "no, I don't want to do that anymore" SO PROBLEM SOLVED! Now she can go back to Ponder and churn out babies for Palmer who more or less gets everything he wanted in the end (the girl *and* the choice never to leave Alaska)
Oh, and Palmer is never wrong either. Meaning that Palmer does the thing that so many women just *~*love*~* which is grow insanely jealous of Josie's boss, tell Josie he's a sexist creep, AND is prove right!
Look, I didn't care much for Josie, but in the end, I quite frankly wanted her flip Palmer off and open her own restaurant in any place other than Alaska, because she could do SO MUCH BETTER.
Oh, and don't get me started on the world's most annoying side character, Jack. Clearly Macomber thought he was comic relief. No, no he wasn't. He was obnoxious and needed to choke on whatever food he was constantly shoveling into his mouth.
Palmer is not the sort of romantic hero a heroine should be pining for. Josie is not the heroine readers should be idolizing, and Alaskan Holiday is not a romance that should be recommended to ANYONE, period. 1 star