What do you think?
Rate this book
Grace
She gave you her baby. Now she wants her back.
Nineteen-year-old Michelle has had a tough life, to say the least. Then she gets pregnant. She is convinced she would be a terrible mother but having grown up in care, she cannot bring herself to subject her child to the same fate.
Amelia and her husband have dreamed of having a family for years, but have lost all hope after the worst kind of tragedy. Then they are offered the chance to adopt baby Grace, and it feels like they finally have everything they've ever wanted.
But then Michelle decides she wants her daughter back, and it's up to the courts to decide. What is best for Grace – a mother's love, or a stable home? Whatever the ruling, one thing is certain: neither woman's life will ever be the same again...
Nineteen-year-old Michelle has had a tough life, to say the least. Then she gets pregnant. She is convinced she would be a terrible mother but having grown up in care, she cannot bring herself to subject her child to the same fate.
Amelia and her husband have dreamed of having a family for years, but have lost all hope after the worst kind of tragedy. Then they are offered the chance to adopt baby Grace, and it feels like they finally have everything they've ever wanted.
But then Michelle decides she wants her daughter back, and it's up to the courts to decide. What is best for Grace – a mother's love, or a stable home? Whatever the ruling, one thing is certain: neither woman's life will ever be the same again...
- GenresFictionContemporary
Audiobook
First published July 7, 2022
37 people are currently reading
301 people want to read
About the author
Victoria Scott
7 books141 followersVictoria Scott is a bestselling British author of life-affirming fiction, known for her gripping gothic historical mysteries and uplifting book club novels that explore themes of hope, resilience and the power of human friendship and love. Her books are perfect for fans of Lucinda Riley, Kate Morton, and Jojo Moyes.
Her novels, The Storyteller’s Daughter and The Women Who Wouldn’t Leave, are both Amazon Top 100 bestsellers. Her latest novel, The House on the Cliff – a haunting, atmospheric tale of secrets and second chances – is out now.
Before becoming a novelist, Victoria worked as a journalist for the BBC, The Telegraph and Al Jazeera. She now combines her love of storytelling with lecturing in journalism at Kingston University.
Victoria lives on an island in the River Thames with her husband, two children, and a cat called Alice. When she’s not writing, she is a keen (but amateur) singer and gardener.
Follow Victoria for updates and behind-the-scenes book content:
Instagram & TikTok: @VictoriaScottAuthor
Facebook: @VictoriaScottJournalist
X/Twitter: @toryscott
Her novels, The Storyteller’s Daughter and The Women Who Wouldn’t Leave, are both Amazon Top 100 bestsellers. Her latest novel, The House on the Cliff – a haunting, atmospheric tale of secrets and second chances – is out now.
Before becoming a novelist, Victoria worked as a journalist for the BBC, The Telegraph and Al Jazeera. She now combines her love of storytelling with lecturing in journalism at Kingston University.
Victoria lives on an island in the River Thames with her husband, two children, and a cat called Alice. When she’s not writing, she is a keen (but amateur) singer and gardener.
Follow Victoria for updates and behind-the-scenes book content:
Instagram & TikTok: @VictoriaScottAuthor
Facebook: @VictoriaScottJournalist
X/Twitter: @toryscott
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
February 18, 2023
Michelle has had a rough upbringing. As a child she was shuffled from one foster home to another. When she becomes pregnant at nineteen she knows there is no way she can subject her baby to a life with her and her partner Rob who is a drug user. When he is on drugs he is never aware of what he is doing. They live from hand to mouth each day.
Amelia and her husband Piers, who is housemaster at a Langland College, boys school in England, have dreamed of a family. But despite IVF it has never happened for them. Amelia already knew the pain of a child’s death with her daughter Leila piers also had tragedy from his past and his first marriage. They start to foster Michelle’s baby, Grace, with the hope of adopting her. But it will be a long process before that can be made official and Amelia can relax and not fear Grace’s birth mother will renege on the deal and will want her baby back. It is left to a judge when Amelia's fears are realised in more ways than she imagined.
The story is told from the point of view of both Michelle and Amelia. The reader is privy to their secrets. I felt for both of them. Did the judge make the right decision in the end? Up to the reader to decide.
If you get through reading this one without heartache and your emotions being torn in two, you are made of sterner stuff than me. A compulsively emotional read that captured me from start to finish. Has the ring of authenticity and I wanted to keep reading all the time. A highly recommended read.
Interesting play on the word grace too. Not only is it the baby's name but grace is shown by characters in this story. I devoured this book.
Amelia and her husband Piers, who is housemaster at a Langland College, boys school in England, have dreamed of a family. But despite IVF it has never happened for them. Amelia already knew the pain of a child’s death with her daughter Leila piers also had tragedy from his past and his first marriage. They start to foster Michelle’s baby, Grace, with the hope of adopting her. But it will be a long process before that can be made official and Amelia can relax and not fear Grace’s birth mother will renege on the deal and will want her baby back. It is left to a judge when Amelia's fears are realised in more ways than she imagined.
The story is told from the point of view of both Michelle and Amelia. The reader is privy to their secrets. I felt for both of them. Did the judge make the right decision in the end? Up to the reader to decide.
If you get through reading this one without heartache and your emotions being torn in two, you are made of sterner stuff than me. A compulsively emotional read that captured me from start to finish. Has the ring of authenticity and I wanted to keep reading all the time. A highly recommended read.
Interesting play on the word grace too. Not only is it the baby's name but grace is shown by characters in this story. I devoured this book.
June 29, 2022
The unfolding of this story is heartbreaking. It is beautifully written with empathy and understanding of the situation. The characters are so real they jump out of the pages - two women whose pain is raw: one the birth mother, Michelle, and the other, Amelia, the hopeful adoptive mother.
Based on true stories, courtroom scenes, social services shortcomings and some very supportive individuals in the care system, the novel provides an insight into the legal process when an unmarried wayward girl at the time of her daughter’s birth decides to give her daughter up for adoption, only later to change her mind. She though is not the only person in the mix, as the father of the child decides he too wishes to care for his daughter. On the other side, we have the couple, Amelia and Piers the prospective adoptive parents, who have their own insurmountable problems.
The story flows nicely with some unexpected twists and turns, A fantastic, totally absorbing novel. My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Head of Zeus, for this advance copy.
Based on true stories, courtroom scenes, social services shortcomings and some very supportive individuals in the care system, the novel provides an insight into the legal process when an unmarried wayward girl at the time of her daughter’s birth decides to give her daughter up for adoption, only later to change her mind. She though is not the only person in the mix, as the father of the child decides he too wishes to care for his daughter. On the other side, we have the couple, Amelia and Piers the prospective adoptive parents, who have their own insurmountable problems.
The story flows nicely with some unexpected twists and turns, A fantastic, totally absorbing novel. My thanks to NetGalley and the publishers, Head of Zeus, for this advance copy.
July 10, 2022
I was so happy to get invited to read this, I loved Patience - both the story and Victoria’s writing style.
Her second book didn’t disappoint at all! It beautifully tells both sides of a foster/adoption story, and where it could have dived into schmaltzy tropes, it never does. The emotional impact on everyone involved (and it’s not just the two women most directly affected, it’s everyone around them too) is told with heartbreaking clarity and detail, I found myself constantly thinking what I would do in their situations as they were all relatable to me to varying degrees, such was the realism with which they are drawn.
It dawned on me early on that the very nature of this story meant that there wasn’t going to be a fully happy ending for everyone and I tried to steel myself in readiness…it didn’t work. I was still a bit of a blubbering wreck as I came towards the end.
Another fantastic read from Victoria Scott, I can’t wait for the next one.
Her second book didn’t disappoint at all! It beautifully tells both sides of a foster/adoption story, and where it could have dived into schmaltzy tropes, it never does. The emotional impact on everyone involved (and it’s not just the two women most directly affected, it’s everyone around them too) is told with heartbreaking clarity and detail, I found myself constantly thinking what I would do in their situations as they were all relatable to me to varying degrees, such was the realism with which they are drawn.
It dawned on me early on that the very nature of this story meant that there wasn’t going to be a fully happy ending for everyone and I tried to steel myself in readiness…it didn’t work. I was still a bit of a blubbering wreck as I came towards the end.
Another fantastic read from Victoria Scott, I can’t wait for the next one.
July 7, 2022
This is such a bittersweet story that moved me emotionally and had me changing opinions throughout.
It is the story of baby Grace, and whether she should be placed with her birth mother or her foster to adopt parents.
This story is definitely one that I’d recommend, it is well thought-out, emotive and demonstrates that things are not always as clear cut as you think they are.
Many thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for gifting me this arc in exchange for an honest, unbiased review.
It is the story of baby Grace, and whether she should be placed with her birth mother or her foster to adopt parents.
This story is definitely one that I’d recommend, it is well thought-out, emotive and demonstrates that things are not always as clear cut as you think they are.
Many thanks to the author, publisher and NetGalley for gifting me this arc in exchange for an honest, unbiased review.
September 19, 2022
Such an emotionally complex book that really makes you have sympathy for the main characters, Michelle and Amelia. By part three, I couldn’t put it down as I became so invested in their stories. Definitely worth a read. 5/5.
July 13, 2022
Grace follows the lives of two very different woman who are worlds apart. Michelle is a teenager, living in an council flat with an abusive boyfriend where they regularly forfeit food and electricity in exchange for drugs. Amelia is married to Piers, the housemaster of a private school where they live on campus. She’s privileged and well-off and has the life she’s always dreamed of having… hasn’t she?
When Michelle gives birth to a baby girl (who she calls Grace) she is taken away by social services and placed into the care of Amelia and her husband who plan to adopt baby Grace. The only issue is… Michelle wants her back.
This book was utterly brilliant. A harrowing look at the extreme class divide in the UK and how so many children are failed by the system. It also explores the idea that all the money in the world cannot buy you happiness.
A really beautiful book that will stick with you a long time after you finish the last page.
When Michelle gives birth to a baby girl (who she calls Grace) she is taken away by social services and placed into the care of Amelia and her husband who plan to adopt baby Grace. The only issue is… Michelle wants her back.
This book was utterly brilliant. A harrowing look at the extreme class divide in the UK and how so many children are failed by the system. It also explores the idea that all the money in the world cannot buy you happiness.
A really beautiful book that will stick with you a long time after you finish the last page.
July 3, 2022
This could easily have descended into a schmaltzy tearjerker but it doesn't, not at all. Instead you have a considered exploration of 'don't judge someone till you've walked in their shoes'. Scott seems to be a talented writer, building on her previous book 'Patience' dealing with sensitive, emotive issues.
November 10, 2022
Victoria has a knack for writing with such sensitivity, whatever the subject. This was a touching story, and I really felt for the two main female characters. It was quite early on that I was not a fan of Piers, however. He was a snobby, misogynistic control freak.
It was beautifully written, and I definitely shed a few years on more than one occasion.
It was beautifully written, and I definitely shed a few years on more than one occasion.
July 17, 2022
Such heartbreaking themes in this story, but one I’ve really enjoyed reading. I was rooting for Michelle and Amelia at the same time and wanted them both to triumph. I think the ending was perfect. Can’t wait to read more from this author
February 6, 2022
This second book from Victoria Scott is another amazing page-turner.
Told from the viewpoint of two women, both at different ends of the same struggle, with an additional view of the judge presiding over a very heart-wrenching child custody case.
Michelle is young and has suffered considerably in that short life, at the hands of an inadept social services team, who failed her, from the moment she was separated from her younger sister at the age of six. Fast forward to her late teens, and she has found herself pregnant, in a relationship with a man who has stood by her more than any of the so-called support workers she has had assigned to her. Even his questionable behaviour towards her doesn't waiver her trust in him.
However, they're broke, live in squalor, and she knows that is no place to bring up a baby, however much she is already attached to that little being.
Amelia is a woman, in a marriage tinged with sadness at the fact that they can't have children, and the one time they thought their dream would come true ended up in the tragedy of stillbirth.
A solution to both of these women's problems could be found, in the placement of little Grace, born to Michelle. She thinks her daughter would be better off in the care of someone who could give her everything.
And that someone could be Amelia, and her husband Piers, who are approached via the Foster to Adopt scheme.
The thing is, nothing is ever that simple.
It was, indeed a roller coaster of emotions as I read the story, following the feelings of a young woman who desperately wants to get her life, and daughter back, and a woman who knows her dream is on the cusp of becoming a reality, but everything balances on the decisions of a judge, after a drawn-out investigation.
All in all, the final conclusion was what I wanted to happen, but there was so much happening in the background, as you read, even if you are of a differing opinion, you would probably agree that it was for the best. People are not always what they seem, and this book demonstrated that, perfectly.
So emotional. But brilliant.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Head of Zeus for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Told from the viewpoint of two women, both at different ends of the same struggle, with an additional view of the judge presiding over a very heart-wrenching child custody case.
Michelle is young and has suffered considerably in that short life, at the hands of an inadept social services team, who failed her, from the moment she was separated from her younger sister at the age of six. Fast forward to her late teens, and she has found herself pregnant, in a relationship with a man who has stood by her more than any of the so-called support workers she has had assigned to her. Even his questionable behaviour towards her doesn't waiver her trust in him.
However, they're broke, live in squalor, and she knows that is no place to bring up a baby, however much she is already attached to that little being.
Amelia is a woman, in a marriage tinged with sadness at the fact that they can't have children, and the one time they thought their dream would come true ended up in the tragedy of stillbirth.
A solution to both of these women's problems could be found, in the placement of little Grace, born to Michelle. She thinks her daughter would be better off in the care of someone who could give her everything.
And that someone could be Amelia, and her husband Piers, who are approached via the Foster to Adopt scheme.
The thing is, nothing is ever that simple.
It was, indeed a roller coaster of emotions as I read the story, following the feelings of a young woman who desperately wants to get her life, and daughter back, and a woman who knows her dream is on the cusp of becoming a reality, but everything balances on the decisions of a judge, after a drawn-out investigation.
All in all, the final conclusion was what I wanted to happen, but there was so much happening in the background, as you read, even if you are of a differing opinion, you would probably agree that it was for the best. People are not always what they seem, and this book demonstrated that, perfectly.
So emotional. But brilliant.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Head of Zeus for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 31, 2022
What a beautiful novel. I inhaled it in two sittings, caused only by my body’s pesky insistence on falling asleep before I’d finished reading for the night. As another reviewer mentioned, don’t start this book at 9pm unless you have a day off the next day and have already taken a nap!
Writing about adoption, fostering and the family court system without personal first hand experience shouldn’t be possible but Scott proves that it is and that is can be done well. She has taken this most polarising of subjects (and a reader who is often quick to pick a side and stick to it) and examined it so sensitively and openly from all angles often stamping out stereotypes on the way. This is made even more incredible when I read what had first inspired Scott to write this novel in the first place.
Another thing that I really liked about this novel wasn’t just its wonderful descriptions of Malvern and it’s eponymous hills and it’s fantastically warm and real characterisations but that so much of the story hinges on a place of worship, the Abbey and yet the book is almost entirely secular with prayer being one reason amongst many for scenes taking place there. Churches have stood in England for hundreds and even a thousand years and have been at the heart of their communities and this book with its food bank and senior’s club reminds people that this tradition continues to this day and I hope this encourages some readers to step into a church and simply enjoy the space and the people within it without being scared that they will be proselytised to.
Although there are some male characters this book is predominantly about strong, feisty women from all walks of life, academic or career backgrounds and without seeking to make them angelic, martyred or in any way super human she has just let them shine and reminded this reviewer in particular, how powerful woman can be when they come together and work together.
Writing about adoption, fostering and the family court system without personal first hand experience shouldn’t be possible but Scott proves that it is and that is can be done well. She has taken this most polarising of subjects (and a reader who is often quick to pick a side and stick to it) and examined it so sensitively and openly from all angles often stamping out stereotypes on the way. This is made even more incredible when I read what had first inspired Scott to write this novel in the first place.
Another thing that I really liked about this novel wasn’t just its wonderful descriptions of Malvern and it’s eponymous hills and it’s fantastically warm and real characterisations but that so much of the story hinges on a place of worship, the Abbey and yet the book is almost entirely secular with prayer being one reason amongst many for scenes taking place there. Churches have stood in England for hundreds and even a thousand years and have been at the heart of their communities and this book with its food bank and senior’s club reminds people that this tradition continues to this day and I hope this encourages some readers to step into a church and simply enjoy the space and the people within it without being scared that they will be proselytised to.
Although there are some male characters this book is predominantly about strong, feisty women from all walks of life, academic or career backgrounds and without seeking to make them angelic, martyred or in any way super human she has just let them shine and reminded this reviewer in particular, how powerful woman can be when they come together and work together.
January 20, 2022
I read this book so quickly it was well written with well developed and believable characters and a good storyline which dealt with raw and emotive issues in a sensitive and simplistic manner. I couldnt put this book down, it was both heartwrenching and heartwarming and I didnt want it to end.
January 14, 2022
Another great book by Victoria Scott
May 16, 2022
I would like to thank the author, the publisher and NetGalley for allowing me early access to this book!
I’ve been in a romance binge read lately and I was looking for something focused on something other than the romantic part, so, when I read “Grace” was about adoption, I was absolutely sold.
Overall, it’ s an interesting book, showing both the perspective of foster parents and birth parents, and which reasons take someone to give up a child. However, for me, the development was too slow. I don’t usually appreciate slow books, and this one felt particularly slow. I understand what the author tried to do, showing Michelle’s growth and that Amelia’s life wasn’t perfect, money isn’t everything. But, as far as Amelia’s story was concerned, I felt there was too much that wasn’t relevant for the main plot. I loved Michelle’s chapters and found her story way deeper than Amelia’s, which, sometimes, just felt boring.
I’ve been in a romance binge read lately and I was looking for something focused on something other than the romantic part, so, when I read “Grace” was about adoption, I was absolutely sold.
Overall, it’ s an interesting book, showing both the perspective of foster parents and birth parents, and which reasons take someone to give up a child. However, for me, the development was too slow. I don’t usually appreciate slow books, and this one felt particularly slow. I understand what the author tried to do, showing Michelle’s growth and that Amelia’s life wasn’t perfect, money isn’t everything. But, as far as Amelia’s story was concerned, I felt there was too much that wasn’t relevant for the main plot. I loved Michelle’s chapters and found her story way deeper than Amelia’s, which, sometimes, just felt boring.
July 31, 2023
A must-read book!
So good, I read it in two days.
A troubled teen, Michelle, who feels let down by services, is in an abusive and drug fuelled relationship when she gives birth to a baby girl but contemplates giving her up for adoption.
A married lady, Amelia, who hasn't managed to have children naturally or through IVF and has suffered a stillborn experience, has the chance to hecome a mum through a foster to adopt programme. Is her married all that it appears to be?
A dual narrative story that is full of twists and turns that will keep you turning the pages.
So good, I read it in two days.
A troubled teen, Michelle, who feels let down by services, is in an abusive and drug fuelled relationship when she gives birth to a baby girl but contemplates giving her up for adoption.
A married lady, Amelia, who hasn't managed to have children naturally or through IVF and has suffered a stillborn experience, has the chance to hecome a mum through a foster to adopt programme. Is her married all that it appears to be?
A dual narrative story that is full of twists and turns that will keep you turning the pages.
July 10, 2022
I normally enjoy stories set in small communities, with romance,a touch of humour and that certain feel-good factor. This story is not really anything like that, instead covering subjects that I've had no experience of including abusive, drug fuelled relationships and the desperation of trying for a baby. Initially I just dipped into it once or twice, but found that I was increasingly drawn into it. I really felt for both Michelle, the young mother, and Amelia, the prospective foster / adoptive mother to be. The way that a book affects me is what makes the difference between a 4* and 5* review - a story such as this that affects me emotionally and makes me consider how lucky my life has been certainly deserves the latter. Overall very highly recommended, just be prepared for some soul-searching whilst reading it.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley,however this did not influence my review of the book.
I received an advance copy of this book from the publisher through Netgalley,however this did not influence my review of the book.
August 25, 2022
Heartfelt and heart wrenching, this book played with my emotions. i had to read it in a day, and was so engrossed. I didn't know who I was rooting for to end up with the baby - teenage mum Michelle, who has been so damaged by the system and let down her whole life, or foster/adoptive mum Amelia who loves baby Grace but who is having to face some hard truths about her marriage. I think this is showing us that nobody is perfect and it's very difficult for an outsider to judge on what they see. Some twists and turns here, and a satisfying ending. A beautiful read. #netgalley #Grace
May 10, 2023
This is a book about the value of motherhood, networks, providing a foundation so that people can redeem themselves and having empathy for others. It's about the value of a strong social welfare system and what happens when it works well.
July 7, 2022
This is Victoria Scott's second novel and I can honestly say that she's getting better and better!!. I really enjoyed this book from beginning to end!!. Of course once again the story follows a hard topic of adoption which seems to be Victoria's trait and she does it do well!.
The story follows a young woman called Michelle who has not had the best start in life and is expecting her first child. She believes that her baby would be better off with people who can love and look after her and give her everything she could ever want. We then find out about the foster to adopt parents Amelia and Piers. So we see the struggle that both sides have had and will have when Michelle decides that actually she wants to have her daughter, Grace to live with her.
If you want to read a book that makes you feel part of the story and all sorts of emotions , then this is the book for you!.
Many thanks to Netgalley for the free ARC book for an honest review.
#Netgalley, #headofzeus, #victoriascottauthor.
The story follows a young woman called Michelle who has not had the best start in life and is expecting her first child. She believes that her baby would be better off with people who can love and look after her and give her everything she could ever want. We then find out about the foster to adopt parents Amelia and Piers. So we see the struggle that both sides have had and will have when Michelle decides that actually she wants to have her daughter, Grace to live with her.
If you want to read a book that makes you feel part of the story and all sorts of emotions , then this is the book for you!.
Many thanks to Netgalley for the free ARC book for an honest review.
#Netgalley, #headofzeus, #victoriascottauthor.
November 13, 2024
I liked how real the characters felt in this book.
The ending was a little too neat, but otherwise it was well done.
The ending was a little too neat, but otherwise it was well done.
June 3, 2024
Really enjoyed this read. Couldn’t put it down ❤️
February 26, 2022
Having loved reading Patience last year, I was thrilled to have an early opportunity to read Grace.
This is a well written and emotional book. Victoria made me feel sympathy for both Amelia and Michelle. A family friend recently went through the adoption route and I know how difficult that was for the couple hoping to adopt, so it was important to see how a woman may feel about giving her child up.
This book covers tough topics including neglect, drug abuse, domestic violence but is written sensitively.. This story looks at both sides - the young mum who feels she cannot give the baby the life it deserves (and that she never had herself) and the older woman who has suffered heartbreak wanting to be a mother..
There are a few twists in the story and I was gripped by this book. Happy to recommend.
This is a well written and emotional book. Victoria made me feel sympathy for both Amelia and Michelle. A family friend recently went through the adoption route and I know how difficult that was for the couple hoping to adopt, so it was important to see how a woman may feel about giving her child up.
This book covers tough topics including neglect, drug abuse, domestic violence but is written sensitively.. This story looks at both sides - the young mum who feels she cannot give the baby the life it deserves (and that she never had herself) and the older woman who has suffered heartbreak wanting to be a mother..
There are a few twists in the story and I was gripped by this book. Happy to recommend.
July 14, 2025
Absolutely loved this book, loved all of the characters and read it so quickly! If I had to say something that could have been improved is that I maybe would have liked a bit more from the ending but would still definitely recommend.
January 17, 2022
Victoria Scott, Grace, Head of Zeus, Aria, 2022
Thank you, NetGalley, for providing me with this uncorrected proof in exchange for an honest review.
Victoria Scott approaches several difficult topics with sensitivity and meticulous attention to detail. The parallel stories of Michelle and Rob, the birth parents of Grace, and Amelia and Piers, Grace’s prospective adoptive parents, are more complex than is immediately apparent. Their putative focus is Grace and her future parenthood.
However, by digging deeper into the relationships, as Scott does so skilfully, it becomes clear that the couples have more in common than initially realised. Linking the couples through their private relationships with each other as well as their public personas is masterful. So too are the observations made about social services and legal systems. Graphic descriptions of the characters’ clothing and hairstyles, which could possibly be seen as a frivolous aside in this novel packed with serious social commentary, are a valid recognition of why and how roles are adopted and understood through image. All these factors add layers upon layers of understanding and complexity to the question to be decided by the court – who should be baby Grace’s permanent parent/s?
The story is told by Michelle and Amelia, Grace’s possible mothers-to-be. Michelle’s voice is heard first as she gives birth to Grace, and in the aftermath of the birth. Her voice, demeanour and attitude are harsh. She is alone in the hospital. In contrast, Amelia is a sorrowful, soft figure, who has had several courses of IVF treatment and a still birth, and is happily married to Piers, a school master. They are parent figures to the boarders at the school. After Grace’s birth, and on the basis that Michelle has done little to demonstrate her commitment to the baby, she is placed with Amelia and Piers on the foster to adopt plan.
Amelia’s belief that the baby will be a magical addition to her household is sadly misplaced – moments of joy are followed by many of sleeplessness, crying, the entrapment that is an outcome of the logistical difficulties of preparing to travel with a baby, and a partner whose support subtly varies. Michelle’s freedom without the baby is also curtailed – by the pain following childbirth and engorged breasts, poverty, hunger, and an obviously unsupportive partner. The women’s struggles, their fights to overcome their physical and mental frailty, and developing relationships outside their domestic environments are well drawn. These women have stories to tell and are rightly given the vital voices in the narrative.
Grace is a novel that has its impetus in personal knowledge of a friend’s similar experience as part of the foster to adopt scheme. However, this kernel of familiarity has been developed well beyond the initial impetus. This is a novel that is impressive in its understanding of the motivations for all the characters, whatever their social situation, and experience. Grace is a very good read, and a positive contribution to understanding complex social questions.
Thank you, NetGalley, for providing me with this uncorrected proof in exchange for an honest review.
Victoria Scott approaches several difficult topics with sensitivity and meticulous attention to detail. The parallel stories of Michelle and Rob, the birth parents of Grace, and Amelia and Piers, Grace’s prospective adoptive parents, are more complex than is immediately apparent. Their putative focus is Grace and her future parenthood.
However, by digging deeper into the relationships, as Scott does so skilfully, it becomes clear that the couples have more in common than initially realised. Linking the couples through their private relationships with each other as well as their public personas is masterful. So too are the observations made about social services and legal systems. Graphic descriptions of the characters’ clothing and hairstyles, which could possibly be seen as a frivolous aside in this novel packed with serious social commentary, are a valid recognition of why and how roles are adopted and understood through image. All these factors add layers upon layers of understanding and complexity to the question to be decided by the court – who should be baby Grace’s permanent parent/s?
The story is told by Michelle and Amelia, Grace’s possible mothers-to-be. Michelle’s voice is heard first as she gives birth to Grace, and in the aftermath of the birth. Her voice, demeanour and attitude are harsh. She is alone in the hospital. In contrast, Amelia is a sorrowful, soft figure, who has had several courses of IVF treatment and a still birth, and is happily married to Piers, a school master. They are parent figures to the boarders at the school. After Grace’s birth, and on the basis that Michelle has done little to demonstrate her commitment to the baby, she is placed with Amelia and Piers on the foster to adopt plan.
Amelia’s belief that the baby will be a magical addition to her household is sadly misplaced – moments of joy are followed by many of sleeplessness, crying, the entrapment that is an outcome of the logistical difficulties of preparing to travel with a baby, and a partner whose support subtly varies. Michelle’s freedom without the baby is also curtailed – by the pain following childbirth and engorged breasts, poverty, hunger, and an obviously unsupportive partner. The women’s struggles, their fights to overcome their physical and mental frailty, and developing relationships outside their domestic environments are well drawn. These women have stories to tell and are rightly given the vital voices in the narrative.
Grace is a novel that has its impetus in personal knowledge of a friend’s similar experience as part of the foster to adopt scheme. However, this kernel of familiarity has been developed well beyond the initial impetus. This is a novel that is impressive in its understanding of the motivations for all the characters, whatever their social situation, and experience. Grace is a very good read, and a positive contribution to understanding complex social questions.
March 21, 2022
Content Warnings: infertility trauma, loss of a child (stillbirth), sexual assault, domestic violence (physical and mental), classism, drug abuse, suicide attempt
Going into this book, I had a pretty clear image of what it would be, and I was completely right until the end, at which point… This book was honestly a little bizarre for me (but still ultimately an enjoyable read, despite the rough topics being covered).
Grace is the story of Amelia and Michelle, two women who at a surface level would appear completely different. Michelle has just given birth to baby Grace, and is set on giving her up for adoption, recognising that she is not fit to care for a child alone, and with serious misgivings about social service intervention, based on her personal experiences in care. Amelia and her husband have been dealing with infertility, something with which Amelia, who longs to be a mother, is particularly struggling. Amelia and Piers, her husband, become Grace's prospective adoptive parents on a fostering to adopt basis. The novel follows both women as Michelle decides ultimately to contest Grace's adoption.
I liked a lot about this novel. Amelia and Michelle - particularly Michelle - were very well written and developed characters. Neither of them were villainised by the narrative, and I really found myself very invested in them and their stories. As a very character focused book, this was a real selling point. I got so invested in Michelle in particular - even shed a couple tears with her towards the end of the book.
However, I did feel there were a lot of missed opportunities here. The book never explores why Michelle decided against an abortion, which I think could have really added to the discussion the book is trying to have. I also wished the author had done more research into how adoptees feel about adoption and incorporated that into the story. I understand that Grace is a baby here, and Michelle and Amelia are the protagonists, but the emphasis is very heavily on adoption as a means for Amelia to achieve parenthood, not necessarily as doing what is best for a child. I wished that had been a little more nuanced.
The main thing with this novel though, is how absolutely mad I feel like it went towards the 70% mark. Out of nowhere in this story which seems very grounded in reality, everything starts to get a bit soap opera-y, with LOADS of new, absolutely wild information being dropped. The novel's structure swaps between Amelia and Michelle's POVs, and towards the end I really felt like I was reading two totally different books - one a gritty courtroom drama, and the other a telenovela. I stayed invested in both stories (admittedly Michelle's more so) but it did catch me a little off guard and felt a bit weird and off from how grounded the story was for the first half of the book. Also, I hate Piers with everything in me.
All in all, this was a perfectly fine read. It's disjointed nature towards the end put me off a little, but it wasn't a bad book by any means. The ending really made me smile.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and Victoria Scott for the ARC of Grace.
Going into this book, I had a pretty clear image of what it would be, and I was completely right until the end, at which point… This book was honestly a little bizarre for me (but still ultimately an enjoyable read, despite the rough topics being covered).
Grace is the story of Amelia and Michelle, two women who at a surface level would appear completely different. Michelle has just given birth to baby Grace, and is set on giving her up for adoption, recognising that she is not fit to care for a child alone, and with serious misgivings about social service intervention, based on her personal experiences in care. Amelia and her husband have been dealing with infertility, something with which Amelia, who longs to be a mother, is particularly struggling. Amelia and Piers, her husband, become Grace's prospective adoptive parents on a fostering to adopt basis. The novel follows both women as Michelle decides ultimately to contest Grace's adoption.
I liked a lot about this novel. Amelia and Michelle - particularly Michelle - were very well written and developed characters. Neither of them were villainised by the narrative, and I really found myself very invested in them and their stories. As a very character focused book, this was a real selling point. I got so invested in Michelle in particular - even shed a couple tears with her towards the end of the book.
However, I did feel there were a lot of missed opportunities here. The book never explores why Michelle decided against an abortion, which I think could have really added to the discussion the book is trying to have. I also wished the author had done more research into how adoptees feel about adoption and incorporated that into the story. I understand that Grace is a baby here, and Michelle and Amelia are the protagonists, but the emphasis is very heavily on adoption as a means for Amelia to achieve parenthood, not necessarily as doing what is best for a child. I wished that had been a little more nuanced.
The main thing with this novel though, is how absolutely mad I feel like it went towards the 70% mark. Out of nowhere in this story which seems very grounded in reality, everything starts to get a bit soap opera-y, with LOADS of new, absolutely wild information being dropped. The novel's structure swaps between Amelia and Michelle's POVs, and towards the end I really felt like I was reading two totally different books - one a gritty courtroom drama, and the other a telenovela. I stayed invested in both stories (admittedly Michelle's more so) but it did catch me a little off guard and felt a bit weird and off from how grounded the story was for the first half of the book. Also, I hate Piers with everything in me.
All in all, this was a perfectly fine read. It's disjointed nature towards the end put me off a little, but it wasn't a bad book by any means. The ending really made me smile.
Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and Victoria Scott for the ARC of Grace.
May 22, 2025
Victoria Scott's "Grace" is a captivating exploration of love, loss, and the complexities of human relationships. The story follows the titular character, Grace, as she navigates the tumultuous waters of adolescence, grappling with her identity and the expectations placed upon her by family and society.
Scott's writing is both lyrical and poignant, drawing readers into Grace's world with vivid imagery and relatable emotions. The character development is one of the book's strongest points; Grace is a beautifully flawed protagonist whose struggles resonate deeply. Her journey of self-discovery is both heartwarming and heartbreaking, making it easy for readers to empathise with her challenges.
The supporting cast is equally well-crafted, adding depth to the narrative. Each character brings their unique perspective, enriching the story and highlighting the various facets of Grace's life. The themes of friendship, loyalty, and the search for belonging are woven seamlessly throughout the plot, making it a compelling read.
However, while the pacing is generally well-handled, there are moments where the narrative feels a bit drawn out, particularly in the middle sections. Some readers may wish for a quicker resolution to certain plot points. Additionally, while the ending is satisfying, it leaves a few questions unanswered, which may frustrate those who prefer a more definitive conclusion.
Overall, "Grace" is a beautifully written novel that tackles important themes with sensitivity and insight. Victoria Scott has crafted a story that will resonate with anyone who has ever felt lost or out of place. It's a heartfelt journey that reminds us of the power of love and the importance of finding our path. Highly recommended for fans of contemporary young adult fiction!
Scott's writing is both lyrical and poignant, drawing readers into Grace's world with vivid imagery and relatable emotions. The character development is one of the book's strongest points; Grace is a beautifully flawed protagonist whose struggles resonate deeply. Her journey of self-discovery is both heartwarming and heartbreaking, making it easy for readers to empathise with her challenges.
The supporting cast is equally well-crafted, adding depth to the narrative. Each character brings their unique perspective, enriching the story and highlighting the various facets of Grace's life. The themes of friendship, loyalty, and the search for belonging are woven seamlessly throughout the plot, making it a compelling read.
However, while the pacing is generally well-handled, there are moments where the narrative feels a bit drawn out, particularly in the middle sections. Some readers may wish for a quicker resolution to certain plot points. Additionally, while the ending is satisfying, it leaves a few questions unanswered, which may frustrate those who prefer a more definitive conclusion.
Overall, "Grace" is a beautifully written novel that tackles important themes with sensitivity and insight. Victoria Scott has crafted a story that will resonate with anyone who has ever felt lost or out of place. It's a heartfelt journey that reminds us of the power of love and the importance of finding our path. Highly recommended for fans of contemporary young adult fiction!
July 19, 2022
I absolutely loved Grace and wasn’t expecting to love this book quite as much as I did.
This is such a bittersweet story that moved me emotionally and had me changing my opinions throughout.
At the heart of this story is baby Grace and the adoption custody battle that ensues. Each chapter is a countdown to the final court session where the judge will decide who gets custody of baby Grace.
The story is told from the perspective of Michelle Grace’s birth mother and Amelia who is fostering with the hope of adopting Grace.
At first Michelle is adamant that adoption is the only choice, she believes she isn’t fit to be a mother – she has no job and no prospects and what kind of life can she give Grace? She’s living with an abusive drug addict with bare cupboards and no power!
Social services think this is a straight-forward foster to adopt case as the birth parents are not willing to engage with the process at all.
Amelia and her husband Piers have been wanting a child for so long. They have what looks like a perfect marriage and can provide a loving home for baby Grace.
So when they get the call that the foster to adopt option is finally an option thanks to baby Grace they gratefully accept the opportunity.
But as the custody case rolls on Michelle starts to have doubts. Can she be the mum Grace deserves?
With the help of Gillian and her husband (who have fostered for years) Michelle starts to turn her life around and realises that she does love Grace and she wants to be her mother more than anything else in the world.
But is it too late?
I really went through the ringer emotionally reading this book, it hit so close to home. My birth parents with to family court in a custody battle for me so many parts of this story really resonated with me.
People are not always what they seem, and this book demonstrated that, perfectly.
This was a really emotional and brilliant read.
With thanks to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This is such a bittersweet story that moved me emotionally and had me changing my opinions throughout.
At the heart of this story is baby Grace and the adoption custody battle that ensues. Each chapter is a countdown to the final court session where the judge will decide who gets custody of baby Grace.
The story is told from the perspective of Michelle Grace’s birth mother and Amelia who is fostering with the hope of adopting Grace.
At first Michelle is adamant that adoption is the only choice, she believes she isn’t fit to be a mother – she has no job and no prospects and what kind of life can she give Grace? She’s living with an abusive drug addict with bare cupboards and no power!
Social services think this is a straight-forward foster to adopt case as the birth parents are not willing to engage with the process at all.
Amelia and her husband Piers have been wanting a child for so long. They have what looks like a perfect marriage and can provide a loving home for baby Grace.
So when they get the call that the foster to adopt option is finally an option thanks to baby Grace they gratefully accept the opportunity.
But as the custody case rolls on Michelle starts to have doubts. Can she be the mum Grace deserves?
With the help of Gillian and her husband (who have fostered for years) Michelle starts to turn her life around and realises that she does love Grace and she wants to be her mother more than anything else in the world.
But is it too late?
I really went through the ringer emotionally reading this book, it hit so close to home. My birth parents with to family court in a custody battle for me so many parts of this story really resonated with me.
People are not always what they seem, and this book demonstrated that, perfectly.
This was a really emotional and brilliant read.
With thanks to NetGalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
April 23, 2025
despite the soft pink cover, "grace" is anything but light. this book dives into some incredibly heavy and complicated themes, such as foster care, addiction, adoption, and what it really means to be a mother-and it made me think about things i honestly hadn’t given much thought to before.
i think what the author does best is give us two sides of one heartbreaking story without villainizing either. michelle and amelia are so different, and yet i could empathize with both of them the whole way through. there was never a moment where i felt like i fully knew what i wanted the outcome to be, because it’s just one of those situations where there’s no easy answer and no real “right” side. i won’t spoil the ending, but i’ll just say that no matter how it turned out, it was always going to hurt, because it’s hard to be fully happy for one woman without feeling awful for the other.
i do think michelle's chapters were stronger, though. amelia’s sections were longer and sometimes felt unnecessarily stretched out, and towards the end her storyline took a turn that felt a little too dramatic for me (almost soap opera-ish) in a book that otherwise felt grounded and realistic. i think that last twist could’ve been left out and the story still would've been just as impactful, maybe even more so.
i’m not sure this book will stick with me long-term, mostly because the subject matter isn’t something i personally relate to, but i’m glad i read it and i’d definitely be curious to check out more from victoria scott. 3.5 stars, but rounding down because it was a bit heavy for me.
i think what the author does best is give us two sides of one heartbreaking story without villainizing either. michelle and amelia are so different, and yet i could empathize with both of them the whole way through. there was never a moment where i felt like i fully knew what i wanted the outcome to be, because it’s just one of those situations where there’s no easy answer and no real “right” side. i won’t spoil the ending, but i’ll just say that no matter how it turned out, it was always going to hurt, because it’s hard to be fully happy for one woman without feeling awful for the other.
i do think michelle's chapters were stronger, though. amelia’s sections were longer and sometimes felt unnecessarily stretched out, and towards the end her storyline took a turn that felt a little too dramatic for me (almost soap opera-ish) in a book that otherwise felt grounded and realistic. i think that last twist could’ve been left out and the story still would've been just as impactful, maybe even more so.
i’m not sure this book will stick with me long-term, mostly because the subject matter isn’t something i personally relate to, but i’m glad i read it and i’d definitely be curious to check out more from victoria scott. 3.5 stars, but rounding down because it was a bit heavy for me.
July 11, 2022
Victoria Scott has a special kind of tenderness and warmth in her writing that you can't find anywhere else.
Grace tells the bittersweet story of two women - 19-year old Michelle who made the decision to give up her baby girl to avoid her suffering the same life Michelle has, and Amelia who had been desperate for a family with her husband and finally gets the chance of a lifetime to adopt the baby. But then, Michelle realises she isn't doomed to repeat the past - she's a mother, and she wants to be a great one - she wants her baby back. But now, it's out of her hands and both women can do nothing but pray until a ruling decides.
This book handles such difficult topics with sensitivity and grace - dealing with truths about motherhood, the care system, toxic relationships and the struggles of being a young woman. Both Michelle and Amelia are perfectly written, their differences clear as two sides of coin, Michelle is hard and hurt, Amelia is soft and warm - but as we get to know them, we begin to not only feel a connection to the characters but start to find ways to connect them to one another too. Both characters have their issues, but are completely empathetic - it becomes clear very quickly that both their lives would be changed forever whether they become the legal parent of the baby or not.
Absolutely absorbing and heart-wrenching, Victoria Scott should buy stocks in Kleenex with the amount of tears she provokes with her writing.
Grace tells the bittersweet story of two women - 19-year old Michelle who made the decision to give up her baby girl to avoid her suffering the same life Michelle has, and Amelia who had been desperate for a family with her husband and finally gets the chance of a lifetime to adopt the baby. But then, Michelle realises she isn't doomed to repeat the past - she's a mother, and she wants to be a great one - she wants her baby back. But now, it's out of her hands and both women can do nothing but pray until a ruling decides.
This book handles such difficult topics with sensitivity and grace - dealing with truths about motherhood, the care system, toxic relationships and the struggles of being a young woman. Both Michelle and Amelia are perfectly written, their differences clear as two sides of coin, Michelle is hard and hurt, Amelia is soft and warm - but as we get to know them, we begin to not only feel a connection to the characters but start to find ways to connect them to one another too. Both characters have their issues, but are completely empathetic - it becomes clear very quickly that both their lives would be changed forever whether they become the legal parent of the baby or not.
Absolutely absorbing and heart-wrenching, Victoria Scott should buy stocks in Kleenex with the amount of tears she provokes with her writing.
February 5, 2022
Victoria Scott poured her heart and soul into this book - it’s been a long time since I felt so emotional - well done and thank you.
Melanie is 19, in a toxic relationship and equally toxic environment with Rob, her boyfriend, and she is pregnant. Having spent most of her life in the care system until she was 16 she had suffered an extremely difficult childhood. She decides to place her child up for adoption to give her a stable healthy life - a life she never had.
Amelia and her husband are a married couple who cant have children of their own so when they get the call to tell them a newborn baby girl is available to them they are over the moon although Amelia secretly has doubts - nobody is that lucky or will the adoption be seamless. Her worst fears come true and they are told that the birth mother has changed her mind and wants her daughter back to raise her on her own.
A family court battle has to be carried out with the judge deciding who is the most appropriate person to raise the child.
Great but heartbreaking storyline loved it.
Melanie is 19, in a toxic relationship and equally toxic environment with Rob, her boyfriend, and she is pregnant. Having spent most of her life in the care system until she was 16 she had suffered an extremely difficult childhood. She decides to place her child up for adoption to give her a stable healthy life - a life she never had.
Amelia and her husband are a married couple who cant have children of their own so when they get the call to tell them a newborn baby girl is available to them they are over the moon although Amelia secretly has doubts - nobody is that lucky or will the adoption be seamless. Her worst fears come true and they are told that the birth mother has changed her mind and wants her daughter back to raise her on her own.
A family court battle has to be carried out with the judge deciding who is the most appropriate person to raise the child.
Great but heartbreaking storyline loved it.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews