I have to say that I was disappointed with this book. While not terrible, it was not the example of wonderful literature that I was hoping it would be. It's main problems were the children and the characters.
Elizabeth Yates wrote very beautiful, vibrant descriptions, which made sense coming from the narrator, but when she had a child describe it in that fashion it felt false. Jared used words that an uneducated farm man wouldn't know, much less an uneducated eleven year old farm boy. She didn't know how to write children realistically. A small child would not thank the Stars for coming out when the moon's gone, the child might not even know what stars were, and while Jared was a sweet boy, the author just could not write children well.
She didn't write a few of the most important characters well either. Both Jared and Jenneta lacked substance. The whole of their beings could be summed up in just a few words. Jared paints beautiful art, has a strong spirit, and loves Jennet. Jennet is strong both in body and mind. Neither of their characters comes to life in your mind. They don't feel like real people.
Ignoring these problems, the book was decent, and the artistic descriptions redeem it a little, so I am giving it three stars.